The Ability Of Third, Fifth, And Seventh Graders To Understand And Apply A General Problem Solving Heuristic Scheme

2487 words - 10 pages

The Ability of Third, Fifth, and Seventh Graders to Understand and Apply a General Problem-solving Heuristic Scheme

Ann Jaffe Pace

Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, California, April 1986.

Abstract

This study was conducted to assess the ability of third-, fifth-, and seventh-graders to learn a problem-solving heuristic scheme and apply it to grade-appropriate tasks. A framework was utilized that focused on metacognitive aspects of task performance, such as planfulness, strategy selection, monitoring, and evaluation. It was expected that use of this scheme would require a degree of reflection about one's own ...view middle of the document...

On the one hand are a growing number of often elaborate programs for the training of general thinking skills. On the other hand are arguments that general thinking strategies may be too content-free and inadequate for the demands of specific domains of knowledge. Instead, effective strategy use may be a function of the acquisition of expertise in a particular domain (Chipman & Segal, 1985; Glaser, 1984).

Though the latter argument may be valid, and while some programs may have had a measure of success in training transferable thinking skills, the kind of approach that may be appropriate for teaching "higher order" or critical thinking skills in elementary or secondary schools is still not clear. Special programs demand a great deal of resources, which are often limited. On the other hand, most students may not acquire sufficient "expertise" in any one (scholastic) domain, even by 12th grade, to become proficient problem solvers or thinkers within that domain. Further, if domain-specific skills or strategies were to be taught, the number adequate to cover the breadth and complexity of the school curriculum would be vast. A viable instructional alternative may be to identify intellectual skills which are, at the same time, content-relevant and general enough to have some utility across a wide range of knowledge domains.

Frequently mentioned as skills which may be generalizable across specific domains are cognitive-control or metacognitive strategies that involve students' abilities to monitor, control, and evaluate their own task performances (Bransford, Arbitman-Smith, Stein, & Vye, 1985; Brown, 1985; Glaser, 1984; Meichenbaum, 1985; Perkins, 1985; and Polson & Jeffries, 1985). Instruction in such strategies may induce students to become more reflective about their own thought processes, as well as about task demands. This reflective attitude may

General Problem-solving Scheme - page 2

Be viewed more appropriately as an aspect of cognitive style, as Baron (1985) suggests. In any case, it represents characteristics associated with academic achievement (Baron, 1985). Thus, explicit instruction may help monitoring and self-regulating behaviors become habitual among students who do not acquire them on their own and thereby provide such students with a greater measure of control over academic activities.

The present investigation was designed to gauge the ease with which students of different ages (third, fifth, and seventh graders) could learn to understand a metacognitively oriented heuristic scheme and apply it to age-appropriate tasks. This approach utilized a problem-solving framework that is similar in many respects to familiar conceptions of problem solving (Dewey, 1933; Polya, 1957). It differs from these examples, however, in that it focuses explicitly on metacognitive aspects of task performance, such as planfulness, strategy selection, monitoring of progress, and evaluation of outcome(s).

While the...

Other Essays Like The Ability of Third, Fifth, and Seventh Graders to Understand and Apply a General Problem-Solving Heuristic Scheme

Critical Lens ( "When writers write from a place of insight and real caring about the truth, they have the ability to throw the lights on for the reader." )

471 words - 2 pages Critical LensWhen writers write from a place of insight and real caring about the truth, they have the ability to throw the lights on for the reader." In other words the critical lens shoes that the writer who cares about the truth and has a deep understanding of the literature can help us understand the literature. Yes, I agree with this statement. I have read two books, which is Odyssey by Homer and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte. Those

Evaluate the Contribution Psychological Research Has Made Towards Our Understanding of How Children from Birth to Five Learn and Develop Competencies in the Processes of Observation, Problem Solving,...

3252 words - 14 pages problem solving (Britz 1993). Babies and children make learning personal and meaningful through exploring, then experimenting, trying out a hypothesis, and solving problems. Within practice in a free flow play children use the thinking processes to decide, imagine, reason, predict, plan and try new strategies. These processes are required for later mathematical thinking (Pound 2006). One of the concept through which children develop their problem

A Doll's House by Henrik Ibsen: Do Women Have Rights to Choose and the Ability to Act Accordingly?

985 words - 4 pages Freedom: Do women have rights to choose and the ability to act accordingly? The answer to this question may seem to be an obvious “no”, or “not really” at least, when we first read “A Doll’s House”. However, in very detailed parts Ibsen did in fact give hints to suggest otherwise. Throughout the story, Nora interpreted “freedom” differently. At first Nora remarked that when she could pay back all the debts she would be “without a care

An Improved Proposal of Reducing and Solving Traffic Problem from Dhaka City

3250 words - 13 pages to inexperience. I hope you will consider my inexperience and this report will meet the standard of your judgment. Sincerely yours Yeasser Ahammed On behalf of my group members _____________________ Batch: 22nd Section: A Project Number | 1 | Project Title | An improved proposal of reducing and solving Traffic problem from Dhaka city | Project Duration | One year | Starting

Leading to the Best of My Ability

600 words - 3 pages others' shoes and has a way of helping people think through their problems. The People Mover's ability to provide motivate with nurturing qualities and the one to introduce new people to new ideas and paths.  The Ambassador style is my third highest score. This style's ability to handle a variety of situations with grace, gentleness and can be respectfully persuasive. The assessment suggests I should be mindful of the affect my leadership has on those

The Aim of Marketing Is to Know and Understand the Customer so Well the Product or Service Fits Him and Sells Itself (Ducker). Though a Simple Statement, as the World Economy Grow and Consumers Change...

1990 words - 8 pages The aim of marketing is to know and understand the customer so well the product or service fits him and sells itself (Ducker). Though a simple statement, as the world economy grow and consumers change this gets increasingly difficult. Globalization has caused marketers to research different countries, creeds, and cultures to make unique marketing strategies. Globalization isn’t the future of our economy, it’s the now. Advances in technology

Understand the Principles of Person-Centred Assessment and Care Planning

542 words - 3 pages Understand the principles of person-centred assessment and care planning 1.1: Explain the importance of a holistic approach to assessment and planning of care and support. The word holistic derives from ‘Holism’ which means to look at the whole person. So the holistic approach rather than focusing on a specific problem area, e.g. (behavioural problems) would take into account all aspects that affect an individual. These aspects can be broken

The Supreme Courts Interpretations of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments; Miranda Warnings and the Exclusionary Rule

516 words - 3 pages anyone's house, even if they showed no criminal signs. They could then use any "dirty laundry" they found in a person's house and use it against them in court.The Miranda warnings are even more well known than the exclusionary rule. This interpretation of the Supreme Court is based on the Fifth Amendment. Basically, this amendment prohibits self-incrimination by suspects. The accused must be informed of their right to remain silent and to have a

Saks Fifth and Avenue

535 words - 3 pages  give details of the various components of the plan. From NHS Lothian ‘Clinical Audit ­ Study Guide’ CD rom (West Lothian 2004)  E = End  Example of Audit Plan ­ notes  1.  Preliminary Discussion  Should establish · Why? · What? · Where? · When? · Who? · Does this audit fit in with Trust priorities? · Will it identify need for change (improve patient care) · Will it provide appropriate evidence ­ to satisfy regulatory requirements (i.e

How Christians Apply Their Beliefs To Abortion And Euthanasia

2351 words - 10 pages , supported and protected’. The mother is to be shown compassion, and her feelings and wishes are to be recognised. “The Foetus has the right to live and develop as a member of the human family; abortion, the termination of life by an act of man, is a great moral evil” Statement by the General Synod in 1983 There are many groups of people that have points against abortion, which

“The True Test Of The Greatness Of A Work Of Art Is Its Ability To Be Understood By The Masses.”

1161 words - 5 pages “The true test of the greatness of a work of art is its ability to be understood by the masses.” The statement "The true test of the greatness of a work of art is its ability to be understood by the masses;" is highly problematic. Art in itself has an ambiguous definition that combines concepts of aesthetics and personal emotion. When one thinks of art, it becomes clear that the definition of art is too abstract. Art can be anything from

Related Papers

Discuss Play In Relation To The Teaching And Learning Of Problem Solving, Reasoning And Numeracy In The Early Years

2206 words - 9 pages Discuss play in relation to the teaching and learning of problem solving, reasoning and numeracy in the Early Years. Children observe and participate in maths within various settings, such as at home, nursery or school, which is carried out during day to day activities. This may vary from estimating the quantity of toothpaste to place on the toothbrush, pouring cereal to telling the time. According to Tucker (2005), children learn about

Creative Problem Solving Styles In The Usa And Japan

3597 words - 15 pages need), and understandable (can be reproduced (p. 14). Nierenberg (1982) adds: Knowledge consists of three basic elements: structure, order and relation... In order to expand our creativity, it is necessary to consider each of these terms individually and understand how in our own problem solving we may habitually neglect one or more of them while we restrict ourselves to using the remaining factors over and over (pp. 37, 39). He defines these

Heuristic Of The Co Workers Opinion Essay

1281 words - 6 pages Heuristic of the Co-workers OpinionPeople make many judgments and decisions in their everyday lives, and occasionally they are well thought decisions and also logical. The decisions and judgments that people make are based on the beliefs regarding to the possibility of unsure events. Most people live in a world of constant deadlines and non stop stress. They often need heuristics, which is a mental rule of thumb or shortcut and biases as a way

Understand The Process And Experience Of Dementia

4493 words - 18 pages Unit 33 Understand the Process and Experience of Dementia Understand the neurology of dementia 1.1 Dementia is an umbrella term for a range of diseases that affect memory, behaviour and motor skills. The causes vary depending on the disease but largely the presence of “plaques” and “tangles” on the neurons of the brain is found in people with Alzheimer’s. Plaques are protein that the body no longer breaks down and allows to build up