This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Unmanned Technologies: Drawbacks Of This Policy

3426 words - 14 pages

Joel Perez
Professor Stoil
Organizing War
December 12, 2014

What have been the chief motivations behind the development and deployment of unmanned technologies and what are the chief drawbacks in this policy?

With the advancements in robotics, unmanned battlefield technology seems to be the military’s newest obsession. This policy of unmanned vehicles came to the attention of the American public with heavy drone use under President Barack Obama’s administration but unmanned technology has been around for decades. The only difference is that now the military is pouring more money into research and development of these types of technologies. The current five-year budget is set at ...view middle of the document...

However, unmanned technologies have some recognized drawbacks. Unmanned technologies such as drones cannot communicate with civilians. In addition, collateral damage not to mention the destabilizing and counterproductive impact these deaths cause on public opinion of the native population may make the operation or mission objective harder to achieve. Another drawback is that unmanned technologies are making war seem more like a video game and less like brutal conflict, which when taking into account the number of civilian lives taken because of drones, makes it seem as if Americans are killing people for fun. The last drawback is the most frightening. If the enemy were to become more tech-savvy or gain hacking capabilities, the worst drawback would be to turn all of the American unmanned technologies against our own military.

Save Lives
When in a policy-maker’s shoes, it is easy to understand the appeal of a technology that promises to save lives. One way that unmanned technologies save lives is that sending a robot into a battlefield is not the same as risking the life of a human soldier on the battlefield. As Sergeant 1st Class Gregory Carroll states, “the cost of losing a robot is not nearly as [high] as losing a trained […] person” (Unmanned Aircraft Systems: Perceptions & Potential, 4). Since the operators of the drones are sitting in a cubicle somewhere in the United States, their life is not in danger and the drone is still carrying out the mission. This is most important when the mission is to eliminate a heavily guarded target. In the case that there actually are “boots on the ground,” these boots are “three times safer from friendly fire attacks when deployed in war zones covered by drones compared with traditional warfare” (Weiner). Drones do not only help our troops but have also reduced the civilian casualties as well. According to the Pakistani Defense Ministry, “citizen fatalities occurred at a rate of 3 percent of total kills” (Weiner).
Unmanned technologies are not affected by emotions. According to Peter Olsthoorn, “a survey done by the US Army Surgeon General’s Office showed that troops who were angry, anxious, had unit members become a casualty, or who had handled dead bodies or human remains were more likely to say they had mistreated civilian non-combatants” (Olsthoorn, 2). Unlike humans, drones will not accidently fire in a tense situation and instead “hold their fire in ambiguous situations” (Olsthoorn, 2). This can be especially beneficial in places such as checkpoints where the tension is already high and any slight movement can cause an accident. With a drone, the situation is being constantly analyzed either by the drone or the controller, many miles away.
Low Cost
Unmanned technologies offer an advantage to conventional aircrafts with regards to monetary costs as well. Drones are significantly cheaper to purchase and maintain. According to Ashley Boyle of the American Security Project,...

Other Essays Like Unmanned Technologies: Drawbacks of This Policy

Biometric Security in the Workplace Essay

3837 words - 16 pages Abstract Biometrics has garnered considerable interest from both the Government and private industry. This interest has lead to a number of biometric technologies each with their own share of strengths and weaknesses. The process used in the verification and identification of people using fingerprint, retina-based, iris-based, hand geometry, and facial recognition biometrics are examined in this paper. The advantages and disadvantages of each

Harnessing Technology for the Future Essay

809 words - 4 pages inexhaustible energy of the sun. Each hour, enough sunlight reaches Earth to meet the world’s energy needs for a year. To harvest this bounty, we need technology that efficiently converts the sun’s energy into forms we can use. Developing this technology is the purpose of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Solar Energy Technologies Program. Powerful Goals, Powerful Technologies The Solar Energy Technologies Program is part of the DOE

Paper Discussion

1127 words - 5 pages participation today, such as casting their votes for candidates, than forty years ago (US Census, 2013). Research by Macedo et al. (2005) and Coffe and Van Der Lippe (2010) highlighted the issue of declining citizen participation in duty-based activities such as “voting, performing watchdog functions over the government, and obeying the law” and outlined the effects this may have on democracy (McBeth et al., 2010, p. 5). Additional research further explored

The Space Shuttle

672 words - 3 pages Agency's unmanned Ariane program for the orbiting of satellites. Then, on January 28, 1986, the shuttle Challenger was destroyed about one minute after launch because of the failure of a sealant ring on one of its solid boosters. Flames escaping from the booster burned a hole in the main propellant tank of liquid hydrogen and oxygen and caused the booster to nose into and rupture the tank. This rupture caused a nearly explosive disruption of the

China and the Esquel Group

1849 words - 8 pages of foreign direct investment (FDI), and a decline in exports, we believe China will, and should, continue a tempered liberalization of its exchange rate policy. This is necessitated by the potential consequences China faces both politically and economically by not moving towards a floating rate. Politically, China will continue to absorb the majority of the blame for foreign countries’ rising trade deficits, spawning potential legislation

Uber Technologies

1548 words - 7 pages ------------------------------------------------- Uber Technologies ------------------------------------------------- What is Uber Technologies? Uber Technologies, Inc. was founded in 2009 by Travis Kalanik and Garrett Camp as a way to solve their own transportation problems in the traffic congested city of San Francisco where it is still based and headquartered. Uber Technologies offers an on demand car service application for smartphone

What Does Representative Democracy Really Mean in the United States?

853 words - 4 pages What does Representative Democracy really mean in the United States? by Christian Gallardo Democracy has been traditionally defined as government by the people. However, here in the U.S. we know by democracy, what is known as representative democracy. In this model, the people transfer, through voting, their sovereignty to some “Representatives”. This model has been used over time to justify the exercises power of a social minority over

Venezuela's Membership in Mercosur

1215 words - 5 pages capita income and GDP; allowing for further growth (Mercosur Trade Center, n.d.). Drawbacks for Venezuela as a result of membership in Mercosur It is important to note that Venezuela faces drawbacks as a member of Mercosur as well. Open trade among member countries is promoted in Mercosur; therefore Venezuela has to have an open door policy for the member countries; some of the member countries are more efficient such as Brazil. Venezuela is not

Hydrogen Fuel Or Others

1040 words - 5 pages needed before the nation becomes absorbed in developing the hydrogen economy. In addition to the hydrogen fuel cells, the nation should continue to investigate other technologies such as new generation diesel, hybrids and solar cells. At present these technologies have come to maturity to some degree. I believe that now it is time to consider the fusion of these technologies. It is stated in the article “Benefits of a Hydrogen Economy” that

Information Systems Proposal

534 words - 3 pages . BENEFITS OF INFORMATIONS SYSTEMS 4. DRAWBACKS OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS 5. CONCLUSIONS INTODUCTION A business partner and I are considering a small business, this business is a small brick and motar nostalgic record store. Since my partner is not proficient on how to run a small business that includes information systems or technology. An understanding is needed about each information system. Also included in this proposal are the benefits

To What Extent Is Negative Heritage a Benefit to Society

2178 words - 9 pages the economic pillar within this region. Evaluation Negative heritage embodies a contradiction between the desire to forget and the need to remember (Mills 2008:81). The drawbacks of negative heritage are the negative past; these sites witnessed racial conflict and elimination, religious strife, political persecution and wars. Forgetting the bad memory is an instinctive choice, because good things are more appealing to human, but human

Related Papers

Short Answer Question On The American Civil War: Explain The 'total War' Policy Of General Ulysses S. Grant. Do You Approve Of This Policy?

582 words - 3 pages make war. This included factories making weapons and clothes, shops and plantations where required provisions such as food can be found. In other words, he wanted to destroy the enemy's economy. He basically wanted to destroy the morale of the enemy to fight. And he didn't care how many soldiers it took to destroy the enemy. All he wanted was to win, regardless of how many soldiers or people died. And this war policy of his was used in the Civil

“The Duke Of Somerset’s Policy Towards The War With Scotland Was The Main Cause Of His Downfall”. Assess The Validity Of This Statement

410 words - 2 pages system couldn't cope with the increase in cases and virtually collapsed under the workload. To apply Humanist ideals Wolsey's legal reforms sought to provide justice for all - used Star chamber to convict powerful subjects. * Wolsey came from a background of poverty and so this could be said as what fuelled his humanist ideals. Wolsey attacked enclosures as immoral and irresponsible on the part of the landowners. Policy to tackle the profiteering

Foreigin Direct Investment Essay

1350 words - 6 pages in Globe Diesels actions to transfer cleaner technologies to the host country China. Although these facts exemplify some of the positive aspects of FDI in the area of development, host- economies, economic and non-economic are not free of drawbacks as a result of FDI. One of the main drawbacks to conducting FDI is cost. Drawbacks from cost can occur when there is a loss of the stability of payments as profits are sent back home, while the need

The Strategic Use Of Uas's Essay

3633 words - 15 pages emergence of drone warfare has completely revolutionized the strategy of our military surveillance and fights overseas. This study is intended to analyze the costs' involved in drone warfare as it relates to our defense budget, and the impact it could have on our U.S. economy. This research will also attempt to show why the use of drones, also known as UAV's (Unmanned Aerial Vehicles), are so appealing to our Air Force, Navy/Marines, and Army