Taking Sides Essay

647 words - 3 pages

Sabre Thompson
May 31, 2009
Mr. Caruso
Taking Sides Paper

Who is Billy Milligan? No one seems to know Billy Milligan these days, not that anyone ever did. Born in Miami Florida in 1955 as William Stanley Milligan, he was a criminal or a victim; an expert actor or so disturbed that his mind fractured into at least 24 personalities. Shortly after moving to Circleville, Ohio in 1960 with his mother, Dorothy, he helped plan a Lancaster drugstore robbery in early 1975. Not much later, Lancaster police arrested him, and he pleaded guilty to robbing the store. He was sentenced to at least two years in prison and paroled in April 1977. Six months later, the OSU campus-area rapes started where he kidnapped three women from the Ohio State University campus area in 1977, raped them and said that part of him did it for affection.
The first rape was on October 14, 1977. Milligan pointed ...view middle of the document...

Doctors examined Milligan, and even the skeptical ones saw what Boxerbaum had described (Phillips, 1988). In the course of preparing his defense, he underwent a psychological examination by Dr. Willis C. Driscoll, who diagnosed Milligan with schizophrenia. He was then examined by psychologist Dorothy Turner of Southwest Community Mental Health Center in Columbus, Ohio. During this examination, Turner concluded that Milligan suffered from multiple personality disorder. Milligan's public defenders, Gary Schweickart and Judy Stevenson, pleaded an insanity defense and he was committed until such time as he regains sanity. Milligan was the first person to be found not guilty based on an insanity defense.
After doing research on Milligan’s case I feel that he should not be held fully responsible for his actions. When under the control of one identity, the person is usually unable to remember some of the events that occurred while other personalities were in control (NAMI, 2000). It is said that the person with DID (Dissociative Identity Disorder) is unaware of their condition until seen by a doctor. A very common complaint in people with DID is episodes of amnesia or time loss. These types of people may be unable to remember events in all or part of a proceeding time period. They may repeatedly encounter unfamiliar people who claim to know them, find themselves somewhere without knowing how they got there, or find items that they don't remember purchasing among their possessions. (NAMI, 2000). Even though it was wrong in many ways with what Milligan did, he had no control of what was going on in his mind. Retrieving and dealing with memories of trauma is important for the person with DID because this disorder is believed to be caused by physical or sexual abuse in childhood. It has been said that Billy Milligan was abused through out his childhood by his father, which could have caused a lot of the mental problems. With that being said I feel what Milligan did was wrong, but in a way he really could not help himself.

Other Essays Like Taking Sides

Kansas City Zephyrs Baseball Club, Inc. Case Study

563 words - 3 pages right?” The case illustrate major areas in which both sides disputed the way the financial information is been presented, and the way key accounting concepts had been used taking in consideration the recognition of revenues and the matching concept: 1. - Players salary expenses, current roster salary, amortization of signing bonuses and non-roster guaranteed contract expenses 2. - Roster depreciation expense 3. - Related-party

Affirmative Action Essay

615 words - 3 pages disagreement at hand and analyze both sides, so that a common thread can be illuminated, and a compromise and solution be rendered. Mr. Connerly didn’t come close. Mr. Connerly made light of the fact that Merit works are squelched in the process of Affirmative Action implementation, but gives no example of a disproportionate separation between the merits of minorities and none minorities. If there were such a case to be made there is definitely information

T O Abort or Not to Abort....That Is the Question

1751 words - 8 pages Jimmy Grossman NOV 21, 2010 English 1C Condon To Abort Or Not To Abort?….That Is The Question For my synthesis essay, I chose one of the most controversial and heat raising topics of the modern day. I chose abortion. I chose this topic because I’m very both-sided on the aspects of this argument. I don’t know which side to take because both sides make very good arguments. First of all, I don’t believe a life

Fine Dining Etiquette

1292 words - 6 pages . • If another diner asks for the salt or pepper, pass both together, even if a table mate asks for only one of them. This is so dinner guests won't have to search for orphaned shakers. • Set any passed item, whether it's the salt and pepper shakers, a bread basket, or a butter plate, directly on the table instead of passing hand-to-hand. • Never intercept a pass. Snagging a roll out of the breadbasket or taking a shake of salt when it is

Against the Backdrop of the Ukraine

1184 words - 5 pages qualitatively new line of policy. The new configuration is already taking shape. With the shock of Ukraine and Syria now over, predictability is beginning to return to Russian policy, as evidenced by the seven trends below. Trend #1 Russian policy on its western borders will be defensive, not offensive. Contrary to the fears and phobias of Eastern Europe, there will be no military steps against the new NATO members. Air, sea and cyber incidents

Daniel and Philip Berrigan

1352 words - 6 pages ). In this one war, more lives were taken than in previous wars and conflicts combined. For both sides during the war, fighting and health conditions were horrific. The soldiers had to try and survive on very slim rations provided by their supporting governments. Soldiers had to go so far as taking shoes off of their dead enemies just to have decent shoes in order to keep on fighting. The terrain was very rough and rugged. The territory of


1285 words - 6 pages shows the ugly and beautiful sides of a marriage. Dennis Scott has tried to tell us that we should not lose hope even if we can’t understand our own wife or anyone of our loved ones for that matter. The reason being her unpredictable behaviour but should always see the bright side of all the problems. The poem was touching as he tried so hard to try and understand his wife, all to improve their marriage and relationship. The poem made me more

How Are the Ycja Consequences?

930 words - 4 pages How are the Youth Criminal Justice Act Consequences for Young Offenders? Introduction: How are the Youth Criminal Justice Act consequences? This may be a question that is never going to be answered. There are many sides, opinions, and views to issues, and this is certainly one of them. One party, usually victims or their relatives, states that it is much too “soft” on offenders, claiming they’re getting off easy. On the other side of the


982 words - 4 pages . They think Carmen deserved more and was cheated by their deceased mother. Juanita tried to be fair with Carmen, however Carmen is taking out on Juanita, and now the business, what their mother did to Carmen. Juanita did not intentionally try to hurt Carmen. Carmen is a drunk and a detriment to the business in her eyes. CARMEN Carmen spent 8 years working at the business and putting up their abusive mother. The family all realizes this and

Advertising to Children

986 words - 4 pages would we need to restrict advertising to children?” Thinking about it a bit, I was unable to think of a reason why it would be wrong to market to kids. Picking up Taking Sides Clashing Views in Business Ethics and Society (Newton, Englehardt, & Pritchard), I was eager to learn why such advertising might be harmful, and thus, unethical, for children. In reading the introduction to the debate, I was reminded that “children do not have the fully

A Moral Arguement on Abortion Rebuttal

596 words - 3 pages did not agree with was when he stated, “ It’s a quantity of life versus quality of life issue” (Loher, 2011). I feel that no matter how many humans there may be in the world at one point in time, that should not factor the life of one human being. There are many issues that I am able to see both sides of when it comes to abortion, but with this topic I cannot see any reason behind this argument. The reason I feel this way is because no matter

Related Papers

The Argument Culture Essay

948 words - 4 pages the other side to see where they are coming from, and maybe this means convincing the other side to another opinion. What good is arguing our views of any subject if no resolve can be found? Our culture needs to do a better job of observing all sides of an issue and taking all sides of an argument into consideration. “In the argument culture, “critical” thinking is synonymous with criticizing,” says Tannen (405). I agree with this statement

When Conflict Arises, It Is Impossible Not To Take A Side, Everyone Has A Role

952 words - 4 pages Encountering Conflict: Prac. Context Essay 1. Prompt: “When Conflict Arises, It Is Impossible Not To Take A Side, Everyone Has A Role” When conflict arises, it is impossible not to take a side, everyone has a role. It is difficult to control the choice of taking and being part of a conflict, because with any decision in almost all circumstances has an effect on the conflict, walking away in itself is playing a role. In a conflict there are

Gender And Relationships Essay

641 words - 3 pages Chapter 3: Gender and Relationships Specific outline I. Introduction about chapter In the old days, it was so simple: men hunted and women raised the kids. Then we moved out of caves, invented gender studies and learned a bit about genetics. Nowadays, everything has changed. They develope into many sides of society. And today, our group will talk about a small sides in

Civil War History Essay

1259 words - 6 pages Both sides at the beginning of the Civil War were less than prepared for a war of any type, much less what it would become over the next four years. Not only were they not prepared with the amount of basic war supplies they would need, but a basic command structure was less than perfect, particularly in the South. No one foresaw the scope that war would take on, since the only experience that either side had with relatively large scale battle