This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Noble Lie Essay

1383 words - 6 pages

The Noble Lie

In Bloom's second edition of "The Republic of Plato," there are many troubling issues. The one that strikes me the most, however, is the idea of the "noble lie." I find this completely disturbing for a number of reasons. It is immoral and wrong to deliberately deceive someone. This idea also completely contradicts Socrates' argument that it is beneficial to be just.
In the discussion between Socrates and Glaucon that involved how to create an ideal city, they divided the people into three classes: rulers, auxiliaries, and craftsmen. In this city each class has a certain role. The rulers are the highest of rank in the city. They are older, wise men who govern the state ...view middle of the document...

Each class is made of a different metal. The rulers were gold, for they have the greatest honor. The auxiliaries were silver, and the craftsmen were brass and iron. After they have been created, they lead normal human lives and they are able to have children. Unfortunately, sometimes parents from one line will have children from another. God states above all else, the races should be kept separate and pure. So if a gold parent for example, has a silver or iron son, this son would have to leave the gold world that his parents come from and take his place in the silver or iron world being an auxiliary or craftsman. The situation could work in reverse also. A silver parent could give birth to a gold son. In this case, the son would leave the parent and take his place in higher rank. Socrates says it is best to tell the people that the races must be kept pure because the prophets have spoken, and the city will be destroyed if the rule is not observed and followed.
Socrates regretfully doubts that the people will actually believe the noble lie to be literally true at first, but that eventually the lie will spread down to the later generations. He wants the lie to teach a valuable lesson that will increase loyalty to the city.
When he delivers the theory of the noble lie to Glaucon, Socrates seems to be hesitant. When Glaucon asks why, Socrates replies that he will understand after the idea is expressed. After Socrates explains the noble lie, Glaucon then understands why Socrates was so hesitant. Glaucon expresses to Socrates that he should be ashamed of concocting such a scheme. Glaucon agrees with Socrates that if the citizens may not believe the myth at first, the children of later generations who have been raised with the idea would believe it. So at first, Glaucon couldn't believe that Socrates, supposedly "Mr. Right," would create this lie and approve of it for the good of the city. By the end of the argument, Glaucon is on board with Socrates and believes that it could possibly work.
I find a few troubling issues that concern this myth. As a result of my frustrations dealing with this concept, I decided to visit the Dictionary.com web site. I researched the definitions of a few words that pertain to this idea of the noble lie.
The first word I looked up is "lie". A lie is an untrue statement with intent to deceive; something misleading or deceiving. I find it very difficult to believe, but more importantly immoral-- that anyone would want the foundation of an entire city based upon a lie. If this myth is targeted towards increasing loyalty to the city; yes, it could very well increase the loyalty, but I have to question the fact that the people are only being loyal because of a myth. How strong is loyalty that is built upon a lie? How...

Other Essays Like The Noble Lie

To What Extent Would You Agree That John Proctor Is Presented as an Honest, Strong but Ultimately Flawed Character?

1348 words - 6 pages town, regarding witchcraft. He and many others are thrown into a freefall of squirting due to the accusation placed by a group of young girls Proctors character is a many-sided, he shows strengths throughout the play, including his loyalty to his wife and friends, but shows flaws because of his guilty pleasures which are seen through his relationship with Abigail Williams, and although his pride seems to be a noble feat of his, it is his honesty

Analysis Of Christopher Smart's "For I Will Consider My Cat Jeofry"

1351 words - 6 pages he worships in his way," shows Jeoffry as a servant of the sun because at the first sign of the sun he goes into his routine, following the sun around his house. He circles a spot many times to find the perfect position to lie. Once he's found the perfect resting spot in the sun he immediately springs to his feet at the opportunity to enjoy some catnip. This catnip is the ultimate enjoyment by a cat, the perfect answer to his prayers. He rolls

Willfull Ignorance of Women

1362 words - 6 pages “Glory of Women” set about discouraging ignorance, Marlow does the opposite by facilitating the Intended’s conception of Kurtz as an honorable, heroic man. He never once contradicts her conception of Kurtz’s “greatness…of his noble heart” (70), offering only the ambiguous comfort that they “shall remember him” (70). In these silent lies, Marlow perpetuates the willful ignorance of women by failing to relay the truth of the memory of Kurtz—one of

Proctor and his Conscious

1097 words - 5 pages . Although he knew it was the right thing to do, he did not want to embarrass his beloved wife by exposing his affair in public. This is why he was willing to die at the end of the play. Proctor felt that he could not have endured living with this sin looming over him everyday. This may consider Proctor as a good and noble man. In addition, Proctor chose to die because he could not afford to double-cross his friends. He felt that by selling out his

Iago's Motivations for Revenge

1024 words - 5 pages previous statement made by Iago: ‘The Moor… Is of a constant, loving, noble nature…’ This contrast reinforces the fact that Iago is a dishonest and lying man, underlining the universal truth from the liberal humanist perspective that Iago is plain evil. The simile employed in Iago's third soliloquy symbolizes Iago's actions: ‘They do suggest at first with heavenly shows/ As I do now’. This simile suggests that when the devil is about to commit a

MY FUTURE PROFESSION- MATHEMATICIAN

668 words - 3 pages programmer develops algorithms and computer programs for use in mathematical modelling, data analysis and problem-solving in fields such as industrial design, climate science and geoscience.At present, I would like to be a maths teacher. To my mind, it is a very noble profession. It is very difficult to become a good maths teacher. Undoubtedly, you should know the subject you teach perfectly, you should be well-educated and broad minded. An ignorant

Valediction

781 words - 4 pages . Yours is the most noble profession for it builds furture leaders and builders or actors in the drama of life, of the future generation. And so fellow graduates, let us not turn our dreams into nightmares and our hopes to disappointments, for in our hands lie the future of our country. In our success lie the progress and greatness of Filipino nation. Ultimately, let us live up to the expectation of our Alma Mater to be advocate of the virtue

Wild Ducklin

1318 words - 6 pages from illness. Gregers himself suffers from an "integrity- fever" and a "delirium of hero-worship." His "claim of the ideal" becomes a disorder rather than a moral or spiritual imperative. The ideal does not figure as some moral or spiritual imperative but is yet another pathology, as closely related to the lie as typhus is to putrid fever. What is imperative for Relling then is not the soul's attainment to truth but the treatment of mental

A Pardoner Who Needs A Bath

1789 words - 8 pages ,” and in any response he could have given; he was to either lie and defy the religious hierarchy’s reasoning, who he was loyal to, or tell the truth and be a hypocrite to his true values (Chaucer 1729). Either decision the noble knight made contradicted and proved The Wife’s reason for having more than one husband: “Choose now, which of two courses you will try: to have me old and ugly till I die but evermore your true and humble wife,” or “will you

The Chemical Earth

4069 words - 17 pages known as METALLOIDS) |NON-METALS | |Lie on the left hand side of the periodic |Lie along the border between metals and |Lie to the right and side of the periodic | |table |non-metals (B, Si, Ge, As, Sb, Te, Po) |table | |Donate electrons (form positive ions) |Varies, depending on where it lies

When Tragedy Strikes

1357 words - 6 pages make quick and poor decisions, simply because he wanted something so bad, and that was to become king. He was not going to let anything or anyone get in his way. When Macbeth first hears the witches’ prophecies stating that he would become the Thane of Cawdor, and that he possibly could become King in the future, his ambition starts to begin. Prophecy, in any “spirit” or interpretation does not lie, but can be deceiving and must be approached with

Related Papers

"Dulce Et Decorum Est" And "An Irish Airman Forsees His Death"

678 words - 3 pages his World War I experience. Owen, an officer in the British Army, deeply opposed the intervention of one nation into another. His poem explains how the British press and public comforted themselves with the fact that all the young men dying in the war were dieing noble, heroic deaths. The reality was quite different: They were dieing obscene and terrible deaths. Owen wanted to throw the war in the face of the reader to illustrate how vile and

Buddha's Opinion On How One Should Live

1250 words - 5 pages If Buddha Were Alive Today, How Would He Answer The Question: "How Should One Live"?      What is right? Who is to say what is right? How do we know what we are doing is right? These are all questions that allude to how should one live? Different people have different opinions on this area. Buddha's theory is one way to answer the question.      Buddha has four noble truths. These

Julius Caesar Essay

978 words - 4 pages assassination of Julius Caesar. Even though Brutus agrees with the conspirators to kill Julius Caesar, he did not agree with their reasoning. Brutus wanted what was best for Rome and the conspirators were jealous. Brutus is a complex character. He was thought of as honorable and noble, but he appears hypocritical when he becomes involved in the plot to kill his apparent best friend. It is Brutus' honorable nature that causes him to fall under Cassius

Wilfred Owen Essay

1729 words - 7 pages antiwar protest upon us as he juxtaposes the Western Front as the abode of madness against the title’s romantic idealism. Hence Owen’s innovating crafting of form and language compels us to relive his ‘haunting’ nightmares alongside the soldiers and in doing so urges us to his truth and refute the propagandist ‘old lie’ of war as a noble pursuit. ‘Anthem For Doomed Youth’ criticizes the fact that a whole generation of youth was lost in World