This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Loss Of Identity Comparison Of Pedro Paramo And Beloved

1583 words - 7 pages

The Loss of Identity of Paul D. and Abundio

IB English A1 Higher Level

World Literature Paper 2A

Alex Koo

Candidate #:

Mrs. Anderson

Date Submitted: January 12th, 2011

Word Count: 1488

The idea of the loss of identity is portrayed both in Beloved by Toni Morrison, and in Pedro Paramo by Juan Rulfo by the characters of Paul D and Abundio Martinez. While both novels illustrate this theme, the two characters have different relationships with their identity. While Paul D continuously runs away from his identity and past, Abundio Martinez yearns to find it. Beloved, was written to expose the long lasting effects the evil institution of slavery have on slaves, even ...view middle of the document...

After Sweet Home, he ends up in a chain-gang where he suffers many traumatic memories, contributing to his identity as a slave. He remembers this time when he was “locked up and chained down, his hands shook so bad he couldn’t smoke or even scratch properly” (Morrison 21). Here, Morrison uses tactile imagery and vulgarity to convey the dirt of his past. This tone connotes Paul D’s bitter feelings towards his past. Finally, he escapes one rainy day with the other slaves to a Cherokee Tribe who tell him to run North by following the blossoming flowers. He arrives in Cincinnati as a free but broken man, running away from his past, opening the novel.

Paul D, like many slaves at that time has been so traumatized to a point where individualism and value are forgotten. Even from the point that Paul D is given his name, he questions his identity as his brothers are distinguished only by a mere letter: Paul F and Paul A. With each further reference as “the Pauls”, connotes that he slowly just becomes a Paul, nothing more. He begins to question his worth and then turns to his owners to find his value which is evident as he thinks, “Schoolteacher would know. He knew the worth of everything” (Morrison 269). One day, he overhears the men talking and “for the first time learns his worth” (Morrison 267). He overhears that “this here one”, a reference to himself, was worth a total of nine hundred dollars – “the dollar value of his weight, his strength, his heart, his brain, his penis, and his future.” (Morrison 267). Here this money symbolizes value, and Paul D’s apparent lack of it.

When Paul D finally escapes to Cincinnati, he appears at the doorstep of 124 as a wanderer. His only identity and worth is what he learned he was in the past - $900 worth of flesh. When he arrives to begin his new life, it is evident that he tries to suppress his past and his only sense of identity. This idea is portrayed as Paul D locking his past away in his tin tobacco box. For instance, Sethe and Paul D are reminiscing about Sweet Home outside of 124. However, as Sethe continues to reminisce, Paul D cannot stand talking about the past and decided that “He would keep the rest where it belonged: in that tobacco tin buried in his chest where a red heart used to be” (Morrison 86). This red color symbolizes life and suggests his lack of it.

Paul D does not intend to open that tin box. In fact, he feels that this tin box is rusted shut. Morrison incorporates an olfactory motif when he claims he has no intention to “pry it loose now in front of this sweet sturdy woman, for if she got a whiff of the contents it would shame him” (Morrison 86), indicating the foulness of his past. This is how Paul D chooses to start his life, and intended on continuing to. However, with Beloved’s appearance, Paul D is confronted with the past and as the novel progresses, Paul D’s tin box begins to loosen and Paul D must embrace the past and his identity that he constantly runs...

Other Essays Like The Loss of Identity Comparison of Pedro Paramo and Beloved

Comparison and Contrasts of the Colonies

1141 words - 5 pages COMPARISON AND CONTRAST OF COLONIES 1 Comparisons and Contrasts of the Colonies of Virginia and Massachusetts Vincent W. Daquilante Excelsior College COMPARISON AND CONTRAST OF COLONIES 2 Abstract This paper will discuss the differences between the colonies of Virginia and Massachusetts in colonial America. I will discuss the differences between the early peoples who migrated to each colony as well as their relations with the

The Comparison of Human Nature and Suffering

992 words - 4 pages The comparison of human nature and suffering. “Parental love is not like bread that can be broken into pieces and split amongst the children in equal share. A father gives all his love to each one of his children without discrimination, whether it be one or ten. And if I am suffering now for my two sons, I am not suffering half for each of them but double” (93, paragraph 10

Comparison of the Poems Drifters and Shooti

618 words - 3 pages “Drifters” “Shooting the dogs” Comparison analytical expository poetry study Australians are a very mobile group of people. Throughout Australian history Australians have had to move due to drought and other perilous conditions. Today Australians have not relinquished this trait. The two poems that are being compared are ‘Drifters’ written by Bruce Dawe (1930-) and ‘Shooting the dogs’ written by Philip Hodgins (1959-1995). Drifters is

Comparison of Inflation, China and the Us

1919 words - 8 pages Comparison of Inflation, China and the US ECON220: Principles of Macroeconomics Comparison of Inflation, China and the US Inflation is a persistent increase in the price of different commodities without a corresponding change in quantity demanded. As such, inflation is a macroeconomic indicator used to measure economic performance of a nation. This research paper sets out to compare inflation in China and United States. The Chinese

Analysis of Themes in Alan Paton's Cry, The Beloved Country

499 words - 2 pages The family in Cry, the Beloved Country involves themes emphasizing the home and family. From the James Earl Jones seeking for his son to the other priest searching and wanting a place of her own, this movie shows how one reacts to the attraction of home and family. The home symbolizes a place of refuge and belonging which are exhibited throughout the movie as James Earl Jones searches for his lost son. It gives the movie viewer the sense of

Determine the Identity of Metals

716 words - 3 pages Experiments to determine the identity of metals by examining the colour of flame when samples of that metal are heated. The aim of this experiment was to find out whether different metals had different reactions when subjected to the flame of the Bunsen burner. This might then allow the classification and identification of certain metals if they have their own reactions, which will be different coloured flames for this experiment. It was hard

The Enron Implosion And The Loss Of Respect For The Accounting Profession

5643 words - 23 pages The Enron Implosion and the Loss of Respect for the Accounting Profession On the surface, the motives behind decisions and events leading to Enron’s downfall appear simple enough: individual and collective greed born in an atmosphere of market euphoria and corporate arrogance. Hardly anyone—the company, its employees, analysts or individual investors—wanted to believe the company was too good to be true. So, for a while, hardly anyone did

Summary Of Clutch Loss

766 words - 4 pages other. The loss of a clutch should also affect the OSR. If a clutch is lost, the parent should reenter the mating pool faster, changing the ratio. Heik Prohl studied how the OSR is affected when D. pumilio loses a clutch. The time males spend parenting only amounts to moistening the eggs. Females take their time choosing mates, and they spend more time tending to their young. The females carry their tadpoles to water and feed them eggs that

Realizations Of Loss

1084 words - 5 pages It is no longer the home I grew up in. The loss of my mother is evident now more than ever, cementing the realization of how one person’s impact can be as much the foundation of a home as the concrete itself. It has been two years since our lives changed forever. My dad is recently remarried and trying to move forward after losing his wife of almost thirty-eight years to terminal brain cancer. Since my mother’s death and my father’s

Love and Loss of Innocence of a Young Boy

1048 words - 5 pages within the structure of the story is the love and loss of innocence by the young boy. Since the story is told in first-person narrative, you are immediately immersed in his feelings and realizations. First the scene that begins on North Richmond Street, which is sort a gloomy and quiet street, but comes alive when the children are at play. This shows despite the circumstances that surround him that he is able to still maintain a childlike view of

Atkins and Low Carbohydrate Diets: Not the Optimal Method of Weight Loss

628 words - 3 pages Atkins and Low Carbohydrate Diets: Not the Optimal Method of Weight Loss In the help of today’s society where looks seem to matter more than personality, different types of diets quickly became popular. In the year 2003 to 2004 the Atkins Diet reached its peak, from its wide advertising to its celebrity connections an increasing amount of Americans focus their interest on this unusual way of losing weight. The Atkins Diet was introduced by

Related Papers

Comparison Of James Jarvis To Stephen Kumalo In The Novel Cry, The Beloved Country

637 words - 3 pages Cry, The Beloved Country EssayThe character James Jarvis changed greatly throughout the novel, "Cry, The BelovedCountry". He was a white Christian man who lived in South Africa during the Apartheid. He wasa racist man who didn't want to accept blacks as equals but he did not go as far as killing them.His son, Arthur Jarvis, fought for equality and even built an African Boy's Club. Arthur died in atragic and ironic way. He was murdered by a young

Gambling And The Loss Of Morality

1980 words - 8 pages element, cultivates laziness and lends itself easily to other societal ills such as alcohol and drug use and prostitution. Gambling undermines the work ethic by offering a “something for nothing” attitude and leads people to profit by causing loss to others. Most proponents of gambling consider it to be harmless recreation. However, like the tobacco industry, the gambling industry relies and thrives on addiction. The bulk of the gambling

The Issue Of Loss Essay

826 words - 4 pages conceal the true emotion of loss. From the simplicity of losing a door key to the heartbreak of losing a home or someone dear, Bishop states and restates that loss isn’t difficult to acquire. Loss is, in fact, a commodity in life –things are lost every day. The loss of a possession is expected, as Bishop alludes [“so many things seem filled with the intent / to be lost that their loss is no disaster.”]. When a possession goes missing, that loss

Amy Of Beloved And Rp Of One Flew Vs. The Cuckoo’s Nest

2033 words - 9 pages Comparing Amy of Beloved and RP of One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest The gentlemen in “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest” were in search of mental freedom. Fear kept them prisoners of their own minds. Perhaps the main focus of the film was to illustrate the point that we are master’s of own freedom. However, it is difficult to change our pattern of thinking. Sometimes, in fact, we need someone to show us just how it is done. Ken Kesey's