This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Question Of Pure Optimism In Their Eyes Were Watching God

1225 words - 5 pages

The Question of Pure Optimism in Their Eyes Were Watching God

In Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie goes through several relationships before "[s]he pulled in her horizon like a great fish net. Pulled it from around the waist of the world and draped it over her shoulder" (p. 184). In other words, not all the experiences that helped her to gain control of her life were positive ones. These experiences can be put into one of four relationships: Nanny, Logan Killicks, Jody Starks, and Tea Cake.
No doubt that Nanny loved Janie a great deal, and naturally she wanted her granddaughter to have security beyond an old woman who would inevitably die. She also wanted more opportunities ...view middle of the document...

At one point he even criticizes her for being "powerful independent" (p. 29) for someone who had been born the way she had (as if she had a choice in the matter!).
If Logan did genuinely care about Janie, then it could not have been a much more complex feeling than his wanting his tools or his mule around. But human beings are a great deal more complicated than that and (hopefully) are not satisfied with being considered a thing rather than a person. Logan goes to town to get a new mule and is expecting that Janie will automatically work with him, something she happens not to agree with. Logan's problem is that he has a set of expectations about Janie and she fails to live up to them. Had Logan been wiser, he would not have built himslef up so much and instead appreciated who Janie was and not who she wasn't. This is the last straw in a strained relationship.
Jody Starks has ambition, which is probably not the thing that least attracts Janie to him. In any case, she leaves Logan Killicks to start a new relationship with Jody.
Jody is the first person to hit Janie, and in general he treats her as if she were his property. She is made to tie up her hair, for instance, so that no one else in town can see her with it down. He tries to maintain her as a thing that no one else may look upon or take pleasure from, therefore he keeps control over her life. Ambition may have attracted Janie to Jodie, but the thing he loves is power, and even at his most sensitive to her he is still a shrewd man who's real intentions have to be second guessed at.
One perplexing thing about Janie's relationship with Jody is why she doesn't leave. She certainly shows that she has the initiative when she leaves Logan Killicks, and by the time Jody has hit her for accidentally ruining their dinner it seems obvious that this is not a healthy relationship. So why does Janie stay? Probably because there is no one to latch on to immediately, like there was when she was with Logan Killicks. This greatly qualifies the reader's optimism since it is showing that Janie is really not so independent- even with the verbal assaults she launches back at Jody, she still stays with him until he dies.
Tea Cake is the only man to ever court Janie...

Other Essays Like The Question Of Pure Optimism In Their Eyes Were Watching God

Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

1270 words - 6 pages Leo Rosten once said, "Money can't buy happiness." Janie from Zora Neale Hurston's, Their Eyes Were Watching God, would agree with this famous quote. Janie's first husband is financially stable and her second husband is powerful; but it is with her third marriage where she finally experiences happiness and receives respect. Through the first two marriages, we see how worldly desires and pride can ruin a relationship. Ultimately, Hurston portrays

Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

1356 words - 6 pages Janie finds her way out when Joe Starks appears. The first thing Joe does after asking for a drink of water is to name himself: "Joe Starks was the name, yeah Joe Starks from in and through Georgy" (47). Hurston's naming of Starks is ironic for several reasons. The word stark is often used as a synonym for barren, and Joe Starks and Janie never have any children. Hurston hints at sexual problems that develop between the pair because of their

Essay on Their Eyes Were Watching God

606 words - 3 pages Body and Power in Their Eyes Were Watching God Zora Neale Hurson’s masterpiece Their Eyes Were Watching God is the first literary work that fully demonstrates a black woman’s process of “Awakening” and serves as a milestone of female imagery creation in black literature. This novel sucessfully depicts a new woman image that tries to break from white-dominated and male-dominated society and pursue her own identity and freedom. This essay

Taking A Chance In Hurston’S Novels, Their Eyes Were Watching God And Seraph On The Suwanee

570 words - 3 pages Taking a Chance in Hurston’s Novels, Their Eyes Were Watching God and Seraph on the Suwanee “‘All right then, you name somethin’ and we’ll do it. We kin give it uh poor man’s trial anyhow.’” “‘Anyhow Ah done got rested up and de bed bugs is done got too bold round heah. Ah didn’t notice when mah rest wuz broke. Ah’m goin’ out and look around and see whut we kin do. Ah’ll give anything uh common trial.’” pp. 168-69; Their Eyes Were Watching

The Role Of Trees In Hurston’S Seraph On The Suwanee And Their Eyes Were Watching

665 words - 3 pages The Role of Trees in Hurston’s Seraph on the Suwanee and Their Eyes Were Watching God Trees play integral roles in Seraph on the Suwanee and Their Eyes Were Watching God as sites of sexual awakening for Hurston’s heroines, providing a space under which dreams bloom into “glistening leaf-buds” or over-ripen and die like spoiled fruit. Close readings of Janie’s pear tree and Arvay’s mulberry evoke strikingly disparate images of female

Their Eyes Were Wathiching God

564 words - 3 pages Their Eyes Were Watching God            Their Eyes Were Watching God is a story about the life of Janie Crawford and the hardships and triumphs in her three marriages, though there were many more hardships. In this essay I will share with you the setting, some characters, incidents from the plot, the theme, and point of view.      This story begins in the 1930's when

Summer Reading Response To "Their Eyes Were Watching God" By Hurston, Zora Neale

893 words - 4 pages Their Eyes Were Watching God1.Hurston, Zora Neale. Their Eyes Were Watching God. New York, New York: J.B. Lippincott Inc., Ã" 1990.2A.The main theme of Their Eyes Were Watching God is segregation of colors. There were a variety of situations in which the Caucasians were separated from the African Americans. For instance, in the start of the story, Janie begins to tell her life to Pheoby with her childhood. When she was a little girl, she

Voltaire Exposes The Fallacy Of Optimism In Candide

1202 words - 5 pages Voltaire was the French author of the novella Candide, also known as "Optimism" (Durant and Durant 724). Famous as a playwright and essayist, Voltaire’s Candide is the book where he tries to point out the fallacy of Gottfried William von Leibniz's theory of Optimism. He uses satire, and techniques of exaggeration to contrast highlight the evil and brutality of war and the world in general when men are meekly accepting of their fate. Leibniz, a

The Mother of the Child in Question

1053 words - 5 pages The Mother of the Child in Question The Mother of the Child in Question, written by Doris Lessing, is a short story from 1988. The story is about a social worker, named Stephen Bentley, and his attempt to persuade a Pakistani family to send their youngest daughter to a special school because she is mentally retarded. The family in question is the Khans, an immigrant family consisting of Mr. & Mrs. Khan, their son Hassan, their daughter

Three Defining Moments In Canadian History In The 20th Century, And Prove Their Significance To The Maturation Of Canada As A Nation (I Created This Question)

1627 words - 7 pages time to constitute a new plan, the Germans decided to stick with the old one and use new warfare. By 1915, the second battle of Ypres was already under way, when the Germans decided to attack the potential weak spot in between the Canadian and French trenches. With the use of chlorine (or mustard) gas, the Germans were able to force the French army into retreating. The Canadians, however, used their combined thinking power to improvise a simple

To What Extent Were The Nazi Party Successful In Persuading Young People To Support Their Ideas?

1556 words - 7 pages Hitler and his party believed in their superiority among other religions or culture. They thought that the eradication of some types of men would be beneficial to the country‘s integrity. They expressed their ideas through negative images and stereotypes. Nazi propaganda was against Jews and other impure cultures and religion. Jews were compared to beasts and were said deceitful and dangerous people of whom Germany should be free. To be

Related Papers

Love In "Their Eyes Were Watching God"

800 words - 4 pages Love plays a very important role in Zora Neale Hurston's “Their Eyes were watching God.” This is a statement that Bertrand Russell agrees with in her quote, “To fear love is to fear life, and those who fear life are already three parts dead.” Love is the essence of life and everybody has the obligation to find their one true love or they haven’t lived their life. In the novel, Janie spent her days looking for love. She thought of

Perceptions Of Marriage In Their Eyes Were Watching God

997 words - 4 pages Perceptions of Marriage in Their Eyes Were Watching God           For generations marriage has been accepted as a bond between two people.  However, the ideals involved in marriage differ by the individuals involved.  The book, Their Eyes Were Watching God, by Zora Neale Hurston clearly demonstrates these differences.  In the book a girl by the name Janie is raised by her

Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

312 words - 2 pages Nick Wong3rd period12/11/13The book is always betterThe book Their Eyes Were Watching God had many more details and had a more "classic" than the movie version. I thought the book was better because it felt linger and there was more action and suspense. For instance, the movie skips all three of Janie's marriages. The movie also skipped the scene where Joe bought the mule. The movie changed a lot of parts and cut out a lot of things.The book had

Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

5977 words - 24 pages on its back, she reaches for the cows tail to stay safe. The dog then attacks and Tea Cake jumps in to kill the dog by stabbing it after he was bit. They both make it to Palm Beach safely. Imagery- “They seemed to be staring at the dark, but their eyes were watching God (160).” -They were praying to God to give them a chance to live in the darkness of the night. Figurative Language- Personification: “It woke up old Okechobee and the monster