The Things They Carried Essay

1488 words - 6 pages

The Things They Carried

The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien is a captivating recitation in which Tim O'Brien maintains that all the stories featured in the entire book are indeed true stories. Tim is the protagonist as well as the narrator of this particular story and it is the experiences that he had regarding war that have drove him to write the this story. The book gives a clear depiction of the war in Vietnam by showing the horrors of war but there have been varying views regarding the question of whether the book is an antiwar or not. As a result, the purpose of this paper is to address this particular issue by addressing different views in regard to whether the book is an ...view middle of the document...

On these there is no much emphasis given by the narrator but what is elaborated widely in the story is on the intangible items. The memories as well as the fears which are the prime focus of the entire narration and this are one of the features that raise some undertones in regard to the story being an anti-war.

Arguing that description of the weapons can promote war is not right and cannot be proved from the text. Some opponents use the description of the deadly weapons that the soldiers carry along with them such as machine guns, grenades and assault rifles as the basis to refute that this is not an antiwar story. However, despite the descriptions of the some of the occurrences that happens during war times, the reader should be careful on the way the narrator handles the description of the tangible items mentioned above. When describing these items, the narrator does not miss to mention how much they way depicting them as burdens and the pressure exerted on the soldiers by them. "The weapon weighed 7.5 pounds unloaded, 8.2 pounds with its full 20 round magazine…. 8.4 pounds at minimum, 14 pounds at maximum." (O'Brien 5). The narrator directs the attention of the reader away from what the soldiers are carrying but the effect these items have on the soldiers and the implication is that these are unnecessary burdens. The writer also focused on the effect the external forces such as nature had on the soldiers, “They carried the sky. The whole...they carried gravity.” (O'Brien 14). On the contrary, much of the emphasis is laid on the intangible items that the soldiers carries, the emotions according to the narrator are the items that exert the greatest pressure on the soldiers; they are the heaviest of all the items that they carry. As Tim O'Brien puts it, “Grief, love, terror, longing these were intangibles, but these items had specific gravity and their mass too, despite being intangible their weight was tangible.” (O'Brien 20). This refutes the view that the mention of the tangible items (weapons) would be a promotion of war in any way.

Another way to look at the narration of the story and the description of the things the soldiers carried as prove that it is an antiwar story is the fact that the physical burdens can be discarded while the emotional must be tolerated. This speaks directly against war and the use of the weapons (Kirszner 167). The physical burdens are the weapons that the soldiers carry along as they attend to their duties while the emotions addresses the effects that war has especially on the personal lives of these soldiers. The pains and suffering that they must undergo everyday and it is their call never to submit or show any kind of fear or retaliation, this is so painful and stressing to the soldiers and the effects of these is indeed tangible. As for the weapons they can always be discarded or put down when the after exhaustion or seize fire but the emotions lie inside their hearts. Addressing fear, the narrator...

Other Essays Like The Things They Carried

The Things They Carried essay

739 words - 3 pages In the book “The Things They Carried” written by Tim O’Brian, uses a plethora of strategies to give the reader a deeper incite into the day life of an American solider during the Vietnam War. O’Brian shares with us his extensive knowledge and first-hand experience throughout the novel. Now O’Brian does give us some information on characters such as Curt Lemon on their personality, experience, and etc. Now Curt Lemon is not that

Character Analysis Essay " the Things They Carried"

953 words - 4 pages “The Things They Carried” Jimmy Cross is a protagonist because the story is about him dealing with the loss of his friend Tim Lavender. Cross is a lieutenant of the Alpha Company fighting the war in Vietnam. He does not care about the war and he does not want to be a leader . Jimmy is insecure about everything he does and he wonders if he makes the right decisions. His way of escaping is to day dream about Martha. She is an English

The Things They Carried

694 words - 3 pages . Priests, at this time, “became their communities moral policemen, and they played a major role throughout society.” For most people, family is a sense of great joy. Jackie is a dynamic character, and is the protagonist of the story. We learn that he hates his grandmother and sister, and is afraid of his first confession. Jackie is out of sorts because his grandmother has moved from the country to live with his family. He is quite disgusted

Things Fall Apart Versus The Things They Caried

1826 words - 8 pages Within the novels Things Fall Apart, written by China Achebe, and The Things They Carried, written by Tim O'Brien, characters are faced with their destiny. Howard Thurman once said, "Fate is the raw materials of experience. They come uninvited and often unanticipated. Destiny is what a man does with these raw materials." Fate is an inevitable event that is predestined for a person. One character from each novel is faced to deal with that fate

Things Carried

842 words - 4 pages n his story "The Things They Carried," Tim O'Brien describes a group of soldiers marching through Vietnam. He does this by describing the items that each of them carries with him during the march. The things that the soldiers carry with them are both tangible and intangible items and what these things are depends upon the individual soldier. They carry the basic "necessities" for survival (if one can consider such things as M&M's a necessity

Love vs War

613 words - 3 pages Love VS. War In Tim O’ Brien short story “The Things They Carried”, Tim shares his memories with the reader about the war and the items some of the soldiers carried. Each solider had specific items that they were required to carry for the war, but they also carried things that were important and meaningful to them. The reader could tell that the items were important because no matter how much weight the soldiers already had to carry, they

The Concept And Antilogy Of Ne

735 words - 3 pages The Concept and Antilogy of Necessity in "The Things They Carried" The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien, a medley of short stories tied together by a common theme, examines the many facets of necessity and poses a question of just how valuable the things we hold to be necessities really are. During the confusion of war, the definition of necessity becomes rather slippery in the minds of the soldiers and in such desperate situations, a soldier

Comparison of Journeys

688 words - 3 pages Kylie Miller English 2025 Lisa Beans 24 January 2014 First Writing Response In the two short stories we read in class, “The Things They Carried” and “The School”, there were to very different, yet very similar journeys the characters had to face. In “The Things They Carried”, the journey was the war. The soldiers taking this journey were faced with many ups and downs during their time spent on it. They faced death and sorrow when someone

Reality vs. Fiction

646 words - 3 pages person and he is the author of The Things They Carried. O’ Brien did actually serve in the Vietnam War as a soldier. Unfortunately, it is impossible to know whether or not any given event in the stories truly happened to O’Brien. Through writing about his experiences in Vietnam, O’Brien’s character is able to sort through his emotions, since “by telling stories, you objectify your own experience. You separate it from yourself. You pin down the

"A Bird Came Down the Walk" by Emily Dickinson

453 words - 2 pages The poem "A Bird Came Down the Walk" reminds us of a nursery rhyme because of its rhyme scheme and rhythm. The poem starts with "A bird came down the walk. He did not know I saw. He bit the angleworm in halves and ate the fellow raw." The rhythm makes the poem very easy to read. The sentence or clause always ends in the end of the line with a punctuation sign and never get carried over to the next one, so that the poem is very easy to follow

Assimilation of the Indians Resistance was Futile

512 words - 3 pages broken up and individual family units established because this was more in line with the white man's religion. Lastly, the lack of knowledge of the way Americans did things and the country's history.These reforms were necessary but several were carried out in haste and without much thought. Results from the reformers efforts would have been more successful and better received by the Indians had they included representatives from every tribe. The

Related Papers

The Things They Carried Essay

1637 words - 7 pages The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien ENG 1300 W5A2 Andrea Carr South University Online The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien “The Things They Carried” is one of several short stories written by Tim O’Brien that brilliantly portrays a squad of young American soldiers in the Vietnam War. Each of the short stories builds on the last but in The Things They Carried the author places focus on how immature boys cope and their

The Things They Carried Essay

1485 words - 6 pages O’Brien would answer why it is said, “Once a Marine, Always a Marine.” It all has to do with “reality, perspective, and the bond Marines” share with one another; it is life-long. No different from the book The Things They Carried, authored by Tim O’Brien. O’Brien’s entire book was about different perceptions and realties; and from those come different types of truths. The Things They Carried, authored by Tim O’Brien.

The Things They Carried (Theme) Essay

574 words - 3 pages As stated in Tim O’Brien’s masterpiece The Things They Carried, “…a true war story is never about war (O’Brien 85).” One can correlate multiple themes uniquely to each death in the novel. However, the deeper meaning O’Brien is trying to convey is the importance of keeping people alive through storytelling. This is most extensively shown in Timmy’s experience of Linda’s death. Unlike nearly all of the other deaths in the novel, Linda’s death

The Things They Carried 13 Essay

528 words - 3 pages In order for Tim O’Brien to explain and understand the truth behind a true a war story in the novel The Things They Carried, was to make it false but also show the truth about the situation. One event that occurred explaining this situation, was when Rat Kiley’s friend Curt Lemon died when they were playing around with smoke grenades and then Curt Lemon steps on a land mine. Following his friend’s death Rat Kiley writes a letter to Curt’s sister