To What Extent Was Market Maturity The Cause Of Caterpillar Restructuring? Critically Examine The Extent The New Strategy Transformed Market, Productive And Financial Performance

2481 words - 10 pages

To what extent was market maturity the cause of Caterpillar’s restructuring? Critically examine the extent the new strategy transformed market, productive and financial performance.
During the late 1980s and the early 1990s Caterpillar Inc. (CAT), a $30 billion colossal in the earth-moving equipment (EME), engines and power systems, underwent a significant restructure. This was because in 1982 CAT posted its first annual lost of its 50-years history. The industry-wide downturn was partly the result of the cyclical nature of the construction equipment industry but also the consequence of an increased foreign competition fuelled by a strong dollar. The inflation and the market maturity ...view middle of the document...

It follows that firms like Caterpillar that constantly move from a market trajectory of real output expansion to one of stagnation and cyclicality experience a decrease in the generation of cash surplus (Haslam, Neale, and Johal, 2000). By looking at the history of Caterpillar, it is possible to see (See appendix - Fig. 1) how its first period after 1954 witnessed a sustained growth, in which downturns are only a small pause before a new growth. Nevertheless, it is also appears clear that a new era begun for CAT in 1973. The effects of this downturn started to be particularly visible in 1981 as the gains of the upturns since 1973 were not consolidated and the additional downturn in 1981 reduced sales by half to 1970 levels (Froud, et al., 1998). It can be therefore said that partially as a result of the cyclical nature of the construction equipment industry and also as a product of increased foreign competition fuelled by a strong dollar, Caterpillar revenues and profits felt. Market maturity should have been the reason for a restructuring, but, although it did bring improvements, CAT management actually did not realize that the reason for the decrease in sales was the market maturity. The firm had really opted for a restructuring because of the impression that “Komatsu had an advantage based on superior manufacturing practise” (Froud, et al., 1998: 699). Caterpillar, in fact, believed that it needed to decrease high labour costs as it increased outsourcing of non-core activities. The PWAF programme never admitted that the promise of cost reduction through improved flow, that did improved the general benefits of the workforce, really depended on the shifting market limitations (Froud, et al., 1998) and the fluctuating exchange rate.
The analysis of the market trajectory, in fact, becomes even more relevant when associated with the dynamics of advantage and competitor interaction. For this reason, it is worth looking into the threat that Komatsu imposed upon CAT. As seen, the process of restructuring was mainly initiated because Caterpillar management believed that Komatsu had a competitive advantage based on superior manufacturing practice. Nevertheless, the Caterpillar - Komatsu case highlights how the effects of factory improvement and productive reorganization in America and Japan were generally overwhelmed by the much stronger influence of exchange rate variation. The structural source of advantage and disadvantage results from movements in the exchange rate, limited the capacity of Caterpillar to actively manage competitor interaction through marketing or productive intervention as envisaged in management tasks (Froud, et al., 1998). In fact, the Yen-Dollar relationship can be actually taken into account as one of the main reasons for the shifting in advantage between the two manufacturers. The rate between the Yen and the Dollar was favourable for the Japanese Komatsu, but in 1985 the advantage brought by Komatsu’s low labour cost...

Other Essays Like To What Extent Was Market Maturity the Cause of Caterpillar Restructuring? Critically Examine the Extent the New Strategy Transformed Market, Productive and Financial Performance

The Influence of Market Strategy on Performance: Which Strategy Type Leads to Superior Performance Under Which Circumstances?

3251 words - 14 pages resources are an important component of evaluating new product success. Financial resources like marketing investments and non-financial ones as newness to the firm and marketing knowledge have an influence on new product performance. Finally, it is necessary to define the measurement of new product performance to judge the superiority of the chosen market strategy. There are several indicators to measure the product performance. Lilian and Yoon

To What Extent Do You Agree That a Free Market Economy Is the Only Approach to Bringing About Economic Growth

2716 words - 11 pages To what extent do you agree with the view that only a free market approach to running the economy can bring about sustainable high levels of economic growth and development? The basic economic problem is that we, as consumers, have unlimited wants and scarce resources. (Anderton, 2008, p.1) Due to this, the questions of what shall be produced, how it will be produced, and who gets the product, arise. (Sandford, 1977, p.42) Therefore

To What Extent Hong Kong Was Modernized at the End of the 20th Century?

573 words - 3 pages , the entrepot trade was revived and it laid the foundation for the industrialization in Hong Kong. Second, there was the industrialization in Hong Kong. Since the geographical location of HK was a favourable factors. Hong Kong lies on the time zone between Europe and America. New York, London and HK were formed an international 21 hours a day finance market. This led HK became an international financial centre. The tertiary industry (finance

To What Extent Was Adolf Hitler Personally Responsible for the Holocaust Between 1934 and 1942

4436 words - 18 pages important role regarding events surrounding the Holocaust, he is seen as not the initiator of the events. Structuralists argue that the decision was made for the Final Solution only in late Autumn 1941. He rarely issued written orders and the absence of such evidence has further contributed to the debate of Hitler's role in decision making. I shall examine the evidence to see to what extent Hitler was personally responsible for the Holocaust

To What Extent Was The US Responsible For The Collapse Of The Grand Alliance At The End Of WW2?

1398 words - 6 pages To what extent was the United States responsible for the collapse of the Grand Alliance at the end of WWII?The role the United States played in the collapse of the Grand Alliance varies depending on who you ask; there are the Orthodox group who place the sole blame for the collapse on Soviet shoulders, or the Revisionists who believe that the Soviets actions were a legitimate response to the threat held by the USA's economic and strategic

To What Extent Was the British Commitment of Massive Resources to the Campaign in North Africa and the Mediterranean, in the Years 1940 to 1944, a Strategic Mistake?

931 words - 4 pages It is argued that the Mediterranean strategy was a strategic mistake and British resources would be better used elsewhere such as the Atlantic where over 3,500 merchant vessels and 175 warships were destroyed during the entire war, but it can be also argued that Churchill, who initiated the Mediterranean campaign was right to commit huge amounts of resources to a strategy believed to win the war. It can be argued that both the North African and

To What Extent Was the Impact of the First World War Responsible for the Downfall of Tsarism in March 1917?

1720 words - 7 pages To what extent was the impact of the First World War responsible for the downfall of Tsarism in March 1917? In March 1917, Nicholas II abdicated and brought Tsarist’s three hundred year reign to an end. The issue of the Tsar’s downfall divides historians with two different viewpoints. The first perspective is that Russia was making progress, however it was solely undermined by the First World War in which the war caused massive losses, poor

To What Extent Was Economic Reasons the Main Reason for the Two Countries' Separation?

756 words - 4 pages To what extent was economic differences the main reason for separation? I disagree to a large extent that economic differences were the main reasons for separation between Singapore and Malaysia. Political differences between the 2 countries instead, were a more predominant factor as it led to social unrest in these countries. Economic differences, on the other hand, played a less subtle role in separating the 2 countries, even though it did

The Main Features of the Global Economy and Examine the Extent of Interdependence Between Economies Has Affected the Australian Economy

893 words - 4 pages shifts of money. Global finance refers to the foreign exchange market which is volatile as speculates have 95% ownership. The daily turn over in global foreign exchange markets in 3.2 trillion, this is predominately the cause of financial deregulation in currency markets, foreign capital, bank interest rates and overseas investment in shares around the world in the 1970-80s. Global investment is the long term flow of money to buy or establish

New Pharmaceuticals and Their Journey to the Market

686 words - 3 pages on the company’s findings of the risks and benefits of the drug. This process usually takes about 2 ½ years. (Drug approvals - from invention to market, n.d. ). In conclusion, what I’ve learned is that it is a long journey for a new drug to reach the market, in which takes a lot of people to achieve. All totaled up, it’s around a 12 year journey that costs $2.9 billion for the pharmaceutical company to even think about doing in the first place

To What Extent Was the Lack of Support from Presidents and Congress the Main Reason Why Little Progress Was Made in the Development of African-American Rights Between 1896 and 1941?

1351 words - 6 pages To what extent was the lack of support from Presidents and Congress the main reason why little progress was made in the development of African-American rights between 1896 and 1941? In 1896, politicians were still a direct way in which African-Americans could use to gain higher levels of civil rights in the United States of America. It is arguable therefore that the support from Presidents and Congress over the time period of 1896 to 1941 was

Related Papers

Use An Example Of Your Choice To Discuss How ‘Corporate Restructuring’ Transformed Market, Productive And Financial Performance

2143 words - 9 pages implemented to restructure the organisation and how it affected market, productive and financial performance. Firstly, I would like to speak about Product Life Cycle, because Caterpillar’s product reached maturity level and it was one of the main causes why it needed to implement corporate restructuring. In maturity stage market becomes saturated and product’s demand slows down, only repeated customers purchase this product. ‘Competition becomes intense

“To What Extent Was Rapid Economic Growth The Cause Of Social Tensions In Wilhelmine Germany?”

1952 words - 8 pages “To what extent was rapid economic growth the cause of social tensions in Wilhelmine Germany?” In Wilhelmine Germany, an industrial revolution was taking place. By 1910, Germany had almost caught up with Britain on the production of industries such as coal and steel, with the rate of growth overwhelmingly surpassing that of the Britons. Germany was also home to new industries, like that of chemicals, which quickly saw 90% of the world’s hair

Q: To What Extent Were The Financial Difficulties Of The Government The Cause Of The French Revolution

1287 words - 6 pages History - Year 10 Assessment Activity: Essay on French Revolution By Debajyoti Chaudhuri KM10 Q: To what extent were the financial difficulties of the government the cause of the French Revolution To a large extent, the financial difficulties of the government were the cause of the French Revolution. A major cause was the economic crisis and financial debt accumulated by the French Government which brought national unrest leading to

To What Extent Was The Rwanda Genocide And Example Of Root And Branch Genocide?

1606 words - 7 pages To what extent was the Rwanda genocide an example of root-and-branch genocide? To what extent was the Rwanda genocide and example of root-and-branch genocide? Plan of the Investigation: While seeking for my Internal Assessment topic I came across the topic Rwandan Genocide and immediately became interested. The term genocide is a term formally used to describe the act of violence towards members of a national, ethical, racial or religious