The Scrutiny Of Virtue Essay

1110 words - 5 pages

The Scrutiny of Virtue

Virtue is a mean condition which falls between the extremes of excess and deficiency which are both subject to vices. Either of those two vices, or the practices of base behaviors, happen to rely on the virtue that one aims for. For instance, courage is a virtue of which cowardice and rashness are the deficiency and excess of respectively. Evidence of this is seen in Book II, Chapter 9 of Nichomachean Ethics where Aristotle mentions “…virtue of character is a mean condition, and in what way, namely because it is a mean between two kinds of vice, the one resulting from excess and the other from deficiency…” It is important to understand that virtue is not acquired ...view middle of the document...

And those who wish for good things for their friends for their own sake are friends most of all, since they are that way for themselves and not incidentally….” This quote presents the relationship that exists between friendship (particularly how a friend is another “self”) and virtue. And it is through real friendship that someone can be fixed on virtue which leads to happiness.
In addition to these things, one cannot fully comprehend what virtue entails unless one practices a virtue. With that in mind, I chose to ethically experiment on the virtue of generosity. Aristotle describes generosity as the mean condition concerning the acquiring and giving of money. In Book IV, Chapter 1 of Nichomachean Ethics, Aristotle conveys to the reader what the excess and deficiencies of generosity are by writing, “And wastefulness and stinginess are excesses and deficiencies in connection with money; we apply stinginess always to those who take money more seriously than one ought, but we carry wastefulness over sometimes, intertwining it with other things, since we call unrestrained people and those who spend money on dissipation wasteful.” In connection to Aristotle’s definition of what generosity is and is not, considering the excess and deficiencies of the virtue mentioned above, I would fall under the deficiency of stinginess. I personally have always taken money matters very seriously and have not taken others into much consideration when I spend my money. I could sit and write down several excuses as to why I decided to be stingy in each and every situation I can recall and justify it, but that would defeat the purpose of participating in the experiment in the first place.
Understanding that to reach a mean condition you must over shoot the mean (and by this I mean practicing wastefulness since I am stingy to reach the mean of generosity), I decided to practice wastefulness, and I decided the best place to start working on becoming a more generous person is at home, with family I’ve spent most of my life with. I began by putting in more of my financial resources by buying...

Other Essays Like The Scrutiny of Virtue

Moral Virtues Essay

3045 words - 13 pages Chapter 11 The Moral Virtues Once the various faculties of the soul are rectified in regard to the supernatural order through the theological virtues, it is necessary to rectify them in regard to the means for attaining that end. This is the role of the moral virtues. As we have already mentioned, it is impossible to enumerate all the moral virtues, since there can be a virtue wherever there can be a morally good habit regarding a given

Shakespeare's Measure for Measure Essay

4243 words - 17 pages Shakespeare's Measure for Measure This reading of Measure for Measure will try to do more than draw attention to the extent to which Shakespeare goes beyond the conventional happy ending in this play. There are indications that the conclusions of many of the comedies are not really meant to bear up to close scrutiny; in Jaques¹ words, their loving voyages are not victual¹d for very long. In Measure for Measure we are openly challenged to

Ethics Essay

565 words - 3 pages , values and moral concepts. Similarities and Differences in Ethics Theories To understand the similarities between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics the first order is to define the meaning of each. According to Boylan (2009), virtue theory has a definition of cultivating excellence in life and constituting an aspect of the “good person” (Boylan, 2009). Utilitarianism according to Boylan (2009), “is a theory that suggests

Family Winemakers vs California

668 words - 3 pages that motorcyclists and other motorists are similarly situated individuals who are being treated differently under the law. 2) What are the three levels of scrutiny that the courts use in determining whether or not a law violates the equal protection clause? The three levels of scrutiny that are used to determine violations of the equal protection clause are Strict scrutiny (used when fundamental rights are being violated), Intermediate scrutiny


1096 words - 5 pages Head agreement permits the grants to be made to the Developer’s nominee) Building and plots of land granted to the Developer by the Owners by virtue of the Head agreements titled FINANCE DEVELOPMENT ARGEEMENT between the OWNERS and the DEVELOPER. DEVELOPER’S GENERAL CONVENANT The Developer shall i. Prepare and present to the financier accurate estimates of amount expended so far on the project and bill of quantities prepared by a

Eth 316 Week 1

668 words - 3 pages virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. Also addressing how each theory deals with ethics and morality. In addition, I will reflect on my personal experience through which I will expound on the association between virtue, values, and moral concepts as they relate to one specific of the three theories. A description of the differences in how each theory addresses ethics and morality is as followed. Virtue theory is different to the

Accountability in Reporting Memo

633 words - 3 pages Memorandum To: CC: From: Stephanie Copenhaver Date: 7/6/2015 Re: Accountability in Reporting Memo To whom it may concern: This memorandum is going to explain how increasing scrutiny and demand for accountability by the public has influenced reporting for not-for-profit and government entities. First, it must be understood on where the money is coming in from to these types of entities. The not-for –profit sector receives money

Ethics Essay

657 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Constance Punch ETH/316 June 23, 2014 Greg Ouellette Ethics Essay Ethics is the science of right and wrong in human action.” (Manias, 2013, Chapter 1, Ethics Applied). With the reading, we can find the similarities and differences between the three major approaches in normative ethics; virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. This will be done by analyzing these ethical theories and by describing them along

Taxes and How It Affects the Growth of the Country

888 words - 4 pages incentives and seemingly arbitrary decision making, not open to judicial scrutiny erode the trust that a member of the community should have in its institutions. This lack of transparency and even-handedness lead to the frequent eruption of scandals which unseat governments more often than not. All these malignant side-effects and by- products might have been acceptable if taxes were to achieve their primary stated goals. That they fail to do so is

Ethics Essay Eth/316

555 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Shannon Williams ETH/316 November 25, 2013 Jeremy Gephart Your beliefs don’t make you a better person, your behavior does. This is a saying that I have been taught as a child. While reading this essay it will discuss the similarities and differences of virtue ethics, utilitarianism, and deontology, theory as it relates to ethics and morals. Also how a personal experience that explains the relationship between virtue

Ethics Paper

938 words - 4 pages People often ask questions like, “what should I do?” or “How should I act?” However, the fundamental questions that define ethics allow individuals to evaluate the moral principles behind the rationalization of their actions. Three forms of ethics come to mind and they are virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. Each has differences, which distinguish one from the other, a point this paper will advocate to readers. In

Related Papers

The Reputation Of Anyone Who Is Subjected To Media Scrutiny Will Eventually Be Diminished

566 words - 3 pages Claim: It is no longer possible for a society to regard any living man or woman as a hero. Reason: The reputation of anyone who is subjected to media scrutiny will eventually be diminished. The issue oversimplifies the relationship between mass media and the hero in our society, and consequently make a somewhat naïve claim. As far as I am concerned, there is no doubt that media is mirror of the society, which can reflect the world in its

Tessa Virtue Essay

1246 words - 5 pages TESSA VIRTUE Tessa Virtue was born on May 17, 1989 in London, Ontario and has studied ballet and other forms of dance since she was three, even moving away from home at age nine to study with the National Ballet of Canada for a summer. She still takes a variety of classes -- including ballet, modern and hip-hop -- to supplement her skating. She began skating because she didn't want to be the only person who couldn't skate when her class took a

Aristotle: The Life Well Lived Essay

1411 words - 6 pages practical reason. Any animal can exercise practical reason in determining what to do to survive, but can an animal reason theoretically? Aristotle says no and that is what separates human beings from animals. It is through reason, both practical and theoretical, that we develop virtue. According to Aristotle, virtue is the next step towards eudaimonia and it is developed through the exercise of reason. Just like with reason, Aristotle separates

Private Manning Essay

527 words - 3 pages catch up, the idea of declaring gays and lesbians mentally unfit by virtue of their sexual orientation alone seems laughable, mere fodder for the discredited organizations that still advocate and practice reparative therapy. Transgender people have yet to experience such a watershed moment. Because gender identity disorder is often considered a mental illness, many trans men and women must endure a great deal of scrutiny, subject to strict