This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Secularism V. Spirituality In The Second Nun's Tale

3167 words - 13 pages

Secularism v. Spirituality in the Second Nun's Tale

 
      In the General Prologue to the Canterbury Tales, Chaucer describes the men and women of the Church in extreme forms; most of these holy pilgrims, such as the Monk, the Friar, and Pardoner, are caricatures of objectionable parts of Catholic society.  At a time when the power-hungry Catholic Church used the misery of peasants in order to obtain wealth, it is no wonder that one of the greatest writers of the Middle Ages used his works to comment on the religious politics of the day. 

 

      Yet not all of Chaucer's religious characters are failures in spirituality. His description of the Second Nun is of a truly pious ...view middle of the document...

  Chaucer does not only the tale to show off his writing abilities -- it is not simply a display of his incredible versatility as an author.  Chaucer uses this tale to contrast his anti-church sentiments within the Canterbury Tales; it shows his great respect for spiritual beliefs and benefits him in making his argument against the Church.  In essence, Chaucer is clearly defending his anti-secular position by showing his reverence and devotion to spirituality; his problems lie with the Church, not the faith. While very well known for his sardonic criticism of the Church, he is less often acknowledged for his appreciation and respect for the religion itself.

 

      Judith A. Weise puts forth one of the more shocking theories concerning the Second Nun's Tale in her essay Chaucer's Tell-Tale Lexicon: Romancing Seinte Cecyle.  Weise argues that Chaucer's purpose for writing the saint's tale as a self-imposed literary penance for the "raptus" of Cecilia Chaumpaigne.  She posits:

 

Chaucer began translating the lyf in the wake of Cecilia's release to deflect negative reactions by his family... Is it just a stunning coincidence that the one saint's life Chaucer writes concerns a virgin martyr with the same name? (1)

 

Why not?  Perhaps Chaucer, like many other writers, uses his writing as some form of psychological and spiritual cleansing; writing can certainly be a form of emotional release.  But perhaps Chaucer genuinely enjoys this particular saint's tale, for it certainly contrasts his other religious characters and shows the rewards of living a virtuous life.  While Weise puts forth an interesting argument, she completely misses the true message of the tale.  Her argument seems more biased and less rational, using inconclusive historical notes and "statistics" to guess at coincidences. 

 

      By simply looking at the big picture of the tale, it becomes clear that Chaucer chose it for the love of the tale itself, and not for some kind of self-sacrificing punishment.  Most scholars agree that the Second Nun's Tale was finished in the latter part of Chaucer's life, a time when people typically begin to reflect and look for more meaning, more substance to their lives and faiths.  The great author could very well have wanted nothing more than to grow closer to his god and show his devotion and respect; perhaps he simply wanted to let god know that he did not necessarily view all clergy in the same light as the grotesque Summoner. 

 

Weise also pointedly states that "the one and only time Chaucer writes a saint's life, he chooses one about a celibate martyr with erotic associations, St. Cecilia" (1).  These allegedly erotic associations come from forms of art and iconography of St. Cecilia in "works of art dating to Chaucer's day" (1).  Yet nothing in Chaucer's tale comes through as erotic - in fact, it stresses continuously the celibacy of not only St. Cecilia, but also of her followers that commit to...

Other Essays Like Secularism V. Spirituality In The Second Nun's Tale

American Troops in the Second Battle of the Marne

768 words - 4 pages The Second Battle of the Marne marked the turning of the tide in World War I. It began with the last German offensive of the conflict and was quickly followed by the first allied offensive victory of 1918 (In Viereck & In Maerker-Branden, 1929). Although US troops assumed mainly a support role in this action, the battle came to be known as the beginning of the end for Germany. 85,000 US troops participated, with 12,000 casualties, gaining the

How Are Dystopias Portrayed in ‘the Handmaid’s Tale’ and ‘1984’

2577 words - 11 pages frighteningly) on the edge of possibility.’ and thus we may consider these novels as social critiques of their era. The structure of the novels allows for symbolic of the dystopia. Chapter two of ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ opens with ‘A chair, a table, a lamp.’, the second paragraph with, ‘A window, two white curtains,’ the next: ‘A bed’. This culmination of simple sentences restricts the narrative and it appears that in these mundane room descriptions

The Theme Of Oppression In 'A Tale Of Two Cities'

626 words - 3 pages Oppression in A Tale of Two CitiesIn the book A Tale of Two Cities, one of the many themes present is that of oppression. There are many examples of this throughout the book, some more obvious than the others.We can see right away in the beginning that the French peasants are under a hideous oppression by the French aristocracy. All the people of the towns that are described are starved and in great pain, they are depressed and slinking about

Wife Of Bath's Tale In Chaucer's "The Canterbury Tales"

682 words - 3 pages In the satirical comedy The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer introduces Dame Alice (who is known as "The Wife of Bath") as an obstinate, energetic and opinionated woman. In addition, she is promiscuous and filled with sexual desire. Throughout her prologue she is depicted as a determined feminist who continuously argues against the belittling of women and forbidden female sexuality. Chaucer uses her tale to add humor to his works because a feminist

Perspective In The Outsiders, And A Squatter's Tale

2148 words - 9 pages countries, governments, and races in an effort to co-exist on the planet.  The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton and A Squatter's Tale by Ike Oguine are stories that tell of this battle to fit in, and both have characters that personify these four definitions of the word, "outsider."  These tales have dramatic themes and stylistics that in some ways are similar and in other ways unique, but they all have significant effects on the readers

A Tale of Three Wheels in the Bicycle Industry

778 words - 4 pages A Tale of Three Wheels in the Bicycle Industry Pacific Cycle Chris Hornung, the founder and the first CEO of Pacific Cycle grabs a lion’s share of the U.S. bicycle markets. In 2005, around 19.8 millions of bicycle were sold in U.S. the total retail value of bikes, parts, and accessories were more than $6 billion. There are basically hundreds of bicycle manufacturers in U.S., but they are small specialized firm. Pacific Cycle is

The Role of the Canadian Army in the Second World War

1302 words - 6 pages The Second World War was a long and life threatening experience that lead to deaths of millions. Throughout the 6-year war, the Allies and the German Nazi’s armies encountered across Europe in several battles to force the opposition to surrender. Although, Canada was not a powerful nation during the Second World War, however, it’s army made many contributions that helped the Allies surrender the Nazi’s. The Canadian military

The Battle Of Stalingrad- A Turning Point In The Second World War

784 words - 4 pages Generals. Conversely, morale in the Red Army soared as a consequence of Stalingrad giving the Russians increased strength and confidence. This battle represented a turning point in the Second World War. By successfully defending the city of Stalingrad the Soviet Union were able to deny Hitler his summer 1942 objective of paralysing the Soviet war effort by interrupting Russian oil supplies and seizing the Caucasus oil fields. This achievement was

Appeasement In The 30s- How It Directly Led To The Second World War

1671 words - 7 pages France didn't want a war with Germany again, the state of Britain's armed forces encouraged appeasement policy, and to prevent a second war, although after a few years it occurred anyway, and it was actually one reason for the beginning of it because it kept giving Hitler everything he demanded and in the end the only way to stop him would have been a war. But Britain and France thought that by appeasing Hitler he would be satisfied and eventually

Spanish Settlers in the V Century + Jamestown and Plymouth Colonies in the Vii Century

1978 words - 8 pages the ten-year-old girl actually did offer her own life to save his or whether this famous tale is a myth. She did, however, become a close friend of John Smith after he helped save the colony from starvation and immediate failure. Pocahontas continued to help the Jamestown colony even after Smith returned to England in 1609 and after her father and the English were no longer on friendly terms. In 1613 Pocahontas was captured by Captain Samuel

The Fear of the Unknown in the Sufi Tale and Lord of the Flies

729 words - 3 pages The fear of the unknown Alina Liu The fear of the unknown is rife in Lord of the Flies by William Golding and “The Sufi Tale”. In Lord of the Flies, the “beast” or the “Lord of the Flies” represents the fear of the unknown, while in “Sufi tale” the watermelon is the symbol of fear. The boys in Lord of the Flies react almost the same as the villagers in “Sufi Tale”, they both cower and are afraid of this unknown. The settings of both stories

Related Papers

Religion And Spirituality In The Workplace

1730 words - 7 pages Religion and Spirituality in the Workplace Today there are over 900 religious employee resource groups, according to the International Coalition of Workplace Ministries (Cañas & Sondak, 2010). These affinity groups can help encourage religious understanding by offering panel discussions that educate employees on their beliefs. By allowing open discussion, answering religious questions and creating an open, welcoming religious environment in the

Aspects Of Women's Spirituality In Tending To The Dying

3517 words - 15 pages |Aspects of Women's Spirituality in Tending to the Dying | |By Leslene della-Madre | |s Page

Fabliaux In The Miller's Tale Essay

690 words - 3 pages In “The Miller’s Tale”, Chaucer perfects fabliaux through the gullibility of John, the characterization of Absalom, and through the characterization of the Miller. Both the character’s John and Absalom elicit humor from their gullibility. John placed a substantial amount of trust in his eighteen year old wife. Utilizing the Miller as the story teller demonstrates Chaucer’s mastery of fabliaux. If this tale was told by a knight or an old sage it

The Social Situation In The Handmaid's Tale

990 words - 4 pages Margaret Atwood's novel The Handmaids Tale belongs to the genre of anti-utopian (dystopian) science fiction where we read about a woman's fictive autobiography of a nightmarish United States at the end of the twentieth century when democratic institutions have been violently overthrown and replaced by the new fundamentalist republic of Gilead. In the novel the majority of the population are suppressed by using a "Bible-based" religion as an