This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Groupthink Theory Essay

1213 words - 5 pages

The Groupthink Theory
“Researchers have studied the influence of group pressure on individual members” (Byars and Rue, 2007, 238).
As defined by Byars and Rue “when group members lose their ability to think as individuals and conform at the expense of their good judgment, groupthink occurs. Members become unwilling to say anything against the group or any member, even if an action is wrong” (Byars and Rue, 2007, 238).
“Keeping a group together under any circumstance is a goal in itself. Groups with this goal believe that the group is indestructible and always right. Group members justify any action, stereotype outsiders as enemies of the group, and pressure unwilling members to conform ...view middle of the document...

This paper will look at the conditions, the indicators or symptoms, and the ways to counteract groupthink.
The conditions for groupthink to happen are important to recognize. When a homogenous, highly cohesive group is only concerned with maintaining unanimity, they fail to evaluate all their alternatives and options. It is obvious that a group suffers from groupthink when the group feels apathetic about its task; group members do not expect to be successful; one group member has very high credibility---group members tend to believe what he or she says; one group member is very persuasive; and group members do not usually challenge ideas; it is expected that group members will agree with one another (Beebe, Beebe, and Ivy, 2001, 282). The members also see themselves as part of an in-group working as an out-group opposed to their goals. The Challenger space shuttle disaster is what can happen when groupthink occurs. Stress can also be a condition that allows for groupthink to take place. As group members realize that immense external and internal pressures come with their task, the level of stress rises. The desire to reduce the stress motivates the members to come to an outcome quickly. Effective groups need to have clear goals, mutual trust among all participants, accountability shared by everyone, external support, and training.
There are many indicators or symptoms that groupthink could be happening in a decision-making process. Groups dominated by groupthink tend to make unethical decisions when compared to the decisions that could have been reached using a fair, open, and rational decision-making process. Many groups have an illusion of invulnerability and they think that they are not capable of being wrong. When the group believes that they are doing the right thing in all circumstances and that it is best for everyone, then they are showing inherent morality. Groups are often close-minded about the situation that is occurring. They ignore the information that does not back up the opinions of the group members. This occurred with the Challenger because the scientists from one group were telling the others to delay the launch. There had been pressure from all around to launch the space shuttle that they did not listen to the scientists and cause seven lives to be lost in the disaster. When any of these occur in a group, changes must be made to ensure that it will not happen in the future.
There are many practices that can help prevent groupthink from happening.
One way of preventing groupthink is to make each member of the group a “critical evaluator” (Janis 1982, 262).
Group members will make an effort...

Other Essays Like The Groupthink Theory

Organisational Learning Essay

2335 words - 10 pages . Janis, I. L., 1982. Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascoes. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Kolb, D. A., 1984. Experiential Learning: Experience As the Source of Learning and Development. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Nonaka, I., Toyama, R. and Byosiere, P., 2000. A Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation: Understanding the Dynamic Process of Creating Knowledge, Knowledge Creation Diffusion Utilization, 1, pp.491-517

Social Influences on Behavior Essay

1248 words - 5 pages is caused by the differences between groups and the similarities of things in the same group. Groupthink is a phenomenon that can occur in the social identity theory. Groups that are affected by groupthink ignore alternatives and take irrational actions that dehumanize other people and groups. Since most people in the social identity theory have members with the same background, they have no outside opinions and also have no clear rules for

Group Influence

1604 words - 7 pages . Everyone seemed to be in agreement with bowling. There was no evidence that any of the members might be vulnerable to groupthink. This is a group that does not appear to have a problem with speaking up or going against the grain. There were a couple of times during the meeting when one or two completely disagreed with what was said and spoke out. At one point, one member agreed to disagree on the subject of warm transfers. There are times

Leading the Project Team

2688 words - 11 pages Topic: Leading The Project Team Topic Preview The literature covering the issues of both team and leadership contains a wide range of perspectives. This topic presents a summary of the key theories supporting both of these issues. The perspective is very much one of presenting a number of theories, rather than selecting a single ‘correct’ theory. One benefit of this approach is that it allows project managers the opportunity to widen their

Unit 1 Foundations of Business Communications

3085 words - 13 pages | |To suggest that communication is a pervasive activity is to state the obvious. One of the fundamental axioms of communication theory, in | |fact, is "You cannot not communicate." What you wear, the words you choose in conversation, presentations, in your report writing, your | |corporate logo, even your silence, sends messages to consumers and associates whether you consciously want them to or not. Even

Organizational Ethics

777 words - 4 pages have been a part of a workplace group that was victimized by groupthink the main symptoms present were, carefully weighing the risks and discussing important moral issues. With many company groups, the group will come to a conclusion and not take the time to think about the risks involved (Boyle, 2001)ConclusionIn my situation the risk involved was losing a patient to another agency. Along with not thinking about the risks involved, the morals of

James Gao

4179 words - 17 pages kind of heathen criminal despite the effect he had on the world. In modern day, his type of scheme based thievery would not be considered deviant enough to constitute crime. Truth be told, he simply saw what was going to happen, so he capitalized on it. If he didn't do it, then someone else would have, and they'd be the rich guy. He and Eisman are nothing short of geniuses who had the capabilities of transcending groupthink. Fiat engineering is

Mgt 5000 - Example Assignment 1

4639 words - 19 pages ). The remedial actions to help in managing the attitudes and perceptions of employees at PBA is are summarised in Task 4. Task 2.2 Two Relevant Motivational Theories and impact of events in scenario upon the motivation of staff (607 words) The following two theories’ relevant to the scenario will be discussed: Expectancy Theory and Hertzberg’s theory. Theory One: Process Theory - Vroom’s Expectancy Theory Employees at PBA were

Enron Case Study

1172 words - 5 pages support the growth.10 Executives believed that as long the law was being followed, they were doing nothing wrong. This kind of sanctimonious moralization only continued until the lies were too large to be hidden any longer. Groupthink among members of the in-group crippled otherwise smart people with the perception of invulnerability and belief in their own morality. These behaviors brought down the company. A lack of oversight and ethical

Theories by Daniel Batson

1212 words - 5 pages 35. On what kinds of group tasks is performance improved by anonymity? 36. Which of the following is NOT an important factor in social impact theory? 37. The “Risky Shift” is an outdated erms now used to explain a phenomona called: 38. What is the loss of a sense of individual identity and the lessening of self restraint that can occur in group situations called? According to Edward Diener, one way to

LDR 531 Final Exam Latest UOP Assignments

1789 words - 8 pages proactively takes up additional job responsibilities. • Kelly always complains about her work to her colleagues. • Kelly shares the organization’s vision of supporting renewable energy. Find the final exam answers here LDR 531 Final Exam Answers 5. The concept that some leadership attributes will work in some situations but not in others can be described by the • Contingency theory. • Tactical

Related Papers

2003 Us Invasion Of Iraq And The Application Of Groupthink Theory

1163 words - 5 pages fail under the pressures of Groupthink Theory, whether or not you personally believe we should or shouldn’t have gone to war. Irving Janis defined groupthink as “a mode of thinking that people engage in when there are deeply involved in a cohesive in-group, when the members’ striving for unanimity override their motivation to realistically appraise alternative courses of action” (Griffin). There are eight symptoms of group think, seven of which

Groupthink Essay

1045 words - 5 pages the social sciences. To some degree this is remarkable, since there has been significant and enduring skepticism about its explanatory power among scholars. Serious methodological queries about the incoherent, the possibly contaminated nature of the various components of the theory, and the biased nature of ex-post facto case study evidence purporting to support groupthink explanations of fiascoes have been raised. Also, the inherently

The Threat And Avoiding Of Groupthink

1393 words - 6 pages private feelings or beliefs held by group members or behaviors performed in private (Thompson, 2008, page 172). A study on group decision-making called Groupthink Theory based human social behavior in which maintaining group cohesiveness and solidarity is felt as more important than considering the facts in a realistic manner. (Janis, 1972, para. 3) Additionally, Janis (1972) identified eight typical symptoms that address groupthink and claimed

Evaluate Why Groups May Not Be Trusted To Make Good Decisions

2042 words - 9 pages they have even heard any facts? Janis (1972) came up with the idea of groupthink, this is when a group come together to make a decision but the need to come to a unanimous decision becomes more important than making an actual rational decision, and facts concerning the decision are seen as not important. Janis (1972) believed that groups are likely to succumb to groupthink if they have a strong direct leader, high levels of stress throughout the