This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rhetorical Analysis Essay

1113 words - 5 pages

A Critique of Karen Wright’s “Guns, Lies, and Video”
In her short article “Guns, Lies, and Video”, Karen Wright lays out an overview of the issue of the relationship between media violence and real life violence. She writes that there is considerable debate on the subject, with some experts claiming there is strong evidence for a link between media violence and real aggression, and some experts claiming there is none. According to Wright, determining how media violence actually relates to real aggression is complicated by many factors. Wright also cites several studies, including a long-term study that implies a correlation between exposure to media violence and violent behavior, and ...view middle of the document...

(par. 1) Wright then points out that there is strong evidence for a correlation between “media violence” and “real aggression,” (par. 2) and in the same paragraph points to an unnamed expert's estimate that 10 percent of juvenile violence can be accounted for by violence in TV, movies, and music. However, Wright fails to elaborate on the difference between video games and passive media such as movies and television.
Later in the article, Wright states that “…those who grew up with the Three Stooges or Super Mario Brothers may have trouble seeing their youthful pastimes in a sinister light. But televised violence has been a topic of national consternation almost from the first broadcast.” (par. 5) Again, Wright implies the interchangeability between television programs and video games, using a video game (Super Mario Brothers) and televised violence as interchangeable parts of a logical sequence.
Wright fails to establish how exactly video games are related to movies/television/music (passive media), aside from the fact that they belong to the categorization “media.” Granted, she does cite a pediatrician, Michael Rich, as having said that “…with video games, you're not only passively receiving attitudes and behaviors, you're rehearsing them” (par. 3). However, Wright fails to point out that there is a possibility that such a difference (passive vs. active) could make all the difference between a positive and a negative correlation. She also points to a long-term (17 years) study on the effects of television viewing on aggressive behavior, but fails to point out that there are no long-term studies that specifically concern the effects of video-game violence.
Wright implies that violence in video games, in movies, and in television can all be lumped together under the label of "media violence." She treats movies/television and video games interchangeably. It is, however, possible that the interactive nature of video games makes them so different from more traditional media that it would merit consideration as a wholly different category of behavioral influences.
Additionally, a large portion of Wright’s article revolves around the effects of violence in movies and television, but there is no mention of any studies on the effects of exposure to interactive violence in contrast to passive violence. Wright does not create a strong enough distinction between...

Other Essays Like Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Rhetorical Analysis

1012 words - 5 pages , who wrote the article "Social Media - A Disastrous Distraction [opinion],” believes media has become a dangerous distraction. Giraso is a student at the Gashora Girls Academy. These authors use ethos by having credibility. Anderson argues how violent images and vulgar language in media have a negative effect on young people and don’t teach a Christian worldview. He is able to support his argument by using the rhetorical device logos. He uses

Rhetorical Analysis

1424 words - 6 pages Rhetorical Analysis Scott Schmidt ENG 112 1/31/15 Robert Zacny Rhetorical Analysis Just picture that you are flipping through your favorite magazine, and all of a sudden an advertisement catches your eye. In the ad, a family stand together, smiling, Christmas tree in the background, each one holding their very own Winchester rifle; well everyone, of course, except mom. Could you imagine the lawsuits that would ensue, (no pun intended

Rhetorical Analysis

792 words - 4 pages Google the Boston Molasses Disaster after he mentioned it several times in his essay.  One aspect of his article that gives me good credibility is the psychological experiments that he shares. The article talks about how distraction is “focused.” A positive example of distraction is also given when he talks about a sort of free-associative wandering is essential to the creative process; “one moment of judicious unmindfulness can inspire

Rhetorical Analysis - 1024 words

1024 words - 5 pages Christina McCollum English 1900 February 4, 2015 Rhetorical Analysis Rhetorical Analysis of What is it About Pit Bulls? Writer, Rose Frosek, in her article in “Modern Dog” magazine, discusses many of what she feels are common misconceptions about the pit bull breed. She does this in an attempt to alter the public opinion on these “frequently misunderstood dogs” (2). Throughout the article she uses a critical yet informal tone to

Rhetorical Analysis - 1025 words

1025 words - 5 pages Rhetorical Analysis The world is full of opportunities and dangers, no one knows what will happen next period. The difference between winners and losers is that winners are always with courage to challenge for the future. In this speech, Tiffany Shlain, a filmmaker, give some advice about this. She recounts in her commencement speech about some difficult periods of her life, such as having no money to shoot an important scene, the internet

Martin Luther King Rhetorical Analysis

818 words - 4 pages Rhetorical Analysis of Martin Luther King’s Speech “I Have a Dream” Likita M. Taylor ITT-Tech English 1320: Composition I November 12 2012 Rhetorical Analysis of Martin Luther King’s Speech “I Have a Dream” “I am happy to join with you today in what will go down in history as the greatest demonstration for freedom in the history of our nation.” These are the opening words of Martin Luther King’s “I have a dream speech”, which he

The Rhetorical Triangle

560 words - 3 pages The Rhetorical Triangle Unit 1 IP Romeo McIver AIU Online University Abstract This paper will discuss the effectiveness and the differences of the two videos I viewed

Bias and Rhetorical Devices

569 words - 3 pages form of bias used was Ethnic bias to describe the citizens of the state as “the working man” and “the underfed,” just to name a few. I think that this speech has one main fallacy, ad hominen. Citizen Kane attacks Jim Gettys throughout his entire speech rather than attacking the issues at hand. A rhetorical device that was used was using the word “boss” as a euphemism to describe Jim Gettys as the boss of the state being a villainous political

Rhetorical Modes Matrix

692 words - 3 pages Associate Program Material Appendix C Rhetorical Modes Matrix Rhetorical modes are methods for effectively communicating through language and writing. Complete the following chart to identify the purpose and structure of the various rhetorical modes used in academic writing. Provide at least 2 tips for writing each type of rhetorical device. |Rhetorical Mode |Purpose – Explain when or why |Structure – Explain what organizational

Understanding Rhetorical Structures

953 words - 4 pages Understanding Rhetorical Structures Rian Davis Shackelford ITT Technical Institute Breckinridge School of Nursing It’s extremely hard being a college-age student. Especially when you have overbearing, over protective parents. The article “No Escape From Helicopter Parents” explains that in great detail and acts as a means to inform and/or make people, parents in particular, aware of what their actions have on their offspring. I grew up as

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Gettysburg Address

924 words - 4 pages the founders. The sixteenth president of the United States was capable of using his speech to turn a war on states rights to a war on slavery and upholding the principles that America was founded upon. By turning the Civil War into a war that was about slavery he was able to ensure that no foreign country would recognize the south as an independent nation, thus ensuring Union success in the war. In his speech, Lincoln used the rhetorical devices

Related Papers

Rhetorical Analysis Essay

634 words - 3 pages Nancy The Anti-Nike Ad In my opinion this is an anti-Nike ad, it is portraying Nike as a bad company. This ad is in black and white with some words colored in red. Looking at this ad I see a young girl running with no shoes on her feet and holding a blanket. I think there is a baby in that blanket by the way she is cradling it in her arms. The ad describes how hard the Indonesian people have to work for Nike to get their products out to

Rhetorical Analysis 1006 Words

1006 words - 5 pages Buying Time for Economy: Greg Ip’s Analysis in Economic Crisis Rhetorical strategies are employed by writers to use in different ways to persuade the readers. In the essay “Think this economy is bad? Wait for 2012”, Greg Ip gives a quite distinct perspective from other economists about the economic crisis. He properly uses organizational strategies in his text to reveal a fact to his audiences what he thought when the economic crisis will come

Mlk Rhetorical Analysis

1103 words - 5 pages Rhetorical Analysis of the I Have a Dream Speech by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Rate This Paper: 1 2 3 4 5 Length: 1025 words (2.9 double-spaced pages) Rating: Red (FREE) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - One of the most influential speeches ever given on the earth was given on a potiumat the Lincoln Momorial in Washington D.C on August 28th 1963. The great speech was given by Martin Luther King

Rhetorical Analysis 858 Words

858 words - 4 pages injustices. In this essay, Ehrenreich echoes her exhausting work in two jobs, both in which she was treated unfairly. Her rhetorical devices and appeals strengthen her argument, which is prominent through narration. Varied syntax and diction create tone, which helps the reader connect with the author. Her purpose is to show the world the daily struggles of low income workers and to bring about change Overall, she achieves this purpose by reflecting