This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Myth Of Rescue Essay

1152 words - 5 pages

"The Myth of Rescue" by William Rubinstein has no doubt been one of the most attacked books by reviewers on this matter of the Holocaust. Rubinstein disagrees with the idea that some scholars supported, that the allies could have done much more to help the Jews, and explains why it was so difficult to assist them. Rubinstein's construction of the situation faced by the Jews of Nazi occupied Europe demonstrates some coherent and thoughtful points about the period of the slaughter of the Jews.

His arguments in opposition to the suggestion made by the different scholars were based on the following facts.

In 1938-39, from the 10 millions Jews that were in continental Europe, among ...view middle of the document...

This gave the impression that more Jews were able to emigrate than was the case.

He argues that this was a proof that the British government showed some collaboration.

He also points out that new policies were established by the British to allowed "carte blanche" for the immigration of Jews. Also many German Jews refused to cross the border, because they believe that the crises and tensions would get solve

Again, Jews from Poland, Soviet Union and Poland didn't get any help because at that time they weren't refugees, but were free in their own countries, which weren't yet invaded and conquered by the Nazis.

A programme offered to the "National Committee for rescue from Nazi terror" by the biggest organization to help the Jews was a typical example of the futility of the plans. Rubinstein says: "this programme was a pathetic confession of helplessness and bankruptcy" because it concentrated on the idea of providing a safe haven for the Jews, whereas the real problem was that they were not being released in the first place.

Finally Rubinstein rejects the argument which is often made that the allies could have bombed Auschwitz or the railway lines leading up to it. He says that bombing Auschwitz would have killed lots of Jews without necessarily destroying the gas chambers. And if railways lines were destroyed, others were always available for use.

Now I'm going to say what I think about Rubinstein's points. In favour of him I think he made a very thoughtful point when he described the circumstances that Britain was in at the time of the killings. There could have emerged in Britain a wish to protect their nation from a possible invasion.

Most of the Jews were in Nazi controlled areas and were forbidden to emigrate from all over the Nazi occupied territory. They couldn't be reached by the allies and if they had tried to rescue them, they probably would have lost thousands of soldiers lives.

We can not forget that many German Jews refused to leave their homeland because they believed that the entire situation would be sorted out in Germany, and they maintained their hope in a new institutionalised regime. It was an option made by Jews and not by Nazis or the Allies.

Finally the attack on Auschwitz, would create a big impact in Jews lives, because would make...

Other Essays Like The Myth Of Rescue

The Different Perspectives Of Being Caught In Ovid’S Myth: Diana And Actaeon

966 words - 4 pages In Ovid’s Metamorphoses the myth of “Diana and Actaeon” is written using descriptive diction and symbolism. The symbolism creates ambiguity leading to many possible interpretations of the myth. One symbolic line is that shows the fear expressed by Actaeon and Diana is: “so deeply blushed Diana, caught unclothed” (Ovid, III, 188). Both Diana and Actaeon become caught figuratively and literally in the myth. Caught prey reacts instinctively and

The Movement Of Liminal Women And Its Consequences In Early Greek Myth

5992 words - 24 pages The Movement of Liminal Women and its Consequences in Early Greek Myth The title of this paper takes as its cue Blondell et al's Women on the Edge: Four Plays by Euripides, [1] which argues in its introduction that "[w]omen in tragedy often disrupt 'normal' life by their words and actions: they speak out boldly, tell lies, cause public unrest, violate custom, defy orders, even kill." (Blondell, Gamel, Rabinowitz, Sorkin and Zweig. 1999, x

Fact or Fiction: a Critique of the Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology

1935 words - 8 pages Fact or Fiction: A Critique of the Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology The Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology by William Arens (1979) examines the evidence or lack thereof in determining what constitutes cannibalism or anthropophagy. Throughout history anthropologists as well as other “explorers” have encountered numerous peoples throughout the world. During their fieldwork they have gathered data which suggest the

The Myth Of Meat

2139 words - 9 pages With America eating more meat than ever and growing sicker than ever, the dangers of a meat-heavy diet must be examined. We may now consider meat an essential part of the human diet, but in previous eras it was nothing more than a luxury. In addition, the present state of factory-farmed animals can lead to nothing but outrageously unhealthful meat. Many omnivores wonder how vegetarians survive on the nonstandard diet. Many vegetarians wonder how

A Comparison Between "The Myth Of Sisyphus" By Albert Camus And "One Day In The Life Of Ivan Denisovich" By Alexander Solzhenitsyn

1103 words - 5 pages "The Myth of Sisyphus" and "One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich" present the criticism of society by using a writing style called existentialism. The Myth of Sisyphus and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich show existentialism in different ways using imagery, conflict, and mood. Existentialism is a 20th century philosophical movement, based on personal responsibility for acts, absence in the judgment of right and wrong, and individual

Tragic Fall Of Icarus--Compares The Myth And How It Relates To "Musee Des Beaux Arts," Landscape With The Fall Of Icarus," And "Waiting For Icarus."

1337 words - 6 pages The Tragic Death of IcarusThe story of Icarus is a classic Greek myth that has fascinated people all over the world. The tale of his demise has been retold many times throughout history. The myth has been honored in art, songs, poetry and by literature artists, with one apparently inspiring the other to explore the tale in one different approach or another. Three of the most appealing of these versions of the tale of Icarus can be found in the

Theories of a Myth

887 words - 4 pages Theories of Myth Melissa McKenna University of Phoenix HUM 105 Dr. Cynthia Begay November 01, 2010 Theories of Myth How did this world come to be? Where did humanity come from? These are questions that have been on people’s tongues since the beginning of time. Different cultures, traditions, and people have their own understanding as to how the world began, and how they came into it. The different narratives of the creation of the

Domination System

788 words - 4 pages in society. Eventually it continued until several centuries. Society struggled for equal system. A domination system lacked of domination myth, which destroyed people’s lives (Wink, 37-42). The myth of redemptive violence has created new era in the world. It became the real myth of modern world. It dedicates the feeling that violence saves the world and brings peace. In other words, when everything else fails to resolve disputes, violence

student personality

370 words - 2 pages type of incident is hazard material incident. Hazard material is defined as any material or substance that could adversely affect the safety of the public. For example, if a high toxic material like Sulfur spills on the ground, a firefighter will wear special clothes and use technique to contain it.In conclusion, a firefighter should be professional and expert in his job. So, he needs to take the right action in the right place for these incidents: fire incident, rescue incident, and hazard material. My advice to all, please try to avoid incident before happen.

Psuchology

1130 words - 5 pages Foundation of Mythology Melissa Colon Professor Chris Jordan HUM/105 January 24, 2016 How is the word myth used popularly? For example, consider the statement, "It's a myth that..." In contrast, how is the word myth used in the academic context? After considering the definition in your textbooks and course materials, write a definition in your own words.   In the modern world word math is used scarcely because the only

Bcom275 Business Communications And Critical Thinking - Week 2

1258 words - 6 pages down to rescue the miners will be difficult and will take some time. However, once news of the collapse spread through the local community and finally to the world, the families of those men trapped were angry and frustrated with the lack of news. The families’ of the miners require some type of feedback on their current status and that everything possible is being done to assist them. The biggest drawback is being trapped that far below, the

Related Papers

The Myth Of Dracula Essay

2629 words - 11 pages The Myth of Dracula Jenny Martinez, Com 220 University of Phoenix Cole Chatterton January 9, 2008 THE MYTH OF DRACULA In October of 1999, a television series began that would run for approximately four and a half years. This series would again sate the American appetite for vampire stories begun by the likes of Bram Stoker, Anne Rice, Tanith Lee, and Chelsea Quinn Yarbro. The name of the series? Angel. The Premise? A

The Myth Of Media Violence Essay

949 words - 4 pages Andrew O’Hehir gives many examples to illustrate his viewpoint in “The Myth of Media Violence” such as how media violence is not a new demon, but something that has been around for as long as Western Civilization. He additionally provides several examples of violence not only in recent times, but as far back as Plato and Aristotle. Media violence, often over exaggerated and with little claim to whom is responsible, has been present for an

The Creation Of Myth Surrounding Stalin

1175 words - 5 pages Assignment 03 Part 1 Stalin What does the source tell us about the creation of myth surrounding Stalin? Joseph Stalin was not just a figurehead of state but a man of many contrasts. Through propaganda and oppression he made himself he made his image to be the unquestionable and if he was questioned by anyone he could and would eradicate them to protect his persona that he created. Stalin succeeded Lenin after his death and needed to set

Rescue Of The Child From Omelas

902 words - 4 pages after much convincing from my neighbors to visit what everyone called "it" I went to see for myself. I couldnt stand there for more than what seemed like the longest minute of my life. I was overcome with sadness, sickening grief and disgust by what I saw. It just didnt make any sense that this is essential for the "happiness" and prosperity of our community. I could not live this life thriving on the misery and torture of an innocent child