Policing And Society Essay

5082 words - 21 pages

Jeff Crowe
Policing and Society
Dr. Greenleaf
March 6, 2015
Question 1
The broken windows theory in policing has changed the way many law enforcement agencies, along with the officers within them, have to look at crime. Police have always responded to crime, that is the belief and that has always been their job. What happens, though, when provided with an idea that expresses that crime can be more preventative just by looking at and involving the community to participate? Policing traditionally has always been a response unit, providing its’ service after the fact (after a crime has happened). The broken windows theory counters that traditional style by looking outside of the ...view middle of the document...

Perceptions of legitimacy are subjective, and will vary among jurisdictions and within specific communities in those jurisdictions. Procedural justice is used to obtain legitimacy by giving the people (victims or suspects) an opportunity to explain the situation as well as their side of the story to an officer or detective. It is important for an officer to know the situation from all angles and in order to do that they need to make sure they give the people a voice. If an officer is poor at providing citizens with proper procedure then their legitimacy within the community will fall, and if police have poor legitimacy then citizens (especially victims) will not give them their voice. According to PERF (2014) the fourth issue to attain legitimacy by procedural justice is as follows; People are sensitive to whether they are treated with dignity and politeness, and to whether their rights are respected. The issue of interpersonal treatment consistently emerges as a key factor in reactions to dealings with legal authorities. People believe that they are entitled to treatment with respect and react very negatively to dismissive or demeaning interpersonal treatment. Although they are similar when paired together, the difference is procedural justice is used to reap legitimacy within the community, whereas police legitimacy could either hinder or service procedural justice. Procedural justice could also be impacted by whether or not a police agency is unionized.
Unionized policing is a very opinionated subject matter when it comes to its’ effect on crime. As late as the mid 1960’s police chiefs had virtually unlimited power to run their departments…Today police chiefs are severely constrained (WODI, 1984). And then you have the opposite spectrum arguing that Unions are essential to American law enforcement because of the combination of nature and demands modern police work endures as well as the practices and history of how the U.S. manages police (Kleismet, 1989). Police unionization has its pros and cons, but they can be very different from an individual standpoint. The assumptions of Magenau and Hunt (1996) are that unionization for the rank-and-file officers will increase their ability to put more emphasis on law enforcement rather than service delivery and order maintenance. Focusing primarily on law enforcement can be both a pro and con depending on how you look at it. For an officer it has the possibility of benefitting them depending how they are measured as an officer. If it is strictly a numbers game then they may focus on more on getting the arrests and/or tickets. On the other hand, focusing on that can decrease police legitimacy in a community leading to distrust in officers and the law. Unions can benefit officers but at the same time may hurt their departments, with such topics being salaries and benefits or complaints of work conditions.
Question 2
The “best” way to measure police performance is difficult to...

Other Essays Like Policing and Society

Policing Developement and Operation Trends Essay

1357 words - 6 pages Policing Development and Operation Trends Jovita Gilliam CJA/394 February 1, 2012 Yolonda Johnson Policing Development and Operation Trends There are different policing organizations present in every community that helps to keep that community safe. A few of these organizations are the local police, the state police, and the FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigations). These organizations play a vital

Early Roots of Policing Essay

1063 words - 5 pages Early Roots in Policing AJS/502 March 14, 2013 Abstract: Early policing was an unorganized concept throughout civilization as rules and laws attempted to be by use armies of various kingdoms and

Criminal Justice..Paper

881 words - 4 pages 1 Relationship Between Private and Public Police Introduction to Security April 10, 2011 Cyndi White 2 Both private police and public police are important to our society. They are both necessary in order to protect our society, it may be protecting a person from harm, or even protecting a business and the personnel within that business. Either way both of them are responsible in helping with crime deterrence. When it comes

David Couper

874 words - 4 pages , violence on the streets and a great dislike of protesters. One might say that not much has changed. I remember thinking, I needed to stay in law enforcement and carry out what I believed police should do in a free society: Guard and protect people and their rights. I never went back into the Marines. When I received my bachelor’s degree, I was a newly promoted detective in Minneapolis in the wake of the Miranda decision in 1966. My senior

History of Police

951 words - 4 pages constructed by Sir Robert Peel, and his statement of, “the people are the police, and the police are people” (Johnson, & Wolfe, 2003). Robert Peel perceived that officers did not need to encroach into citizens lives when preventing criminal activity in communities. Peel created the principles that attributed to Community policing for crime prevention like neighborhood watch, and social institution programs for youth (Johnson, & Wolfe, 2003

The People vs the Police: Building the Trust

1856 words - 8 pages police officers, or the reports of the torture of Abner Louima by New York City police continually spark major public debate, capture the public’s attention and raise troubling questions about police abuse of force in a democratic society. Recently, The Police Foundation, a private, independent, nonprofit organization dedicated to supporting innovation and improvement in policing; conducted a study through a telephone survey of a representative

Criminal Justice Trends

1498 words - 6 pages management and budgets. Courts also has a huge task dealing with support programs that will be a vital, such as mental health, domestic violence and other specialized courts. In conclusion, law enforcement are the guardians of our right under the Constitution and the law, they have an awesome task trying to keep our communities safe from dangerous criminal in our society today. There are several different ways to look at policing with the

Police Influence

792 words - 4 pages Police Influence on Society CJA 344- Cultural Diversity Issues in Criminal Justice John France September 16, 2012 In history the system of American police was something learned from Great Britain and adapted by America. In the past the first ideals of policing were controlled by the able-bodied men and young boys who were part of the first Europeans to venture to our lands. This was mainly a

Sir Robert Peel

1952 words - 8 pages Nine Principles of Policing Sir Robert Peel & Sir Richard Mayne Barbara Cox ECPI CJ 110 Mr. Taylor July 28, 2012 Abstract The Nine Principles are a set of rules that were formed during the 1800’s for police officers so they could maintain order and enforce the law to an extent while still maintaining the

Policing In The Future: Focus On Terrorism

1939 words - 8 pages a terrorist attack are over most people become comfortable and let down on terrorist defense. Americans have been lucky with few terrorist attacks on U.S. soil. However, other countries such as Iraq have not been so fortunate. Therefore, Americans should feel a sense of freedom and pride in knowing terrorism has not been a continuous problem for the United States.Future policing rely mainly on the type of society being policed-the social

To What Extent Has The Policing Of Ethnic Minorities Been Affected By The Scarman Report And The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry?

1913 words - 8 pages IntroductionThroughout recent history the relationship between the British police and minority groups has been greatly tested. This is evident through such events as the Brixton riots (1981) and more recently the Bradford riots (2001). Britain is a multi-racial society and members of the ethnic minority community can face particular problems, such as racially motivated attacks and harassment. This often leads to distrust from minority groups

Related Papers

Police Ethics Essay

1017 words - 5 pages ). The experience of policing within the American society has undergone fundamental transformation with society. Policing prior to these transformations were only White men and in today’s society there are police of every ethnic background as well as both males and females. The relationship between the police and minority ethnic communities has not been a happy one. Today’s controversy about the abuse of police power, the failure to investigate

The Future Of Policing Essay

1507 words - 7 pages new trends improve policing overall, they can also cause more serious issues. It is crucial to continue making changes topolicing because it allows law enforcement officers to keep up with the rest of society, including the knowledge of new crime trends. This paper will describe the current trends and issues in policing and analyze possible solutions to improve policing tactics. One trend currently affecting policing is police-community

Police History Essay

885 words - 4 pages officers should wear a uniform to distinguish them from the citizens. As society and the economy began to change crime increased and the need to establish a more effective and active form of policing effort became necessary. In 1884, paid officers established the first full time force in New York and 24 hour patrol coverage. The aldermen chose citizens to be officers in each district and have their own authority. The frontier in the 1840’s was

Police History Essay

891 words - 4 pages officers. The community thought that the police officers should wear a uniform to distinguish them from the citizens. As society and the economy began to change crime increased and the need to establish a more effective and active form of policing effort became necessary. In 1884, paid officers established the first full time force in New York and 24 hour patrol coverage. The aldermen chose citizens to be officers in each district and have their own