Recall Bias In Research Design Essay

831 words - 4 pages

It is most likely every major text on epidemiology involved in retrospective research is influenced by recall bias. Scientists have identified recall bias to occur when accuracy of recall regarding prior exposure is different for cases versus control (RAPHAEL, 1987). The possibility for recall bias exists whenever historical self-report information is elicited from respondents (RAPHAEL, 1987). Therefore, the potential for the occurrence is likely to be greatest in case-control studies or cross-sectional studies with retrospective elements, as well as some cohort prospective and control randomized trial designs (Hassan, 2006). Since recall bias is an undesired element, intended to potentially ...view middle of the document...

If those risk factors which appear to be significantly related to case status are not believed by respondents to be risk factors for the disease at all, one possesses fairly good evidence of absence of recall bias (RAPHAEL, 1987).

I have analyzed a case study on alcohol and substance abuse disorders resulting in attending a non-fatal emergency room, for recall bias. A Case-Control Study of Alcohol and Substance Abuse Disorders as Risk Factors for Non-Fatal Injury, in the Oxford Journal, provide methodology for review. The article is a case control study, includes 653 injured patients ages between 18-65 years old who attended one emergency room south of Mexico City (BORGES, 2005). The study considered a control including 1131 subjects from a representative sample of residents of Mexico City, of the same age group (BORGES, 2005). It was reported, the information on drug and alcohol use was obtained by interview using the world mental health version of the composite international diagnostic interview (BORGES, 2005). The interview was conducted shortly after admission to the emergency room by the interviewer. It was necessary to have respondents report usage of alcohol or drug use for the last 12 months. Statistical tables were created to reflect hospitalization recorded information and recalled respondent information. Trained lay interviewers were used to collect pertinent information designed to indicate age, type substance abuse, frequency and relationship status (BORGES, 2005). No financial compensation was given to subjects and consent was given, with careful description of the goals of the study (BORGES, 2005). The interviews were reported to have been recorded by paper...

Other Essays Like Recall Bias In Research Design

Family Functionality And Academic Performance Essay

2655 words - 11 pages OUTPUT #3 Research Design Research Question: The Relationship of Family Functionality and the Academic Performance of Students at the De La Salle Health Sciences Institute, College of Medicine in the First Semester of the School Year 2012-2013 General Objectives: To determine the effect of Family Functionality in the Academic Performance of Students at the De La Salle Health Sciences Institute

Country of Origin Essay

3603 words - 15 pages , sustainability) as most important, often not even taking COO into account (Samiee, Shimp & Sharma, 2005). Research on the effects of domestic country bias on the consumers’ preferences and buying decisions in specific countries for domestic products and brands, also show that other factors than COO are crucial (Balabanis & Diamantopoulos, 2004). Published articles on COO are often not distinctive to each other, most are directly related to

Data Analysis for Efficiency

727 words - 3 pages and 16 logos), the author feels that these tests may have fatigue and this might have affected their performance. The second limitation is the overestimation of recall performance of irrelevant information. The reason was that the snack and PDA banner both were placed in same location on rotating bias. This will also give the answer to the question that why the snack banners were recalled, even though they were considered relevant

Outline and Evaluate Research Into the Duration, Capacity, and Encoding of Information in Short-Term Memory

641 words - 3 pages knew they were going to be asked to recall the items after an interval filled with a distracting activity. George Miller wrote a memorable article about the capacity of short-term memory, called ‘The magic number seven plus or minus two’. In this article, he reviewed psychological research and concluded that the span of immediate memory is 7, people can cope reasonably well with counting 7 dots flashed onto a screen by not many more than this. He

Descriptive Research Designs

2290 words - 10 pages doing preliminary quality control checks to evaluate the accuracy and completeness of the frame. This error results from flaws in research design (e.g., incorrect definition of population of interest). It can be reduced or minimized only by means of more careful consideration and definition of the population of interest. This error results from the use of incomplete or improper sampling procedures or when appropriate procedures are not followed. It

Intelligence Report - Personality

999 words - 4 pages visual images. Ability to perceive, analyse and generate visual shapes and patterns. Ability to store and recall visual information and representations. Short Term Memory Ability to attend to, store and recall information which we are aware of in the immediate situation (eg. Events that occurred in the last minute or so). The Test Items: The tests are designed for anyone who is normally capable of sight and hearing and has no

General Motors Ignition Switch

1737 words - 7 pages better compete with global operators.  As of December 31, 2013, GM's total assets were 166,334,000 and its total liabilities were 123,737,000. General Motors has defined their organizational culture as "Design, Build and Sell the World's Best Vehicles". In the design portion of this definition, GM focuses on core brands in order to become a leader in research and development. In the build portion of this definition, GM strives to operate in an

Mktg 400 Midterm

1349 words - 6 pages | _____________ results form mistakes or problems in the research design. | |  A.Systematic error | | |  B.Processing error | | |  C.Interviewer error | | |  D.Random error | | |  E.None of the above | | Answer Key: A | | | Question 17 of 25 | 4.0 Points | A questionnaire that is not computer coded, thereby increasing the complexity of inputting the questionnaire data into a database, will probably suffer from which of the

Psychology Terms and Conditions

1770 words - 8 pages remember, they often misremember the information by incorporating the misleading material into the event. 9. Eyewitness Testimony: Research on memory has important implications for examining eyewitness testimony and the prevention of innaccuries. For example, research has found that if people are forewarned that an interrogation can create a memory bias, they are less likely to be influenced by leading questions. People in the legal field

Nonsense Syllabus

647 words - 3 pages words in 2 seconds intervals. A different core sheet was used for recording for each participant. 3. 4. AIM: This research is to determine whether the recall of nonsense syllabus will greatly influence by the position of items studied. 5. HTPOTHESIS: H1 – the recall of nonsense syllabus will greatly be influenced by the position of items studied. But those who 6. OPERATIONAL EFINITION OF TERMS: 5. METHODOLOGY -A total of 60

Social Science

1013 words - 5 pages factors also tend to reflect weaknesses in most developing country settings such as poor law enforcement, poverty, the unpredictability of local and national politics and changes in leadership. Successful project exit strategies and increased participation by the private sector may also reflect either the project design or a combination of design and the implementing entity bias of government, in most cases. ARTICLE IN PRESS From our review, the

Related Papers

Mr. Calvin Greene Essay

1316 words - 6 pages to be recalled vividly than mundane experiences, and neurobiological research has confirmed that the occurrence of affective responses can increase the likelihood that an event is stored in memory. Most memories are incomplete. Even a seemingly vivid memory of a dinner at a restaurant is unlikely to include details such as the design of the silverware or the color of the napkins. Even “flashbulb memories” are not wholly like a

Social Work Dissertation Proposal Plan Essay

1353 words - 6 pages using these tools and to show I have been systematic in my research approach. As Rutter et al. (2010: 50) pointS out: “ The relevance of a study to the review topic, and the appropriateness of design to address the review question, are two aspects of quality; the integrity of the methods used in the study, and the confidence we can have in its findings, are others ”. * My research demonstrated a high level of quantitative/qualitative

The Effects Of The Pollyanna Principle When Remembering And Recalling Pleasant And Unpleasant Words

1897 words - 8 pages ). Numerous studies have also supported this fact by illustrating that people tend to display optimistic beliefs of themselves (Larwood & Whittaker, 1977; Svenson, 1981, as cited in Silvera, Krull & Sassler, 2002) and the external world around them (Klar & Gilda, 1997, as cited in Silvera et al., 2002).One of the basis arising from the Pollyanna Principle contend that people are more accurate in learning and the subsequent recall of

Effects Of Mood And Memory Essay

1477 words - 6 pages -image. Error in this area would also affect the studies internal validity. Additionally, the study did not evaluate education level, as higher levels of education may be related to a higher level of recall ability. This is a relationship that should be assessed in future research. The construct validity of the study may have been affected by the scale used to assess a negative mood state. The PANAS questionnaire only depicted ten negative