'the Mother's Right To Life Should Always Overrule The Rights Of Her Unborn Child.' Assess This View

1179 words - 5 pages

'The mother's right to life should always overrule the rights of her unborn child.' Assess this view. (15 MARKS)

Interests can conflict, leaving a moral problem centred on the question of mother and baby equality. There is huge debate about who's right should overrule the other. Some believe the women have a greater right to life, whereas others argue the unborn child does.

Firstly, there are many who believe the mothers right to live should always overrule the rights of her unborn child. A pregnancy and a growing foetus have an enormous impact on the mother. Not only does it cause psychological and emotional changes, it also places the mother's body under huge pressure and has ...view middle of the document...

But, they argue, it's not yet a conscious person and hence not yet inherently precious. In Roe v. Wade in the US, the Supreme Court ruled that women have a constitutional right to abortion. The court said that a foetus is not a person but “potential life” and thus does not have constitutional rights of its own.

Judith Jarvis Thompson uses the violinist analogy to support the right of the mother to decide to have an abortion. The violinist (foetus) has the right to life. However this right is not greater than the person's right to freedom. The violinist has no right over the person's body, and therefore the person is morally justified in leaving the hospital- just as a mother has the right to terminate her pregnancy. The foetus threatens the mother, in terms of increased risk, and so abortion is a defensive measurement against unacceptable dangers. Thompson uses the example of a cardiac condition which, should the pregnancy be allowed to continue, would place the mother in real danger. Thompson argues that it cannot be seriously suggested that a person must be stopped from saving their own life for the life of another. This highlights that Thompson believes the rights of the mother overrule the rights of the unborn child.

Mary Anne Warren argues that unlike foetuses, women are already persons. They are already conscious being with thoughts, feeling, memories, hopes and awareness. Therefore, the mother should be given greater right to life than the unborn child. Furthermore, Peter Singer argues that killing a foetus is not the same as killing a person. Therefore, the mother has greater rights than the unborn.

The double effect principle argues that actions to save the mother's life but which also lead to abortion are moral. For example, in an ectopic pregnancy. The fallopian tube is removed and the embryo dies, thus saving the mother. In this situation both lives cannot simultaneously be saved, therefore saving the mother’s life becomes the primary aim, although this has a double effect, to save the mother's life kills the unborn child. In this situation the mother’s life is seen more important than the unborn child, as the unborn child is a threat to her life, therefore the mother has a right to save her life. The intention is not to kill, it is doing evil (killing the foetus) for a good reason (saving the...

Other Essays Like 'the Mother's Right to Life Should Always Overrule the Rights of Her Unborn Child.' Assess This View

Right to Information Linked to the Right to Life

725 words - 3 pages INTRO: India is the largest democracy in the world. We all pay taxes. Even a beggar on the street pays sales tax when he buys anything from the market. This money belongs to us. But do we know where does this money go? RTI gives us a right to question governments. In 1975 SC declared that the citizens right to know flow's directly from the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression.RTI is directly linked to the Right to Life

The Life You Always Wanted Essay

880 words - 4 pages The Life You’ve Always Wanted- John Ortberg The Life You’ve Always Wanted: Spiritual disciplines for ordinary people by John Ortberg   SUMMARY John Ortberg’s book, The Life You’ve Always Wanted: Spiritual disciplines for ordinary people, published by Zondervan in 2002, is a contemporary exploration of the spiritual disciplines. Ortberg first introduces the purpose of the disciplines, and then examines eight specific disciplines, followed by

Child Abuse - Is It The Right Thing To Do?

777 words - 4 pages can injure a child and usually the injury is severe. The consequences of abusing a child physically can be very devastating on the child. The physical injuries can vary from bruises, choke marks, burns, possibly brain damage, permanent disabilities, and even death. Instead of lashing out to children, a parent should help children understand the rules and what happens if they are broken. Children are very dependent for care and protection and should

This Is A Review Of The Life Of Female Writer Charlotte Bronte. Her Most Popular Work Was "Jane Eyre."

384 words - 2 pages Charlotte BronteCharlotte was the third child of six of Patrick Bronte and Maria Branwell. Both parents were literary. Her mother died of cancer when she was young. Her aunt, Elizabeth Branwell, moved in to the family home to raise the children until she died in 1842. Charlotte and three of her sisters were sent away to Clergy Daughters' School at Cowan Bridge, where conditions were so bad that Maria and Elizabeth, the two oldest girls, died of

Do You Tend to Agree with the Right-to-Die or the Right-to-Life Advocate?

629 words - 3 pages disagree with God, and to deny God's rights over your live and his right to decide the length of your live and the means your live ends. In many religions euthanasia is not acceptable generally because God gave us a life and no matter how bad we think our life are, we should live our lives to the fullest. Suffering has value. People consider that dying is just one of the tests that God places for human beings, and that the way they react to it

Assess the Usefulness of the Functionalist View of the Family (24 Marks)

670 words - 3 pages Assess the usefulness of the functionalist view of the family. (24 marks) Functionalists believe that society is based on a value consensus – a set of shared norms and values – into which society socialises its members. This enables them to cooperate harmoniously to meet society’s needs and achieve shared goals. They view the family unit as a construct that fulfils important functions and keeps society running smoothly. Functionalists

Identify the Rights of Children in Relation to Play as Detailed in the 'Un Convention on the Rights of the Child'

871 words - 4 pages The Convention on the rights of the child is a list of rights that is complied by the united Nations that all countries should have each individual country has the choice whether to sign up to it or not, so far 193 countries have signed up to it. In 1991 the United Kingdom adopted the convention. In this there are many rights for a child to be educated, another is that every child has a right to play, leisure and culture. An article within it

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That the Main Function of the Education System Is to Reproduce and Legitimise Social Inequalities

2354 words - 10 pages . This involved all children at the age of eleven undertaking an exam in order to ascertain individual ability in order to separate the children into streams of ability and assign them to what was believed to be the most appropriate school. Those demonstrating exceptional ability went to Grammar schools, which were designed to prepare them for professional occupations. Those of lesser ability moved to Secondary modern schools which focused on

Assess the Functionalist View of the Domestic Division of Labour. (21 Marks)

802 words - 4 pages Assess the functionalist view of the domestic division of labour. (21 marks) Domestic division of labour refers to the roles me and women play, in relation to housework, childcare and paid. Functionalist such as Young and Willmott believe and see that the family domestic division of labour has taken a ‘march of progress’. With this march of progress view they believe that the family life improving for all members within in the family and it’s

Is This the Right Strategy

3512 words - 15 pages Business Strategy Emirates Airlines In a League of its Own By Prof Dr M. S. S. El Namaki T With the global economy Is this the Right Strategy? booming, globetrotting is no longer a perk in the corporate world. With the advent of internet and rapid innovations in the field of communications and travel, the world has truly shrunk in size. Plastic money is passé. Time is the new global currency. he airline industry, which

Discus the Relationship of Atticus to His Children. Compare This with a Parent/Child Relationship

1094 words - 5 pages To Kill a Mocking Bird Discus the relationship of Atticus to his children. Compare this with a parent/child relationship. Atticus Finch is a single parent and lawyer who is upright and tolerant to differences. Atticus is the same way with his kids, Scout and Jem. At the beginning of this book Scout is 6 and Jem is 10 years old. Unlike most children Jem and Scout don’t call their father “father”. Jem and Scout call their father by his

Related Papers

“Representative Democracy Is A Muddled Compromise.” Explain And Assess This View

2133 words - 9 pages “Representative democracy is a muddled compromise.” Explain and assess this view In considering the view that representative democracy is a muddled compromise, there is a broad range of topics to be discussed. This paper discusses the key areas of representative democracy, direct democracy and that of dictatorship. Representative democracy is a system of government where citizens elect representatives to make decisions for them. This

Assess The View That James' Foreign Policy Was Wiser Than The Foreign Policies Favoured By Parliament And Charles I (This Was A 45 Minute Timed Essay Was As History)

953 words - 4 pages want to establish himself as "rex pacificus" can be seen to be wiser than the foreign policies of his contemporises. The calling for peace with Spain through the 1604 Treaty of London allowed fro a great trade expansion that increased Britain's prosperity. Similarly James shrewd negotiative skills helped delay the onset of the thirty yeas war through resolution of the Julich Cleves crisis. While this proved to be extremely successful and wise it

"The Adults Are Always Right?" Essay

1559 words - 7 pages THE ADULTS ARE ALWAYS RIGHT?'Clean your room! Don't do that! Stop watching that stupid television, don't you have a book to read? Didn't I tell you to clean your room, do you want to be a slob when you grow up? Go to school, don't you have school today? When I was a kid . . .'Welcome to the lives of almost every teenager in North America. To most parents, when the above words are spoken, they expect to see their teen rush at the opportunity to

Assess The Value Of The Right Realist Approach To Crime And Deviance. (21 Marks)

684 words - 3 pages Assess the value of the right realist approach to crime and deviance. (21 marks) Right realists argue that crime today is a very real and growing problem. Right Realists argue that crime threatens society’s work ethic, social cohesion and destroys communities in society. Unlike other theories, Right realism focuses on the solutions for crime alongside the explanation of what causes crime in society, this approach also criticise labelling and