The Death Penalty Essay

2028 words - 9 pages

The Death Penalty: Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right
Denise Seymour
Informal Logic: PHI103
Russell Tompkins
April 22, 2013


The Death Penalty: Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right
Some crimes that a person may experience in their lifetime are too horrible to put into words. How can one be punished for a crime so unthinkable? Capital punishment could be one way, but how ethical is it really? The first capital punishment recorded on our land was in 1608. The hanging of George Kendall in Virginia’s Jamestown colony was for the offence of “spying for the Spanish.” In the following four centuries people will killed for crimes such as murder, rape, theft, witch craft, and many others ...view middle of the document...

Even though many Americans are for capital punishment not many of them know the realities of a person sentenced to death row. “Innocent people have been sentenced to die based on such things as mistaken eyewitness identifications, false confessions, the testimony of partisan experts who render opinions that are not supported by science, failure of police and prosecutors to turn over evidence of innocence, and testimony of prisoners who get their own charges dismissed by testifying that the accused admitted the crime to them” (Bedau, Cassell, 2004 p153). Logic shows us that none of these incidences, alone, are good enough to sentence one to death. “Even the guilty are sentenced to death as opposed to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole not because they committed the worst crimes but because of where they happen to be prosecuted, the incompetence of their court-appointed lawyers, their race, or the race of their victim” (Bedau, Cassell, 2004 p153). In some places one could be sentenced to death simply because they are considered not mentally competent (WMJ, 2012). Former Illinois Governor George Ryan use to be for capital punishment until further examination of the system found the demons and errors of its ways. “In 2003, Governor Ryan pardoned four people who had been tortured by police until they confessed to crimes they did not commit and commuted the sentences of the remaining 167 people on Illinois’s death row for reasons that he eloquently sets out elsewhere in this book” (Bedau, Cassell, 2004 p154). It is cases like these that show anyone could be on death row without just cause. “18th-century Italian philosopher Cesare Beccaria believed the death penalty was neither useful nor necessary: The certainty, rather than the cruelty, of the punishment was what counted most” (Massimo, 2007 p5). One should be alive to achieve the certainty of the punishment. “Those against -- the abolitionists -- argue that the death penalty does not help to deter crime, contending that there is no objective evidence to support the claim that the death penalty reduces crime” (Massimo, 2007 p7). One study showed that out of 238 paroled offenders less than one percent committed another murder (WMJ, 2012). Some credible studies relating death-penalty states with non-death-penalty states have shown no evidence that capital punishment has any effect on murder rates (CHE, 2007). "The death penalty is a problem with regard to the fundamental idea of humanity because humanity is based on the idea of the absolute value of a person's life no matter what and the death penalty represents the absolute denial of a person's right to life” (WMJ, 2012 p84). Therefore, capital punishment should not be used, for there are too many circumstances of innocent people being executed for crimes they may have not committed, it is not a strong enough deterrent for future offenders, and also for the purposes of showing that it is not humane to murder another...

Other Essays Like The Death Penalty

abolishing the death penalty Essay

2858 words - 12 pages  Abolishing the Death Penalty PHI 103 August 31, 2009 Abolishing the Death Penalty The Death Penalty in America today is a highly debated issue and has been for many years. Could you imagine not having a life threatening consequence at all, such as the death penalty when it comes to criminals that commit very severe crimes? There are many people in the United States today with many

The Death Penalty Essay

2210 words - 9 pages The Death Penalty The death penalty has been around in our history for centuries. Animals, tribes, and government all use the death penalty for punishment and to prove dominance. When most people think about the death penalty they think of old English queens and the guillotine, or old western America and hangings. The death penalty has evolved over time to the methodical thing we see today. The death penalty is use to punish major crimes

Is the Death Penalty Needed

590 words - 3 pages Kevin Paris 10 September 2013 The death penalty was used as the ultimate punishment in the American courts, but is it necessary now? The death sentence is used when the offender killed another person with undisputed evidence. The death penalty was used more often during the early years of the United States as a way to scare others into not taking anothers life. Even with all the modern technology we have today the death penalty is

Juveniles And The Death Penalty

2094 words - 9 pages Juveniles and The Death Penalty *No Works Cited One of the most controversial issues in the rights of juveniles today is addressed in the question, "Should the death penalty be applied to juveniles"? For nearly a century the juvenile courts have existed to shield the majority of juvenile offenders from the full weight of criminal law and to protect their entitled "special rights and immunities." In the case of kent vs. United states in 1996

The Death Penalty Is Not the Answer

2350 words - 10 pages In a society where there is so much violent crime. We look for a way to try to ensure our safety and protect the ones we love. We use many forms of punishment as a way to deter crime. The most extreme of these is the death penalty it is final and leaves no way to correct any mistakes if made. The death penalty is not the answer to violent crimes; it is a very old form of punishment that offers no deterrent to crime. “There can no longer be any

The Death Penalty Is an Acceptable Punishment

743 words - 3 pages The Death Penalty is An Acceptable Punishment Missing Works Cited When you think of an extreme crime you think of murder. When you think of an extreme punishment you think of the death penalty. Crimes of such severity sometimes deserve an equal punishment and we as a society accept this. However, Supreme Court Justice William Brennan argues that society seriously questions the appropriateness of the death penalty. It is true that over the

The Death Penalty: Justice, Safety, and Deterrence

915 words - 4 pages The Death Penalty: Justice, Safety, and Deterrence Have you ever wondered why the United States has the death penalty? The United States uses the death penalty as capital punishment, so criminals can realize that doing such horrible crimes will lead to punishment, sooner or later. So therefore, the death penalty is a reasonable punishment system for those who committed a horrible crime because it provides justice, public safety, and

The Death Penalty Should Be Re-Introduced

963 words - 4 pages The Death Penalty Should be Re-introduced in South Africa The death penalty should be abolished says the humanist; The death penalty shouldn't be abolished says the community. Well the death penalty is a controversial topic, and it is difficult to have it and also difficult to not have it. What is Capital punishment?  Capital punishment is the death penalty.  It is used today and was used in ancient times to punish a variety of offenses. Even

The Death Penalty vs. Life Sentence

521 words - 3 pages The Death Penalty vs. Life Sentence Determining whether an individual should receive a death penalty or life sentence based on the crime he or she may have committed has been a major controversial debate in the United States and our Judicial System. Along with any possible solution to a problem, it will come with its pros and cons. It may have to do with the fact that costs of the death penalty including pre-trial and trial costs, appeals

Should the Death Penalty Be Introduced

991 words - 4 pages Should the death penalty be introduced? The issue of the death penalty is one of the most fiercely debated topics around the world. The issue is the source of many conflicts within many societies with some people arguing that it is the only justifiable punishment for certain crimes whereas others say that no one has the right to take the life of another human being regardless of their crimes. There are a number of countries around the globe

Death Penalty And The Eight Amendment

1230 words - 5 pages The expression "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" has taken on a whole new meaning. Lately, murderers have been getting a punishment equal to their crime, death. In 1967, executions in the United States were temporarily suspended to give the federal appellate courts time to decide whether or not the death penalty was unconstitutional. Then, in 1972, the United States Supreme Court ruled in the case of "Furman versus Georgia" that the death

Related Papers

Death To The Death Penalty Essay

1008 words - 5 pages Death to the Death Penalty! Human beings have been killing each other ever since our creation. Since then, we have formed civilized societies. One of the most basic, most fundamental principles in almost every society is that the killing of another human being is wrong. Yet execution has been around since the founding of that basic moral. Society does not do itself any favors by allowing the death penalty to continue to exist. The death

The Death Penalty Essay

1673 words - 7 pages Precious C Govt. 2301 Nov. 12 The Death Penalty Research and debate on the death penalty is avidly one of the fastest growing political issues in the history of criminal justice. The issue has continually posed dynamics in our society on whether such an act or decree serves as a justified and valid form of punishment or not. It is indeed a matter of major controversy since the death penalty or otherwise capital punishment is the execution

The Death Penalty Essay

1059 words - 5 pages The Death Penalty The death penalty has always been and continues to be a very controversial issue. The death penalty has declined throughout the industrial Western since the 19th century, and nearly every European nation has either formally abolished the death penalty for civil crimes or has abandoned it in practice. People on both sides of the issue argue endlessly to gain further support for their movements. Opponents of capital punishment

The Death Penalty Essay 719 Words

719 words - 3 pages The Death Penalty December 12, 1984, the first jolt failed to kill Alpha Otis Stephens, he struggled for eight minutes before a second jolt finished the job. The first jolt took two minutes, and then there was a six-minute pause. During this six-minute pause body could cool before physicians could examine him and declare that another jolt was needed. Stephens took 23 breaths, during that six-minute interval. Such incidents prove that the