Should Huck Finn Be Required To Read In Schools

1817 words - 8 pages

Huck Finn: Recommended but not Required
The probability of a student being able to understand and appreciate the value of Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn if having been introduced to it too young and with a poor teacher is like a seed being able on to grow on concrete: improbable and disappointing. Similar to a student, a seed needs conducive and nurturing conditions in order to grow— that’s why only a small few end up reaching their full potential. Seeds need access to direct sunlight, water, and proper soil. Students need access to passionate teachers who are invested in educating their students properly—especially when it comes to challenging literature.
The Adventures ...view middle of the document...

Although it is true that schools who pay their teachers a higher salary and offer better working conditions typically attract instructors with higher educational levels, obtaining a “high education” does not directly correlate with having passion or eagerness to explain all types of complicated text. For example, Jane Smiley is a very educated and accomplished woman. She has her doctorate degree, was an English professor for sixteen years, and won the Pulitzer Prize in 1992. She is living proof that it is possible to be exceedingly intelligent yet still misinterpret Huck Finn. She made the very common mistake in her essay “Say it Ain’t So, Huck” of confusing the narrator with the author. She states, “When the Duke and the Dauphin finally betray Jim by selling him for forty dollars, Huck is shocked, but the fact is neither he nor Twain has come up with a plan that would have saved Jim in the end. Tom Sawyer does that.” Smiley is forgetting that Twain is not Huck. She doesn’t blame or hold any grudges against Huck; instead she criticizes Twain is “the real villain” for never intending Huck to be the hero. Smiley is someone who, if forced by the curriculum to teach Huck Finn, would not do it with passion because she herself doesn’t entirely understand it. I have no doubt that she was an excellent English professor; however, she probably only taught books she was genuinely passionate about – which most likely didn’t include Huck Finn, to the benefit of both her and her students.
Elements of racism also cause many educators to be uncomfortable teaching this work of literature. The word “nigger” is said 219 times during the duration of Huck Finn and is the root of the majority of controversy surrounding this book. The word “nigger” is degrading and painful, but it also has an immense amount of historical significance. It is critical that teachers explain the context and purpose of this word to their class correctly and thoroughly, as it is one of the most misinterpreted parts of this novel. Those who can’t read though Twain’s satire commonly perceive his constant use of the word “nigger” as him supporting the racist attitudes; however, this couldn’t be further from the truth. One of the more prominent examples of Twain’s use of satire is when Huck is asked by his Aunt Sally if anybody was hurt in a ferry accident. “No’m. Killed a nigger,” (232). Here, Twain is using satire very bluntly to reveal the superiority whites thought they held over blacks, and how some whites didn’t even consider them to be human. Here, Twain is obviously soundly criticizing this common belief. Another instance of when Twain uses satire to highlight the “stupidity and inhumanity of the Caucasian belief in genetic superiority” (June Edwards, author of What’s Moral about Huckleberry Finn) is when Huck’s father, Pap, is compared to a black college professor. Pap is ranting about how “It was ’lection day, and I was just about to go and vote myself if I warn’t too drunk to get...

Other Essays Like Should Huck Finn Be Required to Read in Schools

Comparing God in Daisy Miller, Huck Finn, and Country of the Pointed Firs

2093 words - 9 pages Eliminating God in Daisy Miller, Huckleberry Finn, and The Country of the Pointed Firs           The evils of the Civil War and the rise of empiricism caused many to doubt in an omniscient, all-powerful God.  Under empiricism, any statements about metaphysical entities (e.g. God, Unicorns, Love, and Beauty) would be meaningless terms because they cannot be proven by the scientific method. But with a loss of faith in God, what becomes of

Why I Should Be Allowed to Partcipate in Drug Court

648 words - 3 pages Why I Should Be Allowed to Participate in Drug Court The past month has definitely been a learning experience for me. The biggest lesson that I have learned would have to be about complacency. Since I first started attending AA & NA meetings I have heard people say that they became complacent. They felt comfortable where they were in their sobriety and decided that it was okay to slack off a little bit. It was okay to miss the

Driving Age Should Be Changed to 18

931 words - 4 pages With the driving age at 16 there are a lot more accidents. The amount of accidents with teenage drivers is more than triple that of drivers who are older and have had more experience. If the driving age was higher this would lessen the number of accidents more because people would have a better understanding of what they are doing. People should not be able to start drivers Ed until they are 18 or older. This would maximize the understanding of

How Should The UN Be Reformed To Promote International Peace And Stability In The 21st Century?

2670 words - 11 pages required to safeguard peace and security in the 21st century.The veto and secretive behavior of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council are behind much of what is deemed to be currently dysfunctional in the UN, and for peace to be a viable objective this is a reform that is possibly one of the most important. In its beginnings, the Security Council was never intended as democratic institution. Chapter 5 of the UN

A Managers Responsibility Should Be to Increase the Profits of the Business in Order to Maximise the Wealth of the Shareholders. This Should Be the Sole Focus of Their Work Effort and Their Rewards...

1891 words - 8 pages to satisfy stakeholder interests which at the end of the day involves themselves. We will discuss points both for and against a manager’s responsibility of increasing long term profits of a business in order to maximise shareholder wealth and whether any rewards they receive should be calculated on this basis. A shareholder is an individual who owns one or more shares of stock in a company. They are the owners of the company, meaning

? is it a problem in today's society? what should be done to address the issue

1052 words - 5 pages zero for that subject. Phones I your bag must be turned off. If you have a watch alarm, make sure it is turned off. MP3 players, electronic dictionaries and removable calculator covers should be left at home. Use a transparent pencil case or a plastic pocket to store your exam material. Bring a bottle of water and tissues and wear flexible clothing to allow for varying temperature conditions in the exam room. Only ‘silent snacks’ are allowed

Should Teachers Be Allowed to Say Whatever They Want in a Classroom

1660 words - 7 pages Bear 1 Cesia Bear English 7 Nov 2011 Should Teachers Be Allowed to Say Whatever They Want In a Classroom? For years the topic of whether teachers should be allowed to speak their mind in a classroom, has been a constant issue. There are reports being made on a regular basis arguing this subject. We not only see or hear reports about it, however; we experience it first had without realizing that it is in fact a prominent issue. I myself had

Physical Punishment Should Be Allowed in School

2375 words - 10 pages school rules which allow students to be punished using physical pain without causing injury. It is believed that using punitive method can promote students’ obedience and reduce problematic behavior and discipline students indirectly. However, I believe that physical punishment has a lot of side-effects and will bring more harm than benefits. Therefore, the practice of physical punishment in schools should be abolished. (References and Statistics

Should Death Penalty Be Abolished In America?

2342 words - 10 pages Should Death Penalty be abolished in America? Death penalty, or capital punishment, the most severe punishment for criminals, has been in the punishment system in countries all over the world for thousands of years. The history of death penalty is almost as long as the history of human beings. Death penalty was once considered as natural as life itself. It was usually applied to those criminals who had conducted grave crimes and no one would

Prostitution Should Be Legal in Canada

627 words - 3 pages rights to be our own person (http://www.echeat.com/essay.php?t=31137).” Prostitution has existed through out history. It has always been present in human societies, therefore it is regarded as the “oldest profession in the world” (http://www.sociumas.lt/Eng/nr15/prostitucija.asp) the ban goes against human nature. The ban on prostitution has pushed the industry underground and made the working conditions very dangerous. The government should be controlling the situation as well as making profit from it.

Should Children Have the Right to Participate in Decisions That Shape Their Lives or Should They Be Protected from Decision Making

1754 words - 8 pages Option 2 Should children have the right to participate in decisions that shape their lives or should they be protected from decision making? Children although need the protection and guidance of adults also deserve to be treated with the respect we all deserve, to play a part in key decisions that affect their lives. Although children aren’t as mature or responsible as adult’s they still have their own opinions and I believe that when it

Related Papers

All Parents Should Be Required To Volunteer Time To Their Children's Schools

895 words - 4 pages All parents should be required to volunteer time to their children's schools. Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the claim. In developing and supporting your position, be sure to address the most compelling reasons and/or examples that could be used to challenge your position. The statement simply claims that all parents should be required to volunteer time to their children's school. It

Students Should Be Required To Take Courses In Many Fields And Not Concentrate On One Area

567 words - 3 pages “STUDENTS SHOULD BE REQUIRED TO TAKE COURSES IN MANY FIELDS, AND NOT CONCENTRATE IN ONE AREA.” The current education system is nothing but a machine that churns out a set of highly specialized educated professionals who have nothing to do with the world at large except for the parts that pertain to their areas of study. And hence these professionals are mostly insulated from other areas of education, which prevents them

Should Video Cameras Be Placed In Public Areas Of Schools To Help Protect Students From School Violence?

412 words - 2 pages Today, we see a lot of school violence happening. To stop or prevent these violence, we should set up video cameras in public areas in schools. More security will reduce the number of violence in school. People will act and do things more carefully and it will prevent students from getting hurt and provide better learning conditions in schools. Campus security and safety is an important feature of postsecondary education. The Department of

Cell Phones In Schools: A Necessary Convenience, Or Irritating Intrusion? This Is A Persuasive Essay On Why Cell Phones Should Not Be Allowed In Schools

324 words - 2 pages Who can work while listening to the incessant ringing of a cell phone? This does not creat an inviting classroom environment for students. Although cell phones would be useful in the event of an emergency, they should not be allowed in schools because of the increased amount of disruptive and social problems.Despite the interruptions, cell phones do provide on advantage. They allow quick communications during times of an emergency; they also