Situation Ethics Essay

925 words - 4 pages

‘Situation Ethics is not a practical method of moral decision making?’ How far do you agree?

The strongest argument for situation ethics not being a practical method of moral decision making is that it relies on predicting the consequences of an action. It can be hard to predict the outcome and take every possible situation into account, this will hinder things if if decision is needed quickly, or it can make it impossible to come up with a decision if the long term consequences are unable to be predicted.

Another reason that Situation Ethics is not a practical method of decision making is that Situation Ethics sometimes requires a type of decision making that some people do not have, ...view middle of the document...

This shows that situation ethics is more practical for everyday life that legalistic ethics as it takes each individual and their circumstances into consideration.

I don’t think that situation ethics is a practical method of decision making, this is because there are too many variables that have to be taken into account when deciding on the best thing to do, this will in turn mean that a larger number of people are unhappy because you have taken the time to work out the best thing for right now, but that does not mean that this large percentage of the happy population will stay happy for a long period of time as it is extremely hard to know what is going to happen in the future and how it will affect your decision.

Law is also a useful tool to have, this is because it is well known that it would be near impossible to live a normal, everyday life if there were no rules set out whatsoever, this is because society would descend into anarchy with everybody fighting against each other or trying to prove something to a different member of society and not wanting to stop at anything to do so.

One of the key reasons that i don't this that Situation ethics is a practical method of moral decision making is because of what William Barclay said ‘People want security, not freedom’ this means that people may start to manipulate the love to meet their own needs, forgetting about everybody else as long as they are okay. Freedom is also able to give licence to selfishness and cruelty by using the same ideas that people are able to manipulate love for their own selfish benefit.
...

Other Essays Like Situation Ethics

Eth 316 Week 1 Essay

668 words - 3 pages Ethics and Social Responsibility ETH/316 Ethics and Social Responsibility In today’s society, cultural and ethical development is fundamental. There are numerous theoretical methodologies; although different each shares very similar concepts. Comprehending these similarities and differences provide one with greater understanding and gratefulness of these concepts. This paper will elaborate on the differences and similarities involving

Ethics and Morals Paper

854 words - 4 pages a broader level than ethics. According to Shaw and Barry, “Business ethics are mainly concerned with morality in the narrow sense.” Etiquette can have an interaction with morality depending upon the situation. Ethics is refers to a philosophy dealing with values relating to human conduct, with respect to the rightness and wrongness of certain actions and to the goodness a badness of the motives and ends of such actions (Gale, par 1

Critical Thinking and Ethics

558 words - 3 pages Critical thinking and ethics Noella Lubin GEN201 07/13/2015 PAMELA BREITUNG The relationship between critical thinking and ethics . Critical thinking plays a huge role in ethics. Critical thinking is thinking clearly, thinking fairly, thinking rationally, thinking objectively, and thinking independently (Braithwaite, 2006). Ethics is moral principles that govern a person or group behavior and the rule of conduct

Ethical and Moral Issue in Business

619 words - 3 pages professionally must be adhered to. Sometimes personal and professional ethics can conflict with each other forcing individuals to choose between what they believe in or to follow the professional code of ethics. For example, a person in the medical field, such as a doctor may morally believe strongly about an issue, such as abortion, and because of their beliefs think it is immoral regardless of the situation. However, because of the code of

“What Is "Business Ethics"?” Peter F. Drucker

2335 words - 10 pages the concept of moral responsibility in business ethics with a review of seven previous articles. Murphy found that all of the articles investigated the principle of responsibility. This responsibility is defined as the ability to respond to a person, situation, or issue with the appropriate level of understanding. Murphy’s objective in writing his article was to examine the seven articles through the lens of six types of responsibility mentioned

Computer Ethics

2395 words - 10 pages of them occurring can make the transition easier and make individuals more flexible about changing”. (Sahlman, 1999). NDex can look to their employees as well as outside sources to bring different perspectives to the situation and these change agents can often help to create more of a catalyst for change in an organization. NDex can offer their employees training and programs that will help to assist with the issues of computer ethics

The Importance of Professional Values and Ethics in Success

1180 words - 5 pages . Before reintroducing their products to the market, Johnson & Johnson added tamper resistant packaging and the new caplet form. The behavior of Johnson & Johnson, the corporation that owns the Tylenol brand, was well above board in this instance, and is one of the most famous examples of good business ethics. The rebuilding of the Tylenol brand name is directly linked to Johnson & Johnson’s handling of a delicate situation and people

The Ethical Professional

799 words - 4 pages reframe different aspects of a situation. Considering the results point of the triangle which is the greatest good for the greatest number of people and it is achieved by refusing to engage in negative actions due to the negative consequences. In the other hand, the rules corner refers to be fair with everybody and avoid such behavior, and under virtue ethics where you use integrity to do the right thing in each situation. The goal of the ethical

Xmgt 216 Week 4 Assignment

1791 words - 8 pages significant role in the code of ethics set by the company. Managers must ensure that all employees are following ethical procedures set by the company, and without a managers actions and social activity, the ethics set by the company will not be in place with other employees. Terminating employees for not following the code of ethics is not a pleasant situation for any party involved, which is why this situation must be handled with care. However

Organizational Ethics

777 words - 4 pages asking me to abandon the ethics that I have learned in my life. If by chance my employer did ask me to do something unethical, I think that I would try to handle the situation as professionally as possible (McDaniel, 2004)I would do this by making sure not to get angry at my supervisor. In the event that I was asked to do something unethical I would notify the supervisor above whomever it was asking me to commit the unethical behavior. When I

Human Resource

809 words - 4 pages organization goes up in flames very quickly. To maintain our company’s reputation and good name it is vital for us to uphold a very high ethical standard and code of ethics. This will give our employees direction when they are faced with an ethical situation. Below are two strategies that I believe will help to ensure that ethical decision making takes place at all levels of our organization. The first strategy I would feel is essential for our

Related Papers

Situation Ethics Essay

641 words - 3 pages Outline the main principals of situation ethics Situation ethics is based on the idea that you do the most loving thing in a situation, even if it leads to breaking the law. It is known as a relativistic theory. It has no absolute rules that have to be followed in every circumstance. It is also a consequentialist theory, where the end result is held to be of great importance. Finally it is a teleological theory, claiming the morale truth can

Examine The Following Ideas As They Appear In The Theory Of Situation Ethics: * Situation * Conscience * Relativism

598 words - 3 pages Examine the following ideas as they appear in the theory of Situation Ethics: * Situation * Conscience * Relativism First of all, Situation Ethics would produce a situation by setting aside all rules in a situation if love seems to be better served in doing so. Each situation is different and unique therefore reason is required make a moral decision, but only good lies with love. According to Fletcher, the Situationist follows a

Business Ethics Today Essay

646 words - 3 pages Business Ethics Today by Jack Yilmaz Business ethics is defined as a written and an unwritten code of principles and values that are governed by the organization and the actions within a company. Organizations or companies have set a culture inside their structure that sets a solid foundation of what a good and bad decision would be, given a particular situation. In businesses around the world today there are a set of these

Military Ethics Essay

1709 words - 7 pages from day to day. Our Nations military members are some of the most highly respected people throughout our country because of the quality individuals that are wearing the uniform. Service members know that part of the ethics is to respect everyone, no matter what the situation might be. Utilitarianism is also known to be a consequentialist theory. Military ethics are very in line with this kind of theory and logical thinking. The military expects