The Trees Song Analysis

1547 words - 7 pages

The Trees - RUSH

There is unrest in the forest,
There is trouble with the trees,
For the maples want more sunlight
And the oaks ignore their pleas.

The trouble with the maples,
(And they're quite convinced they're right)
They say the oaks are just too lofty
And they grab up all the light.
But the oaks can't help their feelings
If they like the way they're made.
And they wonder why the maples
Can't be happy in their shade.

There is trouble in the forest,
And the creatures all have fled,
As the maples scream "Oppression!"
And the oaks just shake their heads

So the maples formed a union
And demanded equal rights.
"The oaks are just too greedy;
We will make them give ...view middle of the document...

) The moment I finished listening to "The Trees", I started making connections to the possible political and/or social theories it and Selfihness might share. Searching to validate some of my ideas, I scrolled through pages of internet site comments ranging from "these lyrics are not symbolic whatsoever" to "an allegory for the blacks civil rights movement" to "(symbolic of) some form or other of communism." Now before I present my own ideas, I'd like to quickly debunk the first two above.

Just because the writing of these lyrics was prompted by a cartoon does not mean the lyrics are not symbolic. I'd imagine that it would be difficult nearing impossible for an intellectual like Peart to create any form of art that doesn't subconsciously make allusions or form symbols. In fact, these lyrics are written to include such an abundant number of possible connections that the whole song is literally inherently symbolic. There is a plethora of social and political theories that could be symbolized by the maple and oak relationship - I've even read a couple religious ones. Yet, I find a few issues hard to connect with this song; i.e., women's and blacks' civil rights movements.

I understand why some might associate these issues with the song at first. The maples represent women/blacks, and the oaks white males. But the crux of the song, and the part that disproves those theories, is the last two lines: "And the trees are all kept equal/By hatchet, axe, and saw." So both the maples and the oaks are cut to equal height in order to appease the maples' plea for "more sunlight." Therein lies the key difference between the ending of the maples' "oppression" and the ending of women's sexist and blacks' racial discrimination: the white male was not stripped of his rights in order to have the same level of rights as the women or blacks, therefore leveling them all to the same plain. Instead, the two suppressed groups were given some, and eventually almost all, of the rights held by the white man - at NO expense to the white man. That is why this song encompasses some but NOT all of the elements needed to properly portray the issues of the women's and blacks' civil rights struggles.

Now on to what can be symbolized by this song: anti-socialism, anti-collectivism and anti-altruism all in one swoop, as well as a couple topics from chapters in Rand's book. The root of the three "anti-s" (socialists, collectivists, and altruists) are symbolized by the maples, badgering the oaks (capitalists/objectivists) for more sunlight (power, equality, "rights"). The maples seem angered at the oaks for being bigger and taller and sucking up all the light. In nature, maples are actually quite capable of surviving with minimal sunlight, as opposed to oaks who need it constantly to thrive. Similarly, Rand presents the three "anti-s" or, for example, collectivists, as trying to sap those with more talent, money or "rights" and flatten them out under the pseudo-cause of...

Other Essays Like The Trees Song Analysis

Music Used in Spirited Away Brings Emotions to the Audience

1272 words - 6 pages conveys certain emotion instead. When a character is in the same emotion, the music will replay in the background. This kind of music scoring happens to provide Hisaishi a better sense of independence when scoring the films because he does not have to stick tightly to the movie (Rusli, 21). There are three songs that are very similar and, of course, in some parts of the song, they contain the same chords and melodies. There are “One Summerâ

A Brief Analysis of Long Songs in Inner Mongolia

1819 words - 8 pages are not preserved in the song. Performance manner is restrained, with little facial or bodily movement” (Pegg 45). Example of extended long songs: “Altan Ura” (Golden Seed) Performed by Lhajav in Xilingol, Inner Mongolia, 1987 (Lhajav) Musical Analysis: • Melodic contour: It is conjunct moving smoothly without sudden change. • Shape of each melodic phrase is undulating. • Instrumentation: Long songs are typically accompanied by the horse

The Story of an Hour

628 words - 3 pages window.” She “sank into a comfortable armchair,” (Chopin, 1894, para. 4). She was exhausted. Chopin describes Mrs. Mallard’s experience sitting there; she saw the tops of trees; rain in the air; a peddler was crying his wares; the notes of a distant song reached her; and countless sparrows were twittering in the eaves. (Chopin, 1894, para. 5) The descriptions involve the senses of seeing and hearing, which allow the reader to imagine what Mrs

My Eden------A 5-Paragraph Descriptive Essay

541 words - 3 pages silk blankets the sky; the sun is rising! I can see creatures appearing from their slumber. The trees trun in to a girls best friend as the branches sway and the golden leaves sparkle in the sunlight. There is a quiet rustling sound. I look over and see an innocent rabbit nibbling on some shrubbery. I wonder, is he also warming up in the beams? A shudder of fright jolts through me as I hear the magnificent scream of a mountain lion. The

The Most Beautiful House Of Vietnam

816 words - 4 pages . Furthermore, my older sister- a really clean woman- usually keeps the house clean and tidy, and I also want to help her.My garden is very wonderful with many kinds of tree, and the most popular trees are areca trees. They are very tall, surrounding the garden and the perfume of areca flowers is fragrant. But I like fruit trees more, because I like to eat fruit very much. There are three kinds of fruit tree in my garden, orange, litchi and

Stress Management

1546 words - 7 pages song sung by country star Blake Shelton is a favorite of mine because it reminds me so much of my relationship with my mother. The song explains the relationship between a mother and her son and how close they were in comparison to the other children. Towards the end of the song, the mother gets sick and dies before her son got a chance to say good bye. Although this song is very sad and usually makes me cry when I hear it, I love the emotion that

Investigating Pleurococcus

1511 words - 7 pages Investigating Pleurococcus Plan Pleurococcus is a green, single-celled algae that is found on the bark of trees, where it survives better on the north side of the tree and near the ground. It can also be found on stones and fences and usually in moist situations. As it is a green plant, as all green plants do - it photosynthesises. The chemical reaction that is taking place is: [IMAGE] Carbon

Analysis of Sees Behind Trees by Michael Dorris and Bronx Masquerade by Nikki Grimes

1792 words - 8 pages April 28, 2011 Storytelling- The Key to Transformation: Analysis of Sees Behind Trees by Michael Dorris and Bronx Masquerade by Nikki Grimes One essential element of a good novel is a story that involves character transformation. Included in any definition of the word transformation is the phrase “a marked change for the better.” Thus, one might conclude that a good novel must include character transformation that leaves the characters in a

The Role Of Trees In Hurston’S Seraph On The Suwanee And Their Eyes Were Watching

665 words - 3 pages The Role of Trees in Hurston’s Seraph on the Suwanee and Their Eyes Were Watching God Trees play integral roles in Seraph on the Suwanee and Their Eyes Were Watching God as sites of sexual awakening for Hurston’s heroines, providing a space under which dreams bloom into “glistening leaf-buds” or over-ripen and die like spoiled fruit. Close readings of Janie’s pear tree and Arvay’s mulberry evoke strikingly disparate images of female

My Escape

602 words - 3 pages a mirage. Trees that are as high as sky scrapers tower over me allowing the sunlight to disperse thought the branches. The leaves on the trees are entering their final stages of life, turning them to the most magnificent shades of red, orange, and yellow. This time of year, I always think, is what makes New England such a beautiful place to live. Along side of me, out of my peripheral vision, I see a black squirrel gathering some acorns to

Seasons of Change

1246 words - 5 pages ate the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden, causing all men to be subjected to a mortal life with sin. This idea speaks to the theme of mortality and loss of innocence, as both were concepts of the Bible story and Hopkins’ poem. The setting of the poem is a town called Goldengrove in the fall. The words golden and grove elicit an autumnal feel, and literally mean a yellow-orange group of trees. This scenery of abundant trees with beautiful

Related Papers

The Bean Trees Taylor Character Analysis

1185 words - 5 pages The Bean Trees: Character Analysis Taylor Greer is the primary protagonist of the adventurous tale taking place throughout multiple states in America, The Bean Trees. Taylor is girl from a town of simpletons, and she wants to escape that and live freely somewhere else. The Bean Trees is written by Barbra Kingsolver, an acclaimed author, and the story is about Taylor and her life after leaving a small town in Kentucky to find happiness

Critical Analysis Of "The Love Song Of J. Alfred Prufrock"

3555 words - 15 pages     Critical  Analysis  of  “The  Love  Song  of  J.  Alfred  Prufrock”     The  title  of  the  poem  is  Eliot's  first  hint  that  this  is  not  a  traditional  love   poem  at  all.  "J.  Alfred  Prufrock"  is  a  farcical  name,  and  Eliot  wanted  the  subliminal

Poem Analysis Of 'a Song Of The Republic' By Henry Lawson And 'if You Forget Me' By Pablo Neruda

982 words - 4 pages I have chosen two poems, A Song of The Republic, by Henry Lawson (1867-1922), and 'If You Forget Me' by Pablo Neruda (1904-1973). Both of these poems use many different techniques to reflect the context of their time and their values and beliefs.Pablo Neruda was a Nobel prize winning Chilean poet who lived during the times of World War 1 and 2 as well as the Spanish civil war. Due to his first hand experiences, his poems changed overtime from

Song Analysis Dave Matthews Band : Gravedigger

1005 words - 5 pages making it into a sad horror story, he finds death to be a joke. He doesn't really care where he is buried but is extremely cynical when he ask that after being dead, will he still feel the rain? The analysis of this song lead me to actually dislike the song because I found that my first impression of the song was much different than after analyzing it for weeks. I love the bands music but I just don't like this one particular song. I guess