Promote The Best Qualified, Or Consider Diversity?

2626 words - 11 pages

Promote the Best Qualified, or Consider Diversity?
Eric B. Olsen
Excelsior College
LA498M: LA Capstone-(Military Focus)
Mr. Larry Fegans
4 June 2015

The Army, as part of the Department of Defense (DOD), is the premier military organization in the world. Part of what makes the Army an outstanding organization is the diverse backgrounds that their soldiers are come from. There are African-Americans, Hispanics, Asian-Americans, Native-Americans, Pacific Islanders, and more that help balance out its demographic profile. Soldiers who are Caucasian make up the majority of the Army demographic (Army G1, 2014). What is most impressive is the ability for everyone to work ...view middle of the document...

Organizations must always capitalize on their diverse workforce by acknowledging the strengths and skills of individuals; however, they also must meet any imposed constraints, such as the budget and root purposes. If an organization places specific individuals or groups over others due to their demographic, it will have negative effects that will make an organization suffer from second and third level detriments. This presentation studies whether DODs diversity management goals will continue making the necessary gains in fairness by responding to the following questions:
1. What are the implications of adjusting the initial enlistment criterion to meet force strength requirements?
2. Is “affirmative action” really the right policy for the DOD?
3. Why is there such a big push for integrating women into combat arms positions?
Changing Enlistment Standards to Boost Numbers
In 2004, the DOD allowed its services to relax their entrance criterion in order to facilitate its 2006 surge into Iraq and Afghanistan. Although the surge itself was necessary, the DOD should have better planned for the flux of originally unqualified recruits.
Post-Surge Recovery
Examples of the DODs reduced enlistment criterion are reduced aptitude requirements while loosening the moral standards. This dangerous standards adjustment in 2004 placed the military services in their current predicament as blogger Joseph Galloway (2005) stated, the Army elevated its standards to 67 percent for enlistment criteria categories one through three, and two percent for category four scores in 1979. However, the recent drawdown and limited funding is now forcing the services to decrease their numbers, simply directing them to keep the best and brightest. The solution is requiring the services to provide bigger incentive packages to attract the most qualified citizens to join, and retain those who are currently serving; absorbing more budget resources from defense.
Today’s Basic Training Shows Improvement toward Diversity
The U.S. Army starts the indoctrination process with their new members by sending them to basic training, essentially so these new recruits can learn how to be soldiers. According to authors Goldenberg, M., Hamaoka, D., Santiago P., and McCarroll, J. (2010), “Basic training is an intense period of indoctrination and instruction in military skills, rules and customs, including saluting, proper wearing of the uniform, physical fitness, marksmanship, and some combat procedures” (p. 28). Therefore, as a civilian becomes a Soldier, they begin learning Army culture, values, and use teamwork to accomplish training goals. During nine weeks of basic training, soldiers learn everyone has the same opportunity. Army Regulation (AR) 600-20 (2014) states, “soldiers will not be accessed, classified, trained, assigned, promoted, or otherwise managed on the basis of race, religion, gender, or national origin (p. 55). The Army Equal Opportunity Program (EO) is...

Other Essays Like Promote the Best Qualified, or Consider Diversity?

Diversity in the Workplace Essay

1755 words - 8 pages Cultural Diversity in the Workplace Human resources has a big job when it comes to working with people from all backgrounds. Managing diversity is to plan and implement the organizational system and practices to manage people. Cultural diversity involves the differences in the composition of members of an organization in terms of nationality, race, color, gender, creed, religion, or age (Merchant, 2012). The organization has the

How to Write an Essay

1348 words - 6 pages easily relate with one another, this can be a barrier if for example someone is qualified in terms of skills and competence but can not communicate in a required language. Also in instances where the products or services reach a wide range of clients, it can be a disadvantage to those clients whose language has been left out, and this will mean that they will not consume it. At times this diversity can call grouping in the organization in relation

Human Resource Management

4330 words - 18 pages handled effectively and equitably. On the other hand, they must also endeavor to train their employees, and effectively deal with diversity for better interpersonal relationships among their employees, so that all would contribute to the organization's success in a friendly environment without facing discriminations from their work place. Organizational diversity is more than differences in race, ethnicity or age. It actually encompasses a whole

Final Paper Bus610

2568 words - 11 pages to recruitment, promotion, professional development, and evaluation” (p. 21). In the global market diversity and communication is becoming more relevant with education. There are still obstacles within the corporate domain that an individual should understand about the company that he or she is working for. The best diversified companies suggest that the path to diversity success varies according to the company’s history, culture, and mission

Diversity Audit of Walmart

4034 words - 17 pages because of these values and culture that Wal-Mart continues to make a difference in the lives of customers, members and associates. Selected Criteria/Audit Methods Most large corporations routinely provide some form of diversity training for employees, and many report some measure of success. Diversity training programs can be as short or as long as necessary. However, the training should focus on how people, despite their apparent

Affirmative Action - Essay 7

1688 words - 7 pages all people regardless of race or sex are given the equal opportunity in the admissions and job applications processes. Affirmative action was designed to create this equality. What is Affirmative Action? Affirmative action is a policy of favoring qualified women and minority candidates over qualified men or nonminority candidates with the immediate goals of outreach, remedying discrimination, or achieving diversity and the ultimate goals of

Mt203 Unit 2 Assignment

786 words - 4 pages diversity really are helping it achieve business success? GM could consider benchmarking the company’s diversity program against that of another successful company. For example, they could compare their program to that at Ford Motor Co. Resources are also available to GM such as the Executive Summary of Best Practices in achieving Workforce Diversity sponsored by the U.S. Government. The report benchmarks some of the most successful companies in

Explain Diversity and Equaility

3744 words - 15 pages inclusion. The government has its own mandate to build a safe, just and tolerant society for everyone in the UK, regardless of age, race, religion, gender and gender identity, sexual orientation, disability or age. For practitioners and service providers who value diversity there are a number pieces of legislation in place to promote equality and reduce discrimination, these include • The disability discrimination act 2005. • The race relations

Diversity's Importance to the Competitive Advantage

2022 words - 9 pages that members are not excluded. Utilizing different methods of communication can help to identify barriers or enablers to diversity. The diversity plan is never set in stone. Utilizing an organic philosophy when deciding how to best educate your employees about diversity is important. Creating diversity in the workplace is not only in the best interest of the minority groups, but most importantly it is in the best interest of the company


1269 words - 6 pages States is the most diverse country in the world and no wonder is so economically successful and world super power as compared to other developed nations. I believe this same principle applies to business organization. Take for instance, the U. S, boost of some of the world’s finest or talented physicians due the diverse Nature of its population. Another important case for business diversity is recruitment and retention. When it comes to the

Management Research

5013 words - 21 pages aircraft spare parts. As a multinational company, Satair employs people from different cultural backgrounds in its plants around the world. Consequently, the company’s labor force is characterized by a rich cultural diversity. In this regard, the company’s workforce composition and human resource management will provide a relevant case study for exploring best practices in managing cultural diversity in organizations. Literature Review

Related Papers

Does The Human Rights Act 1998 Promote Or Hinder Democracy?

2584 words - 11 pages those complaints are to be judicially determined. The rights and freedoms which are guaranteed under the Convention are ones with which the people of this country are plainly comfortable. They therefore afford an excellent basis for the Human Rights Bill, which was introduced in October 1998.However, does the Human Rights Act 1998 promote or hinder democracy?The Human Rights Act is different from other laws. It promises that the state will respect

Consider One Or More Of The Ways In Which Irish Fiction Addresses The Subject Of Violence

2413 words - 10 pages also gives the sense that unsympathetic, small town living can be destructive to those who are raised in non-nuclear or dysfunctional families. Her situation demonstrates that problems are often ignored at best, and made taboo at worst. As a result the victims and sufferers are unable to reach out for assistance when they need it the most. Rather than face the stigma that can be attached to speaking out and revealing oneself as ‘different’, a

Children Learn Best By Observing The Behavior Of Adults And Copying It. Do You Agree Or Disagree?

572 words - 3 pages Children learn best by observing the behavior of adults and copying it. Do you agree or disagree? Use specific reasons and examples to support your answer. There is no doubt to the perception of how children learn what is needed in life is by observing the behavior of adults and copying it. This process of copying the behavior of adults is known as modeling. However both positive and negative behavior will be applied by the children and

The Best Way For A Society To Prepare Its Young People For Leadership In Government, Industry Or Other Fields Is By Instilling In Them A Sense Of Cooperation, Not Competition

818 words - 4 pages The assertion that the best way for a society to prepare its young people for leadership in government, industry or other fields is by instilling in them spirit of cooperation & not competition is a controversial one. One viewpoint is that instilling the sense of cooperation in young individuals is the best way to prepare them for leadership in each and every field. While, the other viewpoint is that developing the sense of competition in the