State, With Reasons, Whether This Quotation Is Consistent With The Use Of The Doctrine Of Binding Precedent In Australian Courts

1273 words - 6 pages

“Now it is the function of the judges, I believe, to bring laws up to date with the expectations and needs of our society.” High Court Justice Lionel Murphy addressing the National Press Club 1980.

State, with reasons, whether this quotation is consistent with the use of the doctrine of binding precedent in Australian courts.

High Court Justice Lionel Murphy’s statement can be considered consistent with the doctrine of binding precedent. There have been many decisions made by the High Court that reflect this statement, however, when considering the relevance of his statement to the doctrine of precedent, the position of a judge dictates the function they can perform. The doctrine of ...view middle of the document...

Justice Brennan, a sitting judge on the case, discussed the notion that although Australian law is influenced by precedent, it is not strictly bound by this doctrine:

‘Australian law is not only the historical successor of, but is an organic development from, the law of England. Although our law is the prisoner of its history, it is not now bound by decisions of courts in the hierarchy of an Empire then concerned with the development of its colonies.’ Justice Gerard Brennan, Mabo v Queensland (No 2) (1992) 175 CLR at 29.

This recognition that Australian law is not bound by previous rulings is consistent with the view of Justice Murphy and the application of precedent in an Australian court. It is also of note that Justice Brennan refers to the law as organic, which strongly indicates that the law is not set in stone, but rather, can grow as needed.

Justice Kirby makes a significant statement regarding the Mabo case and he touches on the idea that the law is constantly being refined and, that the precedent set by common law can indeed be overruled:

‘The Mabo decision made clear the circumstances in which the common law of Australia may be overruled as it advances to a higher principle. In so doing, it provided invaluable guidance for future courts faced with like problems in completely different areas of the law, less controversial.’ (Kirby 1994)

This goes beyond of the initial statement of Justice Murphy as it includes the idea that future courts will be faced with problems similar to this case. Combining the organic description of the law from Justice Brennan and the clear ruling that precedent can be overturned, it is clear that Justice Murphy’s statement is a parallel to the application of precedent in Australian courts.

It is interesting to note that the doctrine of terra nullius was first documented and implemented in 1835 by Governor Bourke:

‘Whereas... His Majesty’s Subjects have taken possession of vacant Lands... under the pretence of a contract ... with the Aboriginal Natives...for the possession, title, or claim ...within the limits of the Government ... is void and of no effect...’. (Bourke 1835)

When Governor Bourke set this doctrine of terra nullius down, consideration of the beliefs of the settlers and, the relationship Australia had with England at the time may lead us to determine that, on the basis of probability, it was the correct decision in relation to the needs of our society. If we consider that slavery was still the norm for the British Empire, which allowed importation of slaves into its colonies until 1807 and continued using slaves in the British West Indies until 1827, it is conceivable that the powers of New South Wales considered that they were treating the indigenous population favourably.

Considering the...

Other Essays Like State, with Reasons, Whether This Quotation Is Consistent with the Use of the Doctrine of Binding Precedent in Australian Courts

Progressive Case Study: This Memo Addresses the Pros and Cons of the Potential Acquisition of Hotels in Italy, Along with Our Recommendations for Whether We Should Moved Forward with a Purchase

2080 words - 9 pages From: Executive Team (CMO, CFO, COO, and CHCO)   This memo addresses the pros and cons of the potential acquisition of hotels in Italy, along with our recommendations for whether we should moved forward with a purchase. 1. Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) - Larry G. Morris Jr The Positives From a marketing perspective expanding into Italy will be a good opportunity for the organization, as a major player in the U.S. hotel industry already we

The Underlying Theme of Othello Is Reputation and It Is This That Culminates in the Play’s Tragedy. to What Extent Do You Agree with This Claim?

1172 words - 5 pages English Literature The Main theme of Othello is not the theme of jealousy but the theme of reputation and this is one of the main constitutes, responsible for the tragedy of the play: to what extent do you agree with this in regards to Act Two Scene Three and Act Three Scene Three? In William Shakespeare's Othello it could be thought that the main theme is Jealousy however in Act two scene three reputation become a prominent theme

Asses the Significance of Economic Reasons Influencing Britain’s Relationship with Its Empire in Africa in the Period 1870-1981?

2296 words - 10 pages , Britain also had significant investments in Egypt that needed to be protected as trade with Egypt was vital for the British economy. What is more according to Hobson’s study another important driver for African expansion were the domestic economic reasons. The unequal distribution of wealth, under consumption and fall in investment encouraged Britain to change its relationship towards Africa in order to protect its own problematic economy. This

The Doctrine Of Salvation

588 words - 3 pages The Doctrine of Salvation (Soteriology)      God provides us with everything we need; we see this in Genesis where he provided Adam everything he needed. Jesus became a man by reincarnation a verse to support this is John 1:14 “The word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have seen his glory. The glory of the One and Only, who came from the Father, full of grace and truth. Jesus was perfect he did not even

Criminal Justice in Action: Responsibilities of State and Federal Courts

675 words - 3 pages here. Appellate courts do not use juries or witnesses to reach a decision, instead the judges make the decision if the case should be reversed or remanded. The feral court system is three-tiered model consisting of U.S district courts (trial courts of general jurisdiction) and various courts of limited jurisdiction, U.S courts of appeals ( intermediate courts of appeal), and the United States Supreme Court. State court judges are usually

This Essay Is Called "Seven Days In A Week" And Is About The School Board's Consideration Of Whether Or Not To Extend The School Time In Days. This Essay Is In Letter Form

584 words - 3 pages Dear Editor,Imagine that it is a Friday and that you are relieved to be able to sleep in tomorrow morning. Then, the loud speaker comes on and it announces a reminder saying, "See you tomorrow! Remember, we have changed the school week for the rest of the year!" You instantly recall that a new rule had been passed in the Board of Education. You remember all of the depressing notices mailed to your home. You had hoped the rule changed before

The Doctrine of Baptismal Regeneration

4961 words - 20 pages THE DOCTRINE OF BAPTISMAL REGENERATION: AN ANALYSIS OF ITS ASSOCIATION WITH THE RESTORATION MOVEMENT A Research Paper Submitted to Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary Online In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Course Systematic Theology II (TH 530-D09) By Justin Hartpence (23828793) May 12, 2013 THESIS STATEMENT This paper shall argue that this is an inaccurate depiction and seek to put forth the

Constitutional Conventions Are Rules of Political Practice Which Are Regarded as Binding by Those to Whom They Apply, but Which Are Not Laws as They Are Not Enforced by the Courts or by the House of...

2263 words - 10 pages exercised by the Prime Minister and Ministers of the Crown in the name of His / Her Royal Majesty the King / Queen. 5. Unenforceability by the courts Constitutional conventions are not, and cannot be, enforced by courts of law. The primary reason for this, according to the Supreme Court of Canada in its 1981 Partition Reference, is that, "They are generally in conflict with the legal rules which they postulate and the courts are bound to

The Analysis of Law and Courts in Today’s Business Environment

790 words - 4 pages obligation to do this. The supreme court has the final decision of federal constitutional questions. Judicial review allows the judiciary to check the other branches of government under which legislative and executive actions are subject to review. A judiciary has the power to annul the acts of the state when it is found to be incompatible with higher branches of authority. Judicial review acts as a way to check and balance the governmental

With Reference to Located, Examine the Problems Associated with the Increasing Use of Rural Areas for Recreation and Tourism (25)

1013 words - 5 pages With reference to located, examine the problems associated with the increasing use of rural areas for recreation and tourism (25) Rural areas are being used significantly more due to recreation and tourism due to counterurbanisation. This is affecting the social, economic and environmental factors of rural villages. Tourism changes businesses and creates more environmental problems such as pollution as well as causing house prices to rise

Characterizing the RNA-binding activity of MEX-5

2388 words - 10 pages tolerate. MEX-5 instead binds with similar affinities (Kd=10-100 nM) to a heterogeneous set of uridine-rich sequences of at least 10 nucleotides (ref Pagano). The comparison of the sequences of MEX-5 and TIS11d reveals a different scheme in the spacing between the CCCH zinc coordinating residues in each ZF. In MEX-5 this scheme is CX9CX5CX3H for ZF1 and CX10CX5CX3H for ZF2. For TIS11d, both ZFs have the same spacing, with the first two cysteines

Related Papers

Consider How The Doctrine Of Binding Precedent Operates In The English Courts, Having Particular Regard To Its Advantages And Disadvantages

3322 words - 14 pages Judicial precedent is the process by which judges follow the decisions in previous cases where the case facts are sufficiently similar. The main basis for this doctrine is the application of the legal principle Stare Decisis (Elliot and Quinn 2009). Translated this means let the decision stand, the practical application of this means the inferior courts are bound by the decisions of all courts above them in the judicial hierarchy. The principle

"When People Succeed, It Is Because Of Hard Work, Luck Has Nothing To Do With Success”. Do You Agree Or Disagree With The Quotation Above? Use Specific And Examples To Explain Your Position

655 words - 3 pages "When people succeed, it is because of hard work, Luck has nothing to do with success" "When people succeed, it is because of hard work, Luck has nothing to do with success". Do you agree or disagree with the quotation above? Use specific and examples to explain your position. Everyone has strong desire for success in life. Some people believe that success is a result of hard work and luck has nothing to do

Outline Some Of The Reasons Why Aging In American Society Is Often Associated With Sexlessness

497 words - 2 pages "And yes, [he] did want to be that young again. But he wanted to be a boy precisely so he could fall in love with other boys, with no awkward age difference, no accusations of cradle robbing" (Lowenthal, 1998, p. 135).Youth and beauty. And sex.Our society covets youth and beauty. On T.V., in movies, in magazines, everywhere you look youth and beauty are equated with sexiness. Old is rarely equated with beauty. Old is rarely associated with

How Adequate Is Mill’s Conception Of Happiness? How Good Are His Arguments To Show That “Higher” Pleasures Are Intrinsically More Desirable Than “Lower” Ones? Is This Distinction Consistent With The...

2110 words - 9 pages How adequate is Mill’s conception of happiness? How good are his arguments to show that “higher” pleasures are intrinsically more desirable than “lower” ones? Is this distinction consistent with the thesis that pleasure is the only thing of value? In “Utilitarianism” Mill argues that ‘higher’ pleasures are intrinsically more valuable than ‘lower’ pleasures, citing the invariable preference of men who have access to both available (pp.140). I