Religious Belief And Skeptical Responses Essay

2186 words - 9 pages

Although dismissed by many philosophers as nonsensical and irrelevant, religious beliefs are still held by over half of the world's population and therefore the subject must be valid as an area of intellectual discussion. This particular area of thought gives rise to much skeptical debate as the logical fallacies offered by believers seem flawed when held to close scrutiny. It is particularly interesting in that the skeptical problems also go further than merely questioning the validity of the proofs but in fact can be taken so far as to actually question the validity of the original presupposition; that is, that we can even sensibly ask the question, "Does God exist," in the first ...view middle of the document...

This idea is explained metaphorically by Descartes when he claims that "there is no less contradiction in conceiving a God, that is to say, who lacks some particular perfection, than in conceiving a mountain without a valley (144)."The fallacy of this argument, it would be argued by a skeptic, lies in the logic and the incorrect predicate that existence is necessarily a form of perfection (Sawyer, 193). For example, it is possible to imagine a perfect rose that is immaculate in shape, color and scent, and to claim to understand the essence of this rose in a theoretical sense. However, the question of whether this rose actually exists in the material world still remains, which shows that existence is not a predicate of perfection. An apologist's final remark on this subject would be to claim that the definition of existence is wrong and that God's existence would be a necessary existence, which can be thought of as eternity. The skeptic would point out that no object can exist out of necessity as any object that exists may or may not exist and to apply the necessity rule would mean this cannot be so. To argue that that eternity solves these problems is also wrong as it is possible that God could be eternal if he existed, but then we are by default considering the idea that he may not exist and therefore we have a conflict with the original supposition that he must exist out of necessity.The second argument that a skeptic would find criticisms with is that known as the cosmological argument. This argument maintains that everything in the universe has a cause. These causes in turn have causes and so on (Sawyer, 52). It seems that we can always regress the question why for the creation of finite matter and yet there must be a point, maintain the apologists, where we arrive at an uncaused origin of these regressions, and this point it is argued is God.The skeptical challenge to this argument focuses on the claim that every series must have an origin. This is simply untrue. For example, the series of proper fractions has no first term. It is also possible to criticize the way the argument assumes that to explain something fully, a full regression of causation must take place, as this again is just not true. Take for example any form of plant life. It is possible to explain the origin of a weed by explaining how the combination of a seed, the earth, the sun and the rain all combined to produce it. A perfectly adequate answer to explain the origin of the weed can be arrived at without need to explain also the origins of the components that created the weed. The argument also becomes illogical once the final uncaused origin is cited as God, for why can it not simply be called the universe? There are no adequate grounds to assume that the origin must be God.The third argument for God is that of the argument of design (Mcinerny, 90). When we survey the world and universe around us, the apologists say, we must surely not fail to be impressed by the...

Other Essays Like Religious Belief And Skeptical Responses

Latin American Culture Essay

611 words - 3 pages their gender attitudes and roles. Section one describes the symbolic and participatory opportunities that each group offers women. Section two examines the responses to these opportunities and argues that, while both CEB and pentecostal women reconceptualize gender roles, the two religious settings produce different outcomes. The analysis is pre-theoretical. Few specific hypotheses about the relationship between religion and the

Foundationalism, Coherentism, And The Justification Of Knowledge

796 words - 4 pages In this short paper I will examine the positions of foundationalism and coherentism, and argue that a form of weak foundationalism is the most satisfactory option as a valid theory of justification for knowledge and is therefore a viable way of avoiding any sort of vicious regress problem and skepticism. Foundationalism addresses the infinite regress problem in the following way: if person O is to be justified in having belief X, X must be


1443 words - 6 pages and princes: 2, 3, 8, 9 Religious influences: 1, 3, 4, 6 End to Serfdom: 2, 3, 4RESPONSESCondemnation : 1, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12 Riots/plundering : 5, 6, 7, 11 Peasants' responses : 2, 3, 6 Empathy: 2, 5, 9Towns' responses : 4, 5, 9 Nobles' responses : 4, 5, 9 Lay religious figures/favorable responses : 2, 6 Favorable : 2, 3, 6, 9Religious authorities/negative responses: 5, 7, 8 Appeasement : 4, 10, 11 Unfavorable: 1, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12EXPANDED

Health and Social Care Level 2 P4 Unit 2

916 words - 4 pages Equalities Act legislation 2010 The Equality Act protects people from discrimination because of religion or religious or philosophical belief. To be protected, a person must belong to a religion that has a clear structure and belief system. Denominations or sects within a religion can be considered a protected religion or religious belief, for instance Protestants and Catholics within Christianity. A philosophical belief must satisfy various

Religion and society

2175 words - 9 pages , “I suspect that Europeans are increasingly repelled by the societal performance of the Christian states (Gledhill 1).” A paper published by the Journal of Religion and Society says: “Many Americans believe their church going nation is an exceptional God-blessed shining city on a hill that is and as impressive example for increasingly skeptical world. In general, high rates of belief in and worship a creator correlate with a high rate of

My Personal World View

1035 words - 5 pages can’t touch or see it it is not real. The writer feels there is no spirituality in that belief. According to the American Nurses Association with regard to spirituality in nursing: we believe that “attention to the range of human experiences and responses to health and illness within the physical and social environments” is at the center of all of modern nursing practice. Faith, religion, and spirituality are distinct components of what defines

Thomas Jefferson's Statute Of Religious Freedom

1106 words - 5 pages the religious situation of the time. Their general belief was that discrimination against certain religious beliefs, or lack thereof, was unjust and corruptive of the true meaning of religion.Jefferson's Virginia Statute of Religious Freedom expanded on this. Attempting to impose religious belief on someone and expecting him or her to contribute was viewed as "sinful and tyrannical," and forcing them to support and spread the "religious persuasion

The Dead of God in the Modern Society

2511 words - 11 pages “THE DEATH OF GOD” IN THE MODERN SOCIETY INTRODUCTION: Throughout the history of mankind, there have always been certain things that separate men from animals. The opposable thumb, the superior intelligence, and the capacity to make tools are just a few of the things that separate man from beast. Yet one of the longest established and most controversial of these human characteristics is religion. Archaeologists have found that religious

Compare American beliefs or values with your country. List some differences such as culture, relegion, food, etc

377 words - 2 pages that American value is belief in religious. There are many kinds religious in America like Judaism, Christianity, Islam and many others. Judaism is divided on many groups. Orthodox and Reformers. Orthodox belief that if a child was born in a Jewish mother he or she is considered a Jewish person, but the reformers belief that if the father was Jewish and the child was born in a Russian mother it considered that the child is Jewish. However it was different in Ukraine. Most of the people were ashamed of their relegion.All these beliefs and values listed above have many differences in food, culture and religious.

Mgt 521 Final Exam Latest Online Homework Help

1795 words - 8 pages against a noncompetitor. Download for answers MGT 521 Final Exam 10. If a manager rationalizes that he or she does not have time to investigate the source of a problem and instead resorts to putting out fires, the manager is missing the use of ________. • bureaucratic control • basic corrective action • concurrent control • immediate corrective action 11. Which leadership theory is derived from the belief that a

"Religious fundamentalism and terrorism are products of globalisation

2834 words - 12 pages PLT3980: Issues in Global Politics "Religious fundamentalism and terrorism are products of globalisation. Discuss." Following evidence of a revitalisation in religious faith1 throughout the world, and a series of terrorist incidents purportedly motivated by religious fundamentalism, various commentators have argued globalisation has ushered in new forms of radical religious belief and expression and a unique form of

Related Papers

Potential For Buddhism In The West

2548 words - 11 pages that is inherent within nature, and therefore can attain peace and enlightenment. Enlightenment can only be sought through finding the middle path, which is a place within, free of suffering and free of attachment to outside objects. Therefore, it is to the discovery of those who have ameliorated their obsession with materialism and superficial gains in Western society.The teachings of Buddhism denote to the general belief in the cycle of life and

The Worldview Of A Man Essay

2194 words - 9 pages It is crucial to have a complete understanding of how one is to view and respond to the problems of the world in light of the different schools of thought. This is best done with a worldview. A worldview is a comprehensive collection of one's beliefs in every area of rational thought. It dictates a person's actions and responses to the world in which they live. In addition to providing the details of one’s beliefs, a worldview has the added

4152252525 Essay

748 words - 3 pages religious household and still maintaining a belief in God, he was skeptical of religion in later life and was an agnostic.[11][12][13][14][15][16] The common myths concerning Kant's personal mannerisms are enumerated, explained, and refuted in Goldthwait's introduction to his translation of Observations on the Feeling of the Beautiful and Sublime.[17] It is often held that Kant lived a very strict and predictable life, leading to the oft-repeated

Religious Health Care Essay

2216 words - 9 pages feasible. Obviously this is not possible for every decision that the board has to make but, when possible, employee involvement in the decision making process will solidify the belief that they are a part of a team and not just and expendable commodity. I would recommend that Religious Health Care consider including its employees in decisions such as benefits packages. If employees are part of the decision making process, management is less likely to