Pros/Cons On Under Cover Police Essay

1574 words - 7 pages

On July 19, an undercover police officer took the stand in a New York courtroom to testify against an alleged drug dealer named Fabian Joseph. Consistent with longstanding practice in New York City, the officer refused to identify himself by anything but his badge number. Inconsistent with longstanding practice in New York City, trial judge Dorothy Cropper barred the officer's testimony. Judge Cropper ruled that because the undercover officer had failed to show he was in particular danger of retaliation from the defendant for his testimony, he had to give his name. When he refused, she showed him the door.
The basis for Judge Cropper's ruling was the Sixth Amendment, which guarantees the ...view middle of the document...

The officer in the Fabian Joseph case was not part of a years-long infiltration into the Mafia. Nor was he apparently involved in a major investigation into a drug market controlled by an organized gang watching its territory, and willing to protect that territory with violence.
In fact, most drug markets are not tightly controlled by drug gangs. Gangs are hard to maintain, and the economic rewards of controlling territory are not always easy to reap. Thus, many drug markets are open - anyone can deal, anyone can buy. These are the easiest markets in which undercover officers can operate, because there is no one keeping a watchful eye on dealers and customers, as a gang enforcer might.
Apparently, the officer in Joseph's case was involved in a standard "buy-bust" operation in an open market. Here's how it works: the officer buys drugs from a dealer, leaves the scene, and then directs a waiting team of officers to the dealer. The officers then arrest the dealer. Next, the undercover officer - from one of those famous "undisclosed locations" - identifies the arrestee as the dealer, and a drug distribution case is born.
The Sixth Amendment Rights to Public Trials and Cross-Examination
The officers in Fabian Joseph's case wanted to testify anonymously. But many NYPD undercover officers also ask judges to close courtrooms. And in fact, the combination seems necessary if an officer is really serious about protecting his identity.
If the courtroom is open and the defendant's confederates can watch the officer's testimony, then the officer's cover is blown. And if the courtroom is closed, but the defendant finds out the officer's name, that's not much better. It's not that hard to put a face to the name.
But for a judge to both close the courtroom and allow a witness for the prosecution to remain anonymous is hard to defend.
To close a courtroom, the judge needs to find an "overriding" state interest that cannot be protected by any other means. Limiting cross-examination is easier. The judge can do that to ensure that a witness is not embarrassed or endangered. Still, asking for basic personal information (such as your name) is standard during cross-examination. And the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly said that when a question is "normally permissible," the witness needs to provide a good reason why it shouldn't be asked in a particular case.
Protecting an undercover officer's identity in your basic buy-bust is unlikely to pass either test. "Overriding" state interests usually involve rather particularized threats connected to a given defendant and a given witness. Even whether there isn't a direct threat, this test can be passed in cases involving organized crime - such as crime families, drug dealing organizations, and biker gangs. But in your typical buy-busts, which are really a tool for attacking street level dealers or disorganized open-air drug markets, it is much harder (absent a specific threat) to make the case that an individual...

Other Essays Like Pros/Cons on Under Cover Police

Home Depot Essay

1842 words - 8 pages expansion of their business and brand name. * Operating leases would not impact debt and balance sheet ratios. * Leases should provide more immediate tax benefits versus capital investments. Cons * Current cash flow from operations may not be able to cover additional lease payments. * Negatively impacts return on sales ratios. d. Pros * Focus its resources to improve sales in existing stores. * Slows the growth of

Reading Comprehension Essay

525 words - 3 pages Reading Comprehension 8 1. Why is it important for an organization to have effective communication? Communication is an asset in making sure that what you want is being passed on correctly to lower employees as well as confirming any information to those above you. It’s also an easy way in keeping up with what, where, and how your staff is doing. 2. Discuss the pros and cons of the grapevine. The grapevine is a useful tool in

Whatever Happened to Penmanship?

1009 words - 5 pages , 2. no real-time updates, 3. may prove expensive over time, and 4. the extra step of recycling when done. As to the pros of online news: 1. 24-hour access, without having to leave home. 2. the ability to read unobtrusively anywhere (without rustling) and in almost any light (depending on screen quality, 3. up-to-the-minute updates and, of course, 4. the ability to voice your opinion in real time. The cons of online news: 1. it is limited to the

Persuasive Essay

912 words - 4 pages pros and cons of this situation I think you should all know the reason as to why the drinking age is 21 anyway. Well, according to a blog from a reputable source called the mental floss, we ended up with a national minimum age of 21 because of the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984. This law doesn't prohibit drinking per se; it merely requires states to outlaw purchase and public possession by people under 21. So, that being said, the

Pros and Cons of Cloning

564 words - 3 pages Contrary to popular notion, cloning started more than a century before Dolly, the first cloned mammal, became famous. It cannot be denied, nonetheless, that Dolly awakened the imagination of the populace regarding the pros and cons of cloning. It is a debate that continues to polarize society 15 years after the birth of the most famous sheep on Earth. Discussion We must emphasize that the cloning referred to in this article refers to

Are Social Networking Sites Beneficial to the Society or Not?

1441 words - 6 pages message that contains a virus or is a phishing scam. In fact, proponents argue that social networking sites make it safe for all the users by having a minimum age requirement as well as default settings based on the user’s age to protect children. For example, FaceBook requires a user to be at least 12 years old and all the profiles under the age of 16 are automatically set on private so that they cannot be found in a general search. This

Policing and Society

5082 words - 21 pages police chiefs are severely constrained (WODI, 1984). And then you have the opposite spectrum arguing that Unions are essential to American law enforcement because of the combination of nature and demands modern police work endures as well as the practices and history of how the U.S. manages police (Kleismet, 1989). Police unionization has its pros and cons, but they can be very different from an individual standpoint. The assumptions of Magenau and

Robin Hood Case #20

1253 words - 6 pages created chaos at camp and endangered the entire outfit. The group had become too large to adequately police under the current system. Robin needs a way to turn away unwelcome volunteers without causing resentment or animosity. 2. Do Robin Hood and the Merry Men need a new mission? Do they need new objectives? Do they need a new strategy? Explain why for each. Yes to mission and strategy, no to new objectives. Robin and his men have been

Northwest General Case Study

714 words - 3 pages 2015_Spring_BA2020EOL51 Due Date: 01/31/2015 Cathy Bostic The Emergency Room at Northwest General Case Study 1. Discuss the pros and cons of using average demand to access capacity requirements. Is this a reasonable approach for the ER? Capacity planning is a long term strategic decision and is the foundations for establishing the level of resources required to effectively run the business. Establishing the right capacity planning

Affordable Care Act

797 words - 4 pages expensive and the quality is not always great, to say the least. Due to costly healthcare, many individuals do not go to doctors on a regular basis, if at all, nor do they take preventative measures to stay healthy. Little do they realize that this causes a snowball effect. Their minor health issues become problematic and need to be treated with more prescription drugs and doctors visits. Ultimately this means the costs that they were under

Final Draft

1235 words - 5 pages enforcements because officers being on the line of duty protect the people from crime that’s being commit by others. Crimes are reported to the police which are called “crimes known to the police “which are the more serious crimes. Every government agency under the American constitution may have its own police force. But there are some pros and cons about the law enforcement for example in 2008 my cousin Michael Taylor was kidnapped from silver

Related Papers

National Healthcare Essay

930 words - 4 pages presidential election, national healthcare will be a hot topic. Americans must take this time to do their research, look at the pros and cons. As we begin to see changes in our current healthcare system it is vital that both sides come together to find a better more feasible solution to our nation’s healthcare problems. Bibliography Holahan, J., & Dorn , S. (2010, June) State Budgets under Federal Health Reform: The Extent and Causes

Grievance Procedure Essay

961 words - 4 pages by this article, the grievance could go to the next step. If the grievant or the union fails to any of the requirement, the hospital will resolve the grievance on the basic of the last response. E. Both parties agree that nothing in this agreement shall affect the enforceability of any registered nurses existing agreement to be bound by the Tenet Fair Treatment. Pros and Cons Pros The grievance procedure offers both parties

National Health Care Essay

594 words - 3 pages All Americans? http://www.balancedpolitics.org/universal_health_care.htm eHow (2013), Pros & Cons of National Healthcare, http://www.ehow.com/facts_5495188_pros- cons-national-healthcare.html Hundred (2013), The Pros and Cons of Universal Health Care Insurance, http://hundredages. com/pros-cons-universal-health-care-insurance.html Ireland, K (2011), Pros & Cons of Free Universal Health Care, http://www.livestrong.com

Obamacare Essay

804 words - 4 pages . Each year, $125 million will go towards funding school-based health centers and programs to reduce teen pregnancy (Alex, 2012). Along with the pros of this bill are of course the cons which is where the Constitution is questioned and whether or not the Federal Government is violating Amendments. The main con of this bill is the fact that the Federal Government is intruding on the practices of medicine. There are fine lines being crossed and in