“The Historical Structure Of Scientific Discovery”

690 words - 3 pages

“The Historical Structure of Scientific Discovery”

In Kuhn’s essay about “The Historical Structure of Scientific Discovery”, he describes the discovery of oxygen and how an individual is credited with the discovery. Throughout the essay Kuhn show that he disagrees with the current vocabulary describing how and who is the one to be accredited with the discovery of a certain thing, in this case oxygen. He believes that in many cases oxygen was discovered well before when history tells it was and by a different person. The ones he believes to have discovered oxygen did in fact observe oxygen but at that time didn’t fully understand what they were discovering. Given these facts Kuhn thinks that a new vocabulary should be used to describe who and when actually made a discovery.
Using the approach of considering first the historical problem presented by the attempt to and place a major class of fundamental discoveries, is how Kuhn would like to start as how to give ...view middle of the document...

With traditional thought, providing a detailed explanation of your discovery backed with repeated experimentation showing that you truly understand your discovery is the way your going to credited for your discovery and be recorded in history as the true discoverer, in this case of oxygen. This is generally accepted the to accredit a discovery because the only way you can prove a discovery is to be able to explain it in full detail of what you discovered, being able to show full understanding of the discovery. If you were unable to do this, what makes anyone believe you actually discovered oxygen? You cannot possibly be accredited for discovery if you are unable to explain what you discovered. This is where Kahn’s thoughts behind come into question from the standpoint of traditional thoughts behind discovery. A true discoverer has full understanding of what they have observe and are trying to enlighten the world about.
Not all of Kuhn’s thoughts are wrong on this matter. The fact is the earlier observers of oxygen should be given credit for observing oxygen but not credit for the discovery of oxygen. This is I think what Kuhn is trying say, that the credit shouldn’t all be given to one person because that wouldn’t be the truth. Without one observation the next was less likely to happen thus resulting in the need to give credit to earlier scientists working with oxygen. This is where many will agree with Kuhn on the fact that we are in great need of a new vocabulary when it comes to giving credit where credit is needed. In order to do this Kuhn believes that we need to create a new vocabulary for distinguishing where credit should be given in the area of discoveries. With this new language we would be able describe discoveries without any confusion.
Taking in all of these thoughts I think Kuhn has devolved a proper understanding of what needs to happen with the vocabulary when it comes to describing discoveries. The need for this is very necessary because in order to describe discoveries and also it would be the best way to delegate credit to those who deserve it and at what levels of credit each person deserves. This is where Kuhn is thought to be right on his theory with the need to develop a new vocabulary.

Other Essays Like “the Historical Structure of Scientific Discovery”

Discovery and Colonization of the Americas

749 words - 3 pages When we discuss the discovery and colonization of the Americas, Columbus often comes to mind first. These days we analyze Christopher Columbus in various ways. Was he a pioneer that changed the world for the better? Or was he a man who began the end of a native way of life? Can we actually accuse Christopher Columbus of mass murder? These questions will most likely never be answered. One fact is certain: from 1492 and throughout the 16th century

The Historical Roots of Logic Essay

939 words - 4 pages The Historical Roots of Logic People have always reasoned. Even early civilizations made technical and intellectual advances that presupposed logical inferences. For example, the Babylonians discovered and used a theorem (now called the Pythagorean theorem) that expresses the relation between the sides and the hypotenuse of right triangles, and the Egyptians used the formula for calculating the volume of a rectangular pyramid 'h(a^2 +ab + b^2

The History Of Scientific Management Theories

1226 words - 5 pages In the history of management thinking, there are many ways to manage an organization, such as scientific management and administrative management. This essay will discuss the notion that scientific management was a ‘good’ idea in the history of management thinking, by looking at the historical backgrounds and political beliefs of economist, also how the develop management theory by conducting experiments, and how their theories made it into the

The Pros And Cons Of Columbus' Discovery Of The Americas

1150 words - 5 pages permanent settlement. Although the Native Americans did live a comfortable enough life, their lives were still limited to great extent. When Columbus and his successors conquered the Americas, they moved the boundaries of life in the Americas back and sped up the process of development in the Americas. Columbus brought the Americas to the attention of the growing scientific civilization of Western Europe. The European society was the predecessor

The Theory of the Portuguese Discovery of Australia

838 words - 4 pages treaty was signed. But the one that affects the theory of the Portuguese Discovery of Australia, is the original one. 1.12 Where the world was split It divided the world into two between Portugal and Spain. The line was drawn about 480km to the west of the Cape Verde Islands which are off the coast of Africa. Everything to the West would belong to Spain and everything to the East would belong to Portugal. The exact position of the line was not

The Structure of Business Decision

916 words - 4 pages For Office Use: Grade WrittenAnalysis and Communication Individual Assignment No 1 Case Analysis Report On ‘The Structure of a Business Decision’ Submitted by Name : EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Mr. Nakamura recently takes over charges of his family business of lacquer ware. His brand “Chrysanthemum” is the top selling brand of only Japan. He wants to expand his business across the globe. But Japanese government does not

Historical Background of the Garment Industry

882 words - 4 pages Historical background of the Garment Industry Like other 3rd world countries Bangladesh is a developing country. Her economic development depends firstly on agriculture and secondly on industry. Although Bangladesh is not developed in industry, it has been enriched in Garment industries in the recent past years. In the field of Industrialization garment industry is a promising step. It has given the opportunity of employment to millions of

The Structure and Organization of Brown Industries

1188 words - 5 pages The Structure and Organization of Brown Industries MGT/230 January 16, 2014 Suzanne Dunham The Structure and Organization of Brown Industries Dr. Graeme Edwards said, “It’s not the plan that is important, it’s the planning”. Just like the diversity of people there are equally diverse businesses. Companies are managed and organized in different ways. Each organizational structure has its own management style. The organizational

Structure and Functions of the Brain

700 words - 3 pages B F C G S M C F X A S D B Clues: 1. The part of the brain located in the temporal lobe that is responsible for our emotional response. ________________ 2. The portion of the brain involved in intricate cognitive functioning. ___________________ 3. A part of the brain that belongs to the limbic system and is responsible for processing new memories. ________________ 4. A structure that is known to be a key relay station for sensory

Historical Review on the Last of the Mohicans

1944 words - 8 pages French. The aim of this research paper is to evaluate the accuracy and relevance of the historical events as depicted in the novel, in comparison with the actual events. SYNOPSIS Colonel Munro of Fort William Henry requested for reinforcements from General Webb of Fort Edward when his own fort was attacked by the French. Webb fulfilled the request by sending reinforcements. Munro’s daughters, Cora and Alice also left Fort Edward for their

The Ball Mill Structure of Basic Point of the Quality

737 words - 3 pages The ball mill structure of basic point of the quality_Ivylm522 The 1980s to twenty every hour crushing about 800 tons of product a big jaw crusher feed sizing reached 1800 mm equipped using the upper finish of broken cone spindle bearing inside the plaque inside center in the bush, and its reduced finish positioned inside sleeve in the eccentric hole drying equipment, crushing operations normally divided into hard broken, broken, and crushing

Related Papers

The Structure Of Scientific Revolutions Essay

964 words - 4 pages In The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (SSR) Thomas Kuhn argued that science fluctuated between sustained periods of normal science and periods of chaotic reshuffling, called revolutionary science. During periods of normal science the scientific community agree on a set of foundational/basic beliefs called the paradigm (SSR, 10). The paradigm con- tains four basic categories of knowledge, (i) firmly established symbolic laws (e.g., f

Discovery Of The Electron Essay

685 words - 3 pages i did this report for my chem 1 class, its nothing special, but if you need some info on electrons, or the discovery of, then this is great. noneThe Discovery Of The ElectronThe electron was discovered in 1895 by J.J. Thomson in theform of cathode rays, and was the first elementary particle to beidentified. The electron is the lightest known particle whichpossesses an electric charge. Its rest mass is Meequal> 9.1 x 10 -28 g, about 1/1836 of

The Process Of Self Discovery Essay

2141 words - 9 pages The Process of Self-Discovery Dina Carrington Saint Leo University Dr. V. Rose February 23, 2014 Abstract Self-discovery can be a hard task to tackle. Part of self-discovery is determining your values, goals, strengths and weaknesses. Once a person has determined what their values, goals, strengths and weaknesses are, they can set a solid foundation for a rewarding career. A person should have a passion for their career and knowing whom

Structure Of The Hair Essay

722 words - 3 pages STRUCTURE OF THE HAIR Hair is made up of dead cells. On our heads, we have hundreds of thousands of follicles, pore-like structures within the scalp that produce hair. Each follicle produces many hairs throughout our lifetime. Live hair cells are generated inside the follicle by the papilla. As the new cells grow, the older cells die and are forced along the follicle towards the scalp. The dead cells are compressed to form a protein called