The Publicity Of Thought And Language

3820 words - 16 pages

I try to clarify the ways in which one would seek to hold that language and/or thought are public. For each of these theses, I distinguish four forms in which they can be framed, and two ways of establishing them. The first will try to make the publicity of thought follow from that of language; the second will try to make the publicity of language follow from that of thought. I show that none of these strategies can do without the thesis that language and thought are interdependent, and that even while admitting this thesis, the second strategy presents more difficulties than the first.

The sceptical problem of Kripkenstein pertains to both the notions of content of thought and ...view middle of the document...

Hence, there seems to be at least three different ways in which one could try to reach the two desired conclusions. However, the foregoing remarks hide a few difficulties that can partly be disclosed by stating more precisely what the publicity of language and thought is supposed to consists in.

For the case of thought, one can distinguish at least the following four theses:

(1) strong publicity of thought: if an agent has the capacity to think T, then there is another agent who also has the capacity to think T,

(2) moderate publicity of thought: if an agent X has the capacity to think T, then it is possible that another agent also has the capacity to think T (or, more accurately, that X is not alone in having the capacity to think T),

(3) weak publicity of thought: if an agent X has the capacity to think, then there is another agent who has the capacity of having at least one of the thoughts that X is able to have,

(4) anatomicity of thought: if an agent has the capacity to think, then there is another agent who also has the capacity to think.

And for the case of language we have the four corresponding theses:

(5) strong publicity of language: if an agent speaks a language L, then there is another agent who also speaks L,

(6) moderate publicity of language: if an agent X speaks a language L, then it is possible that another agent also speaks L (or, more accurately, that X is not alone in speaking L),

(7) weak publicity of language: if an agent X speaks a language, then there is another agent who speaks at least one of the languages spoken by X,

(8) anatomicity of language: if an agent speaks a language, then there is another agent who also speaks a language.

It will be noted that the weak publicity thesis (i.e., (3) or (7)) presents the advantage of not excluding (as strong publicity does) the existence of a private language or thought, while the moderate publicity thesis (i.e., (2) or (6)) presents the advantage of excluding (as weak publicity does not) the possibility of a private language or thought being necessarily private.

Let us now return to the three strategies that could lead us to the desired conclusions (in one form or another). Two of these rely on a specific thesis regarding the relation between thought and language. The first (call it "the L-to-T strategy") aims to show that thought is public (anatomic) by relying on a prior proof of the publicity (anatomicity) of language and of the thesis that thought depends on (and thus implies) language. The second (call it "the T-to-L strategy") aims to show that language is public (anatomic) by relying on a prior proof of the publicity (anatomicity) of thought and of the thesis that language depends on (and thus implies) thought. Since the dependence of thought on language is more controversial than the dependence of language on thought, and since the T-to-L strategy claims to dispense with the first thesis, while the L-to-T strategy claims only to...

Other Essays Like The Publicity Of Thought And Language

"The Power Of Language" Essay

639 words - 3 pages for the most part. The only real difference is that the elders have a broader range of knowledge, and therefore will use bigger and more complicated words.Another type of communication is done through body language. Body language is another type of communication that is used every day whether you realize it or not. This is a very important type of communication, especially for those who are either deaf or can't speak the same language. I use this

The Language of Hawaii Essay

562 words - 3 pages . The two cultures that I consider myself, Scottish andHawaiian, are both proud, interesting, and contain their own prescriptions towardbehavior. The pidgin dialect is a major part of life in the lower class Hawaiianneighborhoods. For most children in these neighborhoods it is the language spoken athome. The other people of the islands look at this dialect as a sign of a poor educationand up-bringing. My mother did not want her son associated with

Defending Hume's Description Of The Human Thought Process. A Compare And Contrast With My Own Personal Opinions

605 words - 3 pages The human mind is a very intricate machine. There have been many people that have attempted, and failed, to explain how the human mind operates. After reading Hume, I was in agreement with a lot of what he was explaining. Hume, in my mind, has come the closest to uncovering the minds operations.Robert Hume dealt with a lot of what Decarte talked about in his writings. The difference between Decarte and Hume is that Hume 'ironed out' a lot of the

Ancient Near Eastern Thought And The Old Testament

4451 words - 18 pages LIBERTY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY BOOK SUMMARY OF “ANCIENT NEAR EASTERN THOUGHT AND THE OLD TESTAMENT” BY JOHN H. WALTON SUBMITTED TO PROFESSOR DANIEL WARNER IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR OBST 590 BY JOEY F. LANGLINAIS LYNCHBURG, VA JUNE 23, 2013 Chapter 1 History and Methods John Walton begins this chapter by stating that the “rediscovery of Egypt began in the eighteenth century AD and of

The Role of English Language

1346 words - 6 pages Lokamanya could not have thought the thoughts they did without a knowledge of the English language. Of all the superstitions that affect India, none is so great as that a knowledge of the English language is necessary for imbibing ideas of liberty, and developing accuracy of thought. It should be remembered that there has been only one system of education before the country for the past fifty years, and only one medium of expression forced on the country

Dialects Of The Arab Language

2818 words - 12 pages The Arab culture has many different local dialects, where each state has its own individual understood dialect divergent to its neighbouring Arabic speaking countries. Despite this, all Arabs from each dialect have one mutual aspect, they all understand the same Arabic language and it is because of this dynamic that all Arabs are united. The Arab nation states all share a parallel culture, thus when considering Arab hospitality we can say that

The Influence Of The Norman Conquest: Incorporating French Into English Culture And Language

3088 words - 13 pages The Influence of the Norman Conquest Incorporating French into English Culture and Language Normandy and England circa. 1066 Normandy is a coastal district in France that lies almost directly across from England. Its name was derived from the groups of Northmen who settled in the district only a century or two before the Norman Conquest. Although the Norman population would be largely Scandinavian in origin during the ninth and tenth

The Slaughter Of The English Language

1158 words - 5 pages their text messages. They use improper grammar and often times do not punctuate at all. Technology such as texting, facebook and instant messaging work hand in had in the destruction of the English language. Technology has not made people more efficient, but rather has made them lazy. Text messaging is a technology that contributes to the great decline of the English language. The English language is often butchered through the use of text

Effective Use Of Pathos And Connotative Language

949 words - 4 pages Effective Use of Pathos and Connotative Language The Hawaiian culture is known throughout the western world for their extravagant luaus, beautiful islands, and a language that comes nowhere near being pronounceable to anyone but a Hawaiian. Whenever someone wants to “get away” their first thought is to sit on the beach in Hawai’i with a Mai tai in their hand and watch the sun go down. Haunani-Kay Trask is a native Hawaiian educated on the

The Popularity of the Japanese Language

933 words - 4 pages The Popularity of the Japanese Language Nowadays, it is not surprising to hear people from other countries say Japanese words such as Konnichiwa, Sushi, and Samurai. According to the New York based Institute of International Education, the number of people who study Japanese outside Japan is said to be 3 million, increased by 3 times compared to 1990 (Newcomb 4). Although Japan is an island country which had not had much connection with

Communicate in the Language of the People

912 words - 4 pages and succession of feelings, thoughts, or ideas towards a commonly accepted direction or goal. There are three major parts in human communication which are; body language, tone of voice, and vocabulary. According to The Journal of Counseling Psychology (Vol.31, pp.248-52) 55% of impact is determined by body language, postures, gestures, and eye contact, 38% by the tone of voice, and 7% by the content or the words used in the communication

Related Papers

Language And Thought Essay

856 words - 4 pages Pontificia Universidad javeriana Lenguaje y Psicología Natalia Mora ________________________________________________________ TRABAJO # 2 Definir conceptos: Conducta Verbal: La conducta verbal es el comportamiento cuyo reforzamiento esta mediado por la intervención de otra (s) personas Comportamiento Ecoico: La conducta verbal cae bajo el control de la estimulación verbal, la respuesta genera un patrón de sonido semejante al del

"Describe The Similarities And Differences Between The Second Blueprint Of Management And The Fourth Blueprint Of Management Thought."

501 words - 3 pages management.The SimilaritiesThese two blue prints both developed the importance of the role of human in organization on the basis of F. W. Taylor' scientific management thought. Their focus shifted from the formal organization to the informal work group and emphasized the research of relationship between workers, workers and leaders. They pointed out that social environmental conditions had become the most important factor to workers, not only working

The Politics Of Language Essay

1331 words - 6 pages A single language can be bring about unity and message can be get through to the intended target without much hassle, thus bilingualism and multilingualism should be discouraged.Spoken language is a major factor in personal identity. Just as people identify with their own cultures and customs, they identify with their native language dialect. Language is defined by the Collins 'Compact English Dictionary" as a system of spoken sounds or

The Power Of Language Essay

1983 words - 8 pages the words their own. Soon , they begin to creatively construct new words and expressions. This builds on itself, snowballing into a full blown language in just a few years. Other linguists take a different approach to the relation between language and thought. Rather than seeking universal liguistic structures and processes, they believe that different languages produce different ways of thinking. This position is sometimes known as the