Solving The Euthyphro Dilemma Essay

1105 words - 5 pages

Imagine being stranded on the open sea in a lifeboat with a maximum capacity of fifty people. Who would you let go, who would you save? Consider this; there are a total of one hundred and seventy-five people who all deserve to live as much as the next. This can pose a difficult decision for any individual in charge of the situation. There are different ways an individual may go about coming to an ultimate decision which can be traced back to their personal motives along with their background on making ethical decisions. A divine command theorist, a relativist and an egoist could all be placed in this situation and come to completely different decisions on how to best resolve this dilemma. ...view middle of the document...

Divine command theorists may be able to justify their rationale based on divine writings, “actual proof”. By knowing that they have the commands from God to back their decisions it makes it easier for divine command theorists to act in accordance to God’s will. These decisions would not be possible for one individual to make on their own that is why faith in God is obligatory. This theory is consistently contested by what is referred to as the Euthyphro dilemma, which is the question whether morally good actions are willed by God because they are morally good or they are morally good because they are commanded by God.
How would society criticize your actions? Would you be labeled as a hero or a murder? A relativist would make a decision based on their individual or cultural moral backgrounds. The solution may vary from relativist to relativist because of this. An example would be an individual that is influenced by an enlightened society who would no doubt save the women and children versus a barbaric society that would no doubt save the crew members because they are fit to stay alive. If an individual uses their own moral compass they can come to an entirely different conclusion than those influenced by outside means. An individual with a darker side could choose to save no one and take the boat for themselves and let everyone die. On the other hand, an individual that likes a game of chance would have people draw straws to determine who can stay on the boat. For a relativist their decisions are based on the whims of the individual or their culture. Many factors would play into a relativist’s decision and the outcome would vary greatly even with the smallest change.
What is the solution that is most beneficial to you? An egoist would act in accordance with their personal self interest and only take into account the interests of others if they relate. This does not mean that the person is selfish or cold-hearted. Instead their incentive for helping others may be that they simply want to be labeled as a hero. An egoist may go about this in two separate ways. If they wish to save...

Other Essays Like Solving The Euthyphro Dilemma

Workplace Ethical Delemma Essay

1301 words - 6 pages be a gun. Solving the dilemma For this particular problem, I had to let the client go home. The mother insisted that she was not scared of her son and wanted to take him home. I tried everything I could to convince her to let me place the boy somewhere else, but to no avail. I called my supervisor, and she agreed that there was nothing more I could do to keep her from taking Joe home. I asked the police to please patrol the area that night and I

Business Research Methods Essay

667 words - 3 pages tertiary sources includes, dictionaries, handbooks, directories, chronologies, fact books, and guide books (UML, 2014). 2. There are six steps involved in solving the management question hierarchy dilemma in an organization. This includes, identifying management dilemma, asking management question, asking an investigative question, asking research questions, asking a management question and management giving decision (UML, 2014

Pepsi Ethics

2614 words - 11 pages , “Ethical dilemma is a situation which includes the conflict between the two honest or moral choices”. According to them, solving an ethical dilemma may be biased so for the reason, each person thinks and act in a different way. If taken as a whole, the main point is to consider trying to solve the ethical dilemma whether to choose to do it, indeed or in ethical way (Childress, 1999). Company profile- PepsiCo: Pepsi was first made in New Bern, North

Dilemma at Devil's Den

905 words - 4 pages Case :19 Dilemma at Devil’s Den MGT 285 5-15-2015 Jesus Gomez 1. What problems has Susan identified with the night shift operations of the Devil’s Den? How well does the management team perform such strategy execution processes as competency building, shaping the culture, instituting policies and procedures, establishing control system, developing reward and discipline systems, and exhibiting ethical leadership? Susan identified

Refletive Writing Paper

832 words - 4 pages In this project “Transportation Costs (or Trucker’s Dilemma),” we need to use our math skills to solve for the minimum total costs of the trip. We have some basic information to solve the problem. We know the total trip is 290 miles long, at a constant rate of 50 miles per hour; we also know about one gallon fuel can drive 7 miles, and fuel costs $3.60 per gallon. For each mile per hour increase in speed, the truck loses a tenth of a mile per

organisation behaviour

3957 words - 16 pages Point/Counterpoint Lost in Translation? 65 Questions for Review 66 Experiential Exercise Workforce Diversity 66 Ethical Dilemma Jekyll and Hyde 67 Case Incident 1 "Lessons for 'Undercover' Bosses" 68 Case Incident 2 Era of the Disposable Worker? 69 CONTENTS 2 Diversity in Organizations 73 Diversity 74 Demographic Characteristics of the U.S. Workforce 75 • Levels of Diversity 76 • Discrimination 76 Biographical

Walmart Dilema

1408 words - 6 pages very dishonest behavior on the manager’s behalf and degrades the dignity of the employees. All of the actions stated above cross the line as they are unfair, dishonest and degrading. The root of the problem lies in the labor cost budget and should be looked at as having importance above all others. Step 3 in Ghillyer’s 3-step process to solving an ethical dilemma is to finally make a decision. This is done by using the information gathered in

Problem Solution: Harrison-Keyes Inc

5229 words - 21 pages legal right to publish works electronically. The problem is that H-K may have the legal right to publish anyway but morally it would be wrong to publish without the authors’ full consent. Also, E-publishing could bring more business for both H-K and authors. Asia Digital Publishing (ADP) and HK are in an ethical dilemma because ADP interest is keeping the contract with HK for the project. HK interest is keeping the project timeline. HK

Ethical Issues

781 words - 4 pages develops the ability to employ the use of force effectively, efficiently, and lawfully. Officers went through a field training program called (PTO) Police Training Officer, which prepares officers of community policing and problem solving principles. Ethics and Integrity training help new officers with the importance of ethical practices in case they encounter a dilemma about an ethical question. The class have scenarios, streaming video, and

Bus 642 Case Assignment Week 4

1528 words - 7 pages research question hierarchy for Ramada. The research process model can be used to clarify and build the management research question hierarchy for Ramada. The Shifflet customer satisfaction survey began the process, and prompted RFS to find their dilemma the" Management Dilemma" would be a need to increase customer satisfaction. The "Management Question" is what actions need to be taken to increasing customer satisfaction. The "Research Question(s)" is

Aluminum Maker

2215 words - 9 pages of legal counsel not associated with Alumina then follows providing insights applicable to the case. An alternative solution not included on the simulation is then presented along with its impact to the ethical dilemma being faced by the stakeholders. The simulation shows how regulatory compliance will impact a company and its decisions. Furthermore, how the legal system comes into place in solving the dispute presented. . Key facts

Related Papers

Socrates And Piety Essay

1364 words - 6 pages call just and concludes that he still does not have enough to determine this fourth attempt to be a universal definition of piety. Euthyphro responded to Socrates dilemma by suggesting that piety is more about looking after the gods or providing a service and when you perform an act of piety that you are actually making one of the gods better. After much deliberation, Euthyphro proposes his last definition of piety, which states that piety is a

I Donthave Anything To Upload Essay

922 words - 4 pages self-seeking, and it is not easily angered. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth.  It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, and always perseveres. - Corinthians 1:13 The Euthyphro dilemma is found in Plato's dialogue Euthyphro; and asks the question ‘is something good because God commands it, or does God command something because it is good?’ The dilemma is that if the acts being performed are morally good because

Righ And Wrong Essay

661 words - 3 pages Each one of us has been accused of something in our lives that we didn’t do. And to be sent to prison for that crime would be very hard to except. If you were sent to jail for something you felt was right, and just, and had the chance to escape and not be caught again, would you? That is that is the dilemma Socrates had to face. He had the chance and the means yet he chose not to escape. Did he do the right thing by not escaping from jail

Biblical Ethics And Moral Dilemmas: God Is The Answer

2778 words - 12 pages theory. The most common objection to divine command theory was raised as early as Plato in his dialogue, the Euthyphro, where he asks “Does God (in Plato’s case, the gods) command things because they are good, or are things good because God commands them?”1 In response to this, the first thing to note is that it is a much bigger problem for Euthyphro than it is for a Christian, since Euthyphro envisioned a plethora of gods who disagreed with each