The Crown Prosecution Service, Police Culture, Policies And Practices On Domestic Violence

4828 words - 20 pages

The Crown Prosecution Service, Police Culture, Policies and Practices on Domestic Violence.

Across the world the police have a dissatisfactory record when it comes to dealing with domestic violence. In recent years the police in England and Wales have done a great deal to improve dealing with this crime, but have they done enough? Firstly it is necessary to consider this issue from a historical perspective, secondly, the gap between changes in policy and practice and finally, the likely impact of relatively recent initiatives.
According to Binder & Meeker (1992) ‘Prior to this time (before domestic violence was placed on the social and political agenda in the 1970’s) domestic ...view middle of the document...

Although police culture has to derive from somewhere, there are official bodies who criticises the police for their action, or lack of action, against domestic violence, NARCO (2006) stated that ‘The British Crime survey shows that almost half of women in England and Wales have experienced domestic violence, sexual assault or stalking (Walby and Allen, Home Office, 2004).
The Labour Government received an overall score of just 1 in 10 in respect of an integrated approach to addressing violence against women from the Women’s National Commission in 2004. Although the criticisms from these official bodies are somewhat astonishing, that although 1 in 10 women have experienced domestic violence, we hardly hear about it? From a young age we are taught sex education, not to talk to strangers and not to go off with somebody we don’t know, about what to do if were being bullied and told there is always somebody to talk to if there is something bothering us. We are not taught how to deal with domestic violence, the very thing that takes place in our own homes, by the people we think love us, we are not taught how to deal with situations like this, and if the police don’t believe you, who will?
This may be why The Fawcett Society (2005) reported that ‘responses from police forces over concerns of low conviction rate for rape and domestic violence, show a mixed picture, whilst there is good work going on in many areas to improve the treatment of violence against women, this is not a priority for the most forces.’
So why have these criticisms been made? It is most likely because of statements like this, said by Sir Kenneth Newman, former commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, who called ‘Domestic Violence ‘rubbish work’ and a non-police matter, comparable to dealing with stray dogs.’ It is quite possible that this has derived from the ‘cult of masculinity’ within police culture.
‘Much of this order maintenance work involves disputes that erupt between people in some kind of relationship... a staple of policing intervening in ‘domestic’ disputes between spouses, lovers, parents and children... officers typically quell the ferocity of the quarrel and try to discover what it was about, the alternative to resolving the issue or stop it re-erupting and causing a disturbance, then to persuade and ultimately force compliance with the parties preferred solution.’ (Kemp et al, 1992)
Street cops are committed to ‘crime fighting’, with less of an orientation towards crime-prevention and peace-keeping. As the disturbance is often behind a closed door and not publicly attacking someone the police seem to view this as a non-police matter, because they simply are not trained to deal with these incidents. With regards to crime-fighting, it is limited to the public-sphere, thus neglecting the private domain. Domestic violence is a private matter that does go on in a lot of homes, within families and the police see this primarily as a concern...

Other Essays Like The Crown Prosecution Service, Police Culture, Policies and Practices on Domestic Violence

Impact of Domestic Violence on Children

2421 words - 10 pages ., Coben, J. H., Wang, K., & Griffith, J. D. (2009). Collaboration between child welfare agencies and domestic violence service providers: Relationship with child welfare policies and practices for addressing domestic violence. Children and Youth Services Review. doi:10.1016/j.childyouth.2008.10.005 Clarke, A., & Wydall, S. (2015). From ‘rights to action’: Practitioners' perceptions of the needs of children

Western Culture And Policies That Have Shaped The Modern World

1535 words - 7 pages Western culture and policies have shaped the modern world, especially the Middle East, in many ways. Since the sixteenth century, the nations of Western civilization have been the driving wheels of modernization. Globalization is simply the spread of modern institutions and ideas from one high power to the wider world. Technological innovation and economic growth along with such concepts as democracy, individualism, and the rule of law

Translating Strategy Into Hr Policies & Practices: the Hotel Paris Case

526 words - 3 pages Barriers/obstacles There are many obstacles in handling Generation Y especially based on their attitude. Generation Y is a generation that is challenging and hard to handle as it can change today’s corporate culture. There are different attitudes and work habits that happen with the shift of the younger employment force from Generation X to Generation Y. Generation Y are less committed to stay with the same

The Relationship Between School Climate, Culture and Violence

5907 words - 24 pages confirm the true levels of violence within schools due to very little or no research at all. There exists a need for research which specifically focuses on the perceptions of learners and educators, relationship between the school climate, culture and violence and measures which can be implemented to address these issues. The purpose of this research is therefore to determine the perception of learners and educators and the relationship between school


521 words - 3 pages failure of the officer of the watch to take corrective action, despite these warning signs - but it is the root causes, and the human element connotations, that are of interest.The ship's Master and watchkeeping officers were competent and experienced in passenger ship operations, but they had not received any formal training in the operation of the Integrated Bridge System.The ship had been in service for 3 years without incident.Presailing checks

The Effects of Quality Management on Domestic and Global Competition

994 words - 4 pages The Effects of Quality Management on Domestic and Global Competition Introduction Today the concept of quality management has emerged as a significant business practice companies want to adopt. The reason is simple: to become more effective and customer oriented. By implementing quality management, enterprises have become able to ensure quality in their products and services (The Importance of Quality Management, 2010). There are a number of

7 Reasons the Police Culture Is Broken

899 words - 4 pages 7 reasons the police culture is broken (and how to fix it)It is time for the law enforcement profession to think, act, train, prepare, lead, and live differently | The law enforcement profession is an honorable one. The men and women of law enforcement are committed to making their communities safer, and willing to risk their lives to accomplish that mission.However, some elements of the culture are broken, and in order to fix it we need

The History of Domestic Violence in the United States

613 words - 3 pages shelter in 1976 The first bilingual hotline for Latinas in 1985 The passing of the Domestic Violence Prevention Act in 1987 The family Protection and Domestic Violence Intervention Act of the 1994 While domestic violence is a very old problem, an organized response to it in this society is relatively new. It has been scarcely a decade since the mainstream medical profession, criminal justice, and human service systems have offered assistance, and truly begun to research and understand the problem. The criminalization of domestic violence, identifying the problem in public rather than private terms, is also a relatively new phenomenon.

Equity policies are important for human resource management because they affect the whole range of employment practices and policies in an organization. Why is this so? Explain your answer

254 words - 2 pages Equity policies influence many areas of employment practices in an organization. This is because equity issues affect the bottom line of an organization. Areas such asEquitable treatment in all matters related to employment. It is important that the HR department ensures that every employee is given fair and equitable treatment in all maters related to employment. HR has a responsibility to make sure that the 'best' person is hired for the job

Violence On The Tube

1588 words - 7 pages Violence on the Tube One Saturday morning many years ago, I was watching an episode of the ‘ Roadrunner' on television. As Wile E. Coyote was pushed off of a cliff by the Roadrunner for the fourth or fifth time, I started laughing uncontrollably. I then watched a ‘Bugs Bunny' show and started laughing whenever I saw Elmer Fudd shoot Daffy Duck and his bill went twirling around his head. The next day, I pushed my brother off of a

What Did Louis XIV Hope To Accomplish In His Domestic And Foreign Policies?

461 words - 2 pages policies to diplomacy. Louis continued the nobility's exemption from taxes but forced its member into financial dependence to the crown and the provincial nobles also lost political power. Louis does have a genuine concern for his country and despite his dubious methods he does manage to secure the territories that he wishes to secure. He curtailed local authorities and created specialized ministries. Louis's grandson retained the Spanish throne but

Related Papers

Poverty And Domestic Violence Essay

2953 words - 12 pages should be made aware of the deep impacts, such as trauma and the medical burden that accompanies physical injuries. The social problems, the high STD rate, and the two worst case scenarios may be that the aggressor eventually murders the victim, or, the victim murders the aggressor (Johnson). History of Domestic Violence Early settlers in America based their laws on an Old-English common-law that explicitly permits wife-beating for correctional

The Psychological Impact Of Domestic Violence On A Child

2143 words - 9 pages less to live with. Relationships organize children’s lives, their beliefs, and even their cognitive, social, and emotional development (Carol Hudgins, 115). What happens then when a child has to live in a home where domestic violence is occurring, do we actually believe that they will go through the ongoing even unscathed? If even adults go through an epitome of hell on Earth when they are in a domestic violence relationship, imagine what

Culture And Hrm Practices Essay

1449 words - 6 pages whether, and to what degree, the effectiveness of multinational companies is contingent on cultural context. And the result indicated that organizational culture has the strongest effect on psychological and behavioral outcomes, while national culture has the strongest effect on performance outcomes. This underscores the importance of cultural forces operating internally and externally and the need for adapting human resource practices dynamically to

Domestic Violence, Court, And You Essay

2158 words - 9 pages Domestic violence comes in various shapes and sizes. Mandatory arrest laws and a “no drop” prosecution policy were made to protect victims of domestic violence not to destroy families. Unfortunately, with these policies in place the courts have decided who does and who does not stay together leaving the victim still in a controlled situation. So many families are involved in domestic violence that court interference is inevitable but when does