The Miranda Rights As They Are Today Are No Longer Appropriate And Need To Be Modified

1550 words - 7 pages

Thesis: The Miranda Rights as they are today are no longer appropriate and need to be modified.

A young couple is murdered in the middle of the night. The next night a single mother of
two is raped and killed in her apartment. Her children murdered beside her. A killer is on the
loose. The citizens are scared. The police form a task force. Finally, after weeks of
investigations and false leads, a suspect is identified and apprehended. The suspect is
interrogated and eventually confesses to the crimes. The suspect also admits to other murders
that until now were unknown to the Law Enforcement community. Months later the case is tried
in court. An experienced defense ...view middle of the document...

What are your Miranda Rights and where do they stem from? What magical event took
place that would allow our government to create such ridiculous stipulations pertaining to the
questioning of a suspected individual? On 13 March 1963 in Phoenix, AZ, the police arrested
Ernesto Miranda as he was suspected in the theft of $8.00. The police also suspected Mr.
Miranda of raping, robbing and also kidnapping a number of Phoenix area women. Mr. Miranda
was never offered an attorney and he was questioned for over two-hours. Eventually Mr.
Miranda admitted to taking the $8.00 and to also kidnapping and raping an 18-year-old woman
almost two weeks earlier. At the trial, the lawyers of Mr. Miranda argued that even though Mr.
Miranda signed a confession wherein he related knowing his legal rights, Mr. Miranda had not
been informed of his legal right to have an attorney present during the confession. Ultimately,
Mr. Miranda was convicted based largely on his confession and he was sentenced to twenty
years in jail. The case made its way up to the U.S. Supreme Court, who in June 1966 reversed
the Arizona Court's decision. The Supreme Court found that Mr. Miranda's rights had been
violated as a result of not having been advised of his right to remain silent. In the end, Mr.
Miranda, who had won a new trial, was convicted again.

As a citizen of the United States, you have four Miranda Rights. These are vocally

provided to you via the Miranda Warning. Your rights are: “You have the right to remain silent.

Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to an

attorney. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you” ("Miranda Rights and

the Fifth Amendment”). Okay, so as a U.S. citizen, you have rights, but what about terrorists?

Do they deserve the same Miranda Rights as the rest of our society? According to the Obama

Administration they do. “The Obama Justice Department has quietly ordered FBI agents to read

Miranda rights to high value detainees captured and held at U.S. detention facilities in

Afghanistan” (Hayes, 1). So let’s say one of the terrorists who hijacked one of the airplanes

which crashed into the World Trade Center had been detained at the airport. According to the

Obama Administration and the Miranda Rights as they currently stand, when questioned, the

terrorist could have sat quietly in a room, refusing to talk. At the same time thousands of

innocent Americans were losing their lives. Wouldn’t it have made more sense if the terrorist

could have been continuously questioned? Maybe he wouldn’t have said anything. But on the

other hand, perhaps he would have given enough information necessary for alarm bells to go off

in the heads of the experienced interrogators. Thousands of U.S. lives could have been saved.

As we know, none of the terrorists from the World Trade Center...

Other Essays Like The Miranda Rights As They Are Today Are No Longer Appropriate And Need To Be Modified

Describtion of haiku and what are they

401 words - 2 pages of a longer chain.Strictly speaking, then, the history of haiku begins only in the last years of the 19th century. The famous verses of such Edo-period (1600-1868) masters as Basho, Yosa Buson, and Kobayashi Issa are properly referred to as hokku and must be placed in the perspective of the history of haikai even though they are now generally read as independent haiku. In HAIKU for PEOPLE, both terms will be treated equally! The distinction

Database Systems and How They Are Used

517 words - 3 pages Database Systems and How They are Used DBM/380 Week 1 Individual Assignment Craig Gruenbaum Instructor: Kevin Judge Database Systems and How They are used Database systems are utilized in basically every business every day. Businesses use data to perform a multitude of functions, such as sales transactions, customer queries, and the viewing of key performance indicators. Database systems are the management tool that aids in

Drugs: They Are Still The Enemy

660 words - 3 pages find politicians telling our kids they've smoked marijuana and they liked it. Using ideals such as "finally an honest politician" and "its NORML to do drugs" these impractical ideals are not what an impressionable youth needs to hear. We must remember that they are the future of our society; do we really want our future to be smoggy? Our leaders are too high on drugs to make important decisions. These new proposals towards the legalization of

Genetically Modified Foods Are Ethically Unacceptable

1420 words - 6 pages shown that genetically modified foods may bring about many benefits to mankind, we must also look into the ethical issues involved in producing such food before we even consider accepting it as the way of the future. First, we must understand that the word "ethical" is defined as having to do with ethics or morality; or of conforming to moral standards.There will be 3 parts to this essay. Firstly, I will be presenting and defending 2 arguments

Computers are an Essential Item to have in the Household Today

1919 words - 8 pages Computers are an Essential Item to have in the Household Today In the year 1977 computers went on sale for the national public. Today in the year 2004 computers with connection to the internet are an essential item to have in the household. Accountants and typists are no longer the only ones buying computers. Age does not matter. Everyone needs a computer in the household. Computers help all kinds of people. Meeting different

In General, People Are Living Longer Now: Discuss The Causes Of This Phenomenon

325 words - 2 pages I do not agree with that statement although at face value all the prerequisites for a longer life-expectancy exist nowadays. We live in a high-tech world where our life is facilitated no end. Numerous gadgets make our existence easier. The achievements of medicine are enormous and practically few diseases are fatal.However, the life that people lead, despite all the advanced technologies, harms them. The rat race for a promotion, a higher salary

Monsanto Seed Are They Safe

793 words - 4 pages effectively respond to various stakeholders? Like any other large firm, Monsanto also has the responsibility to maintain an ethical culture that can respond effectively to stakeholders when issues arise.   There are issues with their products that still need to be resolved including the risks to health and damage to the environment.   They also need to enforce their code of ethics to mitigate employee misconduct.   Although Monsanto has made

Are They Really That Bad?

1372 words - 6 pages Are They Really that Bad? To hold a higher state of consciousness has been desired since the concept of consciousness was realized. This has been accomplished through such practices as meditation, or through the controversial use of substances which alter the state of consciousness. Before their outlaw such substances as marijuana, psychedelic mushrooms, coca, and even opium were used by people recreationally as a way to find deeper

This Is A Project Is On Earthquakes In Canada. What They Are, How They Are Formed, How To Act Before,During And After An Earthquake

1907 words - 8 pages , largehallways, or shopping malls. Get under a piece of sturdy furniture such as a workbench or heavy table ordesk and hold on to it. Use arms to protect head and neck. If you are outdoors if possible, get inside abuilding. If shelter is not available or there is no time to get indoors, lie in a ditch or low-lying area orcrouch near a strong building. Be aware of the potential for flooding. Use arms to protect head and neck.If you are in a vehicle

Are Children Smarter Today Because of the Internet?

1319 words - 6 pages lazy and they don’t want to try to find something that they want to know and lose their curiosity. While some teachers express hope that the use of the internet will help the student execute novel and complex tasks, others are concerned about students not learning things that they’re supposed to be learning, such as social, physical and interpersonal skills. Parents tend to believe that the internet has helped their children in schools. 93% believe

Are Women Still Discriminated Against Today?

814 words - 4 pages girls from an early age, and which still sharply defines male and female roles with the family and society at large." The perception of certain work as feminine has had a significant impact on women, both at home and in the workplace. Often feminine jobs regulate women to positions where they earn less money and are less likely to become management than their male counterparts. In addition, at home women are still chiefly

Related Papers

'miranda And Ferdinand Are More Important To The Play Than They May At First Seem'. By Considering The Dramatic Presentation Of Miranda And Ferdinand, Evaluate This View

1006 words - 5 pages 'Miranda and Ferdinand are more important to the play than they may at first seem'. By considering the dramatic presentation of Miranda and Ferdinand, evaluate this view. It is insensible and much too simple to imagine The Tempest in absence of characters we deem to be extraneous, such as Miranda and Ferdinand. Shakespeare's mere selection of Miranda and Ferdinand as characters justifies their significance; they have been written, and thus

Constitutional Conventions Are Rules Of Political Practice Which Are Regarded As Binding By Those To Whom They Apply, But Which Are Not Laws As They Are Not Enforced By The Courts Or By The House Of...

2263 words - 10 pages those to whom they apply. However, they are not laws, as they are not enforced by courts or by the Houses of Parliament.1 Often constitutional conventions are more important than written constitutional provisions. For example, the President is empowered by the Constitution to appoint the Prime Minister2, but the Constitution provides no guidance as to who should be appointed as Prime Minister. Here conventions regarding the appointment of the

What Are The Aims Of Academic Study And How Can They Be Achieve1 Essay

944 words - 4 pages What are the aims of academic study and how can they be achieved? Academic study is commonly considered to play the most important part in one's education. Different views such as the aims to undertake an academic study and factors that affect the performance lead to the origin of such importance of academic study. Students' performance in academic study to ensure having a career or to enjoy learning can be improved and achieved by several

Argumentative Paper About Women And How They Are Claimed To Be A Weaker Sex Than That Of Males

1202 words - 5 pages to handle the stress of actually being President?No matter how far women have come over time, they are still the lesser sex and will always be shown as weaker than men. Only through changes in society will being a woman be a wonderful and empowering thing. If a woman President was elected, professional female athletes were paid more, and Barbie got a breast reduction surgery and a career, America would be on the right track for girls to grow up knowing they are as strong and intelligent as boys.