Point Of View In Porphyria's Lover

1424 words - 6 pages

The Point of View in Porphyria's Lover

    "Porphyria's Lover" is an exhilarating love story given from a lunatic's point of view.  It is the story of  a man who is so obsessed with Porphyria that he decides to keep her for himself.  The only way he feels he can keep her, though, is by killing her.  Robert Browning's poem depicts the separation of social classes and describes the "triumph" of one man over an unjust society.  As is often the case in fiction, the speaker of "Porphyria's Lover" does not give accurate information in the story.

      The speaker is a deranged man who will stop at nothing to keep his dear Porphyria.  Although the introduction refers to the ...view middle of the document...


      The speaker is upset about the party going on in the main house.  Porphyria will be married soon, and he feels that if he were an upper-class citizen, Porphyria would be able to marry him.  There is definitely much love felt between the two, and the speaker realizes that he will lose Porphyria if he does not do something.  There is a sense of desperation felt by the speaker.  He also feels that society's rules are very unjust and cruel.  At the same time, though, it seems that the lover does not blame Porphyria for what is unfolding, but nonetheless, the speaker acts in a cold manner towards her.  She, trying to cheer him up, puts his arm around her waist.  During all this time, Porphyria seems to be happy but not necessarily about seeing her lover. The speaker says: "Happy and proud; at last I knew/ Porphyria worshipped me;"  Unbeknownst to the speaker, she could have been excited about the party.  This also comes to show that the speaker was out of touch with reality.

      During the first part of the poem, Porphyria's lover is leaning against her shoulder.  He is completely dependent upon her.  This is where the lover shows that he is acting in a very cold manner, but he is actually trying to make the reader feel sorry for him.  Shortly afterwards, he starts explaining the problem, and states his side of the story.  The speaker begins to feel sorry for himself, and his frustration and fears begin to mount into an expected act of violence towards Porphyria.  

      The only thing that Porphyria's lover can think of is to strangle her with her own hair.  By doing this, he believes that she will be his forever.  The speaker also sees this as the next best thing to marriage.  He is completely out of his mind, and thinks that she does not feel any pain when he strangles her.  Robert Browning does an excellent job in emphasizing that Porphyria's lover is not sure if, in fact, Porphyria feels no pain.  The speaker states: "No pain felt she;/ I am quite sure she felt no pain(Barnet 568)."  By strangling Porphyria, the speaker believes that they will be together, and that everything will be better in the near future.  It seems the speaker "witnesses the woman's apparently wholehearted love-(and) is also the moment that he attempts to preserve by killing her (Maxwell 28)."  Of course, this theory could not be further from the truth, and this shows the reader that there is something wrong with the lover's state of mind.  

      Towards the end of the poem, it is Porphyria's corpse that is leaning on his shoulder.  Her lifeless body is supported by her lover.  From this point on, the speaker's insanity becomes more evident.  The statements that the speaker makes are by no means believable.  He is therefore consciously lying,  or unaware of reality.  The lover makes several statements about Porphyria expressing happiness after she was brutally strangled.  The speaker states: "again/...

Other Essays Like Point of View in Porphyria's Lover

Death From A Buddhist And Christian Point Of View

1355 words - 6 pages Death from a Buddhist and Christian Point of View      “You will be with me today in paradise,” Jesus Christ told this to the thief on the cross while they were dying. However, can people believe that there is truly life after death? In many different religions there are different perceptions of life after death. For example in the Buddhist religion, the Buddhist people believe that life is practice for death. Professor

Ehec Outbreak From An Organizational Point Of View

567 words - 3 pages the ones existing in Japan or in the USA). Remained at the state of project (EU’s EO2HEAVEN project). ➢ Task-force (Which currently do not exist anymore) ➢ Establishment of a super central authority (which could have been embodied by the Robert Koch Institut) Critical point of view According to Klotter’s last two steps, the crisis led to some improvement, which should be internalized in order to enhance the approach for future cases

Second Generation from a Chinese Point of View

1393 words - 6 pages . My parents’ world was opposite of mine because their way of life is different from America’s. The second generation encountered the distinctive problem of finding a balance between the Chinese and American ways of life. The first generation Chinese parents view education as a primary way to have a better life; therefore they push their children to be perfection. For example, children attended public schools in the United States and learned

Compare and Contrast ‘Porphyria's Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, Commenting on Their Content, Style and Form. How Successful Are the Poets in Revealing Their Characters Through Their Chosen...

1960 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, commenting on their content, style and form. How successful are the poets in revealing their characters through their chosen poetic style? There are many contrasts between ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, although they both deal with love, but different types of love. ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’ is about a love sicken knight. Who meets an

"Voyeur" A Description Of Pablo Picasso's "Female Nude" From A Particular Point Of View

936 words - 4 pages broken down into multiples of generalized basic shapes. The roundness in her shoulders is converted into three straight lines. Just short of a ninety-degree angle.Her upper body creates a large triangle that points downward. This is the only real shape that I can see realistically and makes sense to me. This shape contains the same colors as found in her skin.The curtains create a view that only allows me to see shapes that give a hint to what I am

The Main Point Of The Essay Is Violence In Our

529 words - 3 pages The main point of the essay is violence in our schools. Now, more than ever, violence in all grades, even elementary is on the rise.Just last year, 64% of elementary school principals in five Massachusetts cities-Boston, Springfield, Worcester, Lowell, and New Bedford-suspended or expelled violent students. In high school and middle school the figure was close to 96%. In eight public schools, 26 or more students were dismissed for carrying

major turning point in lord of the flies

541 words - 3 pages Tarik H.K.The Main Turning Point of 'Lord of The Flies'Lord of the flies is a book in which a massive transformation occurs. A transformation from refinement to savagery. This happens for many reasons but there is one main event which turns everything wrong. That is the first "sighting" of the beast is made.Samneric where sleeping by the fire. They were supposedly looking after the fire in 'shifts' but both had fallen asleep simultaneously. They

View of War in All My Sons

833 words - 4 pages justifies his actions for he thinks he has a responsibility to his family over the community. To Keller, “Nothin’s bigger than that…I’m his father and he’s my son, and if there’s something bigger than that I’ll put a bullet in my head!” (3.77). Miller uses this to criticize the kind of narrow-minded point of view Keller has. The entire play of All My Sons is a criticism of the American Dream. Joe Keller, is an ordinary American

Slessor' S View Of Change In Sleep

683 words - 3 pages the end of Stanza 3, I believe, is particularly successful in reinforcing the sharp and sudden nature of change.The juxtaposition of the finishing stanza with the previous stanzas also leaves a lasting impact on the reader in finishing the poem with a cynical and detracting view on the child's entry into the world, what we would normally associate as being a joyous occasion.Hence, one could say that 'Sleep' creates a message of how the most basic

Evil From A Theologian's Point Of View

1330 words - 6 pages -powerful, all-knowing and all-good. If this is the case, why doesn't he stop evil? And, since people are supposed to be created in God's image, why are they capable of moral evil? If one believes that God exists, there can only be one answer: evil exists because God allows it, and moral evil exists because God has given us freedom of choice.Evil has been looked at in many different ways throughout the years. Philosophers like Socrates and Plato

Society's View of the Soldier in "The Sniper"

804 words - 4 pages Society’s view of the soldier Present in many writings is a conflict between an individual and a group or a society. This conflict is generally caused by the individual deciding that one of the root beliefs of the society is immoral, wrong, or is hurting themselves. In “The Sniper” the main character is a soldier in a civil war when he isn’t mentally prepared. After killing a man the sniper has a breakdown and starts to rethink these ideals

Related Papers

Leadership Point Of View Essay

1788 words - 8 pages Leadership Point of View Activity 6.6 Dan Sweeny Indiana Wesleyan MBA Throughout the “Applied Management Concepts” coursework, teachings from Blanchard and Robbins, DeCenzo, and Coulter have been numerous in an effort to explain and portray a leadership point of view, defined by the Blanchard as their “thoughts about leading and motivating people” (Blanchard, 2010). Naturally, this

Leadership Point Of View Essay

784 words - 4 pages Leadership Point of View MGT-605 6.4.2013 Leadership Point of View Growing up I had a few key people who helped shaped who I am today. The first was my mother. Her kind and loving spirit showed me that a gentle spirit is conducive to a serving attitude and living God’s kingdom here on earth. A servant attitude is imperative to becoming a strong leader. The second key influencer in my life was my youth pastor Ryan. He was always there for

“I” As The Narrator Point Of View

1745 words - 7 pages Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. She used the first person point of view to write her story as journal. As she used “I” to form her story, the narration made to seem probable because the narrator in this story has some kind of mental problem. In addition, using the first person point of view is hard to judge if the narrator is telling the truth or not, even though the narrator is telling the readers part of the truth. Therefore, it’s

Opera Case Opera's Point Of View

2142 words - 9 pages REVISED NEGOTIATION PLANNING TEMPLATE Opera’s point of view 1. ANAYSIS OF THE CONFLICT |What is the nature of the conflict as seen by the |Person in lead role | |organisation/constituency you represent? |Production will open in 3 wks | | |Sally’s salary