The Reasons For Studying Medieval Past

2240 words - 9 pages

AT A HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION conference in September 2002, I heard of an interesting report: until recently there were only two countries in Europe, the UK and Albania, where history was not part of the national curriculum up to age eighteen. Now, it was said, there is only one--and it is not Albania. As a responsible historian, I have to tell you that the report turned out to be exaggerated, indeed strictly speaking untrue: whereas France, Germany and others do indeed require the teaching of history throughout the secondary education phase, a number of northern European countries do not (and have not for many years).There are many good and not-so-good reasons for insisting on the value of ...view middle of the document...

Knights and castles, and the Vikings, though sometimes done well on television (as recently in series fronted by Julian Richards and Marc Morris), are niche topics that reinforce the stereotype. 'Medieval' remains synonymous with 'barbaric'. Alternatively, for many Britons medieval times are not far removed from rune-reading, New Age magic and Tolkienesque fantasy. This makes for a serious problem in distinguishing fact from fiction. A recent poll suggests that one of the top 100 Britons ever was King Arthur. That the problem is not a recent one may be inferred from the repeated injunction of Sellar and Yeatman in 1066 and All That never to confuse King Arthur with King Alfred, or vice versa. A variant form of such fantasising was Secretary of State for Education Charles Clarke's recent thumbnail sketch of 'ornamental' medieval universities, ivory towers inhabited by beautiful thinkers remote from the perceived needs and priorities of the real world. The opposite was true, since graduates were, in the words of the great medievalist Richard Southern, 'necessary for the conduct of business; they provided a storehouse of technical advice and ensured a succession of future servants of government', not just for secular regimes but for that superstate, the Church.There could be more substantial public interest in the Middle Ages; but we have to ask why is it desirable to have more medieval history in schools? What would it be for? There are a number of answers. On some we might all agree. On others we might agree to differ. Here are three reasons--necessary conditions--that strike me both as agreeable in their own right, and also as things that we might all agree upon.The medieval history of these islands is very old (we share that antiquity with the rest of Europe) and very well-documented in terms of texts. And yet not too well-documented. When I read a recent proposal for a GCSE in medieval history, I was struck by how closely the recommended reading for the reign of Alfred of Wessex resembled the reading list I used to give final-year undergraduates for a Special Subject comparing Alfred's reign with that of his Frankish contemporary Charles the Bald of France. The main evidence (that is, evidence not strictly selected but actually most of all there is) can be got between the covers of a Penguin paperback. For Wales or Ireland in a similar period, the same is true. The student--like the professional historian--can engage with the raw evidence. The student can become not so very different from the professional historian. Consider Domesday Book: there few parts of England that are not covered, and the whole text is now available in English and in paperback. There is nothing remotely like this for any other country in Europe, west or east, until post-medieval times. Consider the evidence for the Peasants' Revolt of 1381: it is so rich, yet so relatively compact, that you can take one paperback source-collection and trace all the rebel moves on a...

Other Essays Like The Reasons For Studying Medieval Past

Reasons for the Outbreak of the First Crusade

1920 words - 8 pages Why was the first Crusade launched? The outbreak of the first crusade in 1095, played an important part in the future of medieval history, we can argue many different reasons and causes for the first crusade and it is impossible to finally put it down to just one reason. The outbreak of the first crusade followed a series of different triggers for example religion or economic gain but historians will always argue which factor was the most

The Reasons For Success Of The Bolsheviks In 1917

1220 words - 5 pages The Reasons for Success of the Bolsheviks in 1917 There are a number of different reasons, why the Bolsheviks seized power in 1917. The Tsar took personal command of the army in the summer of 1915 and left the government in the hands of his wife, the hated Tsarina (who also had the misfortune of being German). She was called "the German woman". The offensive of 1916 had cost the Russians a million casualties and

Q- what were the reasons for the establishment of the UAB?

472 words - 2 pages Reasons for the Establishment of the Unemployment Assistance BoardIn 1932 Long term mass unemployment peaked in Britain with a rate of 10.6% of the workforce (crafts: 1991,p.78). Those few not covered by the 1911 contributory National Insurance Act could claim benefit up to sixmonths until their payments had been exhausted. The poor law was the only benefit option left for those whohad consumed their entitlement or who had not previously

What Were the Reasons for the Greek Cities to Make an Alliance Against Athens

1246 words - 5 pages What were the reasons for the Greek cities to make an alliance against Athens? First of all, to answer this question of this work, it is needed to be displayed when and where did the events happen. In V century BC, the territory of today’s Greece was divided between several polices or city-states. The most powerful amongst them were Athens (which was seen as a democracy in the meaning that Ancient Greeks gave to this word), Sparta (a

To What Extent Was Economic Reasons the Main Reason for the Two Countries' Separation?

756 words - 4 pages To what extent was economic differences the main reason for separation? I disagree to a large extent that economic differences were the main reasons for separation between Singapore and Malaysia. Political differences between the 2 countries instead, were a more predominant factor as it led to social unrest in these countries. Economic differences, on the other hand, played a less subtle role in separating the 2 countries, even though it did

Explain the Extent of and Reasons for Family Diversity in Today’s Society

2014 words - 9 pages Natasha Helps Sociology essay: Explain the extent of and reasons for family diversity in today’s society Over the years society and family structure has changed in many different ways. In the 18-1900s society was in the modernity era where people believed that there was one family structure that had a clear cut predictable structure and anything other than that was seen as wrong, this family structure was called the ‘Nuclear Family’ which

“Examine the Reasons for Differences in Educational Achievement Between Different Ethnic Groups”

1368 words - 6 pages “Examine the reasons for differences in educational achievement between different ethnic groups” There are clearly many factors that contribute to the claim that there is a difference in educational achievement between different ethnic groups in the UK. National statistics claim that: ‘In 2004 Chinese pupils were the most likely to achieve five or more GCSE Grades A*- C in England, with 79% of Chinese girls and 70% of Chinese boys

Is Photography good for you? This essay gives reasons why it is good for you. The title Photography Bound!

385 words - 2 pages Are you ready to take up photography? Well there are many reasons throughout this essay that states why it is. Photography is a wonderful piece of art the lets us explore and enlarge pices of our world.Photography is an expression that allows one another to see the world as the photographer sees it. Photographer Eli Vega states, "I use my photography as a means to express my thoughts, feelings, mental images and interpretations of life

Reasons for the Collapse of the Weimar Republic

1433 words - 6 pages created by the Ebert-Groener Pact, by 1929, German stability wasn’t achieved ergo, leading to the demise of the Weimar Republic in 1933. The shock of defeat was so great for Germans, and many couldn’t accept it rendering Germans to look for a scapegoat to undertake the blame for the defeat. The notion of “dolchstosslegende” or being “stabbed in the back” was being introduced as it was believed that the home-front wasn’t cooperating during the

For What Reasons Did Countries of the ‘5t Enlargement’ Want to Join the European Union?

820 words - 4 pages At the present time, the European Union represents a real power throughout the world politically or economically. Integrate the European Union would make it possible these countries to belong to a major actor in the world, and to share all its values of freedom, democracy and prosperity. But beyond the Community aspect, it is especially financially that the European Union attrated candidates, for example by putting 33milliards of Euros of budget

"Unveiling The Unknown" This Essay Is A Persuasive Essay For English Class Concerning Space Exploration And Reasons In Which To Do So

858 words - 4 pages Some of Life's greatest questions have always been "Who are we?" "Why are we here?" and "Where are we going?" In a lifetime, most of us will probably never discover the answers to these questions. Many people use God as an outlet for answers to the questions they cannot explain themselves. Whether you believe in God or not, you are never going to truly know if he exists until death. That's why re-focusing our efforts on space exploration is the

Related Papers

Tracing The Reasons For Semantic Change

2564 words - 11 pages completely shifted as a result of semantic change. Conclusion The job of linguists is to establish a diachronic study of language change. They have been tracing the origin, structure, historical development of all living languages of the world as well as studying the types and reasons of language change very precisely. At present, discussion about semantic change has received much

Reasons For The Annexation Of Texas

2768 words - 12 pages The Annexation of Texas was one of the most debatable events in American history. The question at hand would, in either which way chosen, deeply impact the United States for generations to come. There was on one side a long list of reasons for why to not allow annexation, but there was the same kind of list on the other side for reasons to push forward for annexation. Some of these reasons of both sides were slaves, war

Reasons For The Partition Of India

988 words - 4 pages ------------------------------------------------- Reasons for Partition By the end of the 19th century, several nationalist movements had emerged in India. Indian nationalism had expanded as the result of British policies of education and the advances made by the British in India in the fields of transportation and communication. However, British insensitivity to and distance from the people of India and their customs created such

Reasons For Gun Violence. Says The 4 Main Reasons For Youth Gun Violence

1138 words - 5 pages Reasons for Youth Gun ViolenceIn 1988, handguns killed 7 people in Great Britain, 13 in Australia, 8 in Canada, and 8,915 in the United States. Between 1973 and 1992, the number of privately-owned firearms in the US increased 73%; from 122 million to nearly 222 million. (Brennen and Polsby 1). These figures are shocking and there doesn't seem to be a solution. Gun control is a problem that our country has got to face. The reasons for gun