This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis Is Unethical And Immoral

929 words - 4 pages

In this day in age, where looks are almost everything when getting and going where you want, having a child with perfect genes is something to brag about. Allowing a parent to choose the perfect genes is not so far off in the future, in fact, it is now possible to pick some of the genes of a baby to make a “perfect” child. A procedure called pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, or PGD, has been used for years by doctors who wanted to reduce the chance of women carrying babies infected with life-threatening diseases. PGD was first used to improve the likelihood of a successful pregnancy for couples suffering with recurring miscarriages and parents who had the chance of passing on genetic ...view middle of the document...

Even PGD, only used in the best ways possible, to lower the possibility of a child inheriting a disease, was, and is, still a controversial issue and has become an even bigger issue today. Jessica Berg, an associate professor of law and bioethics at Case Western Reserve University, said PGD also raises concerns about how society will begin to perceive people with disabilities, along with the parents who chose to have them. Berg (2003) says:
While we hope our children are healthy, the ability to pick ahead of time might lead to some unintended consequences. Society may be inclined to view parents who don't use this technology as irresponsible. Insurance companies may deny coverage to a child born with cystic fibrosis, saying ‘Look, you knew you could have an unhealthy child.’
Although no serious health effects have been linked to PGD, there has not been any rigorous long-term testing on this procedure. Many people agree that it seems highly likely that PGD may have a few long-term health effects because a cell is being removed from an embryo. A few studies using mice as the PGD recipients have shown a higher risk of weight gain and memory loss in adulthood.
One main reason why this procedure should be banned is because of the cost of this procedure. No one less than the upper-middle class is able to afford this price. The PGD test itself costs about $3,000. Additionally, there is the cost of the in-vitro fertilization that costs around $10,000. In most cases, insurance does not cover either the test or the fertilization. Although many people agree that this procedure lowers the number of abnormalities, and therefore fewer abortions, only allowing the rich to have the opportunity to receive the PGD...

Other Essays Like Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis Is Unethical And Immoral

Revolutions in Genetic Technology-an Abstract Essay

1363 words - 6 pages direct examination of the DNA molecule itself. Genetic tests are used for several reasons, including: • carrier screening, which involves identifying unaffected individuals who carry one copy of a gene for a disease that requires two copies for the disease to be expressed • preimplantation genetic diagnosis (see the side bar, Screening Embryos for Disease) GENETIC COUNSELLING Genetic counseling is the process by which patients or relatives

Designer Babies Essay

984 words - 4 pages genetic screening as a means to pre-select unborn human beings is not only considered unethical and immoral by certain groups of people but would also lead to an essentially immobile societal class structure. Therefore, a carefully controlled practice which all of society could benefit is the key. My view after reading the articles about “Designer Babies” is that this topic has at lot of pros and cons, But overall I think that when used in

Genectic Testing

777 words - 4 pages procedures to find out if a person has a genetic condition or disorder or is likely to develop a disease based on his or her genetic makeup. Individuals may wish to be tested if the family shows a history of one specific disease such as Huntington's Disease or breast cancer, if they show symptoms of a genetic disorder which could be improved by early diagnosis, or if they are planning a family and are concerned about the possibility of passing on a

The Case Against Perfection

1113 words - 5 pages (AHEC) of the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC), in the Protection of Human Genetic Information in Australia. There are two main powerful, but conflicting, social reactions in response to the rapid pace of change in genetic technology; the first of which there is a strong public support for the medical breakthroughs that promise better medical diagnosis and treatments, and to assist in law enforcement (e.g. identification

Genetic Counseling

1465 words - 6 pages have a lot of background information on who they are and what they can do, have specific course requirements to become a certified genetic counselor and have an award to follow after from a scientist, who inspires many individuals. In the future, genetic counseling is the career that I would like to pursue.Genetic counselors are health professionals with specialized training and experiences in the areas of medical genetics and counseling

Genetics and Society - Essay

917 words - 4 pages traits for the purpose of cures and treatments or enhancement. Genetic engineering is a controversial topic in which one may believe it to be unethical/socially unfair or a benefit to the world overall. Genetic engineering is not unethical but a benefit to the world only when limitations are present. It should be used for medical or agricultural purposes only. There is no doubt that this topic in biotechnology can amount to great things, but without

Personalized Medicine

1218 words - 5 pages Personalized medicine is a swiftly evolving way of healthcare that customizes treatment to an individuals genetic make-up. This custom analyzes the molecular profile of each patient to determine a personalized diagnosis and course of treatment. The study of how genetic variations interface with drug response and disease risk is called pharmacogenomics (Genetic Science Learning Center, 2011). This revolutionary breakthrough in healthcare will

The Long Term Dangers of Genetic Engineering

1929 words - 8 pages understanding to make informed decisions about the scenario they were given. University Students' Bioethical Perceptions about Genetic Engineering: Genetic Testing and Genetic Diagnosis. (2010). This shows that, while we have the knowledge of what genetic engineering is, what it can do for us and even what it can do to harm us, we still lack the understanding of what we should do with that knowledge. Genetic engineering could be the end of all disease

The Human Genome Project Project

2139 words - 9 pages sequencing and dideoxy Sanger method, were used. The benefits that were to be attained from the HGP were to better the diagnosis and treatment of genetic disorders and to improve forensic science. Many ethical issues are presented about the HGP related to the use and ownership of the information and technologies. In my opinion, the human genome project is something that will benefit the masses because it helps in the diagnosis of diseases

Designer Baby

1383 words - 6 pages be changed. The alterations that parents are able to decide from are the gender, appearance, intelligence, diseases and personality. There is a process that involves screening the embryos that is called pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, or PGD. With In-Vitro Fertilization, embryos are created and grown to the eighth cell stage. At this point, a couple of cells are removed for scientists to examine. The scientists examine the DNA of the

Genes and Society

1534 words - 7 pages gene defect, there is no valid reason for performing the test.” Both guideines have left much to debate about the legal and ethical concerns of such prenatal tests and I will be presenting two opposing views to provide a clearer picture. By carrying out the prenatal genetic testing, there is a possibility of a negative diagnosis and the parents can be spared years of worrying and uncertainty about their child's health prospect in the future

Related Papers

Tay Sachs Disease, No Cure, No Treatment. What Are The Options?

652 words - 3 pages children born per year compared with approximately 60 new cases per year prior to screening.” (476). If these high risk couples that choose to try and have children they are left with two options, prenatal diagnosis or preimplantation diagnosis. For couples who choose to go with a preimplantation diagnosis, this is done by in vitro fertilization, where the embryo can be tested for the gene defect prior to implantation. The healthy embryos

The Ultimate Baby Essay

1246 words - 5 pages children. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) or embryo screening is the technique used to identify genetic defects in embryos created through in vitro fertilization (IVF) before pregnancy. When one or more parents are known to have a genetic disorder, this screening is performed on the embryo to determine if the child will also have the same genetic disorder (Medscape). In the lab fertilization occurs among the egg and the sperm, and then on day

Preventing Genetic Disorders With Gene Therapy Essay

2495 words - 10 pages is called prenatal diagnosis. This method involves performing genetic testing on the amniotic fluid that surrounds the fetus. This fluid contains skin and mucus cells from the fetus itself. The genetic testing is done during the 15th to 17th week of the pregnancy to determine if the fetus has a genetic disorder passed on from the parents. While this method can often relieve the burden of anxiety, if it is negative, it can also create great

Human Cloning Essay

956 words - 4 pages fetalis (a condition in which abnormal amounts of fluid builds up in two or more body areas of a fetus or newborn) and obesity. It is unethical to clone a human knowing that there is a very high chance that the clone will have a genetic disorder. The first step in making cloning ethical is to make sure that every time we clone a human we do it right, which means no gene mutations or physical abnormalities. In order to have a one hundred percent