Racial And Civic Nationalism Essay

1691 words - 7 pages

Essay #1

In his book American Crucible: Race and Nation of the Twentieth Century, Gary Gerstle shows us how much of 20th-century American history can be understood in terms of the changes in how Americans generally and politicians in particular balanced civic and racial nationalism. Gary Gerstle argues that racial and civic nationalism are two largely separate ideological strains that have animated the political history of the United States in the 20th-century (p. 5). When it comes to Civic nationalism, Gerstle put it as an “... American belief in the fundamental equality of all human beings, in every individual’s inalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, and ...view middle of the document...

He does it by looking at the work of American Liberal, such as Theodore Roosevelt, particularly the “Winning of the west”. In some ways Theodore Roosevelt is the figure that dominates this book. The reason he uses the American Liberal as one of his primary evidence to prove his argument is because they were very influential.
In American Crucible, Gerstle relies heavily on Theodore Roosevelt for his inspiration in interpreting the state and nationalism. Gerstle sees Roosevelt vacillating between these two strands of nationalism in almost schizophrenic way, though with civic nationalism largely holding sway. In the chapter 1 which is titled “Theodore Roosevelt’s Racialized Nation, 1890 - 1900” Gerstle uses Roosevelt work “The winning of the west (1989)” to make his case how Roosevelt racialized the American through his work. In Roosevelt’s eyes, the history of racial conflict pointed in the direction of civilization and progress (p. 18). Roosevelt believed that the higher civilized races triumphed over the lower savage or barbaric ones. He uses the Backwoodsmen as an ultimate example to show what and how American people should be. In his eyes these backwoodsmen who bravely ventured forth into the trans-Appalachian wilderness to battle Indian and clear the land were warrior above all. He compares them to the Germans who had invaded Britain and that their primary task were relentless war against the savage Indians who claimed these lands as their own (p. 19). One way this come to be was through war and defeating the enemy. Few man wished for war like Theodore Roosevelt did Gerstle admits. His ferocious energy seems to reach from the grave and grab hold of Gerstle's imagination, much as it did that of the Rough Rider's contemporaries. Moreover, Roosevelt makes Gerstle's argument: "If for Karl Marx history was the history of class conflict, for Roosevelt it was the history of race conflict" (p. 17). Roosevelt offered a history of racial thinking in his times. He compares how an English speaking people conquered North America. Gerstle’s brings to the point how Roosevelt though racial mixing and racial assimilation provided these were properly controlled by the superior race could benefit the nation very much (p. 19). He lead them to war in which he created his Rough Riders, a melting pot in Roosevelt’s eye. This warior were different backgrounds, but they did not include Indian, women, black and Chinese. We referred to as “Rooseveltian nationalism”. It is like a small racial nation that Theodore Roosevelt created. But it only superior race were in it. Later on as the war was on the way, The Ninth Tenth Cavalry played a key role in helping Roosevelt and his Rough Rider win the war. The contribution of these soldiers were acknowledged by Roosevelt and other whites soldiers at the time but later denied (p. 34). This created a problem for Roosevelt to his idea of Civic and racial nationalism, which was supposed to be made of superior race.
In chapter...

Other Essays Like Racial and Civic Nationalism

The Enlightenment Movement Essay

971 words - 4 pages early stages. The Enlightenment promoted equality of all nationalities and religions, as well as rational in knowledge. Nationalism allowed countries to be patriotic (in terms of its best aspect), and in the same instance caused wars and evoked racial divide of certain national groups that were governed by foreign countries. The ideologies of Nationalism became the movement that caused countries to become both exclusive and separate. “It is

Appendix E Essay

864 words - 4 pages , traditions, and civic education. European American cultural lineages can be traced back to Western Europe and is industrialized in the form of its government, traditions, and civic education. European Americans are descendants from colonial American stock and are colonial ancestry. • What are some of the larger racial minorities in U.S. history? What have been the common ancestral backgrounds of each of these groups? When did

Sea Colonial Policies Nationalism

1639 words - 7 pages MJC: To what extent were colonial policies the main reason for the lack of progress of pre-WWII nationalism in SEA? (I try to brainstorm on colonial policies and see what I can come up with first) Intro: Definitions: -Lack of progress: tangible vs intangible progress/ultimate aim of independence -colonial policies: direct/indirect rule, benign/brutal colonial masters which affects their policy stance -nationalism: a political and social

Culture Essay

638 words - 3 pages America’s images. I think the importance and relevance of Langston Hughes work was to mainly give African American hopes for a better future and to remind them how important they were even if others viewed them as ugly or unworthy. He stressed a racial consciousness and cultural nationalism devoid of self-hate. His thought united people of African descent and Africa across the globe to encourage pride in their diverse black folk culture

The Ballot Or The Bullet By Malcolm X

847 words - 4 pages rhetoric. His tone comes across as not only angry and frustrated but also pleading. Given the context, during racial discrimination and turmoil in this country, it makes sense for Malcolm X to talk this way. The movement Malcolm X called “Black Nationalism” seems to be meant as a counter to King’s wish for integration. In his speech Malcolm X explains to his audience why Black Nationalism was the best way forward for the black community. According

Impacts of Art in Life

1828 words - 8 pages . | | | |As with most popular academic concepts, there is no universally accepted definition of either civil society or the related | |notions of a civic culture and social capital. In one of the best

The Debate over Multicultural Education in America

3388 words - 14 pages work at achieving harmony in a varied racial country. Works Cited Banks, James A. "Multicultural Literacy and Curriculum Reform." The Education Digest 13 Dec. 1991: 10-13. Cleveland, Harlan. "The Limits To Cultural Diversity." The Futurist March - April 1995 : 23-6. Duignan, Peter. "The Dangers of Multiculturalism." Vital Speeches of the Day 22 Mar. 1995 : 492-493. Gagnon, Paul. "Balancing Multicultural and Civic Education Will Take

The Chicano And The Black Power Movements

3131 words - 13 pages on the states to give them their rights, but they were willing to give themselves their own rights, pushing for Chicano and Black Nationalism. The growing racism and discrimination that both races experienced helped to mold their similar ideologies as both sought for the end of these negative acts. For example, most people connect lynching to African Americans during this movement, but what is left unsaid is that Mexican Americans were also

Black Press Day

1750 words - 7 pages perspectives and has made them be respectful for colored people in the world. Three millions that are now in the United States, and the eight millions that in twenty or twenty five years, will be in this country. Harlem Renaissance is very similar to Black Press day. The Harlem Renaissance resulted in African-American artists gaining the attention of whites and raising awareness by promoting ideas like racial integration and cooperation, which

Compare the Features of Nazism and Fascism

1483 words - 6 pages individual." Fascism believes in the ‘corporatism’ of all elements in society to form an ‘Organic State’. They were not racial and had no strong opinion of any race. For Fascists, the state was the most important element. The Doctrine of Fascism, which is the authoritative document of the fascism, emphasis on nationalism, corporatism, totalitarianism and militarism. According to this Doctrine the State is all embracing and no human or spiritual value

Racial Identity & Mental Health

3621 words - 15 pages significantly. There were six factors on the CRIS that emerged as independent constructs—Pre-Encounter (Assimilation, Miseducation, and Self-Hatred), Immersion-Emersion Anti-White, Internalization (Black Nationalism and Multiculturalism). Mental health was conceptualized through the Mental Health Questionnaire, the Satisfaction With Life Scale and the Affectometer 2. Results indicated that racial identity (a reference group orientation variable

Related Papers

Notes On Nationalism A2 Government And Politics

1127 words - 5 pages nations who showed the strongest unity would prevail. - This differs from cultural nationalism as it attempts to protect minority cultures being threatened by another culture. Inclusive/exclusive and civic/ethno cultural nationalisms * Civic nationalism: nationhood is defined by common citizenship. A civic nation consists of those who subscribe to its political creed, regardless of ethnicity, race, colour, religion, gender or language

What Does It Mean To Be An American? Patriotism, Nationalism, And American Identity After 9/11

5537 words - 23 pages Political Psychology, Vol. 25, No. 5, 2004 What Does It Mean to Be an American? Patriotism, Nationalism, and American Identity After 9/11 Qiong Li Mershon Center, Ohio State University Marilynn B. Brewer Department of Psychology, Ohio State University The period of heightened nationalism in the United States that followed the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 provided unusual conditions for investigating issues surrounding the

Nationalism Is A Negative Entity Essay

1249 words - 5 pages Nationalism has many definitions and is a universal entity that can be seen as malevolent or benevolent. Nationalism cannot be limited to one definition because there are far too many aspects of nationalism such as cultural, ethnic, civic, relationship to land, etc. Nationalism can be seen as a double-edged sword which can be used to protect and aid its people. However, this same sword is a weapon; and a weapon’s primary purpose is to inflict

Racial Diversity Essay

719 words - 3 pages Racial Diversity: Historical Worksheet Donald K. Morgan Building Organizational Capacity Juancho A. Lim June 5, 2013 Throughout most of U.S. history, in most locations, what race has been in the majority? What is the common ancestral background of most members of this group? According to "The Changing Racial And Ethnic Composition Of The Us Population" In the nineteenth and early