‘The Broken Branch’, To What Extent Is This A Fair Assessment Of Congress? (45 Marks)

1237 words - 5 pages

‘The broken branch’, to what extent is this a fair assessment of Congress? (45 Marks)

Within the constitution, the power of Congress first appears in Article 1, Section 1, ‘all legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States’. This suggests that congress has huge amounts of power Congress in creating legislature, scrutinizing the executive and playing a huge role when it comes to the checks and balances of the three branches of government. However, in recent times, many people argue that congress is ‘broken’. One of the biggest examples of this is the increasingly poor legislative record. Although there is going to be a big bias within congress, ...view middle of the document...

But when we look at congressmen and their role in representing their state. The high percentage of incumbents (usually over 90%) shows they are carrying out at least one function effectively. With an election cycle that comes up every 2 years for members of the house, its very important to ensure you are always representing your members fully, in the past, failing to look after a constituent can prove fatal. In 2008, Senator Elizabeth Dole lost her re-election because her constituents didn’t feel as though she was ‘in touch with their views’. Therefore, although congressman represents their constituents, I can still argue that it is the congressmen who are doing their job properly (voting the district), but congress as a whole is still broken!

Congress key role by far is legislature, but the fact that in an ‘average’ congressional term, only 2/5% of over 10,000 bills introduced are actually implemented into law is quite shocking. Milbank, a political correspondent for the Washington Post stated that the 112th congressional session was the ‘big-talk no action congress’, once again proving that it can no longer carry out its main function, outlined in article 1 of the constitution and is therefore ‘broken’. Perhaps this could be down to the little diversity within congress. Currently, congress is made up of 80% WHITE male, even though they only represent 1/3 of the country. The inability for congress to accurately represent society as a whole and work together within congress could be the biggest reason for a ‘broken’ branch. On top of this, the increasing use of filibusters within the senate (the more prestigious house within congress), which slow down the legislative process are another way to stop bills passing through congress and is further evidence of a broken branch. Senator Storm Thurmond conducted a filibuster that lasted over 23 hours in opposition to the Civil Rights Act in 1957 slowing down the process of the bill and puts a huge emphasis on this slow, un-progressing congressing that seems to work to nothing.

However, when John Boehner, former leader of the House, announced a ban on earmarks in the 113th session, it gives a slight glimpse of future for congress. Money would now go to the right places! Therefore, I cant entirely argue that congress is completely broken, there is evidence, such as the ban on earmarks, that shows congress can still function adequately.

In recent years, it would seem congress have elected those who have a strong personality rather than there leadership/skills for the job. On top of this, the leadership and parties that dominate congress could be another way in demonstrating this ‘broken congress’....

Other Essays Like ‘the Broken Branch’, to What Extent Is This a Fair Assessment of Congress? (45 Marks)

To What Extent Is Pastoral Poetry a Lamentation for a Changing Landscape or Ways of Life?

1193 words - 5 pages To what extent is pastoral poetry a lamentation for a changing landscape and disappearing ways of life? Draw on the work of three poets To lament is to feel sorrow for something. To an extent, it could be said that pastoral poetry is indeed a lament for a changing landscape and ways of life; however, I think it can be nostalgic and remember the past fondly, or even not provide a positive or negative outlook at all. Elizabeth Jennings is a

To What Extent Is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society

2178 words - 9 pages 8-week Pre-sessional Research Essay 15th August 2012 To What Extent is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society? UCL Language Centre Student: QIFAN WANG Tutor: MARK BAILEY Date: 16/08/2012 Word count: 1854 words Introduction Cultural heritage, including monuments, groups of buildings and sites, which are of outstanding universal value from the point of view of history, art or science(1972, UNESCO Convention World

"The Long March Was a Retreat That Changed the Destiny of China" to What Extent Do You Agree with This Statement?

1169 words - 5 pages “The Long March was a retreat that changed the destiny of China” To what extent do you agree with this statement? The Long March was an epic journey across China conducted by the Red army in 1934. After the breakdown of the first United Front, Chiang Kai Shek launched an offensive which forced a retreat from Mao and the Red army. This retreat is believed to have lasted for over a year and covered 6000 miles. By the end of the march, of the

To What Extent Is Anarchism Seen as a “Utopian Creed”?

717 words - 3 pages Anarchism is often described as a utopian ideology in itself, as it aims to create a “perfect society”. From the outset it is clear that many aspects and factors of the ideology are unrealistic, such as the core values of unrestricted freedom and absolute equality. These two values are diametrically opposed in the sense that in order to absolute equality, individual freedom must be limited and vice versa – this leads to the canceling out of one

Evaluate the View That Present Day Lifestyle Is Largely Responsible for Increasing Levels of Obesity in the Uk. How and to What Extent Is Diet a Contributing Factor?

1151 words - 5 pages Evaluate the view that present day lifestyle is largely responsible for increasing levels of obesity in the UK. How and to what extent is diet a contributing factor? Obesity is one of the biggest health crisis’ affecting the UK at present. The UK has one of the highest obesity rates in the world, coming in only second next to America and number one in Europe. To say that the present day lifestyle is largely responsible for increasing the

To What Extent Was the Lack of Support from Presidents and Congress the Main Reason Why Little Progress Was Made in the Development of African-American Rights Between 1896 and 1941?

1351 words - 6 pages To what extent was the lack of support from Presidents and Congress the main reason why little progress was made in the development of African-American rights between 1896 and 1941? In 1896, politicians were still a direct way in which African-Americans could use to gain higher levels of civil rights in the United States of America. It is arguable therefore that the support from Presidents and Congress over the time period of 1896 to 1941 was

To What Extent Is Germany Responsible For The Start Of World War One?

2282 words - 10 pages major powers' minds. However, Niall Ferguson says that the role of the arms race in unleashing the war has been exaggerated; he points out that the country with the largest military expenditure, Britain, was the country which least wanted war.Imperialism is also a major cause for the war. The major European powers during 1880 and 1914 began to colonize rapidly in Africa and Asia, and saw this as a battle for wealth, growth, power and essentially

‘the Tone Says Life Is Fun. the Undertone Suggests Life Is a Catastrophe’. to What Extent Do You Think Eric Bentley’s Comment About the Dramatic Genre of Comedy Is Relevant to Oscar Wilde’s the...

1582 words - 7 pages ‘The tone says life is fun. The undertone suggests life is a catastrophe’. To what extent do you think Eric Bentley’s comment about the dramatic genre of comedy is relevant to Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest? The philosopher and literary critic Sigmund Freud agreed with Bentley’s statement on the dramatic genre of comedy, agreeing that ‘every joke contains an element of seriousness; a joke is never just a joke’. Wilde uses many

To What Extent Do You Agree That a Free Market Economy Is the Only Approach to Bringing About Economic Growth

2716 words - 11 pages To what extent do you agree with the view that only a free market approach to running the economy can bring about sustainable high levels of economic growth and development? The basic economic problem is that we, as consumers, have unlimited wants and scarce resources. (Anderton, 2008, p.1) Due to this, the questions of what shall be produced, how it will be produced, and who gets the product, arise. (Sandford, 1977, p.42) Therefore

To What Extent Are Vladek’s Personality Traits a Pitiable Product of His Experiences During the Holocaust?

936 words - 4 pages actions, these helped him through the horrors of the war and now are part of him, his reluctance to waste anything is a testament to this. Vladek's constant insistence of having Art staying with may be due to a fear of losing more people close to him. Not all of Valdek's personality arose from the holocaust. We can see glimpses if his former self from what he does. Vladek's personality is heavily influenced by his sufferings in the holocaust

To What Extent Is War Inevitable Today?

1545 words - 7 pages To what extent do you believe war is inevitable in today’s world? By: Arianna Lu *Presented to *Mrs. Antonuk & Mr. *Klukas* Sir Winston Churchill High School * * In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for History 30/35 IB *October 23, 2007 Period: 2* To what extent do you believe war is inevitable in today’s world? War has always been a major part of our history, for it is within human nature for conflicts to

Related Papers

To What Extent Have Modern Liberals Departed From The Ideas Of Classical Liberalism? (45)

935 words - 4 pages To What Extent Have Modern Liberals Departed from the Ideas of Classical Liberalism? (45) Liberalism has been active throughout Europe since the early 19th century, although the UKs first experience of Liberalism put into practice was in 1868 under Gladstone’s Liberal government. Early Liberalist ideas concentrated largely around core values of freedom, individualism and a minimal state. However, revisionists have deployed a modern liberalism

To What Extent Was The Rwanda Genocide And Example Of Root And Branch Genocide?

1606 words - 7 pages To what extent was the Rwanda genocide an example of root-and-branch genocide? To what extent was the Rwanda genocide and example of root-and-branch genocide? Plan of the Investigation: While seeking for my Internal Assessment topic I came across the topic Rwandan Genocide and immediately became interested. The term genocide is a term formally used to describe the act of violence towards members of a national, ethical, racial or religious

The Underlying Theme Of Othello Is Reputation And It Is This That Culminates In The Play’s Tragedy. To What Extent Do You Agree With This Claim?

1172 words - 5 pages English Literature The Main theme of Othello is not the theme of jealousy but the theme of reputation and this is one of the main constitutes, responsible for the tragedy of the play: to what extent do you agree with this in regards to Act Two Scene Three and Act Three Scene Three? In William Shakespeare's Othello it could be thought that the main theme is Jealousy however in Act two scene three reputation become a prominent theme

Technology Is The Best Way To Reduce The Impact Of An Earthquake To What Extent Do You Agree With This View

1136 words - 5 pages ‘Technology is the best way to reduce the impact of an earthquake’ to what extent do you agree with this view? (40 marks) An earthquake is a sudden violent shaking of the ground, typically causing great destruction, as a result of movements within the earth’s crust or volcanic action. Impacts of an earthquake can include short-term impacts such as fatalities, or long-term impacts such as income lost through lack of tourism. Technology can be