Response Paper On Post Structuralism

1111 words - 5 pages

Response Paper on Post Structuralism
The idea of meaninglessness that is tantamount to the belief of Post structuralism came into being with the ‘age without reason’, otherwise known as the post- modern era. While defying the possibility of a ‘structure’, it established a center of belief that there are only multiple interpretations, but never a meaning. A word may be interpreted in many ways; it may generate multiple sound images or represent a number of concepts, but until and unless all of them are congruent to each other, defining the ‘meaning’ of the word will always be impossible. If we take into consideration the ever famous example of ‘God’, the sign may lack a concrete signifier ...view middle of the document...

He aims to dig up the history behind and deconstruct social constructs by inverting common binary oppositions. For example, the uneasiness and fear of society’s reaction towards the idea of gifting a doll to a boy child showers light upon the hierarchies set up within society in the binaries of ‘man’ and ‘woman’.
He is also against the idea of the transcendental signifier because it can’t be defined without being differentiated from another transcendental signifier. But the idea of more than one center is not explicitly explained. The explanation of the fact that the existence of any structure is impossible without a center using the example of Levi Strauss’ work, however, seems wanting. That his discourse, both, “reflects itself and criticizes itself”, makes one understand Derrida’s technique of writing better.
He introduces the concept of ‘free play’ which attempts to ignite an idea without any center, if that is ever possible. This concept reminds one of Barthes’ idea of the ‘birth of a reader’ by the ‘death of the author’ which is only possible when one disengages oneself from the center of the author, who is away from the whole structure of interpretation.
MH Abrams in his essay The Deconstructive Angel (1977) seems to debate with himself for several pages about Derrida’s deconstruction theory and Miller’s adaptation of it, but concludes that the absence of ‘a’ meaning is rather a good reason for the continuity of healthy debate. He writes about the substantiality of errors that may or may not occur in a historian’s interpretation of another’s work, but fails to mention who should be the judge of them?
His essay is basically a reply to Hillis Miller’s review of Abrams’s book, Natural Supernaturalism (1973) and is replete with contradictions from both the critics. Miller asserts his belief in Nietzsche’s contradictory statements about the possibility of multiple interpretations and that of no interpretation. This also stands synchronous to the first paragraph written in this paper.
Miller believes that Abrams can never be right in his interpretation and Abrams in turn, labels Miller a ‘deconstructive angel’ implying the same for him. Abrams also seems to...

Other Essays Like Response Paper on Post Structuralism

Why People Are Chutiya? Essay

903 words - 4 pages (auteur theory) emphasis on the role of the author, (ideas in the story or text originate with the author) flag is symbol. What the content influence or person do. Decenter the author • Structuralism(meaning is being imposed upon us), Semiotics (look at the text itself), and Post-structuralism (doesn’t matter what history or text itself is what important is the history of decoder, talk about how meaning is made): emphasis not on the personal, but

History of Psychology Essay

1518 words - 7 pages human experience could   be viewed as simple processes based on controlled experiments of   self-observation and behaviour and this method was termed   “Introspection”.   Structuralism and the Introspection technique attempted to analyse   conscious mental experience and reduce it into elements of sensations   and feelings, i.e. thoughts, ideas, and perception.   At this time during the 19th century, physics and chemistry (natural

Brief History of Psychology

1823 words - 8 pages theology. I looked at this theory of the unconscious mind and the psychosexual child. Next, I gave an insight into Piaget’s works on how the child develops cognitively through assimilation, accommodation and equilibration. I detailed the main theories in behaviourism such as stimulus-response and the contributors to this school of psychology. I next summarised the theories of structuralism and functionalism by over viewing the main psychologist

Foundations of Psychology

915 words - 4 pages in what was modern psychology. The structuralism approach really focuses on breaking down the mental process into really basic components. Functionalism was first formed based on the theories of the structuralist school of thought and was heavily influenced by the work of William James. (Cherry, 2014) Gestalt psychology is the school opf thought that looks at the human mind and a persons behavior as a whole. (Cherry, What is Gestalt Psychology

Psychology

1282 words - 6 pages understood as a combination of simple elements or events * Based on the presumption that all human mental experience could be understood as the combination of basic components * Many psychologists attacked structuralism on three fronts: i. It was reductionistic because it reduced all complex human experience to simple sensations ii. It was elemental because it sought to combine parts, or elements, into a whole

Organizing Knowledge

2775 words - 12 pages redeems you.” Dear life, our biological life on earth, must become the standard of truth if we are to redeem literary studies from post structuralism without relying on blind faith and miracles. (7) Life is certainly a standard of value in Minutes of the Lead Pencil Club: Pulling the Plug on the Electronic Revolution, edited by Bill Henderson. This collection of essays, cartoons, poems, and snippets from newspapers is breezy and informal

Foundations of Psychology

953 words - 4 pages physical responses. It was during these research studies that emotional responses were noticed in the subjects that could not recall the actual memory tied to the response rendered. This is when interest was sparked in the correlation between psychology and biology and further experiments began. Intentional lesions were given to animals to help identify what part of the brain was associated with certain emotional responses. These studies revealed

P1- Explain the Principle Sociological Perspectives

1234 words - 5 pages other hand, the proletariat are the ‘working class’ who have only their labour to sell. They work for and are exploited by the bourgeoisie. Interactionism Interactionists differs from functionalism, Marxism and most feminist theories in that it focuses on small scale interaction rather than society as a whole. It usually rejects the notion of a response or reaction to the system. Interactionism analyses society systematically and

Semiotics

682 words - 3 pages Semiotics. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press/London: Macmillan Chandler, D 2007, Semiotics: The Basics, Routledge, Oxford and New York. Metz, Christian. Film Language: A Semiotics of the Cinema . Translated by Michael Taylor. New York: Oxford University Press, 1974. New Vocabularies in Film Semiotics Structuralism, Post-Structuralism, and Beyond Robert Stam, J. Robert Burgoyne, Sandy Flitterman-Lewis 1992 Innis, Robert E (Ed.) (1986): Semiotics: An Introductor Reader. London: Hutchinson

Phl/215 Philosophy Matrix

1017 words - 5 pages government restrict the liberty of its citizens? | Structuralism | The study of the rules and conventions of the language and cultural mythology that govern large social systems | Saussure applied linguistics to epistemology.Levi-Strauss applied Saussure’s methods to cultural mythology. | Semiotics | SaussureLevi-Strauss | Study of the deep structure of language | Deconstruction | The study of the assumptions about language, including the

Significant Texts in Any Period Arise from Particular Ways of Thinking and Possess an Enduring Relevance

2269 words - 10 pages structures. Through the subversion of the Christian metanarrative, Beckett’s play revolutionised Absurdist theatre to become almost an anti-theatre piece that comments on humanity’s intensified questioning of life- its meaning, or lack there of. French philosopher, Jean-François Lyotard identifies Post-structuralism as a product of Postmodern skepticism that refuses to accept the totalizing nature of metanarratives and there heavy reliance on a

Related Papers

Post Crisis And Regulatory Response On Banking Regulation

3264 words - 14 pages innovation carry risk of harm. Eventually, Parliament and the regulator have responsibility to take the full consideration on the cost of regulation.[16] Indeed, FSA’s regulation is required to be “proportionate to the benefits, in general terms, which are expected to result from it.”[17] Post crisis and Regulatory Response. After all, the flurry of regulatory responses have to be discussed. These are categorised in five groups.[18] Looking on

Response Paper On Black Corona

1582 words - 7 pages Corona, once “a farming and light manufacturing village,” is now a predominantly African American neighborhood located on the northern shore of Queens, Long Island. While Corona used to be a rural town, an influx of European and Caribbean immigrants as well as people traveling from the southern United States caused the industrial economy of Manhattan to expand into its outskirts, consequently causing the population of Corona to grow

The Response Paper On "Advertising And The Construction Of Violent White Muscularity" Of Jason Katz

857 words - 4 pages was viscous, wild, and aggressive but I disagree with the opinion that history carries such a message. The traditional male role in past was to protect the wife and children, to be for them to provide them the financial and emotional needs and I am really sad that modern man is no longer concentrated on this important duties.The marketing industry use also sports figures to persuade men to buy a product. The author shows the examples as the typical

Cognitive Psychology Definition Paper

1645 words - 7 pages of him or herself and their surroundings. Relying on structuralism, Wundt tried to determine if the stage of awareness could be divided into more simply understood units. By using introspection, one was able to self-examine him or herself and collect information about the inner self, such as one’s feelings. While Wundt was busy with this own theory, William James proposed another approach. Functionalism was yet another method trying to relate