Qualitative Article Review

945 words - 4 pages

Qualitative Article Review:

Liberty University

In this article, Assistive Devices for Children with Functional Impairments: Impact on Child and Caregiver Function, the authors, Stacey Henderson, Heather Skelton and Peter Rosenbaum, aim to determine the impact of assistive devices on the components of functioning as defined by the World Health Organization’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF). The ICF is both a model for considering functioning and a classification system to describe health status. It defines health as the result of a dynamic interaction between a person’s domains (Body Structure and Function, Activity, and Participation) ...view middle of the document...

If concerns arose about the appropriateness of a study it was read by both lead authors and discussed until consensus was reached. Early in the review process, five studies were selected which represented a variety of designs and interventions; these were read and summarized by both reviewers. Results were compared and discrepancies discussed until consensus was reached. This activity was repeated late in the review process to ensure consistency was being maintained. No consequential discrepancy was found in the data extracted. Study design was also considered in determining inclusion for this review: only primary research was included, reporting studies published in a peer reviewed journal.
The child-focused outcomes, mainly classified under the categories of activity, participation, and personal factors, were overwhelmingly positive with few undesirable outcomes reported. Results of this study show a strongly positive impact of assistive devices, suggesting that providing them to children with functional impairments can be an important intervention strategy.
Critical Analysis
Results of this study show a strongly positive impact of assistive devices, suggesting that providing them to children with functional impairments can be an important intervention strategy. However, the outcome did not show the devices effect on speech for the users. It did not show whether the use of the devices hindered verbal communication in the children. I think that is an opportunity for further research. The effect of assistive devices on verbal communication for children who have some language and for those who have none should be studied. This study was useful in identifying the breadth of the literature but limits the ability to translate results into specific practice recommendations. There was often uncertainty about the psychometric properties of the outcome measures, leaving open to question the validity of the findings, or how the studies might be replicated. These observations point to the continuing need for valid and reliable standardized measures of these outcomes.
Results of this study show a strongly positive impact of assistive devices, suggesting that providing them to children with functional impairments can be an important intervention strategy.
Peer Editing Rubric for the Qualitative Article Review

Author of Review:

Peer Editor:

|Summary |2.5 |2 |1.5 |1 |0 |Total |
|Description of |Thorough description of |Good description of |Acceptable |Little, if any, |Incomplete |2.5 |
|Participants/Sample |participants/sample, |participants sample and|description of |description of | | |
| |including sample |sample selection |participants sample |sample. No mention...

Other Essays Like Qualitative Article Review

Evaluating the Research Process Essay

1484 words - 6 pages literature review used in this article examines how patient's right to privacy terms be violated and how biometric technologies can ease or eliminate the consequences related. The literature review details how the implementation of biometric technologies can be important for identification, verification, and for compliance with patient privacy laws. Literatures used in this study were obtained through proQuest databases from Walden University, and

Research Methods Essay

2311 words - 10 pages 1 IntroductionProfessional football has been radically transformed in the UK during the 1990sand Premiership league take place at nearly the same time. After almost ten years, the professional football marketing became a big business. In the 1997/98 football season, the Premier league got benefits over 100 million. Therefore, this article introduces an initial indication of how the two Premiership football clubs (Liverpool and Everton) situated

Adherence to Antibiotic Therapy

906 words - 4 pages the study” (Göktay, Telefoncu, Kadıoƃlu, Macit, Şencan, & Clark, 2013, p. 113). It is a nurse’s role before discharge to explain the importance of adhering to the exact medication regimen prescribed. According to the article Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Information Systems Research, “ Qualitative strategies emphasize an interpretive approach that uses data to both pose and resolve research questions. Researchers develop

Expanded Comparison Of Leadership Articles

1711 words - 7 pages This is a comparison of three articles and all the components which are required for a research study. It is a qualitative assessment conducted to measure the validity of research articles, and is accomplished by comparing, contrasting and synthesizing the information. Article one; is a study of existing paradigms which studies the leadership known as transformational. It is suggested in this article that public organizations are not as

Effects of Govt Bailouts

1547 words - 7 pages connectivity of firms greatly influence the amount bailed out and speed of government response. The article is of great help to my research as it will enable me indicate how political connectivity of firms influence government bailouts. Smith, R. C. (2011). The Dilemma of Bailouts. INDEPENDENT REVIEW, 16(1), 15-26. The author conducted the study in respect of the 2008 financial crisis in the U.S banking sector and how the government handled

Evidence Based Practice Task 2 (Wgu)

3800 words - 16 pages patient involvement and hence contributes towards patient-centred care. The research article generates further knowledge in clinical handover in the rural setting especially on clinical handover methods. Kerr, D., McKay, K., Klim, S., Kelly, A. & McCann, T. (2013). Attitudes of Emergency Department Patients about Handover at the Bedside. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 23, 1685-1693. The qualitative descriptive study used semi-structured

Evidence Based Practice

2551 words - 11 pages changes which in turn could have had a detrimental impact on the process. Research findings in the conventional research can take up to two years before they are published however, in action research the emphasis is on the here and now, Parahoo (1997). Subjects Non-probability is the method of sampling employed within the article which is not clearly stated. Qualitative researchers use non- probability samples as the purpose of qualitative

Lowe's Paper

983 words - 4 pages October 2009 inspection by OSHA, there were four willful citations in the Cincinnati stores, and in November 2009 there were seven citations in the Dayton stores. According to OSHA standards, willful violation is one committed with intentional, knowing or voluntary disregard for the law’s requirement or plain indifference to employee safety and health ("Lowe’s Home Centers Recordkeeping Violations," 2010). | Qualitative approach

A Critical Evaluation of: ‘the Crossover of Burnout and Work Engagement Among Young Couples’

1663 words - 7 pages constructionist perspective, yet the measurements used define the ‘stressor’ (work) as tangible, firmly indicating an objectivist stance. In conclusion, one can usually follow a distinctive narrative to define the differences of a qualitative and quantitative study; and the article does just this. Although the paper has highlighted an argument in areas for both competing styles of either methodology, epistemology or ontology, one can

Comp Paper

1614 words - 7 pages Expanded Comparison Matrix | |Article 1 |Article 2 |Article 3 | |Title/Author(s) |Transformational Leadership in the Public Sector: Does Structure |The Effect Of Transactional and Transformational |The Reality of Web-Based Interaction in an


3413 words - 14 pages . The article importance or moral sensitivity when including persons with dementia in qualitative research, Nursing Ethics, (Heggestad, A., Nortvedt, P. & Slettebo, A. 2013). Best describes the important issues is the understanding of schizophrenia and within the field of psychiatry. There are many issues from the past years that have not been resolved. Ethical concerns about schizophrenia research have been raised, for the most part because of

Related Papers

Qualitative Research Article Critique Nrs 433v

1044 words - 5 pages Qualitative Research Article Critique Marianne Green Grand Canyon University Introduction to Nursing Research NRS 433V July 21, 2012 Qualitative Research Article Critique Deciding to proceed with a surgical procedure is not always easy to achieve. Financial concerns are considered due to the time off of work that is necessary for the recovery process. Reduction in income due to surgical procedures can place a hardship on society

Research Terms Essay

1238 words - 5 pages article, this answer is at the beginning of the Discussion section.  But you may have to look around the Discussion section for it. 2. Research Methods Qualitative research methods * Interviews Interviews are particularly useful for getting the story behind a participant’s experiences. The interviewer can pursue in-depth information around the topic. Interviews may be useful as follow-up to certain respondents to questionnaires, e.g., to

Analytical Critique Essay

1579 words - 7 pages Quality Research Article Critique Factors Influencing Emergency Use of Nurse Practitioners: A Critique Problem and Purpose This is critique of a Qualitative Nursing article, the article is: Factors Influencing the Decision to Use Nurse Practitioners in the Emergency Department by Laurie A. McGee, MN, ARNP and Louise Kaplan, PhD, ARNP, published in Journal of Emergency Nursing, Volume 33, Number 5, October 2007. The problem that is stated in

Adherance Essay

840 words - 4 pages preeclampsia. The introduction of this article does give a sense of the importance of the problem area. This four-year study investigates the effects of walking or stretching on the incidence of preeclampsia and reports on adherence to the intervention and on the secondary outcomes of changes in resting heart rate (HR), resting blood pressure and weight gain. Problem Statement The purpose of the study was to compare a walking exercise to a