This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Throughout History Justice Is Not Always Served

4895 words - 20 pages

To understand a nation you should know its history. Once you start digging through the past it will be inevitable meeting people fighting for all the great things, which as Winston Churchill once said “are simple, and many can be expressed in a single word: freedom, justice, honor, duty, mercy, hope”. Unfortunately the path to achieve this greatness often passes through slavery, injustice, dishonor, cruelty, despair and death. That is clearly expressed in the story of Marie-Joseph Angélique, one of the biggest mysteries and Louis Riel, one of the biggest heroes in Canadian history.
To appraise the fairness of the trials of Marie Joseph Angélique and Louis Riel we need to understand ...view middle of the document...

In the following essay I will use the criteria mentioned above to account for similarities and differences between the two episodes.
Angélique lived in society less social than the one we know today and much more hostile. The Sovereign Council of New France was a political body appointed by the King of France and consisted of a Governor General, an intendant and a bishop of the Roman Catholic Church. All were answering to the French Minister of the Marine. The members of the council were chosen as part of the French nobility. The administration of justice was the responsibility of the intendant and followed the inquisitorial method. What that meant was that guilt was presumed until the accused could prove innocence. Trials lasted until the justice presiding decided that enough evidence had been heard to pass judgment. The system was relatively cheap, efficient and quick, with judgments and sentences sometimes being carried out the same day.
One hundred and fifty years later the society in which Louis Riel lived was quite hostile as well, but with different structure. At the late 19th century Canada had establish itself as a country with its own government and judicial system identical to the one in England. In the North West Territories, where the Riel drama took place, justice was served by a stipendiary magistrate who held office at the pleasure of the federal government, and could be dismissed without cause at any time .
These preliminary facts show that the chain of events that led to the ultimate punishment of the two souls were very different and yet similar. Angélique’s trial and outcome was dictated by the social forces of its time. Contrary, the trial of Riel was a political one. To drift the two trials further away from one another it has to be considered the accusations made against Louis Riel and Marie Joseph Angélique. The trial of Louis Riel portrays the political, judicial and legal misdeeds which resulted in unmerciful and unjust execution. He ultimately lost his life in an unfair trial for treason, but he was courageous man who defied the political establishment to stand up for the rights of ordinary people. In contrast, the story of Angélique even today 277 years later is still unknown. The question “Did Angélique burn Montréal?” hangs without answer, which makes it one of the greatest mysteries of the Canadian history. We know that she was black, woman, and slave. We know that the relationship between slaves and slave masters at that time was difficult. We know that she was quite rebellious. What we don’t know is if she really started the fire. Scholars and academic have tried to disperse the ambiguity of her account unfortunately unsuccessful.
In 2004 Beaugrand-Champagne sets out to present the documents in detail, to question the court proceedings and to present all the possible culprits. She concludes that the fire was most likely accidental, the result of poorly cleaned chimneys and a cook fire...

Other Essays Like Throughout History Justice Is Not Always Served

The Supreme Court Essay

1293 words - 6 pages Associate Justice and his married and has three children. He received his B.A. from the London School of Economics and Stanford University. Anthony has served in several positions during his career, the board of the Federal Judicial Center and is a member of the California Army National Guard. President Reagan also nominated him and Kennedy took his seat Feb. 18, 1988. David Hackett Souter, born on September 17, 1939 in Massachusetts, in a small town

Risk Assessment Essay

1355 words - 6 pages boundaries essential to have value in a society, which is continuously changing and developing. The criminal justice system will also always be an absolute vital feature of society that makes sure those that are guilty receive justice and are held accountable for their crimes and that victims get justice. As new technology come forth requiring the criminal justice system to adapt, the value of the justice system will not change but will continue to

On The Genealogy Of Morals: A Work Of History Or Of The Imagination? On The Genealogy Of Morals By Friedrich Nietzsche

1289 words - 6 pages , however, does not mean that the fundamentals of morality are not shared by these seemingly disparate peoples. Accountability and justice, while not always practiced, have at least been adhered to in principle throughout history. While human sacrifice existed in ancient times, indiscriminate murder has never been a generally accepted form of behavior. Universal morals and values have proven to be very real, lasting, and important parts of humanity and to disregard this fact is simply to deny the truth.

Criminal Justice Trends Paper

1642 words - 7 pages past to the present. The way criminal justice is today is a little better than it was in the past. Today we have technology that we did not have in the past. We can only imagine how the future is going to be when it comes to all areas for the criminal justice system. With new technology always coming into pay, we can only hope that it will improve the criminal justice system in the future. References Police: History- Policing Twentieth

History of Dorsey

578 words - 3 pages , Dorsey is a school with such outstanding history and a bright future. Regardless of the community chatter, it’s not always about what is on the outside. Dorsey High school has some of the best and brightest students in all of Los Angeles unified school district. Dorsey’s history pretty much speaks for itself. It already captured lots of the successful alumni, focuses on sports, and now it teaching students on how to respectful. So regardless of the reputation of Dorsey High School, there is more to Dorsey that meets the eye. I am very proud to be, and stay a Dorsey Don until the day I graduate.

Critique of the Nine

1425 words - 6 pages Yorker (Jeffrey Toobin). Under this company, Toobin served as a television legal analyst, and he interviewed many famous subjects, such as Martha Stewart, O.J. Simpson, and Michael Jackson (Jeffrey Toobin). Then, in 2002 Toobin wrote The Nine- Inside the Secret World of the Supreme which has received many awards. Since then, Toobin has continued to write and be a part of politics. The Nine- Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court is a book

Simonodes (Via Polemarchus) Argues In The First Book Of "The Republic" That Justice Is Paying Back What Is Due. Defend Or Argue Against This Position

1528 words - 7 pages well-being is an end in itself. What he meant by this is that one should always act in such a matter that he could not complain if he were in the other person's shoes receiving his reaction. This is an improved way to look at justice because justice should be served in a reasonable and rational fashion in which every aspect of an action is evaluated, and not just done out of spite. This would most definitely keep security within society, unlike

Boys Will Be Men

1410 words - 6 pages as the real men throughout popular lore, Batman’s masculinity is increased by his role within justice. While it would seem accurate to say that Batman is the definitive leader among the DC Comics world in popularity, Spiderman is Marvel Comics’ equivalent lead man. Although not shrouded in notoriety as is the Batman throughout the Marvel series’ history, Spiderman goes through phases due to the same reasoning. Spiderman often goes from being

Death Penalty

2270 words - 10 pages should be justice served for a horrifying act that a convict committed by the convict being executed. Even though some people view this as being true, taking someone’s life to possibly make up for another is always non-ethical since there is still someone being put to death. Another reason on why people support the death penalty is because it could make the world a safer place. This could be denied by the fact that sentencing someone to life in

How Does Aquinas ‘Prove’ the Existence of God?

846 words - 4 pages God a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship. Does God really exist? This is surely a fundamental question that nearly all humans have pondered with throughout human history. It can be said that all humans have an inmate desire; an emptiness that they feel must be filled. For a philosopher, however, this concept has proven to be more than a little difficult to solve. Many people

Effect of Intervention Programmes on Youth Crime

5994 words - 24 pages is overly intrusive or punitive and not commensurate with the offence (Nacro 2000a, 2000c; Giller 2004). Additionally, the use of restorative justice interventions could be excessive in relation to the offence and its effectiveness could be questionable. As Bottoms (2003, p.110) suggests, any attempt to use a ‘blanket’ delivery of restorative justice will always achieve modest and/or patchy results. This newly structured and systematic approach

Related Papers

Death Penalty “To Take A Life When A Life Has Been Lost Is Revenge, Not Justice”

1636 words - 7 pages Death Penalty Seongman An Death Penalty “To take a life when a life has been lost is revenge, not justice.” Desmond Tutu It is believed that the main issue of the death penalty as a punishment is a dispute between its opponents and supporters about the existence of the death penalty itself. Thus, humanity has been divided into two public camps – for and against, which express the current state of the

Chief Justice Essay

818 words - 4 pages the Chancellor, of the Smithsonian Institution. Last but not least he supervises the acquisition of books for the Law Library of the Library of Congress. The Supreme Court is an important policy-making institution. In criminal justice, for example, the high court issues decisions affecting institutions, actors, and processes throughout the justice system, from police investigations through corrections and parole. The Court's policy decisions

A Few Good Men Essay

534 words - 3 pages reality, this is not the case. As a result of this, the public gets poorly educated about what is really going on in their society. Courts are mainly portrayed as being very elegant, expensive, and large. Throughout the courtrooms, we learn a great deal about the various positions vital to cases. There are two different types of lawyers portrayed in A Few Good Men, the prosecutor and the defense attorney. Defense attorneys are interesting

Death Penalty Essay

1227 words - 5 pages About the Death Penalty document, dated up to April 5, 2012. One of the primary reasons why the death penalty has been in existence throughout history is the need for justice. Many believe that the death penalty is actually unjust and a risk of murder towards someone that is actually innocent. An eye for an eye is the general picture that justice implements. It should make no difference in terms of murder. While it may provide zero effect to the