This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

To What Extent Did Elizabeth Control Her Government?

1384 words - 6 pages

To what extent did Elizabeth control her government?

To successfully answer this question there are two main aspects off government to consider, her Parliament and her ministers. It can be argued that Elizabeth successfully controlled both her Parliament and her ministers, and I would agree with this. I would also argue however that whilst she was somewhat successful she also lost control at times such as when parliaments formed ‘factions or Essex's revolt. MacCaffrey supports this view saying “ For the most part, she was extremely successful; however it has to be acknowledged that the start and end of her reign was weak in terms of dealing with parliament”

Elizabeths strong ...view middle of the document...

I would say that from this is is obvious that her control over parliament was successful due to her equally successful ability to utilise the powers she had been granted as the monarch.

It could also be said however that she was unsuccessful to an extent. Elizabeth experienced many problems (particularly at the beginning and end of her reign) with ‘factions’ within government. The main culprits were Catholic bishops and Protestants in the commons. She was inexperienced with dealing with matters such as this, and did not know how to control people with such radically different ideas to her. Patronage enabled MP’s to slowly rise through the ranks to become more favourable with the Queen. It allowed strict control whilst maintaining a happy Parliament. MacCaffrey however states that “Elizabeth kept a firm and economical hand on patronage.” This shows that this again, was in general, solely controlled by Elizabeth, showing that her success was due to her, not other ministers to support this view - Elizabeth was granted many of the things she requested by parliament, including a subsidy in 1576, and a strengthening of all Catholic laws in 1571. This shows a fully functioning relationship well into her reign suggesting that she had successfully controlled parliament at least up until the 1580’s.

Many have refuted this however and would say that parliament changed throughout the reign. A.F.Pollard and John Neale claim that parliament grew away from Elizabeth with time. This is because many MPs stood up against the norm, speaking for more freedom and similar ideas. The fact that the amount doing so increased throughout the reign suggests that although Elizabeth many have been in control at the start of the reign, this control certainly lapsed.

I believe there is no doubt that Elizabeth was extremely successful in controlling parliament. There were moments where she proved inexperience, however the vast quantity of methods she employed to control her MP’s such as pleasing them through patronage, or punishing them through various sanctions proves her success.

When it comes to her ministers it can be said that she was well served until the death of Burghley in 1598. Although the two did have some issues. She also experienced trouble exercising her control over he ministers I the seconds half of her reign as her old trusted councillors stated dying and new inexperienced ones took over.

William Cecil or Lord Burghley is known for being one of the Queens most faithful and willing advisors on the council. John Guy has stated that often Burghley served as the principal force behind the initiatives to force Elizabeth to marry or declare a successor, for example after her illness with smallpox in 1566. Indeed in this was he could be seen as her main opponent but he did have both hers and the country's best interest at heart. He was generally sympathetic with Protestant views and his cautious views echoed those of Elizabeth, in...

Other Essays Like To What Extent Did Elizabeth Control Her Government?

To What Extent Did the Ww2 Change the Lives of Black Americans?

921 words - 4 pages To what extent did the WWII change the lives of Black Americans? The Second World War has caused many changes in America. The fight against Nazis in Europe demonstrated that US suffered from the same problem of racism and the white supremacy and that something had to be done. During the wartime many African Americans had to move from Southern farms to Northern and Western cities, as there was a lack of jobs because of the increase of

In What Ways And To What Extent Did Constitutional And Social Developments Between 1860 And 1877 Amount To A Revolution?

1057 words - 5 pages , "TheFederal government has no dictate the matter of suffrage (Doc D)." To resolvethese conservatives would require literacy tests to vote, and reinstate propertyrequirements. These methods were ways around the vague constitutional developments ofthe 15th amendment. Violence was also used as a means to control the black populationin the South. The Klu Klux Klan and White League would use terrorist acts on blacks andlynch many innocent

Q: to What Extent Were the Financial Difficulties of the Government the Cause of the French Revolution

1287 words - 6 pages History - Year 10 Assessment Activity: Essay on French Revolution By Debajyoti Chaudhuri KM10 Q: To what extent were the financial difficulties of the government the cause of the French Revolution To a large extent, the financial difficulties of the government were the cause of the French Revolution. A major cause was the economic crisis and financial debt accumulated by the French Government which brought national unrest leading to

To What Extent Did Breaking Code Jn-25 and Code Ultra Give Aid to the Allies in the Pacific and Atlantic Theatres of World War Two?

4794 words - 20 pages Extended Essay Group 3: History To what extent did breaking code JN-25 and code ULTRA give aid to the Allies in the Pacific and Atlantic theatres of World War Two? Word Count: 3746 Abstract: This extended essay has the subject of Code Breaking Intelligence. When studying the Second World War, the phrase ‘code breaking’ is not highlighted as a significant factor, so this investigation is to assess the contribution of code

How and to What Extent Did War and Violence Contribute to the Definition of Chivalry as Both an Historical and Social Phenomenon?

1934 words - 8 pages How and to what extent did war and violence contribute to the definition of chivalry as both an historical and social phenomenon? It is largely acknowledged by historians that, while it is difficult to be definitive in the meaning of chivalry-with Maurice Keen believing it to be a ‘word elusive of definition’- it came to denote the culture of a martial estate which ‘regarded war as its hereditary profession’. Thus, it could be considered that

Using the Evidence of Suetonius and Res Gestae, to What Extent Did Augustus Rely on Republican Precedent and Tradition in the Settlement of 31 and 23 Bc

4218 words - 17 pages maintaining his superiority. Augustus made the transition from Republic to Empire in a number of ways that did not cause uproar or result in anarchy for Rome and her Citizens. Augustus had first been made a member of the senate under the consulship of Gaius Pasa in 43 BC, this was where were he first received his imperium. Augustus then became a consul in 32 BC when Rome was on the brink of a Civil war, yet he did not assume solitary power and still

To What Extent Did The Movie, The Tuskegee Airmen, Actually Portray The Factual Nature, And Accurate Events Of The Real Tuskegee Airmen?

3779 words - 16 pages Extended EssayTo what extent did the movie, The Tuskegee Airmen, actually portray the factual nature, and accurate events of the real Tuskegee Airmen?Rashad Morris0119 062May 2009Word Count: 3229Table of ContentsTable of Contents pg 1Abstract pg 2Introduction pg 3Body pg 4-12Conclusion pg 13Bibliography pg 14AbstractThis research paper evaluates the connection between the movie, The Tuskegee Airmen and its relative portrayal of acceptable and

To What Extent Is War Inevitable Today?

1545 words - 7 pages To what extent do you believe war is inevitable in today’s world? By: Arianna Lu *Presented to *Mrs. Antonuk & Mr. *Klukas* Sir Winston Churchill High School * * In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for History 30/35 IB *October 23, 2007 Period: 2* To what extent do you believe war is inevitable in today’s world? War has always been a major part of our history, for it is within human nature for conflicts to

To What Extent Was the Effective Government of Germany in the Years 1919 – 1933 Handicapped by the Nature of the Weimar Constitution?

1022 words - 5 pages they didn’t need to sign the treaty. Other factors that contributed to handicapped the government were the threat from the extreme right and left as they were gaining support from the public therefore it was becoming easier for them to possibly overthrow the constitution. Finally, the nature of the Weimar constitution did effect the government of Germany as A principal threat to the effectiveness of Germany’s government was the threat from the

What Is Good Government to Me?

1378 words - 6 pages Jerika Marie A. Arceo IV-Einstein Essay: What is Good Government to Me? Welcome to the Philippines! Welcome to the 7,107 islands of pure magic, mystery, and mayhem. The Philippines is a third world country; we are all aware of this. Just a stroll down the streets of the metro will slap the reality on your face-street children almost everywhere, middle-aged men shouting their voices out selling fake, pirated, and illegal DVD’s

To What Extent Is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society

2178 words - 9 pages 8-week Pre-sessional Research Essay 15th August 2012 To What Extent is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society? UCL Language Centre Student: QIFAN WANG Tutor: MARK BAILEY Date: 16/08/2012 Word count: 1854 words Introduction Cultural heritage, including monuments, groups of buildings and sites, which are of outstanding universal value from the point of view of history, art or science(1972, UNESCO Convention World

Related Papers

To What Extent Does The Prime Minister Control The Decisions Made By Their Government

579 words - 3 pages there have in fact already been approved of, but merely require formal approval. Thatcher, at first, manipulated the Cabinet to great effect for her cause. She would speak to individuals outside of meetings, change the agenda to suit her, divided and ruled over the ministers and would essentially lay the foundations for what the modern PMs now carry out. This has given rise to the terms “sofa government”, which refers to the informal decision

To What Extent Did The Us Deterrence Successfully Contain Communism?

1237 words - 5 pages The US was determined to implement a foreign policy of containment towards the USSR since the beginning of 1945. The US disagreed to requests Stalin made at the Yalta and Potsdam conference, which served to limit Stalin's power and control over Europe. President Truman became even more concerned after receiving George Kennan's Long Telegram in February 1946. This telegram was sent by the US ambassador in Moscow, reporting on the destructive

To What Extent Did Stalin Transform The Society And Economy Of The Ussr?

2063 words - 9 pages To what extent did Stalin transform the society and economy of the Soviet Union? Joseph Stalin ceased power after the death of Lenin in 1924; by 1928 Stalin was a prominent figure in the Communist party and was ready to implement his transformation of the USSR. He transformed the Soviet Union to an immense degree; he brought about total change. Stalin introduced a command economy after the introduction of Socialism in one country; the command

To What Extent Did America Conduct An Imperialist Foreign Policy From 1939 1949?

846 words - 4 pages To What Extent Did America Conduct An Imperialist Foreign Policy From 1939-1949? The dictionary defines imperialism as “a policy of extending a country's power and influence through colonisation, use of military force, or other means”. America did not conduct an imperialist foreign policy in any sense of this definition from 1939-1949. Before 1941 America was demonstrating a very isolationist policy, focusing on their own recovery after the