Taking Traditional Classes Essay

2629 words - 11 pages

Taking Traditional Grammar Classes; Why the EFL Learners Have to Be Bothered?

ENG | 27 January 2011 | 19:06 Dibaca: 376   Komentar: 4   1 dari 1 Kompasianer menilai bermanfaat
For many years, it may be up to now, grammar has been taught very traditionally to the English as Foreign Language (EFL) learners. However, the way of grammar teaching, whether it should be taught explicitly or implicitly, is still a controversial issue that has been debated at least in the last ten years (Nassaji & Fotos, 2004. p 126). Karshen states that learning grammar explicitly, develops only the declarative knowledge of grammar not the ability of using grammar (Karshen, 1981 in Nassaji & Fotos, ...view middle of the document...

However, Ellis explains that
‘the learners must have at least some productive metalanguage and the ability to provide clear explanations of abstract phenomena, while learners’ explicit knowledge exists independently of both the metalanguage they know and their ability to explain rules’ (Ellis, 2005 in Fei & Tian, 2008. p.56).
It shows that declarative grammar knowledge is different from learners’ language performance. In other word, language performance is more than just grammar knowledge, but it doesn’t mean taking grammar classes is useless. Taking grammar classes still gives advantages, because it supports the teaching learning process as Wang claims that it is also hard for the learners to speak English without knowing English grammar (Wang, 2010. p.78). It just does not give so many advantages when the learners take grammar classes. As Wang restates Hymes explanation that the concept of “communicative competence” should include “linguistic competence” and “linguistic performance” (Hymes, 1972 in Wang, 2010. p.80), it shows that learning grammar is still needed, but the learners need not to learn grammar too much. The EFL learners still need to take grammar class, but they don’t have to take it over and over again in the other terms.
There are some reasons why the EFL learners need not to take grammar classes over and over again, first, learning grammar in formal instruction of a special grammar class does not develop EFL learners’ language performance significantly. It has been researched for the last three decades, when the learners take a grammar class they may be good at understanding the form or pattern of English, but it doesn’t mean they will have a significant development in their language performance. Take for example the learners who have good knowledge about grammar, even advanced grammar, and may do a lot of mistake in their writing and speaking. It is possible for them to forget the pattern of grammar they have known or they are not be able to apply the knowledge they got in grammar class (Soon, 2010. p. 64). Take another example, in speaking class, Chomsky declares that ‘ideal speaker - listener, in a completely homogeneous speech society, who knows its language perfectly and is unaffected by such grammatically irrelevant condition’ (Chomsky, 1965 in Eisenchlas, 2010. p.14). It is clear that the development of declarative grammar knowledge doesn’t guaranty the progress of EFL learners’ language performance, especially in speaking; they still make grammatically mistakes while they are speaking. Another important aspect language performance is communication, but most of EFL learners learn English grammatically, tough ‘grammar is still seen but form - sterile, abstract, and meaningless’ (Garrett, 1986 in Cohen, 2009). It means that grammar is just a concept, when the learners have mastered the grammar it doesn’t mean they can apply this into the language for communication. In other words, taking grammar classes and passing...

Other Essays Like Taking Traditional Classes

Online vs Traditional Campus Degree Essay

674 words - 3 pages Online vs Traditional Campus Degree English Composition ENG 121   Online vs Traditional Campus Degree Adults looking to return to school to obtain a degree have many things to consider. Two main items to think about are online learning VS traditional on campus classes. Although both of these are alike in many ways, there are advantages and disadvantages to each one. It helps when making this decision to look at all the pros and cons. By

Charter Schools Essay

1376 words - 6 pages school was they didn’t offer any extracurricular activities. They offered no sports, music classes, drama, they didn’t have a gym nor cafeteria; my daughter is into music and sports. My daughter excelled in all her academic studies, but was deprived from all the extracurricular activities and programs that other children were participating in traditional public schools. As a result, I ended up taking my daughter out of the charter school and

Traditional vs. Online Education

556 words - 3 pages still complete your responsibilities like taking care of your children and going to work. With traditional classroom you have to bet a school at a certain time on a certain day. This means that you have a set amount of learning hours a week and you also have a set arrival and dismissal time each day. Online learning means that your classroom is basically your home whether it is your bedroom, kitchen or a designated office

The Concept of Distance Learning

922 words - 4 pages . Distanced learning has given people a way to choose their own classroom, a way to learn and grow within their own environments. The flexibility aspect of distance learning is the main driving force for the concept. People are drawn to the idea that they can take part in school from anywhere and anytime. Most adult are already busy with jobs and taking care of families. Few have time to attend night classes or any other schedule-based classrooms

Characteristics of a Successful Online Learner

876 words - 4 pages right for them, due to not enough communication with our instructors, or online courses becoming more challenging than being in an actual classroom. Maybe some students think there is no time in their busy schedules for school, making them feel like it is nearly impossible to pursue any kind of education. Today, students have the opportunity to attend school through online classes. Taking online courses through a university proves to be more

Japanese Fashion Trends

1815 words - 8 pages these jackets (Yoshika, 1998). In cold weather, a Hanten, which is quilted jacket, would be worn over the Kimono or Happi (Yoshika, 1998). All classes wore coats and hats made of straw in rainy weather (Hickey, 1998). There were three types of footwear that are traditional as well as prevalent couple years ago, such as the; Waraji, Zori, Geta, and Tabi socks (Yamanaka, 1986). Waraji and Zori were thong sandals made of straw and Geta was thong

Year Round Schooling Could Be A Positive Change

1354 words - 6 pages review by Palmer and Bemis of many studies from the last three decades provided more insight, saying that “in 75 analyses of student achievement, 42 revealed no [...] effect on achievement [...] while 27 indicated significant positive effects” (1). This shows that year-round school is at least as good as the traditional schedule in helping students learn. Year-round school also allows more time for remedial classes during the breaks, which can help

Admission Essay

519 words - 3 pages Perhaps the most important influence that has shaped the person I am today is my upbringing in a traditional family-oriented Persian and Zoroastrian culture. My family has been an important source of support in all of the decisions I have made, and Zoroastrianism's three basic tenets-good words, good deeds, and good thoughts-have been my guiding principles in life. Not only do I try to do things for others, but I always push myself to be the

Online Learning vs. Traditional Classroom

2213 words - 9 pages Online Learning vs. Traditional Classroom Learning Wiley Lee Langley US/101 November 8, 2012 Linda Wright, PhD Online Learning vs. Traditional Classroom Learning Traditional classroom learning involves teacher/student interaction in a classroom setting whereas online learning is in a virtual environment. The traditional classroom setting is teacher centered involving textbooks, lectures, note taking, recitation, memorization, and the

Mba vs. Tradition Online Education

2836 words - 12 pages classes online has given those who may not have the ability to travel to campus or have a set schedule, the opportunity to gain an MBA degree without having to change their current schedules. Online graduate education has attracted a variety of individuals that may not have been able to gain an MBA degree through the traditional classroom”. Company Overview MBA programs on-line have become one of the most convenient ways of being able to obtain

Analyzing the Impact of the Web

729 words - 3 pages Chaffee surmises that online learning is restructuring the landscape of traditional academia. More and more people are taking courses online and the number is growing exponentially. They are several key points that he argues supports his views, which are a changing academic model, cheaper schooling, and the ease of educating. The traditional academic model is one where we go off to an institution to learn and seek a degree at the end of 4

Related Papers

Online Vs Traditional Classes Essay

553 words - 3 pages Stephanie Simmons Stacey Bybee English 111 20 November 2011 Online vs. Traditional Classes I like going to school to further my education, the only problem is the inconvenience. With three kids, a job, and life going to school to sit in seat can be difficult. If you had to choose between online and traditional in seat classes, that decision should be based on what’s better for you. The option for me is taking an online class. By taking

Traditina Classes Vs.Online Classes Essay

771 words - 4 pages flexibility but without personal interaction. Starting with scheduling between an online class and a traditional class is the time. Taking traditional classes requires the student to set up a schedule and show up for classes. This takes away from family and work. Comparing online classes, there is no set time established for when and where to study as long as a computer and Internet access is available. Courses are accessible from any computer

Online Vs. Traditional Schooling Essay

1504 words - 7 pages their assignments while listening to music, or even watching television. While attending online classes students are not subjected to the drama that they would have to face in a traditional school environment and they do not have to feel rushed when taking their tests and quizzes like people usually end up feeling in a traditional classroom setting. While attending a traditional school students are in classrooms that have many other students and

Online Vs Traditional Education Essay

1144 words - 5 pages methods have some similarities and some differences, but definitely have one thing in common and that’s that you are able to obtain a degree. Online classes are becoming a thing of the future, it helps many parents maintain balance in their lives while furthering their education. Traditional classes are still being offered, more students are just more comfortable been in a classroom setting no matter if there is balance in their lives or