Richard Wallace Grube Et Al. V. Bethlehem Area School District

1605 words - 7 pages

Richard Grube, an athletically inclined senior at Freedom High School in the Bethlehem Area School District, played football his freshman, sophomore, and junior years. Prior to the start of the football season in his senior year, the district claimed Richard was ineligible to play on the basis that Richard only had one kidney. Richard and his family filed a preliminary injunction against the school district claiming the district violated Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) According to the United States Department of Education (2011), Section 504 states that, “no otherwise qualified handicapped individual in the United States shall, solely by ...view middle of the document...

(Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) Prior to his senior year, Richard prepared for the upcoming football season. He attended team practices and participated in physical contact with other players. A few days before the first scrimmage game, Richard was barred from playing and practicing based solely on only having one kidney. Richard and his father, Mr. Grube agreed to sign a waiver accepting full legal and financial responsibility in the event that Richard is harmed playing football. In the 1981 season, Richard did sustain an injury to his remaining kidney and was hospitalized after Richard hit another player’s helmet. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) While in the hospital, Richard was under the care of Dr. Lennart, a specialist in Urology. Dr. Lennart did not advise Richard to stop playing football and stated that it was Richard’s choice to continue playing the game. When Richard decided to continue playing football, Dr. Lennart referred him to Lehigh University to secure protective equipment from Texas. At no cost to the district, Richard obtained a protective “flack jacket” for $400 designed to protect the kidney and ribs. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982)
Dr. Delp, Bethlehem Area School District’s physician and the physician to the school’s athletic teams, conducts medical examinations for all team members. Dr. Delp, checks the players’ heart, lungs, and kidneys. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) Dr. Delp, who is not a specialist in Urology or sports medicine, decided that it would be best that Richard obtain a note from his kidney specialist stating that Richard could take part in this contact sport. Since Richard did not have a kidney specialist he asked Dr. Lennart to write a note to Dr. Delp. Dr. Lennart wrote three letters on behalf of Richard. After receiving the letters, Dr. Delp came to the conclusion that playing football would be too risky for Richard. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) In preparation for his testimony, Dr. Moyer, director of Sports Medicine Clinic at Temple University, examined Richard and determined that Richard is in good health and his remaining kidney is healthy. In Dr. Moyer’s professional opinion, he stated that Richard can safely play football with protective equipment with little to no risk of injury. In the event that Richard was injured, the result would be dialysis or a kidney transplant, which Richard and his family fully understood. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1982) Another important factor in this case is that Richard and his family was not financial sound but Richard demonstrated his maturity by holding down a part-time job to purchase his protective gear. (Grube v Bethlehem, 1882)
Therefore, the court ruled in favor of Richard Grube because according to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, Richard was “otherwise qualified”. The Department of Education 2011 notes that,
The exclusion from contact sports of students who have lost an organ,
limb, or an appendage (e.g. a kidney, leg, or finger) but who are other-
wise qualified is...

Other Essays Like Richard Wallace Grube Et Al. V. Bethlehem Area School District

The Origin of Native American Man: a Look at Possible Migrations of Pre-Historic Man Into North America

1880 words - 8 pages rapid rate of evolution and it’s inheritance through the maternal line (Horai et al. 1992). Haplotypes, or groups of alleles on a chromosome that are transmitted together. These traits make the mtDNA a valuable tool to discern genetic relationships among individuals. The genetic differences, or morphs, can then be traced to ethnic and geographic origins, providing insight into lineages (Schurr et al. 1990). One of the major hurdles to

Mgt 5000 - Example Assignment 1

4639 words - 19 pages words) The attitudes and perceptions of staff in the scenario were directly affected by various compounding problems, especially pertaining to the lack of a value culture that would normally be linked to a business or strategic plan for future direction. An attitude is tendency of individuals to respond in either a positive or negative way to a particular situation, person or something in the environment (Wood et. al. 2006, p. 55

Article Critique: Families as Navigators and Negotiators

1914 words - 8 pages address the importance of oppressive characteristics that exist in other societies (as cited in Theron, et al., 2011, p. 801). These social differences are essential to social workers when developing interventions. The author further states that in order for clients to be receptive at the micro level treatments should be culturally appropriate. At the macro level he addresses the importance of client advocacy in overcoming injustices and

T. Shih, K. Davis, S. Schoenbaum, A. Gauthier, R. Nuzum, and D. Mccarthy, Organizing the U.S. Health Care Delivery System for High Performance (New York: the Commonwealth Fund Commission on a High...

931 words - 4 pages a description of how the EHR helps improve cancer treatment, see P. J. Wallace, “Reshaping Cancer Learning Through the Use of Health Information Technology,” Health Affairs Web Exclusive, Jan. 2007 26(2):w169–w177. 10 J. Hsu, J. Huang, V. Fung et al., “Health Information Technology and Physician-Patient Interactions: Impact of Computers on Communication During Outpatient Primary Care Visits,” Journal of the American Medical Informatics

Same Sex Marriage

2394 words - 10 pages . Internet; accessed 2 June 2011.     University of Missouri Kansas City School of Law. "LOVING ET UX. v. VIRGINIA ." ​UMKC​.  Available from Internet; accessed  3 June 2011.     What is Prop 8?. "California Supreme Court ­ Oral arguments about Prop 8." ​What is Prop 8?​.  Available from Internet; accessed 6 June 2011.      

Lupus Midterm

1139 words - 5 pages L., et al. Pathophysiology: The Biologic Basis for Disease in Adults and Children. 6th. Maryland Heights, Missouri: Mosby Elsevier, 2010. McKinley, Michael P., Valerie D. O'Loughlin and Theresa S. Bidle. Anatomy & Physiology: An Integrative Approach. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2013. Porth, Carol M. Pathophysiology: Concepts of Altered Health States. 7th. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2005. Pullen, Jr., Richard L

Case Study - Student With Special Needs

1229 words - 5 pages problem and provides a thorough examination of reactions of the perceptions and conventions of those individuals involved in the problem. Finally, it discusses how this situation was handled in the court system. Forest Grove School District v. T.A. (2009) On September 11, 1985, T.A was welcomed into this world. Since birth, he resided in the area of the Forest Grove School District. He attended school through the Forest Grove School District

Health South: the Scrushy Way Introduction

3589 words - 15 pages overstated its earnings by at least 1.4 billion since 1999.(Weld et al., 2004, p. 44) and further asserts that HealthSouth's standard operating procedure under the direction of Mr. Scrushy was to manipulate the company's earnings to create the impression that the company was meeting Wall Street's expectations. The SEC complaint aroused, when a CFO reported to the authorities that HealthSouth had misrepresented their earnings to the SEC since 1999

Business Law Study Guide

1123 words - 5 pages • Contemporary Environment: The Process of Choosing Supreme Court Justices • Contemporary Environment: “I’ll Take You to the U.S. Supreme Court!” o Jurisdiction of Federal and State Courts • Case 2.1 Jurisdiction of Courts: Betram v. Norden, et al. o Personal Jurisdiction of Courts • Landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case: International Shoe Company v. State of Washington o Test Review

In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship by Nathaniel Philbrick

1711 words - 7 pages ., al, 1996; Smetana, 2011; Richard et., al, 2009). Risk analysis Risk analysis is indeed a very useful tool to determine factors that may endanger the accomplishment of a project or target. However, this tool is also useful to determine Precautionary measures to minimize the chances of loss and hampering factors. Countermeasures are studied carefully. Four common grounds this tool enables us to analyze that factors cannot be cost effective if

Mobbing: Emotional Abuse in the American Workplace

2106 words - 9 pages over twenty years of research on mobbing. Mobbing is known as a household word thorughout Europe and is intended to stimulate public awareness in America. Davenport et al. (2005) found that “mobbing is ‘Ganging up’ by co-workers, subordinates or superiors, to force someone out of the workplace through rumor, innuendo, intimidation, humiliation, discrediting, and isolation.” They refer the term mobbing as emotional abuse in the workplace. It is of

Related Papers

Case Analysis Of Chevron U.S.A. Inc. V. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Et Al

516 words - 3 pages ".RuleThe Court of Appeals set aside the regulations. National Resources Defense Council, Inc. v. Gorsuch, 222 U.S. App. D.C. 268, 685 F.2d 718 (1982).V. HOLDINGThe Supreme Court after reviewing the judgment of the Court of Appeal reversed the decision and held in favor of the Respondent (Natural Resource Defense Council). The court found that the EPA's definition of the term Source is a permissible construction of the statute, which seeks to accommodate progress in reducing air pollution with economic growth. The Supreme Court felt that the Court of Appeals misconceived the nature of its role in reviewing the regulations of the National Clean Act.

Rjdt1 Constructive Discharge Essay

1091 words - 5 pages ., 1996). All production staff was treated equally under the new work schedule (Trans World Airlines, Inc. v. Hardison et al., 1977), the employee was not harassed, the employee did not make a reasonable accommodation request (Taylor v. Principal Financial Group, Inc., 1996, and the employee was not retaliated against. (EEOC, 2012) The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in (Grube v. Lau Industries, Inc., 2001) posited that changes in work hours

Brown Vs. Board Of Education Essay

2296 words - 10 pages education because their designated school was very far from their home. District Court The case was first argued to the district court which ruled in favor of the board of Education citing Plessy v. Ferguson, which upheld a state law requiring “separate but equal” segregated facilities for blacks and whites in railway cars (O’Connor & Sabato). The three judge District Court found that segregation in public education has a detrimental effect upon

The Civil Rights Movement Social Activism

5736 words - 23 pages civil rights, school integration, and supported the War Against Poverty. Powell's congressional career lasted almost three decades and he was responsible for many of the integration measures at the United States Capitol. d) School Integration: Brown vs. Board of Education, 1954 On May 17, 1954, in the case of Brown v. the Board of Education of Topeka, the U.S. Supreme Court ended federally sanctioned racial segregation in the public schools