This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Something About Law Essay

3234 words - 13 pages

Something about law
1. The advisory opinion issued by the ICJ on the adoption of the declaration of independence leaves a lot of room for us to rethink.
As to me, I do not agree with the conclusion very much on the one hand that the answer is not exact to the question, and on the other hand, I believe the question that in the present case should be reformulated in another way.
2. The ICJ organized the advisory opinion quite clear, seemly. In the substance part, to start with, the ICJ identified the scope and the meaning of the question, and then went to the factual background. After that, it focused on the original question, searching for the applicable law(s) as well as analyzing ...view middle of the document...

Yet the work is in vain. Often a statement that the declaration of independence does not violate international law gives those untutored in law the misimpression that it is lawful. The mass media brandished headlines in many forums proclaiming a similar message, such as “World court says Kosovo’s independence is legal”.
Besides, the only problem as the court sees in the question is whether the author of the declaration is the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government of Kosovo. In assessing whether or not the declaration of independence is in accordance with international law, the Court said it must be free to examine the entire record and decide for itself whether that declaration was promulgated by the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government or some other entity.
II. Find the applicable law
4. Second, the court focused on the original question:
“Is the unilateral declaration of independence by the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government of Kosovo in accordance with international law?”
To then, the problem faced by the court is what the applicable law(s) is (are). The court turned its attention to the general international law and Security Council resolution 1244(1999).
II.A. General international law
5. As to general international law, the court found that “In no case, however, does the practice of States as a whole suggest that the act of promulgating the declaration was regarded as contrary to international law. On the contrary, State practice during this period points clearly to the conclusion that international law contained no prohibition of declarations of independence. During the second half of the twentieth century, the international law of self-determination developed in such a way as to create a right to independence for the peoples of non-self-governing territories and peoples subject to alien subjugation, domination and exploitation. A great many new States have come into existence as a result of the exercise of this right.”
5. Meanwhile, the court denied the opinion that the principle of territorial integrity shall be mentioned in this situation since the court considered that this principle could only be applied in the relationship between states.
6. The court also denied the link of the present declaration with the formers which are condemned by Security Council: see, inter alia, Security Council resolutions 216 (1965) and 217 (1965), concerning Southern Rhodesia; Security Council resolution 541 (1983), concerning northern Cyprus; and Security Council resolution 787 (1992), concerning the Republika Srpska. The Court notes, the illegality attached to the declarations of independence thus stemmed not from the unilateral character of these declarations as such, but from the fact that they were, or would have been, connected with the unlawful use of force or other egregious violations of norms of general international law, in particular those of a peremptory character (jus cogens).
What is the fact...

Other Essays Like Something About Law

felons right to bare arms Essay

648 words - 3 pages , and to some extent it certainly is but you have to do something to delineate serious and less serious crimes. The problem is there are just to many if’s and’s, and but’s to be dealt wit. You have a million different laws each with a million different circumstances for a million different criminals. In the end there are just too many “what if’s” in every single law. And in the end, who would get to decide whether your robbery is

The Law of Contract Confines Itself to the Enforcement of Voluntarily Created Civil Obligations

2096 words - 9 pages will enter into a contract voluntarily. When it comes to the discussion about civil obligations, contract law defines its boundary within the enforcement of civil obligations. This research paper was created with the motive to finding out how the contract law confines itself to the enforcement of civil obligations. Introduction We enter into contracts in our everyday general activities. Paying fare to the taxi driver amounts to entering into a

How to Become a Police Officer


Letter from Birmingham Jail. King Jr., Martin Luther

672 words - 3 pages talks about religion and faith with the hopes of one day being able to talk face to face with his fellow clergymen about the injustice that is taking place in Birmingham. A. Allusion (from literature). “I would agree with St. Augustine that “an unjust law is no law at all.” It helped him make his point about not just obeying the law but having the responsibility to disobey unjust laws. It also made for a great transition for the

The Roles and Functions of Law

882 words - 4 pages incorrect, which also can guide to what people can and can’t do. This is a way to be able to control law and order, which allows the community grow without constant arguments or disagreements about things. Although, no nation will ever be considered to be perfect, law does have a role in providing protection. This allows people and businesses to deal with issues with full confidence. This confidence is backed by justice will prevail and help


1050 words - 5 pages a right or claim through legal action). Judicial decision: A decision about an individual law suit issued by federal and state courts. Ideology: Set of aims and ideas that direct one’s goals, expectations and actions. Theology: Study of god and the relations between God, humankind and the universe. Comprehensive: Including all aspects of something. Integrated: Making connections or creating links. Scholars: A person who studied a

Police Influence

792 words - 4 pages punishment as well as who the victim may be. The same ideas constitute our law enforcement today that did in the past, but not as far as some of the brutality and force that was used throughout history. For example historically it was said that if a crime was committed the punishment would fit the crime such as if someone stole something, then they would have to suffer through having their hand cut off. If someone said something they should not have said

Paper About Dangerous Dogs

1032 words - 5 pages the bad things, but do not offer a solution to the problems he finds. rjQuestion 3 The 1. text do not offer that much of a solution, it only talks about we need to find a solution. The 3. Text is more a critic of the law and system. It points out the faults, but do not come up with any solutions. But both these texts point to there has be done something with the owners, but they do not come up with any ideas to how. The 2. Text is

Some Moral Minima

2881 words - 12 pages they cannot be universally required. Others can. This is the clue to the content of moral law. We know something about the requirements of a moral rule. It must be universally binding. Thus, the test of a moral obligation is simple. Ask whether your action can be made into a universal moral law. If it can, the action is permitted. If it cannot, you must not do it. The law must be universal because all features about you or me are external to

The Natural Law Approach To Ethics

1814 words - 8 pages innocent, to reproduce, to acquire knowledge; to live in an ordered society and to worship God these are called the Primary Precepts. Acts that are in accordance with human purpose are good and those acts, which are not in accordance with human purpose is bad. Secondary precepts are rulings about things that we should or shouldn't do because they uphold or to fail to uphold the primary precept. A Natural Law approach to ethics

Arizona Immigration Law

1188 words - 5 pages the Federal Government. But Arizona isn’t using powers that are vested in the federal government for naturalization. It is well known, that it is against federal law to be in this country illegally. Arizona’s law simply deals with what immigrants can do once they are in Arizona, or what Arizonans can do about immigrants in their state who are there illegally. If it was Arizona’s intention to push the federal government into

Related Papers

Business Finance Essay

1872 words - 8 pages constructions to … The question: What is the nature, or essence, of law? Let us look at two possible conceptions to the question which could be derived and therefore producing different answers:- 1. The question could be looked as addressing the definition of law (i.e. what is the definition of “law”) therefore being a linguistic question rather than being a question about the phenomenon of law. … What we have looked at; in the different conception

The Natural Law Theory Essay

1231 words - 5 pages , and the moral from the immoral. “ natural law theory is a theory about the relationship between morality and human nature, the theory that who we are determines how we ought to act”(Holt 1). Nature is a definitive guide to use when deciding what is appropriate and how God would want life to be lived. Natural law is used by using reason to develop knowledge of life and oneself. The natural law theory is the only way to attain a moral life and can

Mapping Legal Theory Essay

952 words - 4 pages , suggests that nothing is separate or ‘outside there’ about law. The artifactualists join the legal positivists in their opinion that law is made by human and that more focus should be on the tangible aspects of law. The artifactualists however criticize the legal positivists for basing their quest on the significance of law rather than driving the agency analysis to the obvious conclusions; performing contextual analysis about what people do

"Billy Budd" By Herman Melville, Comparison Essay

402 words - 2 pages sympathizes with Billy, he's pressured to follow the rules of the navy. Mutiny was a popular treason among the navy, and Vere wouldn't let something like that happen on his ship. He's a very strict and orderly commander. In the story he's described as "never tolerating an infraction of discipline." Captain Vere's justice is blind, without emotion. He doesn't show favor to Billy but strictly enforces the laws. He prefers law over emotion. He view's emotion