Spanking Versus Child Abuse Debate Paper

2043 words - 9 pages

Debate Paper
Laura Hale-Steingrebe
May 4, 2014
Dr. Hector Iweka

Spanking versus child abuse
The most common misconception that spanking is a form of child abuse has now affected the proper discipline of today’s children and young adults. Some parents are actually afraid to discipline their children in the same way they were brought up due to fears of child abuse claims. Are you one of those parents? It is surprising how many of us are. Is there a right or wrong way to discipline children, and who has the say in it? Most experts on child rearing are against spanking in belief that it causes negative long-term effects, but parents who were spanked as a child tend to believe ...view middle of the document...

“Spanking children under the age of 2 puts those children into a higher risk group for behavioral problems later,” says Eric P. Slade, assistant professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and co-author of the study (Slade, PhD & Wissow, MD, 2004) (Lallanilla, 2014). Some children may be more affected than others with behavior problems (Slade, PhD & Wissow, MD, 2004) (Lallanilla, 2014). “Researchers were surprised to find that 39 percent of all children younger than 2 had been spanked at least once in the previous week.” (Slade, PhD & Wissow, MD, 2004). This study is not the first to show an association between spanking and behavioral problems, but it is the first to show the effects of spanking in children under the age of 2 (Slade, PhD & Wissow, MD, 2004) (Lallanilla, 2014). After the completion of the study, researchers speculate that spanking may be more widely accepted as fair punishment among African-American families but more stigmatized among white families with high stress parents (Lallanilla, 2014). Two-year olds, of any race or gender, instinctually think it is ok to hit anyway, so why should it be ok for parents to reiterate that to them at such an impressionable age by using spanking as a disciplinary action (Zeidler, 2012)? Parents need to use their best judgment when it comes to spanking in their family and if it is obtaining the behavior results they were looking for (Slade, PhD & Wissow, MD, 2004) (Lallanilla, 2014).
The choice to spank or not to spank a child should belong to the parent. Discipline is a personal choice. Parents should have the right to discipline their children as they see fit according to the behavior or action. Spanking is a form of physical discipline that has been used for years and its effectiveness depends on how the parent uses this right. Yes it can cause brief emotional stress or it can also remind the child not to do the same thing again. The lessons learned by kids from their parents may be harsh to some, but the method of spanking does send a clear statement that the situation is not in their control, but that it belongs to the parent. There is no doubt that when a parent has a child that is acting out or throwing a temper tantrum that the first thought is to spank them to get the child to stop the bad behavior. However, it is the way the parents have been choosing to discipline their children that is raising major questions among experts, society, and family and friends alike. Because of those questions, parents nowadays have to be extremely careful in their choices of disciplinary actions, in public or the privacy of their home, so the lines of child abuse are not crossed. Too many parents nowadays are criticized for correcting their child’s bad behavior in public or private, and social workers are overwhelmed with reports of child abuse when in all actuality it is simply a parent who is trying to quiet a kid who is acting out. So how are parents supposed...

Other Essays Like Spanking Versus Child Abuse Debate Paper

Psychology-Effect of Punished Essay

996 words - 4 pages punishment and their children's endorsement of spanking and hitting other children. Child Abuse & Neglect. 34(9), 639–646. Web. February 17. 2016 Sarah Kovac. 2014. Spanking the gray matter out of our kids. CNN. Web. February 19. 2016

Is Corporal Punishment Needed to Discipline Children

570 words - 3 pages coincided with a dramatic decline in acceptance of spanking among parents, from 53% to 11%. From 1979 to 1996, the country recorded only a single death from parent-child abuse. Still it unlikely spanking soon will become illegal on this side of the Atlantic. C. So what? The respected family research laboratory at the University of New Hampshire report that about one-third of parents have hit an infant and that most parents occasionally hit

We Need Corporal Punishment In The Classroom

1618 words - 7 pages punishment should never be used out of spite and should be well-regulated by school officials. In its publications on the subject, the National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect draws a line between legitimate, age-appropriate physical discipline, and “over-discipline,” suggesting that corporal punishment can be a suitable option and should not be dismissed out of hand as a barbaric or inhumane practice. Experts Weigh In On Spanking Corporal

The Fight Against Child Abuse

1993 words - 8 pages Could you imagine how children must feel when they are abused by someone that is supposed to love and protect them, and nothing is done to help them? For this reason, it is important to realize there are legislative laws protecting child abusers from hate crimes, and excuses certain people from mandated reporting abuse. In fact, almost 5 children die every day as a result of abuse (Child Help, 2011). Also, money is spent to convict and

Child Maltreatment and Juvenile Delinquency

3619 words - 15 pages crimes in adolescence. A substantial number of children enter the juvenile justice system with a history of abuse, with approximately one third of these adolescence are actively associated with a child welfare agency at the time of their initial arrest. This paper attempts to establish a clear definition of physical, sexual and emotional abuse, as well as, neglect, while also reviewing a pattern of subsequent delinquency. The effects of racial

Diciplining Your Child

723 words - 3 pages We were all kids once and we all know that we liked to push the limits to see what we can get away with. If you are over a certain age chances are you were spanked as a child. Maybe you were disciplined with a swat of the hand or maybe even a belt, switch, or hairbrush. These days, a lot of people might consider that abuse. But few of us really know what the law actually says about spanking or just disciplining your child in general

Corporal Punishment

2086 words - 9 pages household, it is clear is that the desired outcome be known by the caregiver n order for corporal punishment to be effective. For some, it is difficult to draw conclusions about spanking when compared to abuse. Holden stated that in research on corporal punishment he has reviewed, parents may not be honest in their responses (Holden, 2002). Another interesting issue that may be emphasized is that at home ‘spanking’ is used in conjunction with other

Taming of the Shrew: Male Domination

1122 words - 5 pages also. (Whately, 224)" Acting in "foolish, childish, slavish" behavior permits the husband to teach the wife wrongful doing and therefore taming her not to be a shrew. This circumstance relates to that of a parent spanking a child when discipline is needed. The point is to teach not to do wrongful things. Men revert back to their need to be the best, and to dominate in a spousal relationship fills that void. Petruchio tames

Child Abuse

1126 words - 5 pages the child for bumps or bruises. They would make notation of it and then have the parent sign a paper. If the child had more than so many bruises or bumps, they center would notify social services to take a look at why this child is coming to school with so many scars. Child abuse has so many effects on the person, such as psychological problems such as isolation, fear, and having the inability to trust these can translate into possible

The Effects Of Child Abuse And Neglect

2272 words - 10 pages abused and neglected by people that are suppose to be the closest to them. There are many signs and effects of abuse, depending on the child that is being abused. Throughout this paper, each form of abuse will be addressed and those forms will be analyzed to find a proper treatment for these problems. Under law, a physically abused child means "a child less than 18 years of age whose parents responsible for the child care... inflicts physical

History of Child Abuse

1390 words - 6 pages  History of Child Abuse BSHS 408 September 28, 2015 Amy Willey, LCSW History of Child Abuse All through history, children have been exposed to many different types of abuse. It hasn’t been until the past few decades that legislation and organizations have been created to help the fight against child abuse and neglect. As you will read throughout this paper, the history of child abuse and neglect has contributed to shaping the

Related Papers

Spank Child Help Essay

859 words - 4 pages control on the parent's part. Spanking is often looked at as a violent form of discipline that is never necessary to control a child. *Some feel that spanking or corporal punishment can often lead to child abuse. It is felt that if a parent spanks their child once, it will be easier to do it again and again for any discipline problem, no matter how mild or severe. *Opponents believe that children can lose self-esteem by being spanked as a form

Out Law Spanking Essay

596 words - 3 pages of which passed the corporal punishment law that showed numerous statistics of parents that physically punish their children. In relation to parents punishing their children, two articles contrast whether spanking creates no harm or greater abuse towards corporal punishment. As Baurimd a psychologist, mentions, it has come to show that being spanked or not makes no difference to a child because children will most likely have the urge to behave

Spanking Is Not Okay Essay

1750 words - 7 pages child learns through repetition and by watching others around them. A better way to avoid punishment at all is to place your child in an environment where they will not learn those behaviors. Simple actions can be taken to avoid any need of spanking. Parents, especially soon-to-be parents, should understand the dangers that come with spanking a child for punishment. Parents have been reported for almost board-line abuse with their kids by

Child Abuse...... Is It Allowed? Essay

438 words - 2 pages American adults agreed with this statement " It is sometimes necessary to discipline a child with a good hard spanking". When a parent spanks their children, it means that they are not dealing with the matter in a way where it would bring upon a more permanent change. Spanking loses its effectiveness over time and parents have to hit harder and harder raising the danger of physical injury. So what began as a desire to discipline a child can get