This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Using The Sources And Your Own Knowledge, Describe The Role Of Public Bill (Standing) And Departmental Select Committees Of The House Of Commons

551 words - 3 pages

There is a Select Committee for each government department; for example the Department of Education. From my own knowledge, these departmental committees have a minimum of 11 members, who decide upon the line of inquiry and then get evidence. The government then usually has 60 days to reply to the committee's recommendations. Committees also have power to appoint specialists. These are not permanent committee members, but specialists from businesses paid by the day. They aim to scrutinise the executive and hold them to account, scrutiny includes policy, administration, and expenditure of government departments.

Source C suggests that Select Committees often have their recommendations ignored, and therefore the effectiveness of the committees is decreased. Due to the reports produced by Select Committees not being binding governments can ...view middle of the document...

These committees are formed from between 16-50 members in reflection of party affiliation in the House of Commons from back bench MPs - with the whip system in place - and are established for each new bill, and are dissolved after the report has been made. Examples of the work of Public Bill committees include the Abortion Bill (1967), Tuition fees (2011), and recently Scottish Devolution.

Source A and Source B both mention the presence of the whip system in Public Bill committees, which pressures back bench ties and may reduce the effectiveness of the committee - it is most effective in the House of Lords respectively. Although the ad-hoc nature prevents the committee ties conflicting with party interest. Again, just as Select committees, Public Bill committees are under resourced - comparative to the Westminster, US congressional committees have much larger amounts of staff working for them.

Select Committees and Public Bill committees are both able to influence legislation. However, Public Bill committees, whilst allowed to amend bills through scrutinising bills clause by clause, often have the presence of a whip which means scrutiny of bills may be limited. Select Committees, whilst they do not have the whip system, whips can put forward members to the select committees - which may indirectly have the same effect. Not to mention the ability for governments to disregard the reports from Select committees. I think a merge of roles of both committees into one type of committee with permanent members and a paid chair would be a more effective solution. In the US chairs of committees are very influential, which would provide this greater effectiveness if the same result is achieved in Westminster. The absence of the whip system, alongside the ability to provide amendments to clauses as well as scrutinise the principle and just not clauses of bills would create a much more influencing committee system on bills, and therefore the ideal role of a committee.

Other Essays Like Using the Sources and Your Own Knowledge, Describe the Role of Public Bill (Standing) and Departmental Select Committees of the House of Commons

“Using the Case Study at the End of the Module Assess the Client’s Issues and Describe Your Treatment Plan. What Ethical Issues Might Arise?”

2381 words - 10 pages , drugs etc. (FAI 2014). Food isn’t something that can be eliminated. It would be more effective that a change would need to be considered and an assessment of what the underlying issues are in order for the eating habit to be changed. (Hadley and Straudacher 1996). While the subconscious isn’t a simple power, it is only through permanent changes in this part of your mind that you will experience permanent changes in your life – changes that

Do You Agree with the View That Gladstone Failed to ‘Pacify Ireland’ in the Years 1868-85 Because He Consistently Offered Too Little, Too Late? Explain Your Answer, Using Sourced 4,5 and 6 and Your...

900 words - 4 pages , some of the acts he introduced did not go far enough to fully address the issues at hand. Despite the fact Gladstone had clear aims to try and pacify Ireland in his first and second ministry there is also proof from the sources and my own knowledge that Gladstone introduced too little reforms and when they were introduced it was too late. Source 4 shows Gladstone talking in an election and stating that Ireland had to be dealt with because of

Task 1; Describe What Your Role, Responsibilities and Boundaries Would Be as a Teacher in Terms of the Teacher Training Cycle

585 words - 3 pages Providing assessment via quizzes, tests and having recap sessions of previous lessons 5. Evaluate The responsibilities are to evaluate your own teaching role and to quality Ensuring your own work you also have a duty to ensure that inspectors have access to and observe your work. You could evaluate by Ask for feedback from learners using comments box, postal feedback Using a self evaluation sheet Student evaluation forms Boundaries

Using the Data and Your Economic Knowledge, Evaluate Different Ways in Which the Government of a Country Which Imports Large Quantities of Wheat Can Try to Stabilise Wheat Prices Within the Country

624 words - 3 pages Using the data and your economic knowledge, evaluate different ways in which the government of a country which imports large quantities of wheat can try to stabilise wheat prices within the country. (25 marks) Price stability is when prices in the economy don’t change or don’t change much over time. This means that an economy would not experience inflation or deflation. One of the ways in which the government could stabilise wheat princes is

Using Source 1 and 2 and Your Own Knowledge. Do You Agree That the Chartists Justified Physical Force at Newport Because They Wanted to Gain the Franchise for Purely Political Principle?

1367 words - 6 pages principles that lead to the physical force revolt in Newport on the 4th of November 1839 but instead the factors that engulfed the newly appointed working class at the time and in turn their reaction to this sudden change in their environments. Sources 1 and 2 don’t support the claim in the statement either as they simply don’t mention the Newport rising and how it justified the movement so that it could take a standing in purely political principles

In Modern Day Society There Is an Increasing Need to Work Longer 24hour Shifts. Using Your Knowledge of Biological Rhythms and Their Impacts Disscuss the Impact of These Demands

625 words - 3 pages In modern day society there is an increasing need to work longer 24hour shifts. using your knowledge of biological rhythms and their impacts disscuss the impact of these demands. Shift work is a work pattern that falls outside of the normal 9-5 working hours. Shift hours came into place firstly in hospitals. This was because the patients needed round the clock care. Another place where shift work came into place was in factories. However even

How Would You Perform the Role of Nora in the Opening Section of the Play in Order to Achieve Your Preferred Effects for the Audience? (a Doll's House)

2225 words - 9 pages How would you perform the role of Nora in the opening section of the play in order to achieve your preferred effects for an audience? In the opening section of “A Doll’s House,” I would enter shivering from out of the brumal cold of a Norwegian Winter in a thick, but stylish coat, which I would doff to reveal an all-encompassing dress of the period with ivy green ornate frills to indicate Nora’s primary purpose of appearing pretty. Around my

Use Source T, U and V and Your Own Knowledge. Do You Agree with the View in Source V That Wolsey's Domestic Policis Were Disappointing?

1456 words - 6 pages Use source T, U and V and your own knowledge. Do you accept the view in source V that Wolsey’s domestic policies were disappointing? Thomas Wolsey was Henry VIII chief minister from his rise to power in 1514 after working himself up until his eventual fall from the king’s favour in 1529. During the time period where Wolsey contained his power he made many changes to England’s domestic policies. For this reason I do not accept the view of

Tragedy of the Commons

793 words - 4 pages communities do have rules and regulations that regulate the fertility of the members. It may not be an individual choice for many. Child welfare and their upbringing do play an integral role in the decision of the parent to give birth to more children. The economic circumstances, culture and gender are important factors to be considered. Understanding these conditions often change the fertility decisions. Through The Tragedy of the commons, Hardin expresses his concern about the issue of overpopulation and its effects on the society and the environment. He emphasises on the need to change our values and save the resources for the future generations since they are limited.

House of Commons Revision

1309 words - 6 pages withhold) its approval for most actions of the government, including legislation and the grant of money. Scrutiny of the Executive: The role in scrutinising the policies and actions of the government, in debates, parliamentary questions and within the influential cross-party select committees. The Powers of the Prime Ministers Power to appoint, reshuffle or dismiss ministers Power to create peers Power to give out honours Power to appoint

Explain The Knowledge, Skills And Behaviour Of Hr Role

538 words - 3 pages ACTIVITY 1 1.1. Explain the knowledge, skills, and behaviours required to be effective in an identified HR or L&D role Jackie Orme, ex-chief executive of CIPD said: “The HR profession is changing. More will be required of the HR professional of the future, and today’s practitioners need to be equipped with the capabilities to meet these demands. Roles are more diverse, career paths more complicated and the capacity to impact on the

Related Papers

Use Sources 1, 2 And 3 And Your Own Knowledge. Do You Agree With The View That The 1950s Can Be Seen As A Period Of Great Prosperity For The People Of Britain? Explain Your Answers Using Sources 1, 2...

1206 words - 5 pages will see a state of prosperity such as we have never seen in my lifetime-nor indeed in the history of this country.’ It is clear that the prosperity is helping all people as wages of people were starting to increase. Also, there was an increase in the amount of credit that was available to the public, with that at an increase people are able to go out and buy more materialistic goods such as fridges and TVs which before this time could only be

How Far Did The Rebellions Of 1549 Present A Serious Threat To The Government? Use The Sources And Your Own Knowledge To Explain Your Answer

1128 words - 5 pages How far did the rebellions of 1549 present a serious threat to the government? Use the sources and your own knowledge to explain your answer. The Kett's Rebellion and the Western Rebellion, both of which occurred in 1549 with a variety of other rebellions occurring across the country, both had posed a fairly significant role in threatening on the government. Both of the rebellions however, were located far away from London. The proximity of

Using Your Own Research Of Child Development Textbooks And Theories, Fill In The Chart To Provide A Basic Outline Of The Expected Pattern Of Children’s Development

740 words - 3 pages Table showing pattern of children’s development (201.1.1) Using your own research of Child Development textbooks and theories, fill in the chart to provide a basic outline of the expected pattern of children’s development. |Age Range |Physical Development |Social, emotional and behavioural development |Communication and intellectual development

Describe What Your Role, Responsibilities And Boundaries Would Be As A Teacher In Terms Of The Teaching/Training Cycle

527 words - 3 pages Describe what your role, responsibilities and boundaries would be as a teacher in terms of the teaching/training cycle. 300-500 words All teachers undertake the same activities in relation to the teaching cycle, these include: • Initial assessment • Preparation and planning • Delivery • Assessment • Evaluation • Revision based on evaluation My role is categorized as the associate role and therefore has significantly less