The Obligation To Endure Essay

1413 words - 6 pages

“The discovery of agriculture was the first big step toward a civilized life.” (Arthur Keith)
Civilization began with agriculture, and agriculture continues to be an integral part of our lives. Civilization brought knowledge, knowledge brought technology, and technology brought chemicals and pesticides to “improve” our world. “The Obligation to Endure” is an excerpt from Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring,” a passionate and masterful work on the results of civilization’s efforts to control pests and insects. These effects include destruction of the environment, alteration of gene structures in plants and animals, water contamination, and an upset of nature’s delicate balance. This article ...view middle of the document...

Structure of Major Arguments
Carson’s primary argument is that the ecosystem is unable to adjust and rebalance itself due to the rapidity of the introduction of chemicals into the environment. She points to the common knowledge that it took hundreds of millions of years for life to evolve to its current state. She goes on to explain how, given time (eons), the environment adjusted to natural dangers such as radiation emitted from certain rocks and short-wave radiation from the sun, but that it is impossible for the earth to adjust and rebalance in the face of man-made threats in the relative miniscule timeframe of decades. Her appeal is both logical and emotional. Logically, chemicals sprayed on croplands, forests or gardens will kill not just “pests” but other living organisms, and that some amount of these chemicals will end up in ground water, causing problems for anyone or anything that depends on this water. Emotionally if the possibility of permanent gene damage, which cause deformities, cancers, and early death, is not enough to encourage a second look at this issue then there is no hope for the planet’s future.
Carson’s next argument is that the volume of new chemicals coming on the market each year, the universal use of these chemicals on farms, gardens, forests, and homes, and the lack of information on the short or long-term effect of these chemicals on the beneficial insects as well as the bad, means we are laying the seeds of our own demise. She points to the fact that since the mid-1940s, more than 200 chemicals were created for use in killing “pests” and “weeds.” And her information is current only to the 1950s when she was writing this book (published 1962). She argues that these chemicals should be called “biocides” instead of insecticides. Once again, her arguments are both logical and emotional. If more than 200 chemicals were produced in a ten year span, how many more were developed between the mid-50s and 2011? At an emotional level, the explosive growth of this industry and the widespread acceptance should sound alarms.
A third argument involves the ultimate irony. Carson explains how these “pests” are living proof of Darwin’s theory of “survival of the fittest.” Indeed all pests, whether insects, worms, or fungus continually evolve in order to survive. Therefore, we are systematically breeding super races of the very things we are attempting to eradicate. Carson’s argument that the chemical war cannot ever be won is powerful although disputable (by the chemical industry of course).
Carson next argues that humans created the problem, and continue to create problems, each time we import fruits, vegetables, and livestock from other parts of the world. She points out that (as of the writing) over 100,000 different species of plants were imported from all over the world, bringing with them over half of the known pest enemies of plants. She quotes British ecologist Charles Elton who asserts...

Other Essays Like The Obligation To Endure

Epcg 2011-2014 Essay

1931 words - 8 pages for the export market. The import duty on capital goods — like all other items — was high during that period, inflating the cost of capital goods nearly 50%, so the government allowed exporters to import capital goods at only 25% import duty. For waiver of the remaining portion of import duty, exporters were supposed to undertake an 'export obligation' (a promise to export) which was worked out on the basis of the duty concession obtained

Paper Matches

1311 words - 6 pages Paulette Jiles’, Paper Matches, delves into the struggles women wrestle with for the majority of their lives. She addresses how women are not subordinate to men but are, in fact, empowered by their ability to endure and the necessity of their existence every man has. Upon first reading of Paper Matches, it would seem that the speaker is simply stating the way of the world, that women are on this earth to serve men. However, as Paulette Jiles

Army Accountibility

1238 words - 5 pages the U.S. Army you are expressing your loyalty. And by doing your share, you show your loyalty to your unit. In turn this means that it is a soldier’s obligation to be on time, at the right location, in the right uniform. Without loyalty there would be soldiers missing formations to give out sensitive information to the enemy or just goofing off and no one would be aware of the soldier’s whereabouts. The next army value will be duty. Duty is

Explorations Of Childhood And Duty In “The Chimney Sweeper” And “Casabianca”

1841 words - 8 pages recitation tradition that arose during the second-generation Romantic era. The tradition of recitation of “Casabianca” for school children reflects childhood innocence and obligation to duty. Just as school children were required to follow the orders of their teachers by memorizing verse, the children in both poems are obligated to fulfill their respective duties assigned to them by adults in society. The oral roots of both of these poems are

The Vulnerables

1246 words - 5 pages Physiological needs. Some examples of those necessities are food, water, and shelter. And in order for man to endure in a future, man must fulfill those needs. And the obligation that I’m talking about is the obligation as a human to fulfill these needs and necessities. Steinbeck shows that there is a great price to be paid for not being sensitive to the needs of others as well as taking care of others. In the story Mice and men there are different types

Trueblood Case 09-4 Solution

1792 words - 8 pages deposits to financially protect the lessor concerning the maintenance obligation by setting up a reserve, the guidance in ASC 840-10-05-9A through 840-10-05-9C states that the maintenance reserve shall be recognized as a deposit asset and reimbursed later when the required repair and maintenance is completed by the lessee. However, the provision in the lease agreement does not call upon the lessee to make deposits but simply requires the lessee to

Assisted Sucide

910 words - 4 pages person’s well-being you can’t think about yourself. Besides having that in mind, I believe that this may be how Susan felt. Susan did not want to endure the loss of her father, she wanted to embrace her father and hold on to him as long as she possibly could but Susan knew that was not likely. Ethically she had a responsibility to her father and was accountable to make sure his requests were understood and seen through. However, Susan father

Accounting

1854 words - 8 pages sheet d. The portion so classified will be liquidated within one year using current assets 6. An enterprise is required to exclude a short-term obligation from current liabilities if it intends to refinance the obligation on a long-term basis and: a. The enterprise can demonstrate the ability to consummate the refinancing b. The obligation is not a part of normal operations c. It can demonstrate that

Female Circumcism in Africa

1738 words - 7 pages that they know can bring harm, both physical and psychological, to their daughters. Mothers organize the cutting of their daughters because they consider that is what they must do to raise a girl properly and to prepare her for adulthood and marriage. In discussions about FGM/C, Mannika women in central Guinea explained that parents have a threefold obligation to their daughters: to educate them properly, cut them, and find them a husband

Animal Cruelty

1655 words - 7 pages most widely recognized structures are scientific experimentation, owners leaving their pets at home alone, and abuse. Scientific exploration is a need of life, so it is said. Scientist needs to research to enhance economy and the results of ordinary life. This is fine and dandy, until something or somebody needs to endure. Ordinarily organizations test items on creatures for the security of people. Canines, felines, mice, primates and all

cathrane

396 words - 2 pages Aragon was thrown away like an old wooden leg, and the improper celebration of her passing was further insulted by his yellow banquet attire. Furthermore the fashionable replacement in Anne Boleyn, who bore him a daughter was still not safe. His relentless pursuit for a boy saw Anne endure wild rumours and accusations which led to her beheading!When Henry finally had a son from Jane Seymour even she was doomed to death soon after giving birth

Related Papers

No Moral Obligation To The Earth

1188 words - 5 pages A relatively young philosophy and rapidly groving movement is environmentalism. It has roots in ethical philosophy. It presents a moral duty in having an obligation to the planet. However, its approach is misguided: While it is obviously useful to study and to be familiar with the the Earth we inhabit, presenting a moral obligation of protecting it is an incorrect approach. Many have been lead to accept this falsehood, guided by shaky logic and

Animals And Human Culture Essay

2491 words - 10 pages Animals and Human culture Before the 19th century, the West viewed nonhumans as being outside the legal and moral community (Francione, 2008). In this respect, how they were treated or used raised no legal or moral concern. The Western community could use nonhumans for whatever purpose they felt like, inflicting suffering and pain to whatever magnitude they wanted and no obligation owed to them would be deemed as being violated. In

Computer Addiction Essay

1729 words - 7 pages position it falls to them occupy in life. However, that tolerance should not preclude them from striving to change or improve their social standing or advantage, provided always that they do not breach the Principle of Peace in consequence. The Society requires all its adherents to confine any self-serving effort they may make to improve their own lot strictly within the limits set by their overriding obligation to discharge their Responsibility

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

1630 words - 7 pages different perspective on how businesses work in a global market. Another ethical perspective one should examine is obligation. Obligation can be described as doing what is morally correct without taking into account the ramifications. However, based on the perspective of obligation toward ethics, the results and equity perspectives also needs to be examined. The results perspective fluctuates within the idea of ethics being based upon the perception of