This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Motive Behind The Murder Essay

1858 words - 8 pages

The Motive behind the Murder
Edgar Allan Poe’s short story “The Cask of Amontillado” describes Montresor’s deadly revenge against his friend Fortunato who he claims has insulted him. Since readers are unable to find the precise explanation of Montresor’s abhorrence of Fortunato, most of the readers conclude that Montresor is insane and unbalanced. However, this interpretation fails to explain the character of Montresor and goes against the intricate details of the plot. The short story’s emphasis on the elaborate murder shows Montresor’s sophisticated philosophy of revenge, which is “No one insults me with impunity”. The motive of his vengeance is because of Fortunato’s arrogance and his ...view middle of the document...

At the end of the story, Montresor told Fortunato that “You are happy, as once I was. You are a man to be misses”, which also verified that Montresor used to be as socially conspicuous as Fortunato.
Though now Montresor is not as wealthy and puissant as Fortunato, Montresor possibly has a better aristocratic lineage than Fortunato. The vaults of Montresor’s family are extensive and their vastness genuinely shocks Fortunato. The vaults, surrounded by the remains of Montresor’s ancestors, indicate the hidden wealth of his family, which also shows how powerful and rich his family used to be. “I suffered him to hurry me to my palazzo” shows further evidence of the prominence of Montresor’s family. Poe uses the word “suffered” to indict Montresor’s unwillingness to lead Fortunato to his palazzo. Montresor does not want his noble origin to be disturbed by Fortunato because Fortunato is a comparable minor aristocrat and Montresor is proud of his better aristocratic lineage than Fortunato’s. Furthermore, Fortunato even could not remember that Montresors “were a great and numerous family”. Fortunato is the one who become rich fortuitously, and of course he did not know Montresor’s aristocratic lineage. This fortuitous ground of Fortunato’s wealth and power also become Montresor’s motive of revenge.
Not only did Montresor have a prominent aristocratic background, but he is also more intelligent than Fortunato, which also becomes the motive of his revenge. The crime Montresor did to Fortunato is so elaborate and intricate that only the most intelligent individual could possess the brainpower and patience it requires to meticulously plot it. It takes a lot of planning and forethought to execute such a murder. He planned every detail of this murder including when it would happen, how it would happen, and where it would happen. For example, Montresor picks the carnival season to commit his crime. Montresor had “made” all of the servants off for the night, using the excuse of the carnival. In this way, he prevents others from witnessing the atrocity he planned to commit. When people could not find Fortunato, they would not think he is murdered because it is hard to relate the happy carnival to such a ferocious crime. The carnival provided Montresor occasion to commit his murder, as well as a time when social distinctions were blurred. People will not be disguised by their classes. As Fortunato is wearing a costume of a fool, it is the best time for Montresor’s murder so that he can make a fool of Fortunato. By wearing the costume of a fool, Fortunato becomes socially inferior to Montresor, especially when Montresor is wearing the costume of an executioner. By saying “How remarkably well you are looking today”, Montresor actually mocked Fortunato and he considered the “fool-looked” costume appropriate for Fortunato, showing his in-mind socially superior.
The seemingly negligible but actually crucial detail that he painstakingly arranged shows Montresor is...

Other Essays Like The Motive Behind the Murder

The Truth Behind Arnold Friend Essay

1272 words - 6 pages The Truth Behind Arnold Friend In Joyce Carol Oates short story, “Where Are You Going? Where Have You Been?”, it is argued that the antagonist in the story is the incarnation of evil; Arnold Friend. Connie, the protagonist in the story, was a naïve fifteen year old who was fascinated by boys and was constantly out of the house with her friends. She always talked about the positive effects of her looks, but never realized the negative attention

The Buzz Behind Energy Drinks Essay

1178 words - 5 pages Essay: Argument – Synthesis Word Count: 977 The Buzz Behind Energy Drinks Many people drink energy drinks every day without knowing the negative effects it can actually have on them. Although society consistently chooses to drink energy drinks, proven by the rapid increase in sales since the year 2000, they are extremely damaging to our health. Energy drinks are responsible for numerous unwanted negative effects such as: feeling twitchy

Shawshank Redemption and Murder in the First

1294 words - 6 pages Years ago, the world’s penal systems such as Alcatraz Penitentiary; (refer to Appendix A) were biased, corrupt and unjust. Today if such a system existed and was identified there would be immediate action. ‘Murder in the First’ and ‘The Shawshank Redemption’ are two similar yet equally engrossing pieces of film-making; both films are set in the 1930’s and 1940’s in American prisons and both convey the similar message. The Shawshank Redemption

Case Study/ the Murder of Carolyn Casey

572 words - 3 pages Danielle Johnson 06/28/2014 Writting Assignment 2 Thomas Edison State College AOJ-280-OL009 Case Study/ The Murder of Carolyn Casey Ynobe Matthews was Executed January 6, 2004 at 6:18 p.m in Texas by lethal injection for the 2000 rape and murder of a College student named Carolyn Casey. He was also charged with arson as a result of the fire he started at the crime scene. DNA, a post mortem examination, and fibers left at the

Behind the Arch: The Truth about Drinking

1033 words - 5 pages Behind the Arch: The Truth about Drinking at BVU After reading the book, Behind the Arch: The Truth about Drinking at BVU by Chris Allen, Alisa Dixson, Jennifer Durham, Shelley Katzer, Max Kenkel, Teri Kramer, Toby Malavong, and Courtney Weller, I realized that drinking on our BVU campus is a problem. I think that this is a problem on almost all college campuses though. This same group of students could go to almost any campus in the

Behind the Scenes: How Anime Is Produced

1035 words - 5 pages order to produce it. With each episode having an average of 3000 frames per episode, which are really a lot [1], the artists and producers strictly do their jobs and truly do not have a moment to slack off. Bibliography [1] (January 18, 2011). Anime Production – Detailed Guide to How Anime is Made and the Talent Behind it!. Washi's Blog. Retrieved January 5, 2013 from

Behind the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn

1025 words - 5 pages Behind The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn stands the famous Mark Twain. Even though Mark Twain writes a literal masterpiece, many critics have deprived the novel of its worth. Some believe the story only contains racism. But honestly, did Twain write to degrade the black population? Of course not! Twain did not spend eight years of his time to create a novel based on the corruption of the colored people. In all actuality, Twain unites the story

Martin Luther: Man Behind the Protestant Reformation

686 words - 3 pages message of 95 Thesis gave the summary and expressed the feelings of many of his peers already had about the corruption of Christ's teachings. Luther illustrated the spiritual, material, and psychological truths behind abuses in the practice of buying and selling indulgences. He was not out to pick a fight or to have his own way; his purpose was to uphold the truth, for the cause of Christ. Church officials acted against him. The Saxon Dominican

Can We Leave the Past Behind?

2778 words - 12 pages Can We Leave The Past Behind? Within this essay I will be looking at whether we can truly leave our pasts behind or whether they remain a part of us within our present and future. My own belief is that our past is what makes us who we are today. Our experiences from childhood through to adulthood make up our coping mechanisms for future situations and even if we have dealt with issues that may arise they will still remain in our conscious

Thirty Eight Who Saw Murder and Didnt Call the Police

1082 words - 5 pages “Thirty Eight Who Saw Murder Didn’t Call the Police” Jill Murray Professor Askary English Comp 1 Hudson County College Martin Gansberg Martin Gansberg was born on May 6, 1920 in Brooklyn New York. Graduating from Saint John’s University, he went to be a reporter and editor for the New York Times for forty three years. Mr. Gansberg was married to his wife for 48 years. Her name was Agitha Miller Gansberg. They had a son, Alan, and a

Remembering Babylon - the Motive of Identity

647 words - 3 pages Before we start to define the illustration of identity and development in the book “Remembering Babylon” of David Malouf, which was published in 1994, we need to give a definition of both of them. In our opinion the word identity has two different, but both important, meanings. First of all it stand for the collective aspect of the set of characteristics by which a person is recognized, the individuality, which is just your own. Another

Related Papers

The Kitty Genovese Murder Essay

828 words - 4 pages Katie Wallace Psychology 2301 May 9, 2013 Mrs. Strickland Silent Witnesses: The Kitty Genovese Murder 1. After the 1964 murder of Kitty Genovese, John Darley and Bibb Latane were in shock as the rest of the city/world that a 28 year old lady could be stabbed in a neighborhood with about 38 by standers or more and say or do nothing. Why didn’t anyone try and help her? How could people stand by and watch this go on? People speculated that

Dangerous Behind The Wheel Essay

1092 words - 5 pages Dangerous Behind the Wheel As a husband and a father, the safety of my family is perhaps one of the most important things in my life. Every time I get in a vehicle, I ensure everyone has his or her seatbelt on and I make it a point to be as safe as I can be when I drive. Unfortunately, there are certain things that even I cannot control. Imagine something so dangerous that it can take away everything and/or everyone you have in mere

The Batman Behind The Mask Essay

1771 words - 8 pages The Batman Behind the Mask Greetings! Are you here for your meeting with Master Wayne? Unfortunately he is occupied at the moment, so please take a seat and relax. Oh goodness, where are my manners. Would you care for anything to eat or drink? No? Then welcome to the gorgeous Wayne Manor, home of the one and only Bruce Wayne. I am Alfred Thaddeus Crane Pennyworth, the valet of Wayne Manor, but you may just call me Alfred (“Alfred Pennyworth

Personal Motive Vs. Societal Influences: The Powerful Role Played By Society In "Crime And Punishment" And "The Stranger"

1550 words - 7 pages Dostoevsky have both written novels that successfully criticize these aspects of their societies. Through analysis of the causes and motives in The Stranger and Crime and Punishment, the destructive society of the times positions itself as the major strength and motive behind Mersault and Raskolnikov's criminal activities as well as the final arbitration of their punishments.The Stranger lacks a concrete cause to rationalize Meursault's murder of the Arab