This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Children Have The Right To Participate In Decisions That Shape Their Lives Or Should They Be Protected From Decision Making

1754 words - 8 pages

Option 2
Should children have the right to participate in decisions that shape their lives or should they be protected from decision making?

Children although need the protection and guidance of adults also deserve to be treated with the respect we all deserve, to play a part in key decisions that affect their lives. Although children aren’t as mature or responsible as adult’s they still have their own opinions and I believe that when it comes to decisions about choices that shape lives they should be consulted on a level that is appropriate to their age and level of maturity. The United Nations Convention on Rights of the Child Act goes some way to outlining and trying to ensure this ...view middle of the document...

. The Act tries to create a universal approach to protecting children and insuring all children have basic needs both food and shelter and basic educational needs met. The act also tries to ensure that children’s views and choices concerned with their own lives are taken into account (Lansdown 2003). The problem with this act is it treats children universally and not on a more individual basis in relation to their culture and thus has received many criticisms (Burman, 1996). In the case study of Maya, a mother in Bangladesh who eloped at the age of 15 years old and who is now a mother herself. Maya wishes to carry on her education but her husband will not allow this and wishes her to remain at home with their child, this is going against the Children’s Right Act but this is the cultural expectations of a female once married in Bangladesh. Maya is now a mother and therefore has a new role and although she is still a child herself in her culture this is irrelevant. The Act has no flexibility for individual cultural, social and economic differences (Understanding Childhood, 2003. Pg. 156).

In many African communities children are not seen as individuals but as part of a family network and as such decisions are made for the child based on what is best for the whole family and not necessarily what is best for the child. (Iheaoma Obibi, pg.158). Both these examples of how children are treated demonstrate that the Children’s Rights Act appears to be based on Western culture and ideology. Due to the cultural restraint of the Act many countries who have signed the agreement- America and Solomania being the only 2 who haven’t, have devised their own regional charters. These Regional charters interpret the Child’s Act into a policy that is workable within their cultural needs and expectations (Understanding Childhood, 2003. Pg.159). The African Charter dealt with relevant concerns for the regions of Africa, covering issues that affected children within their regions. The UNCRC is a policy worthwhile as we need to protect those most vulnerable in our world and children are vulnerable but the Act could do with some adaption to allow for cultural differences to be included and thus making it more relevant to all.

The Act can be interpreted too far the other way and lead to people such as aid agencies trying too hard to protect children and not allowing for the child’s wishes to be taken into consideration. In the case study of Hiep- a street boy in Vietnam at the age of 14 who had been living on the streets for 2 years. Hiep had come to the city from a rural life to try and support himself and provide himself with an education whilst still managing to send some money home to help his family. The Vietnamese government set up a program to return children to their place of birth as they feel this is what is best for him, supported by an International aid agency. Hiep wished to stay where he was he was supporting himself and managing to provide himself...

Other Essays Like Should Children Have the Right to Participate in Decisions That Shape Their Lives or Should They Be Protected from Decision Making

Should We Depend on Computers for Their Benefits or Should We Be Suspicious of This Technology ?

797 words - 4 pages , and computers are beginning to change and take over every aspect of our lives. We are becoming overwhelming based on the computers today. As Bill Gates CEO of Microsoft Corporation says, " I think it is fair to say that personal computers have become the most empowering tool we've ever created. They are tools of communication, they are tools of creativity, and they can be shaped by their user, " Or Ken Olsen says, "There is no reason for any

Should Teachers Be Allowed to Say Whatever They Want in a Classroom

1660 words - 7 pages Bear 1 Cesia Bear English 7 Nov 2011 Should Teachers Be Allowed to Say Whatever They Want In a Classroom? For years the topic of whether teachers should be allowed to speak their mind in a classroom, has been a constant issue. There are reports being made on a regular basis arguing this subject. We not only see or hear reports about it, however; we experience it first had without realizing that it is in fact a prominent issue. I myself had

An Arguement That Children That Commit Murder And Other Violent Crimes Should Be Tried As Adults In Court

320 words - 2 pages security juvenile prison, we should put them where the belong, in ahigh security prison with others, regardless of their age, that commit the same type of crime. Juveniles that commit violent crimes are able to make their own decisions. Young criminals know that they can get by with their crimes. Until they are 18, they know that the government claims that they are not responsible for their own actions. By law, if you are 10 years old or younger

Why Children Object Their Divorcee or Widowed Parent to Have Sex?

807 words - 4 pages Why children object their divorcee or widowed parent to have sex? It’s really hard to survive with the fact that your parents are divorced or you lost one of your parents. Well in both the cases (divorce/widow) children lose there complete family and feel frustrated. They just don’t want to see this separation. It has been seen that things become more difficult and dramatic when the parents are divorced. The child who was used to their

All Parents Should Be Required to Volunteer Time to Their Children's Schools

895 words - 4 pages same adults that way. This will cause even more problems in a school and can change the school from a positive safe environment to one full of negativity and disrespect. Parents should have the opportunity to volunteer for events that fit their availability; they should be included in important events such as graduations and parent teacher conferences when necessary, and overall volunteering should be flexible across the board as opposed to imposing a strict requirement.

Who Should Have Won The French And Indian War? An Essay That Describes Important Events In The French And Indian War In A Way That The Reader Can Decide For Himself Who Should Have Won It

732 words - 3 pages provided that a president appointed by the king act with a grand council of delegates chosen by the assemblies, with each colony to be represented in proportion to its financial contributions to the general treasury. This organ would have charge of defense, Indian relations, and trade and settlement of the west, as well as having the power to levy taxes. That right there my friends, is smart. But none of the colonies accepted Franklin's plan, for

Should People Move in or Stay Together Before They Get Married

1800 words - 8 pages could take years to fix, if it doesn't spread and get worse over time. It makes the proposal anti-climactic Ah, the marriage proposal. From time immemorial it's been romanticized as a huge climax in two people's lives -- and most of the romance comes from the idea that the man and woman are entering into a huge new commitment together. A proposal can still be beautiful and touching if you're already living together, but it'll lack a certain gravitas. If you're already engaging in all the intimacy and sacrifice that comes with making a home together, the moment of the big decision has long passed; in a way, your engagement is already over even before rings get involved.

Seven Reasons Why Xerox Should Be Motivated to Diversify Their Workforce

839 words - 4 pages . Implication in Organization To achieve success and maintain a competitive advantage, Xerox was able to draw on the most important resource that is the skills of the workforce. With the increasing richness of diversity in the world and in the workforce, they expanded their outlook and used creative strategies to be successful. Employees can provide this resource. Here, Xerox uses a four-step approach strategic plan for establishing and

1. What Kinds of Applications Are Described Here? What Business Functions Do They Support? How Do They Improve Operational Efficiency and Decision Making? I Believe the Kind of Applications That Was...

1374 words - 6 pages benefit from equipping their employees with mobile digital devices. They have to track the position of each box and to update the shipment information. They can fix all these problems by using the mobile digital devices to equip their employees, which can finish their tracking efficiently. Q4: iPhone is widely used in industries nowadays. It is not just for fun and can play a variety of games, but it can also be used in managing and manufacturing

Governments Should Provide Funding For Artists So That The Arts Can Flourish And Be Available To All People

569 words - 3 pages Nowadays a lot of issues are under the help of governments, seeing the advantage of government funding from some of them. people begin to require the government to provide funding for artsists too so that the arts can flourish and be available to all people.however, these people overlook the essential and distinctive elements of arts and made a hastily generalization.Arts are forms full of vigor and attraction. they have survived for thousands

The Primary Goal of Technological Advancement Should Be to Increase People's Efficiency so That Everyone Has More Leisure Time

620 words - 3 pages relaxing or going out with their family. In other words, people would have got leisure time only if these technological advancements were either non-existent or they were of a lesser magnitude. If we wish to see man more efficient in the future as compared to what he is today, then the technological developments will have to be planned keeping in mind the efficiency of man with total disregard to his leisure time.

Related Papers

In Order To Become Financially Responsible Adults, Children Should Manage Their Money At The Young Age

530 words - 3 pages lead to disharmony in a family. I individually do not believe that children should manage their own money at the young age to become financially responsible adults. The follow writing will clarify some points of my view The first reason I disagree is that children are not able to manage money .Children, at the young age, have no idea about what is money and the value of all merchandises. Given the money, they may be in loss wondering how they

In Your Opinion, How Should The Data Be Used That Is Obtained From An Unethical Experiment

3894 words - 16 pages . Have faith that things will work out, maybe not how you planned, but just how it's meant to be."~ ♥ …♥ Father GOD, bless all my friends and family in whatever it is that You know they may be NEEDING every day. May their LIFE be full of Your PEACE, PROSPERITY and POWER as they SEEK to have a closer RELATIONSHIP with you in JESUS name, amen. GOD BLESS ♥ …♥ The LARGER our FAITH, the smaller our FEARS. The greater our TRUST, the lesser our

Should Women Be Allowed To Have Abortions On Demand, Or Should There Be Restrictions On Abortion Rights?

560 words - 3 pages Political Science 1001 Normative Project Research DesignNormative Social Policy Issue: Should women be allowed to have abortions on demand, or should there be restrictions on abortion rights?Value Position: There are competing values in this question; the individual's right to determine what is done to her body versus the right to life. Both values are critical to individual and social well being. Two key questions that will determine how these

A Managers Responsibility Should Be To Increase The Profits Of The Business In Order To Maximise The Wealth Of The Shareholders. This Should Be The Sole Focus Of Their Work Effort And Their Rewards...

1891 words - 8 pages to them. I therefore agree with Michael Jensen’s theory that a business manager should make maximising the wealth of shareholders their sole objective in the longer term. Stakeholders opinions should also be taken into account they are the people who indirectly contribute to creating value for the firm. The sole concentration of improving shareholders wealth, either by paying them higher dividends or by increasing the market