This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tragedy Of Great Power Politics Essay

1389 words - 6 pages

Mearsheimer: The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
In The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, author John Mearsheimer outlines a new theory of international relations which he calls “offensive realism.” Mearsheimer’s theory is a spin-off of Kenneth Waltz’s neorealism, also known as structural or defensive realism. Mearsheimer follows on the premises of Kenneth Waltz’s theory by deriving the behavior of states from the “structure” of the international system.
Mearsheimer outlines five assumptions or premises comprising his theoretical foundation: 1) the international system is anarchic (no world government) 2) all states posses some offensive capability and are thus capable of using force ...view middle of the document...

36). Of course the security dilemma cannot operate unless we also include the premise that no state can be insured that another state will not attack it (Wagner 2007, pg 26).
In chapter eight Mearsheimer offers an explanation of the causes of war, or so he claims. In reality, he simply outlines three plausible structures of the international system and the relative probability of war under each structure.
From his analysis of the structure of the international system and state’s interests, Mearsheimer concludes that states strive for at least regional hegemony and the prevention of the rise of another regional hegemon. Mearsheimer argues that this is precisely the strategy of the United States and that it can best achieve its goals through what he calls “buck passing” and “off shore balancing.” Mearsheimer argues that the balance of power in Europe is currently stable and that the US need not employ an active foreign policy there. In fact, he argues the US should bring its troops home from Europe as European security provision is not vital to American interests. Mearsheimer similarly argues that security provision in Northeast Asia is not a vital American interest. In contrast to Europe, however, he argues that China has the latent power potential to become a regional hegemon in Northeast Asia and thus the US should employ an active foreign policy of offshore balancing in relation to China.
Critiquing Mearsheimer:
Mearsheimer’s theory is an example of deduction. In order for a deductive theory to be logically valid, the conclusion(s) must follow from the premises. Mearsheimer, as all realists do, fails on this account. A fully developed critique of Mearsheimer, and the lack of validity within his argument, is outside the scope of this assignment. Therefore, my critique of his logic will focus primarily on anarchy.
I will outline three general critiques of Mearsheimer’s argument which I believe are most important for better understating international politics, particularly US-China relations. First is the anarchic logic of structural realism. In creating this logic, realists draw on Hobbes’ theorizing about the state of nature for individuals. Mearsheimer and Waltz adopt Hobbes’ theory to the anarchic structure of the international system. In order to complete this step in their theorizing, both Waltz and Mearsheimer argue that that neither the domestic politics nor the leaders of states matter, thereby treating states as individuals with one monolithic goal—survival.
This is a fatal flaw in realism and in Mearsheimer’s theory. Neither Mearsheimer nor any other realist makes any attempt to explain why or how they can leap from Hobbes’ state of nature for individuals to a Hobbesian state of nature in the international system. They just assert that it is the case. It is not possible to understand the behavior of states in the international system without accounting for the domestic structure of the state. I will give two examples...

Other Essays Like Tragedy of Great Power Politics

Death Of A Salesman And All My Sons As Optimistic Tragedies

4243 words - 17 pages discussed and proven to be a major part of a tragedy, especially Miller's. Death of a Salesman is used to prove this statement. The idea that Miller's plays are optimistic is discussed in great detail. Both plays are used to prove this concept, as well as essays written by literary critics with opinions on this topic. One of the major points in this essay is Miller's use of love. Love is a dominant emotion throughout the tragedies. The important

‘A Gets B To Do Something That He Or She Would Not Otherwise Do.’ Does This Sum Up The Essence Of Political Power?

1944 words - 8 pages , the dictator seems to have great power. In democracies, which are dominant since the late 20th century, it appears every citizen has power, although he passes it on to the people he elects. In any regime, there seems to be different levels and sorts of power. The Constitution and laws in a democratic regime, and the leader in an authoritarian regime, define these different aspects of power. Politics also deals with conflicting interests. Everyone

Hamlets as a Tragic Hero

888 words - 4 pages Tragic Senses in Hamlet In the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, the playwright is set with a tragic tone in a corrupt society. Hamlet, a grieving prince, is the central character whose wrongdoing, if it can be called that, is not obliging to his megalomaniac uncle who murdered his own brother for power. Movingly, the play’s theme of how one’s tragic flaw will inevitably lead to self-destruction demonstrates that even with the best

Kissinger and Matternichian Realism

5701 words - 23 pages expansion. Aside from present-mindedness, Kissinger’s history is characterized by a fascination with the individual and with the great powers. Due to his decision to concentrate on the history of foreign relations and his view that only the rare man of genius influences history, public opinion, domestic politics, political parties, and ideological differences appear in Kissinger’s writings only as extraneous hindrances that befuddle, restrict, and

Essay: 9/11 Brought Us Together, but Was It Unity?

1305 words - 6 pages perception of a united America gave way to the reality of division. Political polarization became the norm. And partisanship, gridlock and a loss of faith in institutions returned in force. As diverse as it is, is this country capable of being truly united? And if we were, would that really be a good thing? Americans come together spontaneously or, perhaps, instinctively at times of tragedy and trauma. We always seem to be on the same page when

Section One – Extended Response – “Othello’s Downfall Is Due to a Basic Flaw in His Own Character” Discuss and Refer to Two Critical Interpretations

859 words - 4 pages convince Othello that Cassio has slept with Desdemona, and to use Othello’s honest and unsuspecting nature to bring him down. Parker’s use of showing Iago moving chess pieces around during his soliloquy represents the God like power he has over Othello and Desdemona and depicts the two as just pieces in Iago’s game of life. It is this manipulation in which is considered to be the central foundation of the tragedy of Othello. Iago is to be held

Administration and Politics Dichotomy

1032 words - 5 pages politics and administration are conceptualized, rationalized and related one to the other” (1987). Politicians should have only the power of creating and letting the administrators implementing and enforcing because of how easily personal feelings, greed and favoritism can cause problems for the people, community, and this country. In using the politics-administration dichotomy among the politicians and public administrations, there is an advantage

Power Of Respect In Pericles' Leadership Of Athens

1765 words - 8 pages mother Agariste, Pericles never had the need to make money or gain a material status at his governing position. Everything Pericles did was out of humane means and out of love for his nation. This alone plays a key factor in why he was re-elected general year after year. His sincere personality was shown before his election when as stated by Plutarch he refused to go directly into politics “since he was rich, of brilliant lineage, and had friends of

International Politics

1392 words - 6 pages these two superpowers created a bipolar power structure in world politics and hence, the breakdown of their alliance coupled with the increased tensions over Western Europe. Classical realism accurately explained the event in Western Europe where the propagation of power and domination triggered a perpetual great power competition. However, realists failed to predict the sudden demise of the Soviet Union and the unipolar international structure

The Power in Words

998 words - 4 pages Jordan Jones Cady 1A ENGL 101 CC 8 March 2013 The Power in Words Speeches can be one of the most difficult things to write and present. Anyone can give a speech about anything, but not all of them are going to be amazing. Actually, speeches are one of those things that not everyone is going to feel the same about. One person could think that the speech was great and it changed their life, while another person could absolutely hate that

Power of Art

1860 words - 8 pages The English Macquarie Dictionary defines the word “power” as: 1. Ability to do or act; capability of doing or affecting something. 2. Great or marked ability to do or act; strength, empower, might, potent, force. 3. The possession of control or command over others; dominion, authority, ascendancy or influence. Throughout history, artists have represented the meaning of power in many different ways to reflect strength, wealth

Related Papers

Critically Evaluate Post War Realist Explanation Of International Politics With Reference To Power

2541 words - 11 pages ” Introduction The tradition of political realism – realpolitik, power politics – has a long history that is typically traced back to the great Greek historian Thucydides in the fifth century BC. Although dominant attitudes towards realism have varied, realist arguments and orientations have been central to the Western theory and practice of international relations. “In particular, “modern” international society, whether dated from the era

The Soviet Tragedy Essay

1349 words - 6 pages History of Socialism in Russia, interprets seven decades of Communism power in The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). The Soviet Socialist Revolution gave supremacy to the Left because the Soviet Spectre became the great polarizing force of twentieth-century politics. After October Revolution in 1917, it had dual face since it was the world’s “first workers state” and history’s “first socialist society and on the otherside it emerged

Comparison Essay Of Shakespeare's Tragedy Of King Lear To Kurosawa's Ran

1083 words - 5 pages Japanese drama to portray a Shakespearean tragedy. Kurosawa, the director of RAN made a very effective and valid film on interpreting the key points of The Tragedy of King Lear. The two works give lessons to the audience, and these lessons are learned once finishing studies on RAN and The Tragedy of King Lear. The characters for the play and the film are very similar, first you have King Lear who is represented by The Great Lord

To What Extent Does Shakespeare Reveal That “Something Is Rotten In The State Of Denmark” In Act 1

891 words - 4 pages To what extent does Shakespeare reveal that “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark” in Act 1. In Act 1 Scene 4 Marcellus state that there is “something rotten in the state of Denmark” and Shakespeare goes to prove Marcellus to be right through his use of politics, faith and individuals. Thus conveying to the Jacobean audience that “something is rotten in the state of Denmark” but also portraying a sense of tragedy which coincides with the