‘Situation Ethics is not a practical method of moral decision making?’ How far do you agree?
The strongest argument for situation ethics not being a practical method of moral decision making is that it relies on predicting the consequences of an action. It can be hard to predict the outcome and take every possible situation into account, this will hinder things if if decision is needed quickly, or it can make it impossible to come up with a decision if the long term consequences are unable to be predicted.
Another reason that Situation Ethics is not a practical method of decision making is that Situation Ethics sometimes requires a type of decision making that some people do not have, ...view middle of the document...
This shows that situation ethics is more practical for everyday life that legalistic ethics as it takes each individual and their circumstances into consideration.
I don’t think that situation ethics is a practical method of decision making, this is because there are too many variables that have to be taken into account when deciding on the best thing to do, this will in turn mean that a larger number of people are unhappy because you have taken the time to work out the best thing for right now, but that does not mean that this large percentage of the happy population will stay happy for a long period of time as it is extremely hard to know what is going to happen in the future and how it will affect your decision.
Law is also a useful tool to have, this is because it is well known that it would be near impossible to live a normal, everyday life if there were no rules set out whatsoever, this is because society would descend into anarchy with everybody fighting against each other or trying to prove something to a different member of society and not wanting to stop at anything to do so.
One of the key reasons that i don't this that Situation ethics is a practical method of moral decision making is because of what William Barclay said ‘People want security, not freedom’ this means that people may start to manipulate the love to meet their own needs, forgetting about everybody else as long as they are okay. Freedom is also able to give licence to selfishness and cruelty by using the same ideas that people are able to manipulate love for their own selfish benefit.