The Questionable Permissability Of Abortion Essay

1264 words - 6 pages

It is not easy to completely approve or disapprove of abortion. Judith Jarvis Thomson and I both believe abortion is morally permissible in some cases, where it is immoral in others. This is the argument that Thomson makes in “A Defense of Abortion.” She makes many comparisons to prove her points in different situations. Though she does not believe that a fetus is a human being from the moment of conception [“A newly fertilized ovum, a newly implanted clump of cells, is no more a person than an acorn is an oak tree” (48)], she allows this premise for the sake of argument. Thomson believes that abortion is morally permissible if a woman decides to have one in the early stages of ...view middle of the document...

If she gives the checkbook back to you, she would most likely die of hunger. Because your money would save her life and she has the right to live, does she have the right to your money? You did not decide to give her your checkbook, so she does not have the right to use it. A woman that was raped never decided to have a child, so it is morally permissible for her to have an abortion.
If a woman voluntarily has sex without any form of birth control knowing that she could get pregnant, Thomson believes it is morally impermissible for her to have an abortion: “[D]oing so would be depriving [the child] of what it does have a right to, and thus would be doing it an injustice” (58). The woman knew the possible consequences of her actions, so it is her responsibility to deal with them. For instance, if you promise your friend that they can borrow your CD, you have given them the right to borrow your CD. You will have to lend that CD to your friend as a result. If you made that promise and were planning on it falling through, you would be doing your friend an injustice. The woman could have used birth control, and you could have told your friend that he could not borrow the CD if you did not want to deal with the consequences.
However, when a woman voluntarily has sex while she is using birth control, Thomson believes it is morally permissible to have an abortion. She compares the situation to barring up your windows and having a burglar come in your house anyway (59). This is obviously not your fault; you did everything you could to prevent burglary. Say that a woman believes she is taking birth control, but her birth control has actually been replaced with a placebo. Both of these situations show that the woman did what she could to prevent pregnancy. The woman attempted to prevent pregnancy, but she got pregnant anyway. She did nothing to cause the pregnancy, so it is morally permissible for her to have an abortion.
In Thomson’s conclusion, though, she reminds her readers that she does not actually believe that the fetus is a human from the moment of conception. According to her, an abortion is permissible under any circumstances if it takes place early in the pregnancy: “A very early abortion is surely not the killing of a person, and so is not dealt with by anything I have said here” (66). Maybe that “clump of cells” is not a human being, but that does not change the fact that it will become one. A woman that has an...

Other Essays Like The Questionable Permissability of Abortion

The Black and White of Abortion

1187 words - 5 pages The Black and White of Abortion Abortion is arguably the most controversial issue that exists today. Abortion is a religious matter, questioning the humanity of a fetus and if one has the right to kill it. This issue also causes disagreement between men and women, and whether women have the right to bodily autonomy. Furthermore, abortion questions which right is stronger, the right to bodily autonomy or the right to life. Mary Anne Warren

The Truth To The Controversy Of Abortion: Pro-Life

1954 words - 8 pages Includes a work cited page and parenthetical documentationOver 4,000 children are killed by abortion in the U.S. every day. Every 20 seconds 1 fetus is aborted. Think about this, every 1 in 4 in our generation is not living, because they were killed before they were born. There has been great controversy concerning the subject of abortion. The banning of abortion, to some, is considered unconstitutional. However, some feel it is morally wrong to

An Overview Of The Socialist Party And Bob Dole Abortion

833 words - 4 pages opression. They strongly dislike the opression or discromintaion of people of color, lesbian, gays, gender, race, class, wages, or origin of birth. To sum up their form of government they say to change the government to the better, in their eyes at least, we, the people, need a total restructuring of the government.II. Dole..Bob Dole ,the republican president canadite, has created a muddle veiw of his stand on abortion. The republican platform

The Christian Beliefs Of Life, Including The Arguments Of Abortion And Euthanasia

688 words - 3 pages One belief shared by all Christians about the beginning of life is that abortion is an evil and that it is always immoral at any stage of the foetus' life, even if it is within the legal 'time limit'. This means Christians believe that from the moment of conception, the foetus is a human being with rights, so it would be a sin to abort it as one of the Ten Commandments is, 'Do not murder'. Christians also use this commandment, to support their

Abortion In Context: What Was The Fate Of An Unwanted Or Orphaned Child In The Nineteenth Century?

2717 words - 11 pages Abortion in context: What was the fate of an unwanted or orphaned child in the nineteenth century? For as much as has been written about the crime of abortion and infanticide, equally much as been said against forced maternity, marital rape, and woman’s lack of control over her own body, all circumstances resulting in unwanted pregnancy and unwanted children. Such circumstances all stemmed from unique family, social, or health issues, with

The Abortion Pill Should It Be Used?

371 words - 2 pages will disagree with the pill, because they protest abortion. They would also be a little more discouraged with the government for making it easier and accessible. Prochoice people would be happier with the legalization of the pill because it is safer. Therefore, the relationship between the government and the people will not change a great deal. The effect on the economic issue, if the abortion pill is used is a positive effect. First, it

Abortion

687 words - 3 pages Abortion A lot of Americans today support the right to have an abortion. Current society is a pro-choice generation, meaning women have the right to control their own bodies. A right to control their own reproductive capability and a right to chose when and whether to have children or not. World wide, more than a quarter of women who become pregnant have either an abortion or an unwanted baby. The reasons most women have an abortion is to

Understanding Abortion

534 words - 3 pages Angelai Homampha English 119 September 29, 2011 Understanding Abortion Did you know that more than half of the six million pregnancies occurring each year in the United States are unplanned? An abortion is a procedure where a woman choses to end her pregnancy. If we try to understand the reason women get abortions it can help personalize the debate over abortion, correct public misconceptions, and allow the chance for compassion

Cause And Effect

604 words - 3 pages Although public morals has become more flexible and indulgent in the 21st century compared to previous epochs, there are still questions and moral problems which are difficult to evaluate and treat without bias. Abortion is one of such issues; although many progressive people have nowadays become more tolerant to abortion, there are still many arguments–apart from public opinion–that speak against this procedure. In particular, abortion causes

Challenges to the Constitution

608 words - 3 pages Abortion represents yet another challenge to the US constitution. Abortion is not supported by the due process clause of the 14th amendment. According to the Roe V. Wade in 1973 decision, Supreme Court that declared a pregnant woman is entitled to have an abortion until the end of the first trimester of pregnancy without any interference by the state. Abortion clinics allow thousands of women every year to have abortions. Having the abortion

Abortion - the Need to Know About Abortions

1554 words - 7 pages The Need to Know About Abortions Abstract An abortion is to terminate a pregnancy before the fetus has developed enough to live outside the uteru.MeyersTamara (2009). Florida Abortion Laws state: The statutory definition of illegal abortionist the termination of a pregnancy during the last trimester which does not meet requirements of legal abortions. Partial Birth Abortion: Prohibited except when necessary to save the life of a mother

Related Papers

The Effects Of Abortion Essay

940 words - 4 pages abortion, psychological and physical. Ultimately, the results may actually be worse than the problems, which were to be solved to begin with. These after-effects should be focused on and dealt with in a better manner. Many may feel abortion causing psychological problems is a myth, but the research supporting it is there. From the time of just after the abortion to years later, there is severe psychological trauma can and does occur. Women

The Effects Of Abortion Essay

982 words - 4 pages The Effects of Abortion Most women can have many reasons of having an abortion but they realized what damaged they could have done to themselves and the people around them? What about the baby that hasn't start living as human being? To indicate more information about this topic, women has high chances of not only getting effected through physically, but also mentally and spiritually, which brings a far deeper meaning in this topic. The effects

The Controversy Of Abortion Essay

1507 words - 7 pages attitude that “my way is right”. Unfortunately, that mindset is not always true. Furthermore, the subject I will be addressing is abortion. Should it be legal? Does anyone have the right to take a life? Is it actually a living person? The word Abortion by definition means the termination of the pregnancy and the development of the fetus before it is capable of independent life. It is also called “the knowing destruction of the life of an

The Choice Of Abortion Essay

773 words - 4 pages The choice of abortion A couple, who were both 20, were in college when they found out they were pregnant. Now this was a definite unplanned pregnancy and they had a tough choice to make. Do they keep the baby and sacrifice the woman’s education or do they have an abortion? They chose to keep the baby and 9 months later their baby girl was born. Now why is that decision so important? Because if they had chosen abortion I would not be here