The Punishment Of Malvolio Essay

1271 words - 6 pages

In Shakespeare’s play, Twelfth Night, the characters endure the fruits of their foolishness at the end of the play, but Malvolio endures a greater suffering and greater embarrassment than the rest of the characters. This is not simply by chance or whimsy: but this is Shakespeare’s stratification of the vices that a person may take upon him or herself. With this stratification, Shakespeare allocates Malvolio’s vices of pride, usurping the social order, and dour temperament as the worst of character flaws, and that is why Malvolio receives the harshest punishment.
Before examining the punishment that Malvolio endures, it is necessary to examine his flaws and offenses. His arrival in the ...view middle of the document...

Malvolio is treading the ground of criminal offense against a lord, who is also the cousin of his Lady. Beyond the offense upon the higher strata of society, Malvolio is also demonstrating his dour temperament in this scene which is also problematic. The importance of mirth and joviality is affirmed throughout the play, and for some characters, their greatest virtue is the ability to enjoy and be passionate for life. Malvolio stands in opposition to this with his protests and derision, and in the play he is the only character that takes offense to other characters enjoying their lives. The hostile environment he creates is important to note because it gives the other characters an impetus to deal with his troublesome personality in order to enjoy their own pleasures and pursuits. The last encounter where Malvolio extends his grievances is the second encounter with Sir Toby. Their encounter takes place after Malvolio’s pride is incensed by the false note of Olivia, so his actions go even further in displaying his own ego and lack of regard for his superiors. Not only does he instruct Sir Toby and Maria to, “go hang yourselves,” (III.iv.120) but he also claims that he is no longer of their, “element” (III.iv.121). The implication is that he has ascended beyond Sir Toby and Maria, but that is merely the delusion of his ego. In this scene he completes the trio of offenses with a straightforward denial of class, and his punishment comes from these crimes against the class structure, his overbearing ego and objection of mirth.
The punishment and trickery of Malvolio is the ironic justice of his flawed personality because it accentuates his deficiencies and then punishes those deficiencies. When the trick is played, Malvolio receives the first punishment for his offenses. The irony exists in the notion that his ambitions, which he plans to fulfill, bring about his social undoing. If the ruse was simply to deceive or humiliate him directly, it would not have succeeded. Maria and Sir Toby simply provide for Malvolio the proverbial rope, and he obliges by hanging himself. Rather than realizing his own danger, the need for caution, and reasserting his proper place in the social order, Malvolio increases his crime and thus increases the severity of his penalty. Eventually he is placed in the dark room, and his punishment reaches its fruition. He laments, “there was never a man thus abused,” (IV.ii.47-48) but the deprivation of senses, and especially that of sight, is a common punishment in this pre-Enlightenment period. This mode of punishment is to rectify the overbearing pride of Malvolio, and the deprivation of sight is meant to compare the criminal with the...

Other Essays Like The Punishment Of Malvolio

Should the Abolishment of Capital Punishment in the United States Should Be Applied

1255 words - 6 pages Introduction Nowadays, the death penalty debate is a heated issue in many countries, especially in the United States. The death penalty or the capital punishment is a sentence imposed by the law, which remove the legal life of the person who commit or is suspected of having committed a serious crime. The history of death penalty in the U.S is long and ruthless and the first recorded execution was in 1608. There are many kinds of death

"The Punishment" By Rabindranath Tagore: How Destiny Took A Twist And Changed The Life Of A Woman

619 words - 3 pages The story 'Punishment' written by Rabindranath Tagore is a poignant story about two brothers and their wives, and the relationship each of them shared with one another. It is a heart rendering tale about conflicting emotions.The story starts when the two brothers Dukhiram and Chidam return home in the village after a long, hard day at work. They find their respective wives sitting in the verandah with the elder wife's little son, eerily quiet

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner Is Simply a Tale of Crime and Punishment. How Do You Respond to This View?

919 words - 4 pages Although Coleridge’s protagonist in ‘The Rime of the Ancient Mariner’ commits a ‘crime’ of sorts and faces a series of ‘punishments,’ it is debateable whether it can simply be considered a ‘tale of crime and punishment’. As a phrase, ‘crime and punishment’ refers to a specific crime fitting a specific punishment, usually adjudicated by a governing body but could extend to the judgement of God if the historical context of the text is to be

The Use of Deception in Twelfth Night

697 words - 3 pages Belch trick Malvolio into making a fool of him. A third example of deception is when Feste the jester disguises himself as Sir Topas and taunts Malvolio. Each of these scenes and characters helps depict the different uses of deception. The first example of deception is Viola's decision to dress as a man. She must do this in order to survive. Viola is a young woman who escaped a shipwreck along with her twin brother, Sebastian. Unfortunately

Twelfth Night

2061 words - 9 pages unhappily that “My state is desperate for my master’s love” (II.ii.35). This desperation has the potential to result in violence—as in Act V, scene i, when Orsino threatens to kill Cesario because he thinks that -Cesario has forsaken him to become Olivia’s lover. Love is also exclusionary(ayrımcı): some people achieve romantic happiness, while others do not. At the end of the play, as the happy lovers rejoice, both Malvolio and Antonio are

"Twelfth Night" By William Shakespeare

945 words - 4 pages complete: Viola loves Orsino, Orsino loves Olivia, and Olivia loves Cesario--and everyone is miserable.Meanwhile, we meet the other members of Olivia's household: her rowdy drunkard of an uncle, Sir Toby; his foolish friend, Sir Andrew Aguecheek, who is trying in his hopeless way to court Olivia; Olivia's witty and pretty waiting-gentlewoman, Maria; Feste, the clever clown of the house; and Malvolio, the dour, prudish steward of Olivia's household

Twelfth Night Lenses

562 words - 3 pages the town” (III, III, 19). Lens 3: The lens of Class studies is shown throughout the story by depicting the difference between the upper and lower classes. One way this is shown is through Malvolio’s feelings toward Olivia. These feelings are brought up in the story when he receives a letter from “Olivia”. In the letter it explains how if they were to have a relationship Malvolio’s lower class status would be raised. The letter tells Malvolio

A Theatre Review of ‘Twelfth Night’ by Propeller

1729 words - 7 pages looked stupid in front of Lady Olivia who he loved and then Malvolio is completely humiliated and on his last line is he will get revenge. The director of the ‘Twelfth Night’ Edward Hall wanted to try and make the audience focus on the sub plot as it is more interesting. In the play he displayed a range of emotions. He used darkness for example in the prison scene he used a very dark light on Malvolio to show that he has been humiliated. Edward

The Comedy of the Merchant of Venice an in-Depth Analysis on Shakespeare's Shylock

2906 words - 12 pages upset in character who received due punishment based on his flawed morals and negative actions upon others. The context of The Merchant of Venice provides the basis for the setting of the play to be a factor in determining the play as comedy rather than tragedy. To many, Shylock in The Merchant of Venice can be sympathized with and defended. However, modern readers must be careful to distance themselves from the automatic sympathy that comes

Shakespeare's Three Comedies

1770 words - 8 pages aristocrats want to marry her for the social position. With all these men competing for her hand, it is not a wonder that she did not want to have anything to do with any of them. It must feel terrible to have all these men come after you while you know that they are not there for you, but for your money. Malvolio was an ambitious steward in Olivia's household. His high ambitions made him vulnerable and easy to manipulate. He must

Physical Punishment Should Be Allowed in School

2375 words - 10 pages a teacher 3-times because the teacher make him angry. (emotional appeal&words)If the teachers’s authority is invaded cruelly, who protects the teachers’s authority? Jamie : (Cogent argument) In these days, one of the most commonly practiced strategies used by teachers to alter long term behavior of their students is physical punishment. Physical punishment has been used in schools as a way of handling disciplinary problems. It refers to

Related Papers

Life Of Malvolio In The Twelfth Night Play Original Writing

1343 words - 6 pages Life of Malvolio in the Twelfth Night Play- Original Writing Twelfth night is a comedy which means that the audience’s expectations are for a light hearted, humorous funny play. Usually in a comedy there is bawdy, lewd language and romantic liaisons. In the play there are also a lot of ridiculous and improbable coincidences which the audience only believe because of willing suspension of disbelief. The title Twelfth

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment

1275 words - 6 pages The topic of capital punishment is one that is highly debated in our society today. Capital punishment is the ultimate punishment our society can give one for their actions. On the other hand, it is viewed as a denial of human rights that promotes more violence in our society. Religious Tolerance.org states that in the United States, over 13,000 people have been legally executed since colonial times. ("Religious Tolerance") Is capital

Capital Punishment Essays Benefits Of The Death Penalty

634 words - 3 pages Capital Punishment Essays - Benefits of the Death Penalty   In the eighteenth century,England would punish by death for pickpocketing and petty theft. Ever since the 1650's colonist could be put to death for denying the true god or cursing their parents advocates. Capital Punishment have clashed almost continuously in the forum of public opinion in state legislatures and most recently in courts. In 1972,the case of furman

An Analysis Of The Article Billy Budd And Capital Punishment: A Tale Of Three Centuries

1645 words - 7 pages H. Bruce Franklin of “Billy Budd and Capital Punishment: A Tale of Three Centuries” investigates the underlying controversial feud that represents the issue of the story, and details the debates surrounding the “profound influence on American culture” (1-18). Capital Punishment is a controversial debate that has been justified and condemned for over a century. When interpreting Billy Budd, there are two general ways to judge the novel, either