The Battered Woman Essay

2813 words - 12 pages

Battered women make up what is one of the most marginalized groups in society. Their relationship experiences sometimes bring these women into conflict with the law, especially when they kill their abusive partners. Battered woman syndrome was developed in the 1970's by a clinical psychologist and was created to describe the cycle of events that abused women often go through in their relationships. In Canadian law it is recognized in the context of other defenses, bringing battered women syndrome into the courtroom involves the use of well-prepared proof. It has become obvious in the past that women have been treated in a stereotypical way by the Canadian courts. Their circumstances and ...view middle of the document...

Clinical psychologist Lenore Walker developed the battered woman syndrome. It provides psychological explanations of the mental cycle that abused women experience throughout their relationships. Walker describes the "cycle of violence" as having different phases, which take charge of the victim. Over time, the abused women feel worthless and empty. The battering of the women leads to a sense of helplessness, whereby she believes there is nothing she can do to prevent the attacks. What is important about the syndrome is that it attempts to answer some of the most puzzling questions for people who have not experienced abuse, for example, why would anyone stay in such a bad relationship? Battered women live in fear often with low self-esteem and the feeling that they are powerless and cannot stop the violence. Many believe that leaving or separating from the relationship will not end the violence.Criticisms of the battered woman syndrome have become a main point in many writings. Sociological thinkers, feminist scholars and legal agents have all had their own opinions on the syndrome itself. Many psychologists criticize the concept of learned helplessness; which is described as an apathetic, depressive state, which women with the syndrome suffer from. Much of the research of this concept comes from animal studies and little is known about how it operates in human beings. 1 Not all battered women experience the stages in Walker's cycle, or in the same order, yet they are however traumatized by their abusive experiences. As well, criticisms have been brought against Walker's research methods.With all the criticisms and the view on the use of the battered woman syndrome, it is important to think about what is positive regarding the use of the syndrome. Author Elizabeth Sheehy, while admitting to the difficulties with the syndrome, admits that it offers "mercy for women who have defended their own or their children's physical integrity or very lives, and as providing an opportunity for public and legal education about the facts of women's lives."2 The battered woman syndrome indeed may play an essential educative role for a situation that many laypersons misunderstand. To recap, battered women often experience harsh conditions that are unfamiliar to many, especially the majority of men. Such women have usually been under appreciated and misunderstood by the criminal justice system. Many feminists, while not all happy with the definition of the syndrome, they have been pleased that more research and legal attention has been given to this group of women in society. Now that a foundation of the battered woman syndrome has been made, it is necessary to construct the introduction of this into the Canadian law.The battered woman syndrome became recognized in Canadian courts in the decision made in R. v. Lavallee. In that case, the Supreme Court of Canada acknowledged the battered woman syndrome within the situation of spousal homicide. Prior to Lavallee in...

Other Essays Like The Battered Woman

Francine du Plessix Gray’s: At Home with the Marquis de Sade: A Life

4615 words - 19 pages the revolution. However, the true liberation is that of Pélagie, who refuses to see her husband when he comes by her convent. “Pélagie refused to appear. She sent down a message informing her husband that she never wished to see him again.” (300) At this juncture, du Plessix Gray makes her battered woman reading abundantly clear. Again, Pélagie is collapsed into “every battered woman” happily assuming, once more, her simple, plodding

Marital Rape Essay

1207 words - 5 pages significant topic since it is said that wives since taken as personal asset of the husband and that husbands has right to have criminalized rape in marriage. They also push their wives to have sex against her choice and force. According to the classic definition husband have intercourse without consent other than his wife (Barshis, 1983, p. 383). According to this notion woman is a personal belonging of their husbands and it is said that once got

Dating Violence

2240 words - 9 pages teens from falling through the cracks, and opened one of the few teen shelters in the country that will take in a young woman and her child.Pregnant teens that are abused often cannot go to shelters for teens or to those for battered women. The March of Dimes shelter, however, caters to pregnant teens' needs in its counseling groups, and offers such services as having social workers go to wherever a girl is staying and bring her to the

Criminal Law Essay

1187 words - 5 pages is that there is an abnormality of mind, the second that it results of a disease, arrested or retarded development of mind, and any inherent causes or injury. The third requirement is that it substantially impairs defendants mental health. Abnormality of mind is not rage, jealously or dislike. There is a history of abuse that Amina suffers by Yasin she could prove with medical evidence, battered women syndrome; she could also argue that this

Battered Women

591 words - 3 pages There are many reasons why men abuse women. A one reason men abuse woman is because the men feel like they need to be in control all the time. Another reason is because they might have been surrounded by it as a child. Third reason is they have no respect for women. These men keep getting away with beating and harming these innocent women, and the women are not doing anything about it. “Statistics say, 71,000 episodes of domestic violence

Tennessee Williams' The Glass Menagerie

550 words - 3 pages was how the book called her, “A little woman of great but confused vitality clinging frantically to another time and place.” (p. 5). This is very true on top of that Amanda was loquacious and always bragging about how many gentleman callers she had. By doing this Amanda made her daughter Laura feel bad. An example of such is “One Sunday afternoon in Blue Mountain- your mother received – seventeen - gentleman callers! Why, sometimes there weren’t

Battle Royal

1352 words - 6 pages the affair. But in so doing, they unwittingly humiliate themselves as well. The youth’s grandfather, lying on his deathbed admits that he feels like a traitor, but prompts his son to give the Whites what they want. Throughout the story, Ellison’s symbols give layers of meaning. The White woman is used just as the Black youth are, to humiliate and denigrate them, and keep them in their places. The woman is symbolic of the thirst the youth has

Bloodline- Short Story

1357 words - 6 pages Bloodline- CrimeLove/Family Relations Jamal Rowe. Golden rays of sunshine peeped through the cracks in the musty apartment’s windows; Mother Nature’s early morning alarm clock. Disgruntled, he got up out of his battered leather couch and headed for the old-motel-esque bathroom. A quick flick of the light switch revealed his reflection staring back at him in the dirty bathroom mirror. His hair was the opposite of the regular. His black locks

Analysing Blessing And An Old Woman`

2113 words - 9 pages Analysing Blessing and An Old Woman Poetry from other Cultures Question 2 Culture means the beliefs, traditions, and customs of people within a society. Fundamental aspects of a culture are faith, values, and history. People that share a culture also share its beliefs and ways of life, which are different to others. Poetry is an effective way of describing and exploring a culture, and events within it, because certain aspects can


1093 words - 5 pages the breaking down of appreciation and restrain in American social order. From past eras to present eras, this message could be comprehended. Grandma speaks to the past with her solid "Southern Hospitality" legacy. Case in point, “The old woman settled herself agreeably, evacuating her white cotton gloves and putting them up with her satchel on the rack before the back window. Her neckline and sleeves were white organdy trimmed with trim and at

Steinbeck's Use Of Symbolism In "The Chrysanthemums"

1206 words - 5 pages In his story "The Chrysanthemums", Steinbeck introduces us with a woman, named Elisa, who is trying to gain power in a man's world. Elisa Allen tries to define her role as a woman in a very close society. Her environment portrays the social depression, the garden shows her power and masculinity, and the chrysanthemums portray Elisa's existence and emptiness of her life. Elisa has trouble extending this power outside the fence that surrounds her

Related Papers

Investigate A Social Issue Essay

695 words - 3 pages The Impact of Social Ties on Coalition Strength and Effectiveness: The Case of the Battered Women's Movement in St Louis, Social Movement Studies: Journal of Social, Cultural and Political Protest. The world we live in has been one that has not been so equal to women. We have had issues that involve women that include the right to vote, being able to run for offices and fairness in the boardroom. Woman battle daily with the system of

Starbucks Essay

1054 words - 5 pages children, to ensure their safety is and not compromised by domestic abuse. Anna Marie was a local Minnesota woman who was forced to raise four children as a single parent. Throughout the lives of her children, Anna Marie taught them the importance of community outreach and connection. Many problems could arise from these situations because women who want to desperately to seek shelter would find it more difficult and emotionally

Abused Women Essay

2512 words - 11 pages big companies have established special counseling services that offer psychological help to battered women so that they can resolve their domestic problems (Lowell, p.29). When a woman gets beaten by her husband in front of her children, her role as a mother and as a representative of authority at home is immediately endangered. How can a child be expected to obey his or her mother when she is not respected by the husband? In addition to this

Unsettling The Truth, Review Essay, Evaluation Of Mandatory Arrest/Charging Policy

1315 words - 6 pages all cases of domestic violence/assault where there are "reasonable grounds".Although this new justice system brought certain effects to women's lives, it also complicated our justice system and impacted in negative ways as well. Through this essay I will argue that battered women's advocates rest their support for mandatory arrest on the deterrence of batterers and empowerment of women, though on the other hand any beneficial effects produced by